The Bennett house continues to fall apart as it sinks into the fissure in the ground. Inside the house, Tabitha is unable to free Timmy after he's pinned down by debris. Timmy puts up a brave front as he urges Tabitha to leave him behind and escape while she can. The two share an emotional good-bye before Tabitha solemnly walks away. Charity, Kay, and Miguel also remain trapped in the house. As the kids prepare to die, Kay blurts out she's going to hell. She comes close to confessing her wrongdoings, but reconsiders when she notes Charity doesn't remember that the soulless teen allowed her to get pulled into hell. Miguel devises a plan to escape. Meanwhile, firefighters try to put out the wall of flames surrounding the Bennett house so rescuers can get inside. However, the fire is too strong. Everyone watches helplessly as it seems certain the kids will die. Affected by Theresa's distress, Ethan rushes to the house for one last rescue attempt. Meanwhile, Sam and Julian have a confrontation after Julian tries to abuse his Crane power. Sam is about to punch Julian when Theresa's screams interrupt them. Luis tackles Ethan before he reaches the burning house, and Sam orders Ethan to remain outside. They share an intense moment as Sam vows not to lose his newfound son. Later, more lives are placed in danger as Sheridan and Theresa fall into the widening fissure.
Elsewhere in the house, Charity asks God to save Kay and Miguel because they risked their lives to save her, and that he should take her instead. Kay screams to her parents to help them. Suddenly, Charity begins to pray. Kay starts screaming that they are going to die, but Miguel refuses to believe that. He asks Charity to tell Kay that they will make it, but CHarity says she can't do that.
Outside, Grace and Sam hear Kay scream for help. Sam wants to go save her, but Hank holds him back because he will only die too. Ivy begs Sam to listen to Hank because she'd die if anything happened to him. Hank tells Sam that Grace needs her, so he should go to her. Sam realizes Hank is right and goes to Grace. Hank then confronts Ivy about what she's done to his family. He warns her that Sam is married to Grace now, so she shouldn't get any ideas. Ivy tells Hank that Grace thinks Sam still loves her, and she is urging Sam to spend time with her to resolve his feelings for her.
MEanwhile, Ethan and Theresa hold one another, and Ethan can't believe he's going to lose a sister he never got to know. Reese continues to try and find something on the internet to help, but Pilar tells him only God can help them now. Theresa attempts to run into the house to save Miguel, but Luis and Ethan hold her back. Grace begs God to save Kay, Charity, and Miguel. Chad feels guilty for not trying hard enough to save the others, but TC, Simone, and Whitney tell him that he did everything he could. Whitney tells Chad to think about the songs he always play, and that love can conquer anything, so perhaps Miguel and Charity's love will save them.
Everyone watches helplessly as the entire Bennett house sinks into the fissure and the ground is completely leveled! Not a trace of the Bennett house remains! Grace and Sam grieve, and Hank tells Ivy to look at them, she may still love sam, but he loves Grace. Everyone else grieves as well, and when Father Lonigan begin to pray, Sam becomes angry. He says that God can't bring back his daughter and niece, but perhaps her can. Sam begins to dig where his house once was. Sam begins to lose faith. Father Lonigan says they must all pray, they must have hope. Father Lonigan and the others, except for Sam, drop to their knees and pray. Sam eventually joins them and begs God to bring their loved ones home. Later, Theresa realizes that she isn't the only one who lost a sibling, Ethan lost his half sister. Meanwhile, Luis calls for a bunch of construction equipment, and while on the phone, Sheridan hears someone moan. Suddenly, Miguel walks out of the woods! Pilar hugs her son, and Father Lonigan thanks the lord for hearing their prayers. Miguel thinks Charity and Kay must have made it out as well, but they don't seem to have escaped. Miguel recalls how the angel appeared to them in the house and told them to follow the light, which they did. Miguel says that they all followed the light, thinking that it would lead them home, and the next thing he knew he was in front of the house, or where it used to be. Grace thanks God that Miguel made it, but where are the girls? Sam tells her to hold onto her faith, the girls will make it. Grace tells Sam that he promised her that he'd save the girls, and he didn't, so none of his promises mean anything. Grace runs off, and when Ivy tries to go to Sam, Hank grabs her. He tells her to leave Sam alone, he needs Grace now, and she needs him. Father Lonigan talks with Grace and tells her that she should not blame Sam for this, it is not his fault. Sam begs Grace to forgive him, and she tells him that she is sorry and she was wrong to blame him. The two embrace, bursting Ivy's bubble.
