At the mansion, Ethan lectures Ivy and Rebecca about how to deal with Theresa if they want a case for themselves. Ivy, however, refuses to allow the tramp to have one damn thing! Ethan tells his mother than he's made some progress with the divorce courts, but it isn't definite yet. However, Ethan says if she would compromise he could find a solution. Ivy tells Ethan that Theresa is just playing him. Later, Ivy and Rebecca talk about Ethan and Gwen's budding relationship, and how to deal with Theresa. Ivy says she has made some progress in dealing with Theresa. Ivy says she's made sure every lawyer in town knows that if the they take on Theresa, they will be destroyed.
At the LF's, Theresa is steaming and vows to carry out Julian's plan to get Ethan, the Crane money and power, damn the consequences! Theresa gets out the phonebook and begins looking up lawyers. Theresa calls up lawfirms to hire herself a lawyer, only to find herself being hung-up on. Whitney figures out what is happening, Ivy has threatened everyone in town. Theresa says there must be a solution, and finds a new lawfirm in town that just open who might not have been scared off yet. Theresa calls them up, and they agrees to take her on.
Theresa meets with her lawyer, Woody Stumper. Woody tells Theresa that he has researched her case and he feels she is being mistreated, and they must right this wrong! Theresa and Woody head to the mansion, and Woody says that they have something that belongs to her client and they want it back! Woody then presents Ivy and Rebecca with papers that state they are going to sue their sorry butts for what is rightfully Theresa's, the name, money and the house!
At the Lobster Shack, Hank rigs the contest so Luis wins the trip. Luis is not happy about winning the trip, and says he doesn't want it! Luis says he appreciates the prize, and the waiter says he can give it to a member of his family. Luis refuses to take the trip, and goes to get the trip. Beth tells Hank it was a bad idea to switch the plates, and when MAttie learns Hank switched the plates she throws a little fit. Mattie says they would have had a fabulous time, and walks off like a little snob. Beth tells Hank that he really screwed up tonight, but Hank isn't so sure. Luis returns, and Luis and Beth take off.
On his walk home, Luis discover the wharf being remodeled and the old railings being burned! Beth finds the railing burning and tries to save it, but burns herself. Luis is touched by Beth's actions, and he thinks the burning of the wood is a sign that he needs to move on with his life. He then asks Beth to go to Bermuda with him.
On the islands, Brian tells Sheridan about Bermuda. Sheridan/Diana hopes she will be recognized once they get there. Brian wishes she would just live her life to the fullest and forget about the past, but he knows its not fair to say that. Brian just doesn't want to see her get her hopes up and being let down again, but Sheridan says her hopes are all she has. Brian tells her that sometimes people with amnesia get their memories back all at once. Brian notices Sheridan has doodles something in the sand, but when Brian alerts her to it, she stops and doesn't remember what she was drawing. She was drawing a heart like the one Luis carved for her with their initials inside.
At Tabitha's, Tabitha burns the book of spells in the fire. However, once she leaves the room, the book floats out of the fire, puts itself out, and sets down on the table. Up in Tabitha's attic, Zombie Charity plays with a bunch of pillow dolls that look like the residents of Harmony. Tabitha shows up and tells Charity that the spell book is gone forever, she burned it. Charity knows she did it for Timmy because she loves the little brat. Charity tells her that she is weak, Timmy is her soft spot. Charity also says she can't guarantee Timmy's longevity, he might still die if he tries to rescue the real Charity. Later, Timmy shows up snooping as usual, and sees the dolls Charity is playing with. She tells them that Sheridan and Luis are headed for something that will change their lives forever. Timmy begs Tabitha to tell him where the spell book is, so she tells him that she burned it. He asks her why she did it? Charity says she did it to save his life. Timmy says that was the only way to save Charity, now she will die. When Timmy continues to keep whining, Charity says Tabitha is a loser as a bad guy, she loves him more than the witchcraft. Timmy tells Tabitha that he loves her too. MEanwhile, the book of spells floats up to the attic!
At the Crane mansion, Woody tells Ivy and Rebecca that they are sueing them for everything that is due to Theresa, including the Crane name, money, and mansion! Pilar shows up at this point, and wonders what Theresa is up to now. Ivy says she won't win, but Woody says he will Miss Winthrop! Ivy demands she be called Mrs. Crane. Pilar can't believe what is going on here, and Ivy and Rebecca are infuriated by Woody's tactics. Woody says Theresa is the real MRs. Julian Crane, and they are just posers! Ivy says Theresa will never see one dime of the Crane money. Woody tells them to start packing, because Theresa will be moving in soon and they will want back rent from both of these women. Ivy tells them to get out, and Ethan begs Theresa to stop this. Theresa refuses, and says this house belongs to her. Theresa says she is going to throw them both out like they did her! Suddenly, Rebecca lunges at Theresa and strangles her!
On the docks, Luis thinks the burning of the railing is a sign that he needs to move on with his life. He asks Beth to go with him to Bermuda. Beth says she'd love to go with him, but only if he's sure. Luis says he's not sure if he's up to it, but if he's going to find out, he wants to find out with her. Later, Hank shows up with the prize information, and is shocked to learn Luis and Beth are going on the trip. Luis thinks everything is telling him that it is finally time to move on. Luis opens the envelope, and learns the trip is to the Bermuda Pavilions, the place he was with Sheridan before she died. They also get tickets to a dinner dance being held during their time there. Luis is stunned, so Beth says they don't have to go if he's changed his mind. Luis says he still wants to go with her. She says she would love to go, and hugs him. Luis remains behind to watch the railing finish burning, and thinks it is time for him to move on once and for all.
