At the Lopez-Fitzgerald's, Theresa asks Ethan to make love to her. Ethan asks her if she is sure, and she says yes. Ethan tells her that he loves her, and then kiss some more. When they are very close to making love, Ethan stops and says they shouldn't do this. Theresa asks him why? He tells her that he knows her wish is to wait till her wedding night, but Theresa says she has changed her mind. Ethan asks her why she changed her mind? Theresa says she just couldn't see a reason to wait, and that they will be married any day now anyways. Ethan says that he still thinks that they should wait, he wants this to be special for her. Theresa tells Ethan that she doesn't want to wait, she can't wait! Ethan asks her why she can't wait? She replies "because I don't want to lose you!" Ethan asks her why she would lose him, what is she frightened of? Ethan tells her that she can tell him anything, and she can always be truthful with him. Theresa chickens out and tells Ethan that there isn't anything she isn't telling him, she just realized how much she wanted to love and belong to him completely. She tells him that she just realized how fragile life was, and that she doesn't want to lose him. Ethan asks her if she is sure, and she says she is. She asks him to take her to her room and make love to her. Ethan picks Theresa up and carries her to her room. Upstairs, Theresa tells Ethan that the red negligee she is wearing was to be for her wedding night, and that she wants this to be their wedding night. She tells Ethan that from this night on, in her heart, she will be his wife. Ethan tells Theresa that this night will be everything they have both dreamed of, it will be the most special night of their lives. Ethan and Theresa kiss, and Ethan begins to take off her negligee! He stops, picks her up, and takes her to bed.
At Sheridan's cottage, Luis proposes to Sheridan, but she does not respond. When Luis looks down at her, she has fallen asleep! Luis puts Sheridan to sleep on the couch, and then Hank stops by with some champagne to celebrate. Luis tells Hank that he did ask Sheridan to marry him, but she fell asleep in the middle of his proposal! Hank laughs and says this could only happen to him. Luis says he just wants the moment he asks her to be perfect, one they will always remember. Sheridan, who is still asleep, begins dreaming of the perfect proposal. In her dream, she and Luis are in a garden of flowers, and are dressed all in white. Luis gets down on one knee and proposes to her. Back outside, Luis shows Hank the ring he is going to give her, and he thinks it probably isn't the ring she always though of wearing. Hank tells Luis that Sheridan could buy any ring she wants and it wouldn't mean as much as the ring he gives her. Luis says it is a simple ring, like the life he can give her, but Hank tells Luis that Sheridan loves him. Luis once again begins to have doubts and panics that Sheridan will hate living a simple lifestyle. Hank tells him to chill, Sheridan will love the ring and will love him. Luis tells Hank that he knows he had feelings for Sheridan, and that he loved her. Hank says he did, but he has accepted that Sheridan chose him, and he is happy for him. Luis thanks him, and then looks at Sheridan asleep on the couch. Hank knows this love is different, Luis is different. Luis goes back inside, and Sheridan wakes up. She is furious with herself, and tells Luis that she feels so terrible. Sheridan says she remembers he was going to ask her a question before she fell asleep, and she wants to know what it was.
At the cottage, Sheridan asks Luis to ask her the question he wanted to ask her. Luis says this question will change their lives, so Sheridan suggests she just give him an answer before he asks the question. Luis tells her no way, he wants to ask this question only once in his life, so he's doing it right. Sheridan tells him to ask away, but Luis says not here, he doesn't want anyone walking in on them. Luis and Sheridan go into the bedroom, and as they are talking, they overhear Julian and Rebecca playing outside. Sheridan tells Luis that it is only a cat, and to continue. Julian overhears them talking, and decides to spy on them. Sheridan is telling Luis about her dream proposal, but she tells Luis that they are getting off track, he was about to ask her a question. Luis tells her that there is something he must do before he can ask her the question, and he runs off. Sheridan can't believe she has ruined the moment yet again, this time by blabbing to him about her dream. MEanwhile, Julian comes up with a brilliant plan to cause Luis and Sheridan the pain they deserve.