Elsewhere in the woods, Tabitha and Timmy wake up in a tree. Tabitha theorizes that the wind from the house sinking into the abyss blew them up here. Tabitha thinks her friends down below saved them, but Timmy thinks the angel did this. From the tree, Tabitha sees that Miguel is still alive, but she doesn't see Charity or Kay anywhere. Suddenly, Kay shows up! Kay learns that Miguel is safe, but Charity hasn't returned. Suddenly, Tabitha is spotted by Reese, and Reese blames Tabitha for all of this! Reese accuses her of being an evil witch! Tabitha asks him why he is saying this, her poor old heart can't take much more of this! Sam tells Reese to cut it out, and then offers to help Tabitha out of the tree. Reese knows Tabitha is an evil witch, because only a witch could cast such a spell to cause what happened to the Bennett's house. Kay tells Reese to leave Tabitha alone because none of this is her fault. Tabitha thanks Kay for defending her, but Reese is sure he is right. Reese asks Tabitha why she was in the tree anyways? Tabitha says she was packing clothes up for the needy when she saw Sam and Grace's happy house sinking into the abyss. Fearing her house would be next, Tabitha says she jumped into the tree to save herself. Simone asks Kay if she thinks she caused all of this by selling her soul? Kay says she does, and she says she has to get her soul back after seeing how awful hell was. Kay says some good did come out of this, she and Miguel grew closer. Simone realizes that Kay is hoping Charity doesn't make it out so she can keep Charity. Later, Simone tells Reese to forget about Tabitha being a witch, but Reese vows to prove she is a witch. Tabitha tells Timmy that they have to keep an eye on that Ross boy. Timmy tells her that it is Reese, and he is like Mrs. Cravitz on Bewitched. Tabitha says she'll have to take care of that Ross when she gets her powers back. Meanwhile, Miguel gets checked over by Eve, but wants to go help search for Charity. Pilar and Eve tell him that everyone is busy searching for her right now. The others search for Charity, and Luis eventually finds her. CHarity is passed out on the ground, and Luis fears she is dead. Miguel hears this and runs to her. He begs Charity not to leave him. Tabitha and Timmy spy on them all, and Tabitha hopes Charity is DOA. Eve shows up to check out Charity, but she doesn't respond. Eve says they should get her to the hospital. Miguel tells Charity that she can't leave him now, they've made it this far, and they belong together. Charity comes to and tells Miguel that she loves him too, and she'll never leave him. Tabitha is furious, and vows to destroy all love in Harmony. Tabitha swears to break up all the couples in Harmony, and she says she has a special surprise for Grace. Timmy says it will be a long hot summer.
Outside, Simone asks Kay if she lost her soul as well as her heart, her cousin almost died tonight. Kay says all anyone cares about is Charity Charity Charity! Even her name makes her want to throw up! Kay tells Simone that Miguel told her that he loved both her and Charity. Simone says that Miguel only loves her as a friend, but Charity is his soul mate, and if he knew how Charity ended up in hell then he'd probably never talk to her again. Simone turns around and sees Whitney with Chad, which makes her angry. Simone goes to see Chad and thanks Whitney for keeping her boyfriend company while she's hasn't been around.
Theresa's family is reunited with Miguel, and Theresa tells him that even Ethan tried to save him. Miguel thanks Ethan, who says that he will be his future brother and law, and Kay and Charity are his family, even if they don't think of him as family. Meanwhile, Ivy listens in as Sam tells Grace that God heard their prayers and brought the kids back. TC tells Sam that he needs some help with some supplies, so Sam goes with TC. Grace sees Ivy and says there are only so many prayers that God can answer. Sam begins handing out supplies, blankets and stuff, and when he reaches Ethan and Theresa, he offers them any help he can after they get married and need a place to live. A shocked Ethan tells Sam that he just lost his home, so he should concentrate on his family. Sam says that is what he is doing, and walks away. Theresa says Sam is trying to reach out to him. Ethan just wishes he would reach out to his mother. Theresa says he loves his wife, but Ethan doesn't want his mother to be alone for the rest of her life. Sam gives Grace a blanket, and then asks Hank to pass the rest of them out.
