Sheridan and Gwen go to the Book Cafe, and Sheridan admits to Gwen that she's been dreaming about Luis, and she doesn't know why. Gwen doesn't think it is that difficult to figure out, she wants to be with Luis. Sheridan tells Gwen that she and Luis went out last night, and she wonders if she and Luis could make a go at it. Gwen tells Sheridan to get real! She says that Luis is a gate crasher just using her to get into a world he can't get onto on his own, he is just like his little sister. Gwen apologizes, but she feels that she's losing Ethan to Theresa. Sheridan says that Ethan loves her, but Sheridan isn't so sure anymore. Gwen thinks that Ethan must have feelings for Theresa, otherwise he would have seen that she was manipulating him long ago. Gwen realizes it is getting late and she has a date to get ready for, so she says goodbye to Sheridan. Gwen leaves, and Sheridan wonders if she and Luis could have a future together.
At the Lopez-Fitzgerald House, Luis explains what happened with him and Sheridan, and how bad he felt about "using" Sheridan. Hank asks Luis if he's sure all he wants from Sheridan is information? Luis asks Hank if he's implying that he's interested in Sheridan Crane? Luis assures Hank that he has zero interest in Sheridan Crane. Still, Hank doesn't know why he turned down Sheridan's offer to search the mansion? Luis says he doesn't want to be like the countless of other men who have used her. Hank asks him if he's sure he's not falling for her? Luis says Sheridan is different from the rest of her family, but she is still way too rich for him.
At the Lobster Shack, Gwen shows up and sees Theresa sitting at her table along. Gwen tells Theresa that she is sick of her manipulations and goes off on her. She tells her that nobody at the country club would ever accept her as Mrs. Ethan Crane, so she tells Theresa to admit that she is lying about her boyfriend so she and Ethan can get married right away. Theresa is hurt and wonders why Gwen is doing this to her, and Ethan tells Gwen to stop this. A waiter ends up running into Gwen and dumps a drink on her. She tells the waiter that he will be fired for this! Ethan has enough and tells Gwen that he can't believe he ever loved someone as hateful as her, and it is clear that he belongs with Theresa. A furious Gwen storms out of the restaurant as Ethan and Theresa look into one another's eyes. Ethan tells Theresa that Gwen is out of his life forever, and from now until the end of time it is just the two of them. Ethan tells her before he can take her back to the mansion, there is one last thing he needs to do. As Ethan was about to kiss her, Whitney throws a glass of water on her! Theresa was dreaming, and Whitney tells Theresa that she was talking in her sleep and she could hear her all the way from the living room! Whitney tells Theresa that it will not end up like she was dreaming, but Theresa is positive that it will. Theresa asks Whitney to help her pick out a killer dress for tonight.
Whitney and Theresa go shopping at a fancy dress store for Theresa's date tonight. Whitney asks Theresa how she's going to afford these dresses? Theresa says she has the money she's earned working for Mrs. Crane. Whitney thinks she should save that money, but Theresa says she has to have one of these dresses. Theresa is confident that after tonight, she and Ethan will be together. Whitney asks Theresa "What about your boyfriend?" Theresa doesn't think she'll have to produce one because fate will step in. Theresa finds the perfect dress, and later Whitney tells Theresa that she will come with her tonight just in case.
At the mansion, Julian has a talk with Ethan about handling his women a little better. Ethan is appalled by his dad's suggestions. Julian tells Ethan to just lie to Gwen and claim he believes that Theresa doesn't have a boyfriend, but Ethan says he won't lie to his true love. Julian laughs and tells Ethan that there is no such thing as true love. Julian says that he should never have mentioned bedding Theresa, and he also says that at least Sheridan doesn't think she killed anyone anymore and hopefully Luis is out of their lives. Ethan tells Julian that ever since he's come home he's realized they have very little in common. Ethan says he wants to be a man with ideals. Julian tells him to hold onto those ideals, but when he wants advice on how to deal with the real world then he should come talk to him for some real advice. Ethan says he won't be that kind of man, and he walks away.
Ethan and Gwen go to the Lobster Shack, and they see Theresa, who is waiting for them, and she is alone! Meanwhile, Sheridan calls Luis and tells him that she's home alone at the cottage, and she thinks someone is stalking her!
