Meanwhile, Sam talks to Ivy and Rebecca. Sam asks Rebecca if she had a gun in her possession last night? Rebecca plays innocent and says "where would I get a gun?" Meanwhile, Ivy is hit with a pain, and drops her medication. She tries to bend down to pick it up, and ends up falling out of her chair. Sam hears the commotion and runs to Ivy. He helps her back into her chair, and gives her her medicine. Sam goes to get some help, and Rebecca accuses her of faking her pain to get out of being questioned. Ivy plays on Sam's sympathy with her pain. Sam holds Ivy and tells her to calm down, everything will be fine.
At the Bennett's, Kay drops her glass when Miguel thinks he knows why Charity has been acting odd. Miguel says he was at the pond, he figured it out! Timmy thinks that Kay is busted, and the real Charity is going to be saved very soon. Miguel thinks that Charity's bad premonitions have just taken their toll on her, and perhaps she is blaming herself for all the bad things that have happened. Miguel thinks Charity is pushing him away to try and protect him, and Reese agrees. Timmy can't believe this, and wonders how he will ever get the real Charity rescued. Tabitha shows up looking for Timmy, and he fills her in on Miguel's theory. She then makes sure he knows what will happen if he reveals Kay's secret! Timmy says he knows, everyone will find out she is a witch. Kay orders Zombie Charity to do something to discourage Miguel. Charity tells Miguel that she is not pushing him away because of her premonitions, she's pushing him away because he is smothering her! Charity says he is sweet, but she wants hot, fun, she wants to partay! Miguel tells Charity that he loves her and refuses to let her get away from him! Miguel stomps off, and Kay realizes she has to figure out a solution to this. Later, everyone hears Charity scream! They all run to Charity, who is pretending to be having a premonition of her and Miguel. She claims she sees him with someone else, but he is happy. Miguel claims he can't be happy with anyone else but her. Charity says she sees him with Kay, and they are very happy.
On the plane, Sheridan continues to sleep as the plane begins its decent. Liz wonders what Sheridan could have been dreaming about, who in her past deserves to die? Sheridan eventually comes to, and tells them how she had a horrible dream. She says she felt guilty, and felt like she had taken someone's life. She realizes she was sleepwalking again, and is embarrassed. Brian tells her not to worry, and asks who she was dreaming about? Sheridan says she just knows it was someone who hurt her badly. However, she does remember smelling Tuna. One of the stewardesses talks to Sheridan about her scene, and how convincing she was! Brian fills her in on the excuses they gave, but Sheridan begins to wonder if she did kill someone. The gang returns to Liz's hotel, and they all turn in for the night. Doc talks to Liz and tells her that if she can find Sheridan/Diana's fiancee, she may be able to get back with Brian. During the night, Sheridan wakes up and goes over to Brian's room. She climbs into his bed, says she needs him, and begs him to make love to her! The two then kiss.
At the mansion, Luis tells both Pilar and Theresa to keep their gun toasting last night a secret, because he knows neither of them could have done it. Luis says this will just make them prime suspects just like him, but Pilar says she knows he couldn't have killed Julian. Luis says there were many people who wanted to kill him, even Ivy and Ethan. Theresa says Ethan didn't do it! Luis asks her if she knows who did? When Theresa begins to say the reason she knows, Luis stops her and says he doesn't want to know. Luis says that they should have listened to their mom so long ago and neither of them should have gotten involved with the Cranes, and he says to hell with all of them! He knocks over some pictures, and one happens to be Sheridan's. He starts apologizing for everything he said, and that he wishes he could have her back. Luis leaves, and Theresa wishes she had listened to Luis long ago and never started drinking until she turned 21. Theresa had promised Luis that she would never drink. Theresa wished she had never drank that champagne, then none of this would have happened.
On the island, Liz and Doc are outside looking at the stars. Doc says that they are in for some strange things tonight. Liz says he is outta his mind, and walks off. Suddenly, Liz is transported somewhere else. She recognizes where she is, and voice asks her why she came here? Liz sees who is talking to her and calls him a bastard! Liz tells him that the only reason she cam here is to tell him that he got his wish and she is leaving. Suddenly, Doc grabs Liz and asks her what is wrong, why is she yelling? Liz says she was remembering an argument, but it was more than a memory, it was like she was back there. Doc says that is proof of the power of the triangle! He says the triangle must have transported her back!
