Brian, with Sheridan by his side, arrives at the Crane estate to see Pilar. Brian relives a confrontation he had with Julian right before he left Harmony. Unaware his lost love is nearby, Luis struggles with his grief. Brian and Sheridan share a New Year's kiss. Thanks to Tabitha's evil magic, TC's father appears to his son and insists Julian be killed for ruining their lives. TC is stunned when his "father" states he can provide proof of Julian's involvement in the car accident. Then, in a surprising turn of events, Julian confides to Rebecca that he misses having Ethan as his son. At the party, an exuberant Tabitha surveys everyone's pain. David feels guilty as he's forced to go along with Ivy's hurtful scheme against Grace. Armed with a picture of Theresa entering the abortion clinic, Ivy prepares to destroy her son's fianc�e. Pilar is horrified when she realizes where her daughter has been. Ivy enlists the help of an unlikely person to expose Theresa.
At the mansion, Ethan threatens to have the reporter thrown out. Mort says he doesn't have that power. Ethan asks his mom to do it, but Ivy says she has tried, but they are ignoring her. Ethan asks Mort what he wants? Mort says he wants his reaction to the fact that his fiancee is pregnant. Ethan says that Theresa is not pregnant, but Mort says she is, and does he have any comments for his readers about how he doesn't seem to know all that much about his fiancee's health. Theresa and Whitney show up, and when they see the reporter with Ethan, Theresa fears her secret may have come out. Fortunately, Ethan and Chad have had enough, and threaten the reporter and try and throw him out. Theresa and Pilar confront Ivy and blame her for this. Ivy plays innocent, but says Theresa's worst nightmare is about to come true. Meanwhile, the reporter begs Ethan for a chance to prove what he is saying is true. He says if he is lying, he'll never bother him again. Ethan says fine, he'll get Theresa to confirm that he is lying. Ethan gets Theresa, and he asks her to tell the reporter that she is not pregnant. Theresa looks around the room, and then looks into Ethan's eyes again. Ethan asks her once again to tell them that she isn't pregnant.
Eve finds TC strangling Julian, and attempts to keep her husband from killing him. Sam eventually shows up to help, but TC's rage is too much and he continues to attempt to kill Julian! Sam eventually grabs TC, and tells Julian to get out of here. Julian does just that, he runs! TC tells Eve and Sam about the proof he found, thanks to his father's ghost. He shows them the car repair receipt for Julian's car, the proof that he was behind his accident years ago! TC swears to make Julian pay with his life! Eve is lost, so Sam tells TC that it is time he tell her the whole story. TC finally comes out and tells Eve the truth about why he hates Julian. Eve and Sam say that killing Julian won't bring his father back, but TC says it will avenge his broken heart.
Brian stands on the grounds of the Crane Estate and wishes he could turn back the clock and do things differently. He damns the Cranes for running him out of Harmony years ago. Brian remembers Julian threatening to ruin his family if he didn't leave Harmony. Brian damns Julian Crane to hell! Suddenly, Julian shows up, and Brian begins to lay into him for what he did to him and his family. Julian begins to laugh, and says he won't take this on his own property! Julian doesn't remember who Brian is, so Brian decides to jog Julian's memory! Brian tells Julian how his mother used to slave all day for his family, and he would sneak out of bed and make sure his mom didn't have to walk home alone, and then when she got home, he would sneak into bed before she came in and kissed him good night. Brian says he saw a lot of things back then. Julian asks Brian to just tell him who he is and leave. Brian says he won't leave until he pays for what he did to his family! Brian says he is Antonio Lopez-Fitzgerald! Julian is shocked and says he never expected to see him again. Brian says he never expected to come back, but now that he is back, it is time for him to get what he deserves! Brian tells Julian that he stole his family from him, and for that, he's going to take his life! Julian tells him not to do anything he might regret! Brian says ending his life would be he best thing he's ever done in his life!
Tabitha and Timmy spy on what is going on. Tabitha says Ivy is so mean she might overtake her nastiness if she doesn't watch out. Timmy feels bad for everyone involved, which makes Tabby sick. Timmy decides to ditch Tabitha and head over to the youth center to join the other kids party.
At the kids party, the kids boogie down. Miguel continues to wonder what is going on with Charity. He wishes she would talk to him and let her know what is bothering him. Meanwhile, Kay approaches Zombie Charity, who seems to be getting sick of Kay and her orders, as she rolls her eyes behind Kay's back. Kay decides to shake things up a bit, and gives Zombie some new orders. Later, Timmy shows up and shocks a couple of the kids, until Jessica explains who he really is. Jessica and Simone say hi to Timmy, and Reese is very suspicious. Jessica asks Timmy to dance, and he says sure Jessica! Reese asks how Timmy knew Jessica's name? Timmy says he knows Jessica's name because Tabitha sent him pictures of all the Bennetts. Jessica then dances with Timmy. Kay goes to talk to Miguel, and tells him not to worry about what Charity said, she's just trying to make him jealous. Miguel says he hates to say it, but it worked. Charity shows up and comments how short Tabitha's nephew is, so why are Jessica and Simone wasting their time on him? Miguel is shocked and tells Charity that she is acting like a totally different person. Miguel tells Charity that they are no longer connecting, why is she so different?
