In Boston, Sheridan can't stop thinking about what she did to Luis. She tells herself that she never should have signed that complaint. Tina talks to Sheridan, wondering why she isn't on her way back to Harmony. Sheridan says the only car service she could locate wasn't open, so she has to wait until morning. Sheridan also says she feels bad about putting Luis in jail. Tina says she just checked on Luis and he was sound asleep. Sheridan says she just wanted to teach Luis a lesson, she didn't think that filing these charges could ruin his career. Sheridan tells Tina that she owes Luis her life. Tina tells Sheridan that she doesn't blame Luis for doing what he did, she would have done whatever it took to get her out of Paris. She tells Sheridan that if she had stayed in Paris, those drug dealers would have iced her. Tina also thinks something else is going on, she thinks some of these troubles she's having with Luis have to do with sexual frustration. Tina accuses Sheridan of being frustrated with Luis for not taking her to bed! Sheridan thinks that is absurd, but Tina says that Luis is sex on a stick, can she honestly admit she's never fantasized about the guy? Tina gives Sheridan a romance novel and compares her and Luis to the novel. Sheridan then begins to have fantasies about Luis saving her and taking her in his arms. Sheridan tells Tina that a romance could never occur between her and Luis, never! Tina asks if that is true, why is she still here? Sheridan says she's waiting for a car, but Tina doubts that. Tina knows she is sorry for what she's done, so she should go tell Luis that she regrets signing the complaint. Meanwhile, Luis has nightmares about coming upon Sheridan's dead body, he was too late to save her from Roger and Pierre. Time and time again in his nightmares, Sheridan is killed and he is always too late. Later, Hank shows up in Boston and talks with Tina about Sheridan and Luis. Tina starts telling Hank that it is so odd that both Luis and Sheridan won't admit that they are in love with one another. Hank says he's never seen this love, and Luis has never said anything about it because he is the one who is interested in Sheridan! Tina apologizes and says he guesses she was wrong. BAck in Luis cell, SHeridan shows up to see Luis, who is still having nightmares. Luis ends up grabbing Sheridan when she tries to wake him up and gives her a kiss! As they are kissing, Hank walks in on them!
At Tabitha's place, Tabitha tells Timmy that she's going to make sure she helps Kay break up Charity and Miguel at the prom. However, right now they have to come up with a way to turn Harmony High's prom into the biggest disaster this world has seen. Tabitha starts looking through some of her old spell books for an idea. Timmy asks Tabitha if he can go to the prom with her? Tabitha says of course he can! Timmy then begins to have a disco fantasy about the prom and dancing like John Travolta with Charity. Timmy tells Tabitha his fantasy, and she says she should never have let him watch that R rated movie. Timmy says he loves movies because he gets all kinds of ideas when he watches movies. Tabitha exclaims "That is it!" Tabitha thanks Timmy for the idea, because now she knows how she will ruin the prom. Tabitha goes over to her private video collection and finds her personal copy of "Carrie." Timmy says he's never seen this movie before, and Tabitha tells him to thank his lucky stars because it is far to scary for him. Tabitha tries to think of a way to get this video to Kay so that she will do the work for them. Timmy asks how she will get it over to the Bennett's? Tabitha says he's going to go climbing again!
At the Bennett house, Charity wonders why she is having these premonitions of Miguel proposing to Kay. Miguel tells Charity that he doesn't know, but he does know that he wants to spend his life with her. He tells her to put those things out of her mind and just concentrate on the good things, like the prom. Charity asks Miguel what will happen, so he paints this scenario about how their prom will play out. Charity starts fantasizing about the prom and how everyone will applaud when they enter together.
Up in Kay's room, Simone says she will help Kay, but only if she swears to help her get Chad. Still, Simone doesn't think it is possible to break up Miguel and Charity, they will go to the prom and probably be crowned king and queen. Kay refuses to allow that to happen! Kay starts looking through her stuff to find out a way to break up Charity and Miguel.