In Brian's room, Brian is stunned when Sheridan walks in and asks him to make love to her. Brian asks if she is sure, and she says she is. When Sheridan looks at Brian she sees Luis, and she begins telling him how much she loves him. When she asks him to make love to him like he used to, Brian realizes she is sleepwalking. He decides to hold her and help her fall back asleep. HE also wonders who it is that she loves so much. Later, Doc and Liz show up, and Brian tells them what has happened. Doc thinks she is remembering her lover, and is creating that reunion in the here and now, it is the power of the triangle! Sheridan continues to cry about how much she's missed him. Meanwhile, in Harmony Luis goes to bed after lighting a candle for Sheridan. Back on the island, the candle in BRian's room magically lights, and she says he is here! Liz and Doc wonder if her lover has come, but Brian says he can't have come because her lover is dead. Brian also claims he must not have put the candle out all the way earlier. Sheridan ends up running out of the room and after her lover. Back in Harmony, Luis can't sleep, and takes a walk. He ends up at the Crane mansion, and starts swimming. Back on the island, the gang looks for Sheridan, and notices the odd lights in the sky. Doc claims they are the power of the triangle. Meanwhile, SHeridan swims out into the ocean to meet her lost love. Back in Harmony, Sheridan suddenly appears in the pool! When they meet, Luis is transported to the ocean where Sheridan is! The two hug and kiss one another.
Ethan and Gwen go out to a hamburger joint, which reminds Ethan of Sheridan. The waitress recognizes Ethan and asks where Theresa is? Ethan says they broke up, and she says she's sorry to hear that. Later, Gwen and Ethan reminisce about old times. Later, Ethan hears from Sheridan's attorney, he has to follow through with Sheridan's last wish to auction off her wardrobe for charity. Ethan says he's been putting this off, but he will go through with it now. Gwen offers to help him.
At the mansion, Theresa tries to find Luis, and heads to the pool. Penny, one of the maids, says she heard someone in the pool, but nobody seems to be here. Suddenly they hear a splash, and see odd lights. Theresa finds Luis wallet, and worries that he may have fallen into the pool and hurt himself. Theresa shouts out to Luis, and Hank eventually shows up, and Theresa explains what is going on. Suddenly, Theresa sees a flash of Luis and Sheridan together! Hank decides to jump into the pool and see what is going on.
On the island, Brian looks for Diana/Sheridan. Doc thinks the power of the triangle is trying to reunite with her lover, possibly in the world beyond. Brian refuses to allow Sheridan to swim to her death and goes after her. A worried Liz swims after Brian. Out in the ocean, Sheridan and Luis are finally reunited. Luis doesn't understand, but Sheridan says all that matters is that they are finally together again. Sheridan hears Brian shouting for her, and says he is coming for her. Suddenly Luis hears Theresa calling him. Brian grabs Sheridan and begins pulling on her, In the pool, Hank can feel Luis, but not see him. Weird lights flash off and on, and both Sheridan and Luis zap in and out of their locations. Hank eventually manages to pull Luis out of the pool, and Brian gets Sheridan. Liz begins to wonder if Doc was right about the forces of the triangle after all? They take Sheridan to shore and back to the hotel, and when she comes true, she swears she was with her lover. Later, Sheridan sees Luis walk into her room in a tux!
Back in Harmony, Luis says he had Sheridan, but he lost her all over again. Luis tells him that he was with Sheridan, but they weren't here, the water was warm and had waves. Theresa admits that she thought she saw him in the pool with Sheridan. Hank thinks this is nuts, but does say that when he was pulling him out of the pool, he disappeared. Luis says he was both here and there, in the ocean! Hank tries to explain it as Luis subconscious affecting them all, and he says they need to be logical about this. Hank and Theresa help Luis out of the pool house so he can get some rest. They take Luis to the cottage, and when Ethan and Gwen show up to get Sheridan's clothes, Luis becomes upset. Ethan and Gwen decide to put this off till another day. Hank asks Theresa why she didn't talk to Ethan? Theresa says she couldn't. Hank tells her that it is obvious Ethan still loves her, so she should go talk to him before he walks out of her life forever. Hank tells her that she has nothing to lose, so she takes his advice. Theresa goes outside to talk to Ethan, and he agrees to give her a moment. Theresa asks Ethan if there is any chance they could get back together?