On the island, Brian and Sheridan/Diana pack the boat for their trip to Bermuda. Liz brings Brian his old dufflebag, packed with some of his favorite things. Sheridan remains hopeful that someone in Bermuda will recognize her. Liz asks them where they are staying? Sheridan blurts out "The Pavilions" and she doesn't know why she knew that was the place. Liz suggests maybe she stayed there as a guest before. Liz then gives Sheridan a gift, tickets to the dinner dance Bermuda holds each spring. Liz says she thought she would be able to go, and bought them for herself, but things didn't work out. Sheridan gets her hopes up that someone will recognize her. Later, Brian, Sheridan, and Liz all eat dinner before Brian and Sheridan set sail. When Sheridan excuses herself, Liz reminisces about old times, but says she never had the right to assume he'd invite her to go to Bermuda with him. Brian leaves, and Liz wonders why he loves DIana, someone who doesn't even love him. Later, Sheridan realizes she might not have the right clothes for the resort, so Liz offers to give her some of her stuff.
At the mansion, Rebecca lunges at Theresa and begins strangling her when Theresa throws Ivy and Rebecca out! Theresa breaks free, and Rebecca and Ivy begin chasing Theresa around the mansion! Ethan, Gwen, Woody, and Pilar save Theresa. Ethan scolds Rebecca for attacking a pregnant woman, and he tells his mother that she is in no condition to fight! Theresa is shaken, but catches her breath. Pilar and Ethan want to talk to Theresa about her lawyer, whom neither of them like. When Woody learns Theresa was involved with Ethan, he thinks it will help their case even more. He paints a picture of Theresa being passed around their family, but Ethan says that isn't how it was! Ethan begs Theresa to trust him and work things out between the two of them. He asks her if he trusts him enough to let him do that. Theresa says this is business, not personal, and she refuses to dump her attorney. Woody soon realizes that Theresa is after more than the Crane name and fortune, she is after Ethan. Pilar asks Theresa if she is doing all of this to get Ethan back? Theresa says she does want Ethan back, she doesn't care about the money at all. Woody and Pilar are both stunned. Woody doesn't understand how her plan is going to win Ethan back. Theresa tells him to just trust her. Meanwhile, Ethan and Gwen tell Rebecca and Ivy that Theresa's strong arm tactics are probably due to them throwing her off the estate the other day and lying to her. Ethan says Theresa is carrying Julian's child and she is entitled to some kind of support from the Cranes. Ivy says "never!" Woody tells Ivy and Rebecca to start looking for new places to live, because they are going to be evicted from this mansion very soon. Theresa and Woody then leave.
Hank, Luis, and Beth go back to the Book Cafe for some coffee. Beth goes to get them coffee, and Hank pushes Luis to try and explore his old feelings for Beth again. Luis tells him to slow down a bit. Hank says he's sorry, he's just happy he's moving on. Later, over coffee, Hank reads a book about a guy who writes a message, puts it in a bottle, and throws it in the ocean and hopes it reaches her. Luis says he did that awhile back hoping it would find its way to Sheridan. Luis tells them about the letter, which Beth says is beautiful. He apologizes for dredging Sheridan up again, but she says she knows how much he loved Sheridan. Luis assures Beth that he has finally accepted that Sheridan is gone, and he is ready to move on with his life.
Brian and Sheridan/Diana board the boat and get ready to sail to Bermuda. They then set sail for Bermuda, and Sheridan notices something in the water. Brian shines a light on it, and it turns out to be a bottle. He thinks it is trash, but Sheridan isn't so sure. Brian fetches the bottle, which has a letter inside. Sheridan opens it, and it is the letter from Luis! She reads the letter, which moves her to tears. She wonders if the letter could be from the man that she loved.
Down on the sea, the boom hits Sheridan/Diana and knocks her into the water. She falls unconscious and sinks to the ocean floor. BRian dives in after her, and pulls her to the surface. However, she thinks it is Luis and kisses him. He takes her back up to the boat, and she asks him what his name is? He asks her if she doesn't remember? She says she does, but then she realizes she is talking to Brian. She claims she thought he was her dead lover, and then she begins having memory flashes of past lives. She sees herself with BRian on the Titanic after losing Luis/Liam, and later that they were married. She tells Brian that they had children, and they were very happy. Brian tells her perhaps they are meant to be together, and gives her a kiss.
Theresa and Ethan agree to do something nice for Chad, and take him to a recording studio where he can work on his music. The studio is dark, and Whitney and Theresa end up seeing glowing yellow eyes staring at them! Ethan and Chad don't see the eyes, and Whitney thinks they are the eyes of evil, and that Theresa's deal with Julian has brought evil back to Harmony. Theresa refuses to believe that. Chad is grateful to Ethan and Theresa for helping him jump start his music career, and he asks Ethan to draw up a formal contract which will give the Cranes 20% of any money his music makes. Ethan says they have enough money as is, but Chad says he doesn't take handouts. As Chad tinkers with the equipment, Theresa tries to convince Whitney to sing for Chad. Whitney refuses, claiming she doesn't want to, but Theresa knows she is lying. Later, Chad puts a song together and then asks Whitney if she'll sing it. She says she can't, and runs out of the studio in tears. Whitney tells herself that she just can't be around Chad, and runs home crying. Meanwhile, Theresa talks to Ethan, who tells her that this was a great idea she had and she is a wonderful person. Theresa thinks Julian's plan is working, and then gets a chill. Over her shoulder we see the eyes of evil once again.