Kay and Simone go downstairs, and Miguel asks them to join the decorating committee. He then tells Kay that they are lucky to have Charity and Reese in their lives, otherwise they we'd be going to the prom together. Kay takes it as a sign that she should be going to the prom with Miguel, not Charity!
Kay and Simone go back up to Kay's room to search for something to break up Charity and Miguel. While they look through Kay's junk, Timmy sneaks into her room, and is heard by Kay! However, Simone says something probably just fell over. Timmy hides under Kay's bed, and wonders where to plant the video. Timmy ends up sticking the video behind Kay, and Kay realizes it is the answer she's been looking for. Simone says it is just a movie, but Kay says this is Carrie, the biggest prom movie ever! Timmy tries to sneak out as Kay is telling Simone she knows exactly how to ruin the prom for Charity. Timmy is forced to hide once again, and Simone decides to search for whoever planted this tape in Kay's room.
At the Bennetts, Simone thinks someone had to plant "Carrie" in her room, but Kay thinks it dropped into her room as a sign, the answer to her prayers. Timmy eventually jumps out the window, and Tabitha catches him. Timmy tells Tabitha that he accomplished the mission.
Charity and Miguel are talking on the phone about the prom. They are both in bed while talking. Miguel is positive that they will be voted king and queen. Suddenly, Charity goes into a trance! She starts saying that on prom night the evil must be destroyed. Charity walks out of her room, and Miguel, who was left on the line, decides to get over there and see what is wrong.
Downstairs, Kay and Simone are watching "Carrie." Tabitha and Timmy are spying on them, and Timmy is blinded by what he sees. Charity comes down the steps in her trance, and Simone spots her staring at the TV. Charity doesn't even see Kay or Simone, she just goes over to the TV and starts destroying the tape and screaming "Evil!" over and over. Grace and Sam come downstairs and asks what is going on, what is wrong? Charity breaks down into tears, and Grace comforts her. Timmy feels bad for Charity, and Kay quickly grabs the tape and runs. Miguel shows up and tells Sam what happened while they were on the phone. Sam asks what they were watching that upset Charity so badly? Kay says they were watching the sound of music. Simone warns Kay that she better be careful, Charity does have those visions. Kay asks when Charity's visions have ever had anything to do with real life? Charity snaps out of her trance and remembers nothing that happened. Grace says that Charity must have just been sleepwalking. Charity says she feels fine now. Later, Kay tells Simone that if she thought Carrie's prom was bad, wait till she gets a load of Charity's. Back upstairs, Charity has nightmares about the prom.
In Boston, Sheridan wakes Luis up. He is so happy that Sheridan isn't dead that he grabs her and kisses her through the cell bars! As they are kissing, Hank shows up and sees them. When Luis snaps out of it he apologizes and says he must have been dreaming. She asks if he was dreaming about her? Luis says he doesn't remember, and it was only a dream. Hank sneaks out, and Sheridan and Luis once again start arguing. Sheridan tries to apologize for throwing Luis in jail, but he won't let her speak. Luis wonders if she will file an assault charge against him for kissing her. Sheridan says she is trying to be nice! Luis asks Sheridan to stop being so nice to him and just get out of here because he's tired of looking at her. Sheridan says that makes two of them, and she's sorry she let him kiss her. Luis says he was probably dreaming about someone else, like Beth. Sheridan is furious and leaves. Luis wonders why he did kiss Sheridan, and then starts telling himself that Sheridan means nothing to him, he could care less about her. Sheridan runs into Hank in the other room, he claims he just got here. Hank says he came to try and help. Hank wonders is going on with her, why did she leave Harmony? If Luis saved her life, why did he have him arrested? Hank thinks she had Luis arrested as pay back, and wants to know what she is paying him back for. Sheridan says that kidnapping is enough to have a guy arrested, but Hank doesn't buy her reason. Sheridan says that she didn't mean for things to go this far, she just wanted to teach Luis a lesson. Hank asks if she tried to tell that to him? Sheridan says she tried to, but she never got the words out. Sheridan tells Hank about the kiss, and she says that she doesn't think there is any way to clear the air between them. Hank asks if that bothers her? Sheridan says she doesn't think they should be talking about this, but Hank says it is okay if they talk, he can take it. Sheridan says she is sorry she put him in jail and would like to know why he kissed her. Sheridan asks Hank if he can talk to Luis for her, and he says he will. Hank goes to see Luis, and Tina talks with Sheridan again. Sheridan tells Tina how confused she is, and she's hoping Hank can find out some answers to her questions. Hank goes in to see Luis, who really isn't up for more visitors or a lecture. Hank asks Luis why he did "it," is he in love with Sheridan? Luis says of course not, but he couldn't just not do anything to help her. Hank needs to know if he is still in competition with his best friend for Sheridan? Luis says no, and he is nuts if he still wants Sheridan. Hank asks Luis if he wants him to tell Sheridan anything? He says yeah, tell her to stay the hell out of my life. Hank goes to see Sheridan and tells her that Luis is sorry he ever went to Paris and wants her to stay away from him. Sheridan says fine and walks off, and Hank smiles.