At the Bennett's, David drops off some photos of John growing up for Grace. Eve happens to be with Grace. Grace makes some coffee for them, and suddenly has a premonition of Sam holding Ivy. Grace wonders why she would see such a thing when she knows Ivy has given up on Sam? Eve doubts Ivy has changed, and some people don't deserve the benefit of the doubt. Still, Grace says she has faith in Sam and who he wants to be with. Eve wonders why she is having this premonition then? Suddenly, Eve gets Sam's call, and Grace insists on going with her. David offers to give them a ride there.
Back at the mansion, Eve and Grace arrive, and Eve learns that Ivy has been doubling up on her pain medication. Sam apologizes for Grace seeing him comfort Ivy, but Grace says nobody deserves to be in that much pain. David, who is also there, mumbles that this is an exception! Eve overhears David, and is puzzled. David claims he was thinking some people say pain is caused by spiritual amissness inside, but he doesn't know Ivy at all and cannot judge what she deserves. Meanwhile, Grace tells Sam about her premonition. Later, Eve helps Ivy rest comfortably, and tells her that she needs to stop doubling up on her medication. Ivy manages to get alone time with David when she asks him to get her a glass of water, but really she just wants to blackmail him some more. She warns him if he doesn't break up Sam and Grace, she will break him in front of his precious son! David tells her to concentrate on staying alive. Ivy assures him that she will stay alive, long enough to see Sam and Grace torn apart! David says he's never met anyone as evil as her! Out in the hall, Grace continues to talk to Sam and assures him that she is not jealous or suspicious of Ivy anymore. Meanwhile, Eve calls the hospital to have some equipment set over to help Ivy.
Inside the cottage, Luis tells Hank that he doesn't understand why he keeps seeing Sheridan alive. He is confused about what is going on. Luis says he still feels so close to her. Hank eventually leaves to check on Theresa, and Sheridan suddenly appears to Luis! They dance, but then Sheridan vanishes.
Outside the cottage, Theresa asks Ethan if there is any hope for a future for them? Ethan says he is thrown by her question, he already told her that it was over, he cannot trust her. Theresa knows she lied, but she was afraid of hurting him. She says his faith in her is shaken, but has she destroyed his love for her? Ethan tells her that he cannot forgive, even if he does still love her. Theresa swears it will never happen again, and that she is sorry, but Ethan says her being sorry isn't enough. Theresa asks for another chance for Sheridan's sake. Ethan asks what this has to do with Sheridan? Theresa says Sheridan was taken from Luis before they could start their lives together, but they don't have to suffer that loss if he is willing to forgive her and try again. Ethan tells her that he can't trust her, and she has proven she doesn't understand what trust is. Ethan says they have no future together, it is over. Ethan hopes she can move on and find happiness elsewhere.
Hank talks with Gwen about what is going on. Gwen says she doesn't know, she doesn't eavesdrop on other people's conversations. Gwen wishes Theresa would just let Ethan go. Hank says Theresa loves him, but Gwen says she brought all of this on herself. Hank says if two people are meant to be together, they can overcome anything. Gwen says they will soon find out if they are meant to be together, and sometimes two people who seem to be the perfect match aren't. Later, Hank consoles Theresa. Meanwhile, Ethan finds Gwen crying. She feels bad for both Luis and Theresa. Gwen admits that she used to hate Theresa, but now she realizes that she isn't a bad person, she just made mistakes. Ethan hugs Gwen and tells her what a beautiful person she is, which Theresa witnesses. Theresa realizes that she has lost Ethan for good.