At the Lopez-Fitzgeralds, before Ethan makes love to Theresa, he tells her that he has a confession to make. Ethan tells Theresa that he loves her unconditionally, and there is nothing about her that he doesn't love, she is his dream come true. The two begin to kiss some more. Ethan tells Theresa that he'll never betray her, which gets Theresa thinking about what she is doing. As they come close to making love, Gwen shows up outside Theresa's window and exclaims "That bitch!" Suddenly, Ethan stops because he realizes he doesn't have something, protection. Ethan gets up to leave to get some protection, and once he is gone, Gwen shows up and asks Theresa if she has forgotten something! Theresa asks Gwen what she is doing here? Gwen says she came here to see Ethan, and he just ran out of here in a hurry to get those condoms. Theresa tells Gwen to leave, but Gwen refuses. When Theresa says she and Ethan will be married and grow old together, Gwen warns Theresa not to count all her chickens before they are hatched, because she is a long way from the altar. Theresa says she and Ethan are getting married, but Gwen tells Theresa that she knows deep down her secret will come out, and she will lose him!
At Tabitha's, the friends in the basement roar, and Reese wants to check it out. Tabitha tells him not to, so Reese asks her if she is hiding something? Tabitha says no, and Sam says he thinks he should check it out. However, the door is locked, and Kay remembers seeing a key on the table. Tabitha can't seem to remember where she put the key, and she says she is getting so absent minded. Grace asks Tabitha if the noise doesn't bother her? Tabitha says of course not, it is just her pipes acting up. Charity says it sounds much more scary than pipes, and familiar. MEanwhile, a snooping Reese finds Tabitha's closet of shoes belonging to the victims of the friends in the basement. Reese becomes suspicious and grabs a crowbar to find out what is in the basement. Tabitha tells him not to do that! Reese asks Tabitha what she is afraid of, what do witches hide in the basement! Miguel tells Reese to lay off the witch thing, but Tabitha says it doesn't matter to her if Reese wants to make up stories. Reese says maybe he'd quit believing she was a witch if he was able to see what was in her basement. Tabitha says she wouldn't mind letting him down there, but she has lost the key! She then tells Sam that if the sounds of her pipes bother him and his family, perhaps they should stay somewhere else. Sam says nobody has enough rooms for their family, and asks if there is some reason she doesn't want them to stay here? Tabitha says of course not! Kay thinks this is the perfect place for them all to stay, and lists a million reasons why. Grace says Kay is right, and Sam asks Tabitha if they can stay or not?
Meanwhile, Jessica begins talking about how they are a family and need to stay together, Charity has a premonition that she is saying goodbye to Miguel, who fades from her site. Jessica asks Charity if she is okay? Charity tells her about her premonition, which Jessica thinks she should tell Miguel about. CHarity refuses because she doesn't want to upset Miguel, and she doesn't want him to think she is insecure about their love. Charity then asks Kay to please look after Miguel for her. Kay promises that she will. Simone tells Kay that if Charity knew the truth, she wouldn't let her within a hundred miles of him! Simone asks Kay if she has learned nothing? Doesn't she feel like she owes Charity anything after what she did to her? Kay says she doesn't owe Charity a thing, Charity owes her Miguel!
Elsewhere, Timmy thinks with Charity here, he will be able to make her love him and not Miguel. Tabitha tells him to hold up, she hasn't given them the key to the house just yet! Timmy asks what she is up to? Tabitha tells him to just watch. Tabitha tells Grace and Sam that she knows their family doesn't want to be broken up, but she only has three guest rooms. Grace says that is okay, because only three of them will be staying. Grace says that she and the girls will stay, but he is not. Grace tells Sam that he should not be staying here with her and the girls!
At Tabitha's, Sam is shocked when Grace tells him that she doesn't want him to stay here with her and the girls. Sam refuses to leave his family, not after what they've been through! Tabitha tells Sam that he's more and welcomed to stay on the couch, but Grace says she can take care of the kids just fine. Sam says he's not worried about the girls, he's worried about their marriage. Jessica becomes upset, so Sam and Grace go to Tabitha's kitchen to talk. Jessica begins to cry, and Charity comforts her. Charity says Aunt Grace and Sam love each other way too much not to work things out. Reese tries to comfort Kay, but she runs into Miguel's arms. Whitney says that their parents are in love as much as hers, so they have to work it out. Reese then blurts out that his mother told his father that if he ever had a child with another woman, then she'd kill him! Kay tells Reese to shut up, her dad had an affair with Ivy long before he met her mom. Reese says that his mom has lived in Harmony a long time, and she says that Ivy always gets what she wants. Tabitha tells Timmy that geekboy is right, Ivy will get Sam, and everything else she wants.