Meanwhile, Ethan calls Gwen, who tells Ethan that she misses him so much, but she doesn't know when she'll be back home. Ethan tells Gwen about the contest he and Theresa competed in, and how they tied Chad and Whitney for the perfect couple award. Gwen says that it is a good thing that she's not jealous of Theresa anymore. Ethan says that Theresa really made him laugh tonight. Gwen says that Theresa can make him laugh, as long as she is the one who makes him love.
Chad walks Whitney home, and Whitney tells him that he doesn't have to walk her to the door. Chad knows she is afraid that her parents might find out they were together. Whitney doesn't want another blow up to occur. Chad says her parents are asleep, but in case they are looking out the window, they should give them something to freak out about. Chad leans in to kiss Whitney, but stops before doing so and tells her that he would never do that, he knows she wants them to keep their distance. Chad tells Whitney that there is no reason for her parents to think anything is going on between them, though he wonders why those judges picked them as a perfect couple. Whitney says she doesn't really know. Chad then starts talking about Ethan and how he believes that Ethan does love Theresa, he just hasn't realized it. Whitney tells him that he is wrong, Theresa and Ethan come from two different worlds and can't be together. Chad replies with "Just like you and me." Whitney just says that Ethan won't fall in love with Theresa. Whitney then apologizes to Chad for hurting him, but she says that she can't get involved with him because of Tennis, that is the only reason. Chad doesn't believe that and thinks she agrees with her mom, that he is just no good. Chad says that he doesn't have a family, doesn't know who he is, and when he finds his family, he doesn't think he'll be greeted with open arms. Whitney doesn't know what else he can do, he's searched everywhere. Chad says he has one last chance, a reporter from the Herald is going to help him. Chad tells Whitney that after he helps Ethan finish planning the wedding, he's going to leave Harmony, unless a really good reason to stay pops up. Whitney says I just wish . . . ., but then she chickens out and says she wishes him the best of luck. Chad gives Whitney their trophy and hopes one day she'll find a guy who she will let love her, then she'll be part of a perfect couple for real. Chad leaves, and Whitney tries to convince herself that Chad leaving would be for the best.
Up in TC and Eve's room, TC tells Eve that she can't hide anything from him, he knows she was dreaming about Ivy and blackmail. Eve asks how he figured it out? TC says he pieced it all together, Ivy is the one being blackmailed. Eve tells him that he is wrong, and she wishes she could tell him what is going on, but she can't. TC says he deserves to know the truth, if Ivy's not being blackmailed, then who is? Eve says nothing, and TC says he is more convinced than ever that Ivy is the one being blackmailed, she is just trying to deny it. TC tells Eve that it is nice that she cares about her, but she is nothing but a high class whore. TC picks up the phone and says he's calling Ivy and telling her to stay out of their lives! Eve hangs up the phone and tells TC not to do this. TC tells Eve not to worry about Ivy, if she is being blackmailed then she probably did something to deserve it. He doesn't understand who would ever sleep with a man like Julian, and if Ivy is going after Sam and has someone helping her, he will hate that person with a passion! TC leaves to make Eve some hot milk, and Eve puts on some music and remembers singing in the Jazz Club. Eve remembers her good friend Crystal, and how they knew all each other's secrets.