On the island, Sheridan thinks she once again sees Luis in her room. Brian, Doc, and Liz see Luis shape behind a blowing curtain, and can't believe this. Doc says the triangle must have reached into the world beyond and brought him to her! Brian decides to throw this guy out, but when he goes to find him, there is nobody behind the curtain! They wonder where he went, and Doc realizes he is still here because Diana can see him. Sheridan and Luis begin dancing, and soon the connection between her and Luis begins to fade. She begs him not to go, but he disappears. Brian consoles Sheridan, who is devastated. Brian tells Doc and Liz that there has to be some rational explanation for all of this, but Liz believes Diana's lover was here. Liz tells Brian that he has to face it, Diana/Sheridan loves someone else, and he cannot fight the love they witnessed tonight. Brian says he'll fight her old memories by giving her new ones with him, and she will forget about her past! Later, Sheridan calls out to Luis in her sleep, and back in Harmony, Luis can hear her! Luis tells Hank that he feels Sheridan is searching for him, and if he doesn't find her tonight, he never will.
TC shows up at the mansion to see Eve. HE says he was at the hospital when she called asking for some equipment, so he agreed to take it to her, not realizing she was at the Crane mansion! He can't believe she came back here, but she says she has to take care of Ivy. Eve begs him not to get upset because Sam is here, and he is taking statements about his murder. TC says this house is still evil, even if Julian is gone, and anyone who gets mixed up with this family is headed for pain. Eve tells TC that she hates the Cranes as much as he does, they took something from her to. TC asks her what the Cranes took from her? Eve says she just meant if they have taken something from him, they have taken something from her. TC thinks she is sweet and hugs her. TC starts talking about how Ivy getting struck by lightening is God's way of getting rid of more evil, because he honestly doesn't trust her at all. Eve says if Ivy is faking her pains to get Sam back, the tests she's about to do will expose her.
Grace tells Sam how worried about Ivy she is. Sam says he had no idea she was in so much pain, and she has been having multiple doctors write her prescriptions. A snooping Rebecca wonders what Ivy is up to. Grace asks Sam what is wrong, what isn't he telling her? Sam says something is wrong, and it has to do with Ivy. Sam says he feels guilty about Ivy's injuries, and blames himself. Grace tells him that he had nothing to do with what happened to Ivy, so he shouldn't feel guilty. Rebecca ends up knocking over a vase, and is caught spying by Sam. Sam uses the opportunity to question her as to whether she had a gun. Rebecca lies and says she doesn't own a gun, and wouldn't even know how to use one. Rebecca then begins crying about her dead pookie, and she says she could never have killed him! Sam says that is all for now, but he may have more questions for her later.
In Ivy's room, Ivy continues to blackmail David. She tells him that she wants Sam back no matter what the cost! Ivy shows David a picture she has of him, and threatens to show his son if he doesn't help her! As Ivy and David really begin arguing, Eve and TC approach Ivy's room and hear them! David says he's leaving HArmony with John, but Ivy swears to destroy him! Suddenly, Eve and TC walk in!
At the cottage, Luis tells Hank that he feels Sheridan is out there somewhere, and if he doesn't find her tonight, he'll lose her forever. Hank can't believe Luis is believing in this, but Luis says over the past few years he has seen some pretty odd things happen. Luis says he knows he can reunite with Sheridan, and then gets an idea how to. Luis heads to the gazebo, because that place is special to them. A strange light appears in the sky, and Luis thinks this may be his last chance to connect with Sheridan. Luis calls out to Sheridan. Hank tells Luis not to do this to himself, but Luis knows this will work.
On the island, Liz tells Brian he can't deny Diana/Sheridan's connection to her dead lover, but Brian says he doesn't care, he just wants to keep her safe. Doc is positive that the Bermuda Triangle has something to do with what is going on. Sheridan wakes up and says that Doc is right, she was with her lover earlier, and she has to get back to him tonight! Brian says she thought his lover was dead, and Sheridan says she thought he was too. Doc suggests maybe he isn't dead, and maybe the triangle is bringing them back together. Sheridan thinks she would remember if he lived, but she doesn't. However, the Triangle's power is bringing them together, and she says she has to use it to get back to him. Doc asks her if she remembers him calling her by her real name? Sheridan says she doesn't think either of them called each other by their names. Suddenly, Sheridan hears Luis calling out "Where are you my love, tell me where you are?" Sheridan says she is here, and she hears Luis begging her to come back to her. Sheridan says she is coming!