At Tabitha's, Timmy realizes there is only one way he can help Tabitha, who has melted into a puddle. Suddenly, Miguel and Charity show up to see Tabitha! Charity has brought Tabitha some muffins to repay her for the pastries. On their way there they heard cats screeching, and Miguel jokes that in the old country cats screech when a witch dies. Charity realizes the door is open, so they walk inside and call out to Tabitha. Timmy hides and hopes they don't step in the puddle Tabitha has become. Miguel steps on Tabitha, and she lets out a yelp. Charity hears it recognizes Tabitha's voice. Timmy is overjoyed that his princess still lives. Charity says Tabitha's voice came from the floor, and she wonders if Tabitha fell down the basement steps? Miguel and Charity go to the basement door, and Tabitha tells Timmy to do something! Timmy calls out for the witchdoctor to come help a sick witch. The witchdoctor, aka Dr. Bombay and his lovely little nurse, show up. Dr. Bombay wants to know why he's here and he asks "the doll" to start talking! Timmy tells Dr. Bombay that Tabitha melted into the puddle, and the kids from next door are about to go into Tabitha's basement. Dr. Bombay refuses to have anything to do with Tabitha's basement. Timmy says that Miguel and Charity are looking for Tabitha, and are heading for the basement. Dr. Bombay realizes that Charity Standish must never see what is in Tabitha's basement, so something must be done. At the basement door, Miguel and Charity are banging on the door and calling to Tabitha. They have not noticed the red light and fog seeping out from under the door. Meanwhile, Dr. Bombay decides to come up with a diversion. He produces a phone and calls Tabitha's house. Charity answers Tabitha's phone, and it is Tabitha on the other end! Actually, it is Dr. Bombay pretending to be Tabitha. He tells them that she's at the doctors and will be home soon and she'll see her later! Tabitha tells Dr. Bombay that he's not funny at all and to just help her out of this situation! TImmy, however, is impressed that his scheme didn't backfire, unlike all of Tabitha's. Suddenly, Charity shows up, and she recognizes Dr. Bombay. She thinks she's seen him on TV, and she asks him what he's doing here? Charity calls for Miguel to come quick, and he says he'll be right there. Miguel is in the kicthen looking for a mop to clean up Tabitha's floor. Dr. Bombay tells Charity that he knows all about her, but she doesn't remember him because of her amnesia. Dr. Bombay tells Charity that her life is going to be a roller coaster, referring to the trials and tribulations of true love, and he tells her to hold on! Dr. Bombay wishes Charity well, says she'll remember nothing of him when he's gone, and then he disappears! Miguel shows up with a mop and bucket to clean up the puddle, aka Tabitha, and he asks Charity why she was calling him? Charity tells him that she can't really remember. Miguel begins to clean up, but then notices that Charity doesn't look well, so he decides to take her home. They leave, and Timmy wonders what he's going to do with Tabitha because half of her is on the floor, and half is in the bucket thanks to Miguel. Dr. Bombay returns to help Tabitha, but only because his nurse Heidi has taken a liking to Timmy. Timmy likes Nurse Heidi a lot and he asks her if she can yodel? Heidi tells him that she can do anything! Timmy says that he's in love, but Tabitha says Timmy doesn't have hormones! Timmy tells Tabitha that he does now! Dr. Bombay casts a spell to help Tabitha, but he turns her into a fish! Dr. Bombay tells Timmy that the only thing that can help Tabitha now is to receive love from her enemy. Timmy doesn't understand, so Dr. Bombay tells him to figure it out!
At the Book Cafe, Chad is telling Simone how all his chances of finding out about who he were destroyed when Orville's apartment burned down. Chad tells Simone that perhaps she should split so her family doesn't find her with him, but Simone says she's tired of her family running her life. Chad tells her that she should be glad to have a family who knows where they come from. Simone tells him that is not entirely true. She says that her dad can trace his family history back for generations, but her mom's past is a mystery. When Chad asks what she means, Simone says that her mom never talks about her family and they know nothing about them. Chad thinks that perhaps Eve has a secret past too, but Simone says she just thinks it is hard for her mom to talk about her family because they are all dead. Later, Chad tells Simone that he's thinking about hitting the road and getting on with his life. Simone tells him that he never knows who else he might meet who might have the answers he needs, and she begs him not to give up. Chad tells Simone that she is the best thing in this town, and he agrees to stick around. Meanwhile, Ruth, Orville's neighbor, comes in with the bird statue and she tries to sell it to Beth. However, Beth says she's just a little short on money right now. however, Beth offers to bring her some coffee and cookies on the house. Ruth sits down at the table right next to Chad and Simone!
