At the Seascape, many of the residents of Harmony gather for dinner. The Bennetts, Russells, and Lo-Fitz all arrive as Ivy and Rebecca spy on them. Rebecca wants to know what Ivy is up to, but she claims she is up to nothing. Zombie Charity has invited Tabby and Timmy to dine with them, and ZC assures Kay that she will help her get Miguel. When Kay walks off, Charity says that girl is becoming a pain in the butt. Theresa shows up, and everyone is proud of her for making a break with Ethan. They all go inside and sit at their respective tables. Miguel wonders if Charity is coming. Grace says she is, so Miguel says he'll sit with the Bennetts, until his family gets here.
Gwen and Ethan happening to be dining at the Seascape as well. Ethan tells Gwen that he can't be with Theresa anymore, and Theresa has maken a step towards independance and doesn't want to see him anymore either. Gwen is shocked, but says she'll always be here for him. Chad, who is working there this night, talks with Ethan for a bit. Chad ends up running into Whitney, and he tells her one days she will realize her whole life has been one big lie. When Ethan sees that Theresa is here, he decides to leave. Theresa's family asks her if she wants to leave, but Theresa says no, and that Ethan shouldn't have to leave either. Theresa says it is a small town and they are bound to run into one another from time to time. Luis goes over and tells Ethan that Theresa wants him to stay, they have to get used to running into one another. Ethan realizes that Theresa is right, and she is acting very mature.
TC and Eve scold Whitney for talking to Chad. Whitney tells her parents not to worry, she won't see Chad again.
Zombie Charity joins her family for dinner, and acts sickenly sweet to everyone. She then shocks her family by saying she invited Tabitha and Timmy, because she heard her talking about dinner tonight, and so she is going to sit with them. Grace and Sam think Charity is being very sweet to Tabitha. Miguel decides to go sit with his family. Kay tells him that he can stay with them, but he says he should be with his family. Grace then asks Kay to go to the ladies room with her and have a talk. In the ladies room, Grace accusses Kay of taking advantage of the situation to go after Miguel. Kay says she isn't, and the two end up fighting about it. Grace asks Kay to stop pursuing Miguel. Kay says she is only his friend, and if he wants to hang out with her then she should be happy for her. Grace asks Kay to give up on Miguel, which makes Kay furious. Kay says she favors Charity and John over her, and she doesn't understand why what she wants doesn't count for anything! Grace says what counts is doing the right thing. Kay says what she has learned about doing the right thing doesn't pay, and if she wants something she has to depend on herself. Kay says she wants Miguel, and nothing and no one will stop her!
At the Lo-Fitz table, Theresa asks Miguel her question, would he do something wrong to get Charity back? Miguel says he wouldn't. Later, Hank asks Kay Theresa's question, and she says it depends how much you love the person, and if you think your the only person who can make them happy.
Ivy comes in and waits for her table, and is shocked to learn Rebecca called ahead and added herself to Ivy's table. Ivy tells the maitre'de that she doesn't want to sit with Rebecca, but he says her table is the last they have and there is nothing they can do. Rebecca goes to powder her nose, and Ivy decides to show Eve Russell who is boss. Ivy produces a tape, and leaves it with a note and some money asking it to be played. The tape is given to Chad, and Sam catches Ivy talking to herself about the DNA test results. He wonders why? Ivy says she is just upset to be involved in these schemes, but Sam says she's been involved in these things before. Rebecca returns and agrees with Sam, she has done horrid things before to try and get Sam. Ivy says the results will prove her innocent, and Sam says she better hope they do for Ethan's sake. Sam says she will be dead to both him and Ethan!
Chad plays the tape of Eve singing, and it freaks Eve out. TC thinks the voice sounds very familiar, and he really likes it. Simone thinks she knows who it is, it is Whitney! TC says it isn't Whitney, this woman is more mature and has been through a lot of pain. TC says he knows this voice, he heard it at Julian's library one night. TC says Julian is probably why that woman is hurting so much. Eve decides to ask Chad to change the music since this night is supposed to be about celebrating. Eve confronts Chad about the tape, and he says he doesn't know who it is, the waiter just asked him to play it. Eve asks for the tape, and he wants to know why? She says just because and demands it! Chad doesn't get her at all, so she says she'll pay him for it! Chad says he doesn't want her money, and gives her the tape. Eve destroys the tape, and confronts Ivy for doing this. Ivy says if she doesn't change the test results, she'll expose her secrets! Later, Whitney accusses Chad of playing that song to manipulate her. Chad says the waiter gave him the tape, but she doesn't believe him and tells him to leave her alone!
Zombie Charity, Tabitha, and Timmy all spy on the various people of Harmony. Theresa stands up and makes an announcement to everyone. She thanks everyone who has been kind to her lately, and she says everyone's dinner is on her. Everyone toasts to Theresa, especially Tabby and Charity! Pilar tells Theresa that she doesn't have that kind of money, but Theresa says she knows what she is doing. Theresa goes on and appologizes to her family and friends for hurting them the way she did recently. Theresa thanks the Russells and the Bennetts for being second families to her, and she thanks her friends Theresa and Chad. Theresa says that everyone in this room has taught her so much. Theresa then thanks her new friends Ivy and Rebecca, who have taught her about life, love, and how to get what she wants. She says that is why dinner is on her, Mrs. Julian Crane! Everyone gasps.