Eve finishes her examination of the children, and can't believe they have all made it out just fine. The Bennetts all hug, and Hank tells Ivy not to try and mess with this family. Jessica says they may have lost their house, but at least they have each other. Pilar tells Ivy to let Sam go, he is with his family now. Ivy says Ethan should be with Sam too! Pilar tells Ivy that perhaps someday he will be, but that is not what she is thinking. Pilar knows that Ivy is wishing to have Sam's arms around her. as Ivy rants and raves about Sam, a fed-up Pilar tells her to shut up in Spanish. Ivy is insulted, but Pilar tells Ivy that she should hear herself, does she not realize what has gone on here? Has she not heard a word Father Lonigan has said? Pilar says evil will destroy her if she does not change her ways. Ivy doesn't care and says she deserves to be with Sam. Pilar replies "Says who?" Pilar tells Ivy that she made her choice years ago, and she has to live with the consequences. Ivy says that she will not accept that!
Father Lonigan calls everyone's attention and says they should all thank God for saving the lives of their children. Sam tells Father Lonigan that he was right, it was God who saw them through this. Timmy, who is spying with Tabitha, says he helped too! Father Lonigan also thanks "the small creature" and prays for the little fellow who gave his life for the children. Timmy becomes upset because he is not dead! Tabitha tells him to settle down. Father Lonigan continues to preach to his flock, and tells them that evil is still in Harmony, and if they are not careful, it will destroy them all next time. Tabitha tells Timmy that this war has just begun, and when the last battle is fought, they will be the only ones standing. The friends in the basement growl, and Tabitha says they will prevail! Back outside, Hank and Luis tell Father Lonigan that he is scaring everyone and should tone it down. Pilar says that what Father Lonigan is saying is that there is more to evil than hell and demons. Father Lonigan says Pilar is right, there are people in this world who want something so much that they go after it without thinking of right and wrong. Father Lonigan says these people are capable of inflicting great pains on others, and can even destroy themselves in the process. Kay realizes that Father Lonigan could be talking about her, as does Ivy. However, Tabitha tells Timmy that Ivy and Kay won't listen to Father Lonigan, and they'll continue to go after the men they want. Tabitha tells Timmy that everyone out there has no idea what is in store for them.
Grace can't believe that there house is gone. Sam tells her that it could have been worse. Grace knows that, but she says this was more than just a house. Sam remembers when Grace first saw the house and she knew it was wear she wanted to live for the rest of her life, and fortunately, he already owned it. Grace remembers bringing Kay home from the hospital, and Jessica's first trick or treat. Sam promises to build her a new house, and he says they can do it together. Grace tells Sam no, their marriage is gone, just like their house. Sam refuses to believe that and won't let anyone take their marriage away from them. As they hug, a spying Ivy tells Sam that he is so wrong. Ethan catches his mom spying on Sam and Grace, and asks why she is back here alone? Ivy says she was just taking a moment to herself. Ethan thought it had to do with Sam, and he tells his mom that he never realized how lonely she was until tonight. Ivy thanks Ethan for his concern and says that she won't be alone much longer. Ethan tells her mom that she can't break up Sam's marriage, but Ivy says there may not be much of a marriage to break up. Ivy tells Ethan that Grace is going to push Sam straight into her arms. Ethan asks why Grace would do that? Ivy says it is the only solution to this situation, and that Grace understands Sam has to resolve his past with her. Ivy is positive that once they spend time together, Sam will realize he still loves her. Ivy asks Ethan to give her some time alone, so he and Theresa leave. Theresa then admits to Ethan that she fears that maybe one day he will realize he never got over Gwen.