At the graveyard, Matilda tells Timmy that he must find Tabitha's doe skin bag which contains the first curse Tabitha cast, because only it can turn her back into a witch. Matilda tells Timmy that hundreds of years ago Tabitha cursed the pilgrim governor by hiding the cursed bag in the governor's desk, and Tabitha, who is swimming in her fish bowl, tells Timmy that the Cranes bought the desk. Matilda tells him to find the bag and get out of the Crane mansion "beep beep!" When Timmy says "A mans gotta do what a mans gotta do," Tabitha tells him that he's not a man, he's a doll. Tabitha asks Matilda to give Timmy some help, and when Timmy begs, Matilda caves. Matilda casts a spell on Timmy and turns him into a mini super-hero in black leather and shades. He calls himself "The Matrix-Man" as in the movie "The Matrix."
At the Crane mansion, Julian calls his father for advice on dealing with Luis. Alastair tells Julian that he need to keep Luis from digging into the Crane business, and to keep Sheridan from helping him! Julian doesn't think Sheridan will hang out with Luis, but Alastair isn't so sure about that. He tells Julian to keep an eye on his sister, and asks Julian if all their bases are covered? Julian is positive and he says that he even had a silent alarm set up to guard the wall safe in the library. Alastair thinks it is a mistake to keep those papers in that safe, and he tells Julian that he'll hold him responsible if anything goes wrong. Julian says "What else is new," and eventually hangs up on his dad to call Sheridan back. However, he only gets her answering machine, and he wonders where she has gone to. Julian then leaves by the back stairs.
At the cottage. Sheridan tells Luis that Julian is going away for a business trip and Ivy is at a fund raiser, so they can search the house now. Luis tells Sheridan that if he finds any incriminating evidence, he will stop at nothing to make her family pay. He tells her that she must understand that she could be helping him bring down her own family. Sheridan says she understands. Luis tells SHeridan that until he finds out the truth about the past, everything in his life, even a relationship, is on hold. Sheridan tells him once again that she understands, and she'll check the house to see if anyone is home. She calls, but nobody answers because Julian is talking to Alastair, who tells Julian to ignore the call. Sheridan tells Luis that nobody is home, so they are free to search the house.
Sheridan and Luis sneak into the mansion, and Sheridan suggests they search the library first because it is where Julian would hide information. Luis looks through Julian's desk, but finds nothing. Sheridan suggests they check the wall safe. As she reaches for it, she's unaware of the laser alarm guarding it! Luis stops her, and she doesn't understand why. Luis asks for a compact, so she produces the one he gave her. He smiles when he realizes that she's using it. Luis blows the compact powder in front of the safe and reveals the hi-tech alarm system. Luis says that the main switch is probably in the basement, and if he shows her the way, he can probably turn it off. The two then leave to find the switch, but they can't. Sheridan says the laser wasn't there the other day, which makes Luis all the more suspicious. Suddenly, Sheridan thinks she hears something in the library. Luis doesn't hear anything, so Sheridan says that she just must be jumpy because Julian would freak if he knew she let him in here. Luis offers to let her off the hook and leave, but if he lets her stay, he promises her that he's going to get into that safe. Sherdian is confident that her family had nothing to do with his father's disappearance, and Sheridan hopes to herself that she didn't either. They decide to go back into the library to check the safe out, not knowing that Timmy is inside and has set the alarm off.
Timmy, aka Matrix Man, breaks into the mansion and is impressed. He calls the place a palace and fantasizes about living in the mansion. In his fantasy, Timmy is decked out in top hat and tails and is serving Nurse Heidi a MarTimmy. Timmy snaps back to reality and tells himself to remember his mission. Timmy makes his way to the library and finds the desk. He starts looking for the secret compartment, but can't seem to find it in any of the drawers. He decides to climb on top of the desk to search for it. Unfortunately, when he climbs onto the desk, he sets the alarm off!
Julian goes to another part of the mansion and calls his father back. Alastair tells Julian that they have no choice but to get rid of Luis. Julian is shocked and tells his dad that everything is fine, but Alastair wants Julian to kill Luis! Julian doesn't think taking drastic action against Luis will be necessary. Suddenly, the alarm in the library goes off! Alastair tells Julian to go down to the library and find out who is there. Alastair tells Julian that it could be Luis, so he should take a gun and use it!