Down on the island, Liz scolds Brian for spending too much helping Diana and not doing his own job. Brian wants to go to bed, but Liz says she needs those guests rooms painted before tomorrow. Brian says okay, he'll do it now. Meanwhile, Diana/Sheridan sleeps and continues to dream about Luis. When she wakes up from her dream, she says "Brian!" Sheridan goes to see Brian, who is of course painting the rooms without his shirt on. Sheridan thinks he must be exhausted and thinks he could do this tomorrow, but he says Liz needs the room tomorrow. Sheridan realizes he was supposed to do this today, but he helped her instead. Sheridan tells him he is all together a wonderful man, and decides to help him paint. Brian insists she go back to bed, but she won't take no for an answer. Brian and Sheridan end up getting into a paint fight, and then take a midnight swim to wash it off. Liz comes to bring Brian some food, only to find the room empty, and not finished, and Sheridan's robe on the ground. Sheridan and Brian finish their swim, and continue flirting.
In Harmony at the seascape, Theresa tells everyone that dinner is on her, Mrs. Julian Crane! Everyone in the restaurant gasps. Ivy and Rebecca are furious because they both think they are Mrs. Julian Crane. Pilar and Luis tell Theresa to stop this, but Theresa says she has enough money to support their family for the rest of their lives. Theresa says she has a baby now, and she has to put this baby first. Theresa says she is married to Julian and carrying his baby, and therefore she is going to give this child what he or she is entitled to. Meanwhile, Ivy demands Ethan stop Theresa from trying to take the Crane fortune from her. Elsewhere, Grace begins to feel that something is wrong, something is very wrong. Grace asks Charity if she is feeling anything tonight, but Zombie Charity says she isn't feeling anything. Grace says she feels like evil is here, and what Theresa is doing is going to cause pain for a lot of people. Charity says she senses nothing. Grace thinks she must be mistaken then. Gwen attempts to calm Ivy and Rebecca down as Ethan talks with Theresa about what she is doing. Ethan tells Theresa that she's not really married to Julian, she was drunk and doesn't remember being married to him. Theresa says that is right. Ethan says he is representing his mother, contesting the divorce Julian got, and he says that Ivy deserves what is rightfully hers. Theresa says that Julian divorced Ivy, and married her, and then he got her pregnant. Ethan says it still isn't a real marriage, she never loved Julian. Theresa says Ivy never did either, she lied to Julian every day they were married. Theresa says she is Mrs. Julian Crane, and the mother of his child, so it is her right to claim everything that is rightfully hers! Meanwhile, the Bennetts decide to head home, and Theresa's family doesn't know what has gotten into her. Ivy and Rebecca continue to argue about who the real Mrs. Crane is, and Theresa chimes in. Theresa tells them both that they aren't Mrs. Crane, she is. She then asks them both to move out of her house, tonight! Ivy has an asthma fit, and Eve checks her out. Ivy continues to blackmail Eve, but Eve refuses to be blackmailed. Eve tells Ivy that she hopes Theresa take all the Crane money and leaves her with nothin! Gwen talks to her mom about how funny things have turned out for her, and she tells her mom that her plots and schemes always backfire and she wants no more of them. Elsewhere, Chad talks to Whitney because he thinks this is just another plan of Theresa's to get Ethan back. Whitney says she wouldn't know. Chad says at least Theresa is following her heart, inspite of what her parents tell her to do. Whitney tells Chad that her parents just don't want her to be hurt. They once again begin to argue about Whitney's parents. Whitney claims her parents are perfect, but Chad says nobody is perfect, and people who appear to be always have some flaws on in the inside. Later, Beth shows up because Hank invited her. Luis basically disses Beth to be with his family, and Beth tells Hank that she just can't compete with a ghost. Hank thinks it is time for that ghost to dissapear! Zombie Charity says this is all going perfectly, but she wants to up the stakes a bit. Zombie walks off, and Rebecca heads to the ladies room where "Julian" appears to her in the mirror! She wants to know what he wants from her, and he says he wants to tell her who killed him! Zombie Charity returns to her table, and Rebecca storms out of the bathroom and announces that she knows who killed Julian! Rebecca then asks Sam to arrest Theresa for Julian's murder!
Outside the seascape, David talks to Grace, who is waiting for Sam, about her premonition. Grace says Charity didn't sense anything, and her premonitions are much more stronger. The two then watch John and Jessica talking, and Grace tells David that John is an answer to her prayers, so she needs to know if he isn't really her son. Before David says anything, Jessica lets out a scream. She only tripped, and John caught her. Grace appologizes to David for putting him on the spot, because she knows John is her son.