Chad goes to the Jazz Club and sees the new singer, Crystal! Crystal dedicates the song to an old friend, who just happens to be Eve! Though she doesn't say her name, it is the same song Eve remembers singing.
Ivy has a dream about meeting Sam in their old meeting place, so she decides to go there to meet him, because she's sick of waiting for him. Ivy goes to their old meeting place, and finds an old note from Sam. A car drives by, and Ivy says that could be one of Alastair's spies, and if he finds out what happened on her wedding night then she could loose everything! However, it turns out to be Sam. Ivy shows Sam the note to prove how much he loved her, and probably still does. She thinks they can have another chance, but Sam says it is over and has been over for years. Ivy says that this love note survived the ravages of time, and so has their love! She hugs Sam and says they can be together again, the way it used to be, the way it was meant to be! Ivy tells Sam that she loves him and he has to believe her. Sam says he believed her that night she came to her after she married Julian, and when he woke up the next morning after making love to her, she was gone! Sam tells her that is when he went to Boston and never looked back. Sam tries to walk away, but Ivy won't let him. She grabs him again and says she knows he still loves her! Sam says he's going home, to his wife. He assures Ivy that they will never be together again. Sam leaves, and Ivy says they will be together again, and Eve will make it happen.
Kay and Simone go over to the Russell's house. Kay is bummed that her copy of Carrie has been ruined because there are so many great ideas she could have gotten from it. Simone is glad the tape was destroyed and hopes she never sees it again because it was disgusting! They start talking about Whitney and Chad, and Simone is angry with Whitney for lying to her about her feelings for Chad. Kay suddenly gets an idea as to how they can get her hooked up with Chad. Kay says that they need to let her parents hear about what happened with Chad and Whitney tonight!
Whitney is still on her porch trying to convince herself that it is best that Chad leaves Harmony. She tells herself that her mom really has it in for Chad, and she can't let her mom down because she is the best role model in the world. Whitney goes to open the door, and sees her mom in the living room listening to music. She fears that her mom might have seen her out here with Chad. Whitney sneaks in through the backdoor, and is caught by Simone and Kay. Whitney yells at Kay once again for opening her big mouth the other day. Simone says that Kay does shoot off her big mouth a lot, but she has an uncanny way of zeroing in on the truth. Simone asks Whitney what she was doing with Chad tonight? Whitney says she has no idea what she is talking about. Simone calls her a liar and says she saw them at the benefit tonight on TV! Simone asks Whitney why she lied to her about not going after her boyfriend? She accuses her of lying to everyone by claiming she didn't care about anything but tennis. Whitney says that she did not know Chad was going to be there, she only went with Theresa. Simone then asks why she had to do a sexy dance for him? Whitney claims the MC made her, and she wanted to prove that he meant absolutely nothing to her. Whitney refuses to try and explain herself to Simone, because she won't believe a word she says, but she does ask her not to tell their parents.
Eve is busy thinking about the past and talking to her friend Crystal in Boston. Eve says she has made the biggest mistake she possibly could, so she needs to leave Boston and start a new life. TC approaches Eve and asks her what is wrong, she looks like she's seen a ghost! He realizes that this song has meaning to her. He remembers when they were trying for a third child, a son, but it never happened. TC says they could try for that third child again. Eve isn't so sure, but TC loves the idea of having a son to carry on the Russell name. Eve remembers telling Crystal that she was pregnant, and how she wanted it to be a boy. Eve said she couldn't tell Crystal who the father was, and she had to leave Boston. Eve tells TC that a baby right now would only upset their lives. Suddenly, they hear the girls arguing, and go into the kitchen right as Whitney is asking Kay and Simone not to tell mom and dad about it. TC want to know what they aren't supposed to know about? Whitney says she just forgot she had a paper to write, but she'll get an extension and will get an A on it. Eve asks if she is sure that is all this is about? Simone assures her mom that it is. Eve asks how the benefit went, and Whitney says it raised a lot of money and she had good time. TC and Eve decide to turn in for the night, and Kay asks Whitney is she swears she won't have anything more to do with Chad Harris? Because that is why she kept her mouth shut about the benefit. Whitney says good night, but Simone refuses to let her leave until she answer's Kay's question. Whitney says she has no feelings for Chad, and she tells Kay to stay out of this or she's going to hurt her! Simone says things could still change between them, but Whitney says they won't because Chad is getting ready to leave Harmony for good! Simone is heartbroken, but Whitney says she's glad he is leaving because he's been nothing but trouble for this family. After Whitney leaves, Kay tells Simone that they will keep Chad in Harmony by helping him find his family.