In the kitchen, Grace tells Sam perhaps he cam come by for dinner some nights, but Sam says no. He says if they aren't sharing a bed, then what she is talking about is a separation. Grace says she guesses that is what she is talking about then. Sam can't believe this is happening to them. Grace tells Sam that they need some time apart. Sam tells her once again that Ivy means nothing to him, and that he loves her. He asks to put the past behind them and start over. Sam begs Grace not to shut him out. Grace says that a separation is the only way to get back what they have, he needs to find closure with Ivy. Sam says there is no closure, but Grace says she thinks there should be. Grace tells Sam that they need time apart to reevaluate things. Sam hopes this is what she wants, because it isn't what he wants, but he'll do it. Sam tells Grace that he'll resolve his past with Ivy, but then he is coming back to her. Sam leaves, and goes back out to see the kids. He tells them that there isn't enough room for him here, so he's going to leave. The kids beg him to stay, but he says he has to go. However, Sam says he isn't leaving their mom, and he will come by to see them every day. Kay asks her dad where he will stay? Sam says he'll use the bunk at the station, but Jessica says "no!" Grace returns, and Sam tells the girls that he won't be away for very long. Sam tells the girls that nothing can separate them, and that they all belong together. Grace says she will be right here waiting for him to return. Sam offers Kay a ride to Miguel's, but Kay says they can walk. Kay then tells Simone that she plans to use the moonlight to get Miguel in a romantic mood. Simone can't believe this, how can she think about Miguel when her parents are about to split up. She then remembers that Kay has no soul. Sam hugs the girls, gives Grace a kiss, and then leaves. Miguel tells Charity goodbye, though he wishes she could come with him, but Kay was right when she said she should be with her family. Miguel notices that CHarity is shaking and he asks if something is wrong? Charity recalls her premonition, but says she is just upset about her aunt and uncle. Kay tells Miguel that they should probably get going, so they leave.
Later, Tabitha vents to Timmy that the Bennett's are the last people she needs snooping around here. Meanwhile, Grace gets a glimpse into the future, and sees those who should be together, will be apart. Charity, who is with her aunt, tells her that she had the same premonition about her and Miguel. Grace tells Charity that will never happen because Miguel loves her too much. Charity tells her aunt that Sam loves her too.
In the park, Ivy sits on a bench and writes a love note to Sam. As she is leaving the note for Sam, Pilar catches her. Pilar thinks that Ivy just can't sleep and is out for a walk. Ivy says so much happened tonight, but now she and Sam can finally be together! Pilar tells Ivy that Sam will never leave Grace, but Ivy says Grace is pushing Sam right into her arms! Ivy says she knows Sam will realize he never stopped loving her, and then she, Sam, and Ethan will be the family they were meant to be. Ivy vows to do whatever it takes to make sure her dream comes true. Pilar sees Ivy is leaving Sam a note, and wonders how she can demean herself like this. Pilar tells her that she'll never get Sam back, she will only get her heart broken all over again! Ivy refuses to let this go, and tells Pilar that she thinks she is trying to be cruel deliberately. Pilar says she is just being realistic, Sam will meet with her, tell her that he has no feelings for her, and they go back to Grace, leaving her out in the cold! Ivy tells Pilar that she is just being cruel now, doesn't she want her to be happy? Pilar says the last thing she wants to do is hurt her, but people's lives are at stake here! Pilar tells Ivy that she has to move on with her life, but Ivy doesn't think she has a life without Sam. Pilar tells Ivy that she has her best years ahead of her, and she will find love again. Pilar tells Ivy that they need to concentrate on Ethan and Theresa right now. Later, Kay and Miguel show up, and Pilar tells Kay she is welcomed to stay as long as possible. Ivy asks if everyone else is staying at Tabitha's? Miguel says that Chief Bennett is staying at the station. Kay and Miguel leave, and Kay says that she hates Ivy Crane for trying to break up her family. Ivy is delighted to learn that Sam and Grace aren't living together, and she thinks that she has a chance to win him back now.