At the Lobster Shack, Ethan asks Theresa to please says something, anything, to prove that her boyfriend exists. Gwen tells Ethan that Theresa can't tell them who he is because she's been lying. Ethan asks Theresa if she's been lying about having a boyfriend? Theresa doesn't answer, so Ethan says it is obvious Gwen was right. Gwen smiles as she watches Theresa choke. Theresa asks if he would hate her if she was lying, would he never speak to her again? Ethan says he could never hate her, but he won't tolerate deceit or dishonesty, and he couldn't tolerate anyone hurting Gwen. He says that he'd never want to see her again. Gwen tells Theresa that she's been exposed and to just admit it! Theresa says she will tell them the truth. Suddenly, Theresa's boyfriend suddenly shows up! He introduces himself as Chuck Wilson, Gwen's boyfriend. Ethan, Gwen, and Theresa herself are all shocked. Ethan eventually smiles, and Gwen growls. Chuck apologizes for being late and says his lemon of a car broke down again. Chuck says he can't believe the bad luck he's had trying to meet them and jokes that they must have wondered if he even existed. Chuck hears a song, which he claims is his and Theresa's song, and he asks her to dance with him. As they dance, Theresa thanks Chuck for doing this, though she doesn't know how he did it. Chuck says it was Whitney's doing, she helped him with Tennis, so he is repaying her favor. Chuck just hopes they don't ask him anything else, because he's said everything he knows about her already. Theresa doesn't think that they will ask any questions because Ethan looks bad for doubting her. Back at the table, Ethan tells Gwen that he feels like a fool, but Gwen to admit she was wrong just yet. Gwen thinks that Chuck could just be some actor she hired. Gwen says she has some questions to ask Chuck about Theresa.
Sam and Grace stop by the Book Cafe after seeing a movie. The movie upset Grace because it was about a man going through a mid-life crisis and ending up with another woman. Grace and Sam run into the kids, Kay, Jessica, Charity, and Miguel. Charity loves the way Sam and Grace act, but Kay and Jessica think that their parents kissing in public is so embarrassing! Suddenly, Charity begins to have more premonitions of someone she cares about being trapped in a small space surrounded by water. Later, Reese reminds everyone that tonight is Witch's Night! Charity doesn't understand what it is, so the kids explain that on this night three hundreds years ago all the witches were burned at the stake, and they try to rise from their graves, and it is a local tradition for the kids in Harmony to explore the cemetery to try and catch a glimpse of them. Charity doesn't like the idea and Miguel offers to stay behind with her, but Kay thinks it would be the perfect way to snag Miguel. Kay, dreaming up a scenario in which Miguel sees what a wimp Charity is and leaves her, tells Miguel that he loves witch's night more than anyone and he has to go! Charity agrees to go with him so she doesn't ruin his fun. Reese gets his dad's car, and he tells everyone that they are all set to go! The kids leave, and Grace opens up to Sam about her fears. She tells him that she can't stop thinking about seeing him in Ivy's arms on New Years Eve. She tells him about the silly magazine article, which she knows is silly, and it makes her even more ashamed of her feelings. Sam tells Grace that she has nothing to be jealous of! When they kiss, Ivy walks in and is stunned to see them in a lip-lock! As they kiss, Sam opens his eyes and sees Ivy watching them. Ivy butts her way into their date by saying it is so nice to see friends, and Grace invites her to join them. However, Sam tells Grace that he so enjoys their time alone. Grace says they'd still love her company, but Ivy says she wouldn't think of intruding. Ivy leaves, and Grace is upset with Sam for being rude to Ivy. Grace goes to check on Ivy, who is crying. Ivy claims that the book she is reading is very sad, it is about a man involved in a romantic triangle. Grace asks how it ends? Ivy says one woman is crushed, and one finds happiness. Later when Grace is on the phone, Sam threatens Ivy. He tells her that he will make her sorry if she hurt Grace. He threatens to tell Grace the truth about them, and that she means nothing to him now!