The party continues at the Youth Center, with Timmy being the star dancer. Meanwhile, Miguel and Charity continue to argue. Charity says she can say whatever she thinks, and she's sorry if it offends his macho Latin pride! Miguel asks Charity what has happened to her? Charity says she hasn't changed, he was just rude and wouldn't let her finish. Charity claims that Jessica has been looking for a boyfriend, and personally she thinks Jessica is wasting her time dancing with someone from out of town. Miguel apologizes, and Charity says she is sorry too, because his know-it-all attitude is a real turn-off! Later, Kay gives Zombie Charity a new batch of orders. Zombie Charity ends up grabbing the ties of two boys, and dirty dances with them! The guys make a Charity sandwich!
Timmy becomes confused, and heads to the cave where Charity is frozen. Timmy swears he would tell Charity how he feels if he could just get to her. He then begins to try and move the rocks sealing the entrance to the cave. Timmy is unable to move the rocks, so he asks the angel girl to help him. Suddenly, the rocks begin to glow, and an opening appears! Timmy heads inside the cave, and finds Charity trapped in the ice.
At the mansion, Sheridan continues to wander the grounds and think about Luis. She is positive she has been on the estate before, and slowly begins to remember the layout of the grounds. Back in the cottage, Luis continues to have memories of Sheridan. Luis feels that Sheridan is close by for some reason. He wonders when the hurt will stop, when will he be able to accept that she is dead. Luis sees, in his mind, Sheridan waiting for him at the gazebo, so he rushes to the gazebo. Meanwhile, Sheridan heads to the cottage! Luis and Sheridan both wander the grounds, and once again have a near miss when Luis leaves to go back to the mansion to check on his mom.
Elsewhere, Brian decks Julian, who falls to the ground. Brain swears to make Julian pay for everything he has done to him, his family, and everyone else's life he has ruined! Julian says he couldn't have come back to kill him, why is he really here? Brian says he is here to see his family, and because of a woman. Brian continues to rough up Julian, and Julian tells Brian that if he kills him he will go to jail! Brian lets Julian go, and Julian warns Brian that if he stays in Harmony he will ruin his family's life. Julian reminds Brian on the threats he made to him years ago, and he promises to make good on them! Brian agrees to leave, and he tells himself that one day he will make Julian pay. Brian finds Sheridan, and he admits to her that the people who own this estate are evil people, and they are why he left Harmony. Brian says now is not the time for him to reunite with his family. Brian suggests they head back to the boat so he can think. Brian tells Sheridan that he's so happy to have her is his life, and says she is the best thing to happen to him since he left Harmony. They return to the boat, and when Sheridan goes down below, Brian pulls out a gun and thinks about killing Julian.
In the mansion, TC says the body shop receipt he found in Julian's safe proves that Julian is responsible for his car accident, which ended his career and causes his father to die from a broken heart. TC says he will kill him! Sam, Eve, and Grace all try to reason with TC, and they manage to calm him down. Still, TC believes his father was here, and helped him find the receipt. TC gets all angered up again, so Sam urges TC to just go home and get a good nights sleep. TC agrees, and Sam says he'll try and convince Julian not to press charges. TC and Eve head home, and Eve tries to calm TC down, and rationalize what happened tonight. TC refuses to believe that he is hallucinating, he believes his father really came back to him. Eve begins to remember when the mysterious fog on the Crane grounds showed her the vision of her baby being kidnapped, and she wonders if it is true as well. This begins to worry Eve greatly, as she wonders if her baby might still be alive. Both Eve and TC, seperately vow to kill Julian for what they've done to their lives.
At the party, Ethan asks Theresa to prove the reporter wrong and tell them that she isn't pregnant. Theresa says nothing, and Ethan realizes she is pregnant, it is written all over her face. Ethan says she's been keeping a secret from him, and he knows why. Everyone fears Ethan has figured it out, but he hasn't. Ethan thinks Theresa didn't tell him because they have no way to support the baby. Ethan is happy about the news, and announces to everyone that he and Theresa are having a baby. Ethan has faith that God will help them through this. The reporter tells Ivy this isn't going the way he thought it would, but Ivy tells him not to worry, Theresa's secret will come out. Luis shows up, and Ethan wants to tell him the good news. Theresa begs him not to, but Ethan says it is okay. Ethan tells Luis that he and Theresa are having a baby. Luis asks how they could let this happen? Ethan says it was a surprise, and they'll get married right away. Luis congratulates them, but the reporter says there is still more to tell. He tells Ethan not to go marrying Theresa just yet, because what he has to say will put a damper on things! Mort tells everyone that Theresa is not pregnant anymore! He claims to have proof that Theresa got an abortion!