Sam goes to the station, his new home, and he refuses to allow his marriage to be destroyed. Sam tries to sleep, but he can't, and ends up looking at a picture of Grace. A spying Ivy looks in on him.
At the Russell's, Chad gives a sleeping Whitney a kiss on the cheek, and it causes her to wake up. She asks him what he is doing? Chad says he couldn't sleep, he kept thinking about earlier. Chad tells Whitney that he loves her, and he can't help thinking about what she said earlier about wanting to wait until making love. Whitney tells Chad that it would be wrong for them to make love right now. Chad asks her if she really believes that, knowing how she feels about him? WHitney says she likes him, but Chad thinks she more than likes him. Chad tells Whitney that he wants to make love to her, and the two kiss. However, Whitney stops him and says they can't do this, they haven't even told Simone yet. Chad says he'll make things right with Simone, and it won't change things between them. Whitney tells Chad that she still can't have sex with him, she thought he understood. Chad says he knows she wants her first time to be special, and to be with the man she will be with for the rest of her life. Chad tells her that he wants to be there for her for the rest of his life. The two kiss again, and Chad tells her that he loves her and always will. Suddenly, Simone walks and asks what is going on! Whitney's phone begins to ring and Simone demands to know what her boyfriend is doing in Whitney's bed! As Whitney tries to explain, the phone stops ringing. Chad tells Simone that the truth is that he loves Whitney, and he never loved her. Simone cries "that is a lie, you did love me, and Whitney took you away from me!" Simone damns Whitney for putting her claws into Chad, and she asks her why she just couldn't let her be happy. The phone begins ringing again, and Whitney wakes up from, yup, her little nightmare. Whitney answers the phone, and Theresa asks Whitney to come over. Whitney says okay, she'll be there soon.
Elsewhere in the house, Kay talks to Miguel about her parents, and uses the situation for sympathy. Miguel hugs her and tells her that everything will be better in the morning. Miguel lets Kay stay in his room, and he says he will bunk with his brother. Kay tells Miguel there is something she needs first, and it is only something he can give her. Kay kisses Miguel. Miguel pulls away from her and asks her what she is doing? Kay tells him if he doesn't feel the connection between them? She also asks him if he doesn't remember telling her that he loved her? Miguel remembers, so Kay tells Miguel that she loves him, she's always loved him. Miguel says he is with Charity, but Kay tells him that he's not with Charity right now. Miguel kisses Kay, and yup, it is another dream.
Theresa and Whitney have breakfast together, and Theresa tells Whitney that she and Ethan didn't make love last night. However, Theresa tells Whitney about her dream, and how it was the most amazing experience. Whitney says there must be something in the water, she had a dream about her first time with Chad! However, her dream turned into a nightmare when Simone walked in on them! Later, Whitney tells Theresa how close she and Chad actually came to making love. Theresa asks her why she stopped? Whitney tells Theresa she knows why, she wants her first time to be with her husband. Theresa then tells Whitney what happened to stop her and Ethan, the Gwen confrontation. Whitney tells Theresa that if Gwen knows the truth, she better tell Ethan before she does, or someone else does. Suddenly, Theresa gets a call from the Crane mansion. One of the housekeepers is asking her to come over right now! Theresa panics, and thinks Gwen might have blabbed.