Meanwhile, Sam tries to convince Grace that they will survive. Grace reminds Sam that he has another family, but Sam says accepting Ethan as his son doesn't mean he no longer loves her, Noah, and the girls. Sam refuses to believe Grace no longer loves him, and she admits to Sam that she wants things back the way they used to be. Sam tells her that he will rebuild their marriage, and their house exactly as it was. Grace wants to believe that can happen, but she has lost faith in them. Grace tells Sam that they cannot start over until he resolves his past with Ivy. Sam says he already knows what he feels for Ivy, and he knows what he feels for her. Grace tells Sam no short cuts this time, the only way she can believe in his love for her is if he sorts out his feelings for Ivy. A spying Tabitha tells Timmy that Grace's in for a lot of pain when she finds out what is really in Sam's heart. As they continue to talk, Sam catches Ivy spying on them, and he is furious with her. Grace tells Sam to let Ivy stay, this is about her too. Grace hopes that perhaps they can resolve this tonight, once and for all.
Father Lonigan talks to Kay about her soul. He tells her that she must do her part to get her soul back. Kay says she has done everything he's asked, what more can she do? Father Lonigan tells Kay that her motives must be absolutely pure in order to reclaim her soul.
Elsewhere, Hank tells Luis that he knows he has something on his mind, so spill it. Luis tells Hank that he wants to ask Sheridan to marry him, but he's frightened. Luis talks to Hank about his fears, and he decides that when he gets back to Sheridan's place tonight, he will ask her to marry him. Hank recalls that Luis was going to marry Beth, but Luis says he never loved Beth the way he loves Sheridan. Luis says that he always thought love was just something two people went through, like paying the rent and loosing their virginity, but then he met Sheridan. Luis says the reason he has to ask Sheridan to marry him is because he can't live without her. Sheridan overhears Luis, and she walks out from the bushes and tells Luis that she loves him too.
Chad asks Miguel and Charity what Hell was like? Miguel and CHarity says it was awful and they never thought it would end. Kay says she felt the same way. Charity says there was so much pain and suffering in hell, and she feared she would spend the rest of her days down there with those lost souls. WHen Whitney wonders what those people did to end up there, Charity says they committed sins which cost them their souls. Charity says she can't imagine knowing that she would spend the rest of her days in hell. Chad can't believe that Charity feels sorry for these demons. Charity says all those demons know if how to cause agony, so she does feel sorry for them. Simone warns Kay to change her ways, or she'll end up just like those soulless creatures in hell. Kay tells Simone to stop worrying about her and keep her eye on Whitney and Chad. Simone confronts Whitney and asks her what she is doing hanging all over her boyfriend? Chad tells Simone that there is something they have to get straight.
Out in what was the Bennett's back yard, Hank clears his throat to get Sheridan and Luis to stop kissing in front of him. Luis asks Sheridan how long she was standing back there listening to him spill his guts to Hank? Sheridan says she didn't hear all that much, just that he kinda likes her. They kiss again, and Hank ends up stealing Luis away. He urges Luis to take Sheridan to that special place and propose before he gets cold feet again. Luis says he will, and then he realizes he doesn't have a ring. Hank says SHeridan won't care, but Luis wants to do this right. Luis then remembers his grandmother's ring.
Elsewhere, TC wonders why the demons went after Charity in the first place, and how did they manage to get a hold of her? Charity says it is all such a blur, she really doesn't remember. Charity asks Kay if she remembers? Kay says she can't remember either, and maybe her brain is just fried. Father Lonigan tells Kay that unless she makes a full confession, she will never get her soul back. Kay says there must be another way, because confessing will cost her Miguel. Father Lonigan says there is no other way. Meanwhile, Reese is positive that Tabitha sent Charity to hell, and he's decided to find a way to prove his theory correct.
Meanwhile, Simone asks Chad what he has to tell her? Chad says he didn't want to get into this tonight. Simone says that he can tell her anything, he is her boyfriend. When Chad hesitates, Simone thinks that Chad wants to talk to her alone. SHe asks Whitney to please excuse them, but Whitney tells Simone that there is something the three of them need to settle. As Chad is about to tell Simone the truth, Tabitha begins to scream, as she has been captured by Reese (see below).