Down on the island, Brian and Sheridan/Diana clean up after their swim. They decide to start a fire to warm up, and Brian points out the constilation of Diana to Sheridan. Sheridan agrees to wake Brian up if he wants to take a nap and rest a bit. He says okay, and curls up and goes right to sleep. Later, Brian wakes up, finds Sheridan gone, and heads back to the hotel. He is shocked when he finds that Sheridan has painted the rooms for him! Sheridan says she just wanted to do something nice for him. Brian says it is probably the nicest thing anyone has never done for him. Sheridan accidentaly gets paint on him, and they decide to head back to the beach.
Back in Harmony, Hank finds Luis on the docks. Hank asks him if everything is okay? Luis is worried about Theresa, and says if she doesn't snap out of it she will be in trouble. Hank thinks there is more going on with Luis. Luis tells Hank to just stay out of his love life, and walks off. Hank says Luis needs a refresher course, and he's the one to give it to him. Luis continues to think about Sheridan, and ends up heating an alarm going off in the Book Cafe. Luis investigates, and turns off the alarm. He ends up catching Beth running around and acting suspicious, in her own store! Beth says she was just trying to find out who set the alarm off, and Luis finds that some punk kid threw a rock through the window. It is of course Hank, who is trying to fix up Luis and Beth whether they like it or not. Luis tries to help Beth, and ends up ranting and raving about Theresa. In order to shut Luis up, Beth ends up kissing him!
Back at the Seascape, Rebecca demands Sam arrest Theresa for Julian's murder! Theresa says she did not kill Julian! Rebecca says she knows what she saw! Sam asks Rebecca if she saw Theresa kill Julian? Pilar says Theresa is a good girl, she would never take a human life! Everyone in the restaurant begins thinking about how they stalked Julian that night. Pilar asks everyone to vouch for Theresa, and her friends do. Ethan says if charges are pressed, he will defend Theresa. Ivy says she will not allow it, but TC says it won't come to Ethan defending her because nobody believes Theresa killed Julian. Rebecca still continues to accuse Theresa of being a money, grubbing slut. Pilar slaps Rebecca, and says Theresa is nothing like her! Miguel has to hold Pilar back, and Sam asks Rebecca what she knows? Rebecca says she saw Theresa at the wharf, and she saw her rushed into the cannery with a gun! Rebecca says that is when she heard the shot, but she admits she didn't see Theresa fire the shot. Pilar says everyone here was angry at Julian, and she reminds Rebecca that she had a gun with a bullet missing. Rebecca says Julian was better alive to her than dead, and she claims she was only at the wharf getting some air. She then says she also heard Ivy's wheelchair down at the wharf that night. Ivy says she did not kill Julian, she couldn't handle the wheelchair and a gun at the same time. Ivy says she was there and heard a voice she recognized, Eve Russell! Eve claims she was there to talk to Julian about the fight he and TC had, but Ivy says Eve had a gun in her hand! TC defends his wife and says that Julian is dead, and whoever killed him did this world a favor, so they should just leave it there. Sam says he can't do that, he has to find out who killed Julian. Everyone begins talking with one another about their motives, and Simone ends up telling Chad that she doesn't believe he drugged Whitney. He thanks her, and she gives him a hug and says he can always count on her. Later, when TC confronts Chad about him being a little punk, Chad tells TC that he has more to worry about, like where he and Eve was the night of Julian's murder! Chad says he may be street trash, but at least he's never been accused of murder! Elsewhere, Rebecca and Pilar continue arguing about Theresa's guilt of innocense. Sam assures Rebecca that he will find out who killed Julian and make them pay, no matter who it it! Meanwhile, Tabitha steals a lobster and tries to run, but is caught by a waiter. He tells her that if she doesn't give it back, he'll call the police. Timmy claims that his friends memory isn't what it used to be, and he attempts to talk to her. Tabitha refuses to give back the lobster, and they end up fighting over her purse. Tabitha ends up being bit by the lobster. Timmy gets the lobster off of Tabitha, and throws it on the waiter. He and Tabitha then make a run for it.
At the LF's, house, Luis and Pilar scold Theresa for what she did tonight. Luis says she just gave herself a motive for murder, but Theresa says the whole town has motives for wanting Julian dead, and she is only thinking of her baby. She also says she is going to share the advantages of being Mrs. Crane with her family, and no one will stop her. Theresa and Luis begin arguing, and Theresa says some hurtful things to Luis about Sheridan, who she thinks would never have been able to give up the fortune even for him. She apologizes, and says she just wants to use the Crane money for good. Pilar says that money will bring no good, and she asks her to think what Jesus would do. Theresa says she'll think about it. Theresa goes up to her room, and is greeted by "Julian" again. He tells her to stay the course and she'll have all the money, and Ethan!
Down on the island, Sheridan and Brian share a kiss, and when they go back to the hotel, they dance the tango together! Sheridan is stunned she can tango so well, and she asks Brian where he learned to dance? Brian says his mom taught him, and he teaches her his mom's special step. He is stunned when she already seems to know the step! Sheridan says she just must have been able to follow his body. As they continue to dance, Sheridan begins to cry. Sheridan recalls dancing the tango with her dead lover, and Brian wonders, to himself, if she will ever get over her lover.