At Tabitha's, Tabitha wakes Timmy up because she can't sleep with all the Bennetts here. Timmy says all he can think about is sneaking into Charity's room and giving her a kiss. Tabitha tells the cheeky-chappy to keep his hormones in check, they can't let anyone know he is alive with Reese sneaking around. Suddenly, Reese and Charity show up, and Reese tells Charity that he told her that Tabitha was a witch! Reese tells Tabitha that it is payback time, he's going to tell everyone that she is a witch, and that she brought evil into Harmony. Charity and Reese tie Tabitha up, and Reese tells her that she is going to die by fire! Outside the window, the Bennetts have gathered and are holding torches! As Tabitha screams, Timmy wakes his sleeping Princess up from her nightmare. Tabitha tells Timmy that they have a serious problem with this Reese kid. Timmy says at least he isn't staying here. Suddenly there is a knock at the door. Tabitha answers it, it's Charity and Reese! Charity says she forgot her key, but she just wanted to bring over some muffins Aunt Grace made at the B&B. Tabitha asks Reese what brings him over here at such an early hour? Reese then points at Timmy and exclaims "Your doll!" Tabitha asks what about her doll? Reese says he is wearing pajamas! Tabitha says is that against the law? Charity says of course not. Jessica shows up, as do Miguel, Simone, and Kay. They all decide to have breakfast together. Jessica reads the paper and learns that it is reporting that their house was swallowed by a sink hole, and the Bennett's are crazy for believing in demons. Miguel says it doesn't matter, they all know what happened. Miguel suggests they forget about the paper and eat. Everyone but Kay and Simone go into the kitchen, and Kay tells Simone that she is going to make sure Miguel forgets all about Charity and makes love to her. Later, Jessica calls her dad, and afterwards, Charity tries to reassure her that it will be okay. Jessica says it won't be okay, her world is falling apart. Timmy feels bad for Jessica, but Tabitha says it's only going to get worse. Suddenly, Reese sees that Timmy is crying, and he demands Tabitha admit that her doll is alive. Tabitha tells "Ross" not to be ridiculous, she just washed some pancake powder off his face! Miguel tells Reese to leave Tabitha's doll alone, Jessica and Charity are already upset enough as is. Jessica decides to go upstairs and take a shower before school. Charity tells Miguel that she's worried about Jessica, this separation has been hardest on her because she is the youngest. Miguel says that this has got him thinking of marriage, and he wanted to talk to her about these things. Tabitha overhears this and doesn't like it at all. Miguel wonders when the right age to get married is, and he begins talking about Luis and how he is older, but then there is Theresa, who is their age, and is also getting married. Charity says she loves Theresa, but she isn't mature enough to be getting married. Miguel agrees, and they both agree that they are much more mature than Theresa. Miguel then asks Charity how she would feel about having a triple wedding with Luis and Theresa? Meanwhile, Kay asks Simone if she wants to hear about her dream. Simone tells Kay that she is incredible, her sister just left in tears, does she not even care what is going on with her parents? And does she even care about her, she hasn't asked her if maybe she's had dreams about Chad. Kay asks if she has any hot dreams about Chad. Simone says she did dream about him, but every time she does so, Whitney is there. Simone says she can't shake the feeling that something is going on between Whitney and Chad.
Luis proposes to Sheridan just like she dreamed. Unfortunately, it IS another dream. Sheridan wakes up and Luis climbs into bed with her. Luis asks her what she was dreaming about? Sheridan says she was dreaming about something she wants very, very much. Luis has made Sheridan breakfast in bed, pancakes this time. Later Luis asks her what she was dreaming about, and she tells him. Luis tells her that he will make that dream come true, but with a little extra surprise. Sheridan tells Luis that he doesn't have to go to the trouble of decorating the gazebo, all he has to do is ask her and it will be her dream come true. Luis tells Sheridan that he wants to make her dream come true, he wants this to be everything she ever dreamed of. After some kissing, Luis gets up to heat up their breakfast. Sheridan decides to come with him, but after Luis leaves the room, she notices he dropped something. Sheridan finds the engagement ring Luis has for her, and thinks it is beautiful. Luis returns, and he asks her what she's doing with his grandmother's ring. Sheridan says it fell out of his shirt, and she's sorry if she ruined the surprise. Sheridan tells him it is so beautiful, it is absolutely perfect. Luis takes it and says she won't get to see it again until he proposes. Sheridan tells him not to make a big deal out of this, she's seen the ring, so ask the question!
Ethan and Chad hit the gym, and guy talk. They decide to talk about anything but sex, because it drives them both nuts. Chad decides to concentrate on finding whoever leaked the information about him to the tabloids.