At the Crane mansion, Julian, who is armed with a gun, assures his dad that if officer Luis has broken into his study, he won't leave this house alive! In the library, Timmy sets off the alarm while trying to find the doe skin bag in the secret compartment of the desk. Timmy finally finds the bag after he gets mad and hits the desk, which causes the secret drawer to pop open. Sheridan and Luis return to the library to investigate the safe, narrowly catching Timmy! Timmy quickly hides when the door opens and the come in. When he hears Luis speak about being careful not to set off the alarm, he worries that he might have already set it off. Luis wants to protect Sheridan from her brother and asks her to leave, but Sheridan says she will worry too much if she leaves him. Luis says he can handle himself and thinks he knows a way to get into the safe. As he goes to work, Timmy sneaks out, and Sheridan hears the door open. She quickly grabs Luis and kisses him just as Julian walks into his study. He is shocked by what he sees! Julian, who is holding a gun on them, demands an explanation! Sheridan says Julian is her guest and she brought him in here for some brandy. Julian asks why they are by the safe and not the bar? Sheridan says she forgot about the safe, and asks if that is why he has a gun? Julian says the silent alarm was triggered, and Sheridan plays innocent and says she had no idea he had an alarm. Sheridan tells him to put the gun down, and then asks what the high-tech alarm is for? Julian says that there are papers in there which deal with business matters that are of a private matter. Sheridan thanks Julian for ruining her date, and she and Luis leave. On their way out, Julian tells Luis not to come back. Luis warns Julian that if he ever points a gun at him, he'll regret it! Suddenly, Julian orders them to stop when he realizes someone has gone through his desk. Sheridan says that if the papers on his desk have been moved it is probably because they were leaning on it! Luis and Sheridan try to leave once again, but Julian makes Sheridan stay behind to question her. He tells her that he knows she wasn't in here playing kissy face, but Sheridan says it is true. Julian warns her not to go out with Luis, but Sheridan says she won't let him or Alastair to dictate her social life. Later, Julian calls his father and reports to him about what he found. Alastair is furious and says they have to deal with this Sheridan/Luis problem.
At the cemetery, Matilda is floating over her grave and is talking to Tabitha, who is resting on a tombstone in her bowl. Tabitha is wondering what could be keeping Timmy. Matilda thinks that Timmy is probably on his way to Las Vegas as the speak! Suddenly, the kids show up looking for witches. Kay scares Charity to "get her in the mood." Reese tells them all that they should go look for the graves of the Harmony witches, who are buried in the deepest and darkest section of the graveyard. Tabitha hears the kids, and Charity coming, and Matilda has had about enough. Matilda starts howling, which scares the kids. They decide to leave, but Charity senses someone is in trouble and needs her help./ However, Reese produces a bible and tells the heathen witches to go back to their graves! It works, and Tabitha tells Matilda that Reese just made her enemy list. Matilda's powers are fried, so she decides to vanish. Timmy returns, and wonders what the kids are doing here. Suddenly, Miguel notices that Charity is gone! Charity calls to Miguel after she finds Tabitha the fish on a grave! She thinks that this is who her premonition was about. Timmy sees Charity grab Tabitha, and he lets out an "uh-oh!" Reese thinks that it must be an offering or sacrifice and wants to dissect it, but Charity says nobody is touching this fish! When she says it could be a reincarnated person, Kay thinks Charity is nuts. Charity says she's taking the fish home and will figure out what to do with it tomorrow. The kids leave, and Timmy asks Matilda to help Tabitha and bring her back! Matilda tells Timmy that she can't help Tabitha if she's not here, and if he doesn't turn her back soon, she could remain a fish forever!
The kids go home, and Charity takes care of her new pet, Tabitha! Timmy spies on them from the windows and wonders how he'll get her out of there.
In the library at the mansion, Julian questions Ivy about Sheridan's relationship with Luis. Ivy was under the impression that Sheridan was grateful to Luis for saving her life, but other than that she couldn't stand him. Julian says that is not so because he caught them kissing last night! Ivy says that last night certainly was a night for kissing. She remembers Grace and Sam's kiss, and Julian asks her who she saw kissing? Ivy says no one in particular, and she suggests that Sheridan was just thanking Luis. Ivy decides to leave, but Julian shows her the silent alarm before she leaves. Ivy realizes the safe is the reason he was upset to find Luis in here, and she realizes that the safe must contain something on MArtin Fitzgerald. Ivy accuses her husband of being afraid of Luis! Julian denies it, and when he sees Pilar, he wishes Ivy would fire her. Ivy refuses abd says that Pilar is not a threat. Julian gives Ivy a list of duties to take care of today, and then he leaves. Pilar comes in to see Ivy, and Ivy questions her about Luis and Sheridan's kiss. Pilar says that Sheridan only has feelings of gratitude for Luis. Ivy thought as much, but she says that Julian sees their relationship as a threat to the family. Pilar tells her that the only relationship which could threaten this family is her love for Sam. Ivy she can't help loving Sam, so Pilar tells her to love him from afar. Ivy's talk of Sam upsets Pilar, so she stop. She tells Pilar that she has to go out, but wants her to be careful of the laser alarm guarding the safe. Later, Pilar catches Julian looking at the papers from the safe!