Upstairs, Eve starts singing, and TC tells her that she has one sweet voice. Eve says it is an easy song to sing. TC tells her that she is a terrific singer, she must have had a lot of music lessons when she was growing up. TC says says it is a shame that their girls didn't inherit her love for music, but maybe their son still could. Eve once again tells TC that a baby is out of the question.
At the Harmony Jazz Club, Chad questions the bartender about Crystal. After Crystal finishes her song, she sits at the bar next to Chad, who offers to buy her a drink. Crystal refuses and says she buys her own drinks. They start talking about music, and how well Crystal sings. Crystal tells Chad that he should hear her friend sing the song she just sang, it would break his heart. Chad says perhaps he has, and asks what her name is? Crystal says he wouldn't know her because she quit singing a long time ago, and she could have been a big star. Chad asks what stopped this woman? Crystal says she got side tracked, she got pregnant! Chad says he thought he was the only one who got bad breaks in life. They start talking about the music industry, and Crystal eventually asks him his name. Chad tells her his last name, and she is shocked because that is her last name, Harris! Chad is shocked and says he came to Harmony to find out who his parents are, and he asks if she knows anything about them? Crystal says that Harris is a very common name, and she is not from Harmony. However, they could be related, she doesn't know. Chad says he is on the lighter side of black, and he could have a white parent. Crystal asks how long he has been trying to track down his parents? Chad explains the whole long story to her, and how he has come up with nothing but dead ends. Crystal asks him what his first name is, and she's even more shocked to learn it is Chad. Crystal says this is not possible! Chad asks Crystal if she knows who he is? Crystal says she might, about nineteen or twenty years ago someone asked to borrow her maiden name and her father's first name for their son!
Hank takes Sheridan to the Harmony Jazz Club and offers to show her a wonderful time, if she'll let him. Sheridan doesn't think she should be thinking about a relationship right now, but Hank says she just hasn't found the right guy yet. Hank leaves to rustle themselves up some drinks, and later takes Sheridan home. Sheridan doesn't know if she'll be able to get to sleep tonight, because of jet lag, so Hank offers to stay and keep her company. Sheridan thanks him, but says he's done enough. She also thanks him for not being upset with him for not filing that complaint against Luis. Hank says he'll call her in the morning, and he doesn't want her thinking or worrying about Luis. Sheridan remembers when Luis took her home one night and gave her a kiss. Suddenly, Hank grabs Sheridan and forces her into a kiss!
At the cottage, Sheridan and Hank are still kissing, but Sheridan dreams she is kissing Luis! After the kiss ends, she realizes she was kissing Hank. She tells Hank that she's really tired, and she wants to turn in. Hank is confused, especially after that kiss. Sheridan says she is just really tired, and still feeling a bit guilty about what she did to Luis. Ethan shows up, so Hank decides to leave, but says he'll call her in the morning. Ethan asks Sheridan if she and Hank are now . . . Sheridan tells Ethan it is not what he thinks, Hank is a good friend, and there are just some people you don't feel anything romantic for. Ethan then confronts Sheridan and says that is because her heart still belongs to Luis! Sheridan admits that she was thinking of Luis while kissing Hank, but that doesn't mean her heart belongs to him. She says that she has just been spending a lot of time with him, and right now she is just angry with him. Ethan knows she had him arrested, and asks if she feels guilty about it? Sheridan says she did, but she doesn't now because he doesn't want to have anything to do with her. Ethan says she must be very confused about Luis. Sheridan thinks maybe Julian was right about Luis, but how could he have known he should trust Luis? How could he have been so sure? Ethan asks if she was sure it was Luis she saw and heard that night on the pier? Sheridan is positive it was him, unless he has a twin. Ethan notices her place is a wreck, so he suggests she sleep in the main house tonight. He also tells her that he thinks when it comes to Luis, she should listen to his heart, because he did save her life at the risk of his own. Ethan asks what if she found out she was wrong, that Luis never intended to use her? Sheridan says that would change everything.