In yet another part of the yard, Theresa tells Ethan that she fears he is going to leave her for Gwen, his first love. Ethan tells Theresa that he will never leave her, and that his mother and Sam are a different story. Ethan says it took him a long time to decide who to marry, and he knows he made the right choice. Ethan tells Theresa that he knows she is the only person he can completely trust, who is incapable of telling him a lie. Ethan tells her that honesty is so important to her, especially now that he knows he's been lied to his whole life. Theresa recalls learning that Ethan was Sam's son, and how she hid the truth from him. Ethan tells Theresa that because they have been up front and honest with one another from the beginning, they're relationship will last forever.
And in another location, Grace wants Ivy to stay, because she is part of their lives until he faces his past. Sam says he'll do this right now, and he orders Ivy to stay away from him because he hasn't loved her in years. Sam asks Grace if he resolved things enough, and to tell him that she knows he only loves her. Grace tells Sam that if she was to take him back right now she would always wonder what might have been between him and Ivy, so she has to be sure. Ivy says she can't blame Grace. Sam tells Ivy to stay out of this because it is between him and his wife. Grace tells Sam no, this is between the three of them now. Grace tells Sam that if he wants to rebuild their marriage then he should stop arguing with her. Grace says she is no fool, and she knows that Ivy will try and take advantage of the situation, which is okay. Grace says that if Ivy can take him away from her, then she never had the marriage she really wanted. Sam tells grace that Ivy can never take him away from her. Grace hopes that this time, he is telling the truth.
As Tabitha is spying on Grace, Sam, and Ivy, Reese catches her. He tells her that he has her now, and he can prove she is the source of all the trouble in Harmony! Reese grabs Tabitha, who begins to scream for help and demand he unhand her. Everyone runs to see what is going on, and they find Tabitha smacking Reese her doll. Reese says that Tabitha is a witch and he can prove it to them! Reese says the exact same thing that happened here tonight happened hundreds of years ago, and the pilgrims found out who was behind it by making a square of evil around the house. Tabitha remembers how the square if evil lead the townspeople to her years and years ago. Tabitha asks Reese what that could have to do with her! Everyone defends Tabitha, and she eventually decides to go back home. However, Grace stops her and asks her why she came back over here? Tabitha says she was on her way to bed when she realized they had no place to sleep, so she wants to offer them her house to stay at. Sam thanks her, but says Eve and Pilar have also offered them a place to stay. Tabitha says very well, and leaves to go back home. However, Reese jumps her and vows to prove she is a witch.
Father Lonigan has to leave, but before going, makes a big speech about not letting evil into their hearts, and to always be honest. Theresa tells Whitney that she's decided to tell Ethan that she knew the truth about him. However, Theresa says she will sleep with Ethan before she tells him, because she thinks that will make him never leave her. Whitney tells Theresa that this is wrong, but Theresa says she won't talk her out of this, she will sleep with Ethan tonight! Pilar, who has been listening, tells Theresa "Over my dead body!"
Meanwhile, the Bennetts try and figure out where to go. Grace wants them to be able to stay together, and Eve and Pilar don't have enough room, and Grace's Bed and Breakfast is all filled up. Jessica suggests they take Tabitha's offer, so they decide to stay at Tabitha's. Later, Sam finds one of Grace's angels in the rubble, which makes her smile. Grace walks away, which Ivy thinks was a stupid move. She says that once Sam is gone, he won't go back to Grace.
Over at Tabitha's, Timmy asks Tabitha to read the Wizard of Oz to him. They soon get into a heated debate over whether the wicked witch is the bad guy or just misunderstood. As Tabitha talks about her plans for the Bennett's, Timmy wonders what if they Bennetts take her up on her offer. Tabitha says that wasn't a serious invitation, and she is the last person they'd want to bunk with. Suddenly, there is a knock at the door! Tabitha answers the door, and finds the Bennett clan on her doorstep. She promptly faints.
Luis and Sheridan head to Pilar's home, and as Sheridan looks at the pictures on the mantle, Luis finds his grandmother's ring. Luis packs a bag, and finds Sheridan looking at the pictures. Sheridan tells Luis that she loves this house, it is the kind of house she wants someday. Luis doesn't know why, she grew up in a mansion. Sheridan says this house has warmth, and she knows she is loved here. Luis asks her if she could get by in a place like this? Sheridan says as long as she was with him it would be a dream come true. Sheridan and Luis head to the cottage, and Luis tells Sheridan that he wants to show her how much he loves her.