At the party, Miguel is devastated when he sees her dirty dancing with two guys. Kay tells Miguel not to watch this, but Miguel says he's putting a stop to this now! Miguel breaks up the dirty dancing, and the guys claims they didn't know she had a boyfriend. They take off, and Miguel asks Charity what she is doing? Charity says she was just dancing, and that he needs to lighten up. She tells him that he has been acting so weird lately. Miguel becomes upset and yells "I've been acting weird!" Miguel tells her that the way she was dancing with those guys was like she was coming onto them. Charity says she is here to have a good time, and she's not going to dance with him the whole night. Kay sees the way things are going between Charity and Miguel, and she smiles. Kay finds Miguel outside thinking, and she talks to him. Miguel says Charity has suddenly become a stranger to him. The other kids join Kay and Miguel, and Miguel sees something in the woods. He worries, and they all decide to check it out. Kay panics and wonders if it is coming from the cave where she trapped Charity.
At the Russell's, TC can't stop thinking about what his dad's ghost said to him. TC vows to make Julian pay for what he did to him. Meanwhile, Eve remembers her vision, in which someone kidnapped her baby from the hospital. Eve thinks Julian was behind it, and vows to kill him. Eve clams herself down, and then gives TC a pill to help him relax. She tells him to lay down and relax, and he does. When Eve thinks TC is knocked out, she decides to go take care of Julian, and heads out. Later, TC has a nightmare about the car crash. TC wakes up, and vows to make Julian pay for what he did!
On the boat, Brian thinks about Julian and his threats. Brian produces a gun, and thinks it is time someone put a stop to Julian Crane. Sheridan shows up, and he hides his gun. She tells him that she's sorry things didn't work out for him, and that maybe someday things will be better. Brian says he's planning on them being. Sheridan asks him if it is strange being back in cold weather? Brian says no, that he's missed the seasons. Liz and Doc show up, and Liz says maybe he shouldn't go back to the island! Sheridan is surprised to see them, as is Brian. Liz says they've been worried about him, and asks if he got in touch with his family? Brian says no, and Liz and Doc say they understand if he doesn't want to talk about it. Liz says they all know what it is like not to want to face their past. Brian talks to them about his family, and how now is not a good time for him to contact them. Liz can tell that Brian wants to see his family, but something is stopping him. Brian says someone very powerful is stopping him, and he's powerful enough to tear his family apart. Doc says this person sounds like a monster. Brian says he is, and he is the reason he had to leave Harmony and can't come back. Liz asks if he could go back if this person were out of the way? Brian says absolutely. Brian says if this guy was gone, a lot of people would be better off. He says killing this person would be a blessing. Sheridan is shocked, but Liz says they all have someone like that in their past.
At the mansion, Eve shows up and confronts Julian. Julian threatens to put TC away for a long time, but Eve says she won't do anything to her husband because she is afraid of him. Julian is sick of people threatening him! Eve blames Julian for ruining TC's career, and she vows to help him prove it! Julian tells Eve not to dig to deeply, there is more to this story than TC or she knows. Eve asks him what he is talking about? Julian tells her to go tend to her husband's insanity. Eve says TC is not insane, what happened tonight is real, and she also knows that their baby didn't die, he had someone kidnap him! Julian tells her that she is mad, their baby died and she needs to move on! Eve says she knows the baby is alive and he had him kidnapped, he ruined her life and is a monster! Julian says "Boo hoo, I've ruined everyone i've ever met, blah blah!" Julain says he'll have her insane husband locked up, and he will let everyone know about their affair and child! Eve says that will ruin him, but Julian says nobody will care, and he's sure he's gotten other young women pregnant. Eve begs him not to do this because it will ruin her life, but he says he is sorry. Julian walks out, and Eve says her life is over! Eve says she can't let Julian do it, goes through his desk, and comes across Julian's gun!
Meanwhile, Mort tells Ethan and everyone else that he knows something else about Theresa, she's no longer pregnant! Mort says he has proof that Theresa got an abortion! Ethan and Luis both claim that is a lie, that Theresa would never have an abortion! Ethan becomes physical with Mort and tells him that he won't let him ruin Theresa's life! Mort produces and envelope and says this is the proof! Everyone becomes very silent as Ethan and Luis look at the proof. Mort has a photo graph of Theresa at the abortion clinic. Luis asks her what she was doing there? Ethan asks Theresa if she got an abortion? Theresa says she can explain, but he says she doesn't have to, this is all his fault. Everyone is shocked. Ethan says he kept harping on about how they had to get established before they started a family, and he blames himself. Ivy can't believe Ethan is blaming himself. Theresa tells Ethan that he doesn't understand, but Ethan says it was all his fault. Theresa finally comes out and says it is not his baby! Luis asks whose baby is it? Suddenly, Julian walks in and exclaims that this party is over and they should all go home! Ethan and Luis realize that Julian is the father!