Ethan and Sheridan go into Julian's office, and reminisce when it was once their grandfather's office. Ethan says he thought this desk held the secrets to the world in it. Sheridan wonders what secrets it holds today.
Hank is walking home when he gets a mysterious call. Hank tells the person that he is through with that part of his life, he won't do it anymore. The person on the other end then threatens to bring "her" into it.
At the Russells, Kay assures Simone that if they help Chad find his parents then he will stay in Harmony. Simone says that won't work, they have tried for months to find his family and have found nothing! Kay tells her to think positive, there has to be a way to track down his parents. Simone calls Chad, learns he is not leaving Harmony after all, and that he is at the Jazz Club. Kay then comes up with a plan so they can sneak out and go to the Jazz Club. Kay dresses Simone up like a Jenny Jones teen obsessed with sex! Unfortunately they are almost caught by Eve, but manage to hide.
Eve can't stop thinking about singing at the Jazz Club, and talking to Crystal about her pregnancy. Eve thanks God that Crystal is gone because she knows what happened, and no one can ever know what happened. Later, Eve sees the advertisement for Crystal at the Jazz Club, and she freaks out. She decides to go to the club and try and convince Crystal to leave town before she tells anyone about her past.
At the Harmony Jazz Club, Crystal tells Chad that one of her friends asked to borrow her father's name and her maiden name for their child. Chad asks who this person was, he has to know! Suddenly, Simone calls Chad's cell phone. Simone asks if he is leaving Harmony? Chad says he was going to, but plans have changed because he has a lead on his family. Chad says he has to go because he's in the middle of something. Kay pushes Simone to find out where Chad is, so he tells her where he is. After he hangs up, Chad asks Crystal who borrowed the names from her? He tells her that she has to tell him, but she gets up and says he doesn't have to tell him a damn thing! Chad apologizes for yelling at her, and tells her that he needs to know who he is because he feels like he has a hole inside of him. Crystal understands and says she wants to help him. Unfortunately, her break ends, so she has to take to the stage, but asks Chad not to go anywhere. As Crystal sings a song for Chad, a tear rolls down his cheek. Later, Simone shows up, and Chad is shocked to see her dressed the way she is. Crystal returns to Chad, and he introduces her to Simone. Crystal tells Chad that she doesn't think this is the right time to do this at. Chad tells her he though she was going to help her? Crystal asks if Simone is cool to talk in front of? Chad says she is, she has been trying to help him find his family since he got to Harmony. Crystal tells Chad that she can tell him who one of his parents is.
Julian shows up at the club and looks around the place. Later, Eve also shows up at the club to find Crystal and stop her from telling anyone her secrets.
Back in Boston, Tina brings Luis some food, and tells him that his friend Hank took Sheridan back to Harmony. Luis says that Hank can have Sheridan because he has no interest in her. He refuses to interfere in Sheridan's life again, and the best thing that could happen to him is if he never saw Sheridan Crane again. Tina tells Luis that she can't fool him, she saw the sparks between them. Luis admits there was a time they were getting close, and he thought they might even have something. Tina asks what happened? Luis says he doesn't know, one day things were great, the next she is slapping him across the face. Tina asks why she slapped him, but Luis says he doesn't know, and she won't tell him. Luis says he and Sheridan have had a rocky relationship, and he tells her about how they met. He also explains to Tina about he feelings about the Cranes. Tina tells Luis that if he and Sheridan could clean this mess up then they might realize they don't hate each other, the love one another. Luis tells Tina that she is nuts!