At the youth center, Hank shows up and finds Luis thinking about Sheridan. Hank accuses Luis of being in love, and he asks who the lucky girl is? Luis says he was thinking about a woman, kissing a woman. Hank thinks he was thinking about Beth, but Luis says it wasn't Beth. When Hank asks who he was kissing, Luis says it was Sheridan! However, he explains everything to Hank and says that he would never steal his woman. Besides, Luis says if and when he starts dating again, he won't be dating a rich woman like Sheridan. Hank says it is silly to think that he and Sheridan would be doing anything behind his back, and jokes that once her community service is up, he'll probably never see her till their wedding! Hank leaves, and Luis shoots some hoops. Hank's words about not seeing Sheridan again bother Luis. Sheridan shows up to tell Luis that she's sorry about last night, and that the time limit on performing her community service is almost up according to a letter she got from the court. Sheridan thinks she only needs about 10 more hours, but she has to put them in ASAP. Luis says she could ask for an extension, but she says she doesn't mind working long hours here. Luis reads the letter and looks at his records, and figures out she only needs three hours! He lies and tells her that she needs at least 20 more hours.
At the Bennett's, Grace and Sam are in bed. Grace enjoyed their night of love, but Sam says it's not over. Sam plans to take the day off to show Grace how much he loves her. Grace realizes it is getting late and says she better get downstairs and cook breakfast. Downstairs, Jessica gets ready for breakfast. Miguel shows up to see Charity, and Kay almost walks into the kitchen, where Miguel is, looking like a member of the living dead. Kay had just woke up and was not looking her best. Kay fixes herself up, and then goes in to cook everyone her special pancake omelettes. Sam and Grace show up and Sam asks Kay what she is doing? Kay tells her dad that she is fixing breakfast, and he knows she loves to cook. Reese shows up to see Charity's fish, which is on the window sill. They all stare at Tabitha, who says it is rude to stare. Reese says he spent all night looking through books and on the internet to identify the fish, which Sam says is truly ugly, but he couldn't find out what type it was. Therefore, Reese announces that he plans to dissect it to identify it by its internal organs! However, Miguel tells Charity that he won't let Reese dissect the fish, especially since she feels connected to it. Sam asks what she means by feeling connected to the fish? Charity says she's been having premonitions about someone she cares about being in danger. Reese says that he done research on ESP and it runs in the family. Grace says her sister had premonitions, but she doesn't know if she and Charity have any special powers. Jessica jokes that Kay is a "psycho," which angers Kay, who threatens to put bacon in Jessica's omelette. Tabitha realizes Charity's powers are growing, which means danger for her. She contacts Timmy via ESP for help. Later, Kay burns herself during a grease splatter, and she throws her pan into the sink. Unfortunately the pan hits Tabitha's fish bowl, and Tabitha heads for the drain! However, Charity saves her at the last minute, which Tabitha finds embarrassing. Sam and Grace decide to go upstairs, and Grace asks the kids to looks after the shop for her. Kay says she and Simone have to work on a paper, so Charity and Miguel are left to tend the shop.
At Tabitha's house, Timmy locks himself in a cage to keep away from Fluffy, but he ends up trapped inside because Fluffy won't budge from outside the cage! Timmy feels that he's let his princess down. In his PJs, he looks through binoculars into the kitchen and sees that Charity still has the fish, and he wonders how he'll get it. Tabitha uses ESP to contact Timmy and she tells him to hurry up and rescue her because Reese is going to dissect her! Furthermore, she fears that Charity may soon learn she is not a fish! Timmy doesn't know how to help Tabitha. Tabitha tells him that he must find the right incantation in the ancient tome, and then their psychic connection fades. Timmy doesn't know how he's going to get past Fluffy to the tome, or even find the right incantation. Timmy, who is now dressed as a wizard, gets the tome and learns he has to empty the doe skin pouch into Tabitha's fish bowl to rescue her. Suddenly, Tabitha, who almost went down the drain, ESPs Timmy for help. She tells him that her water broke! Timmy grabs a whip and plays lion tamer with Fluffy so he can escape and rescue Tabitha.
Grace and Sam go upstairs and look through their old bank statements to do their taxes. Grace finds a separate bank statement which contains money in an account with only Sam's name on it. She becomes suspicious and confronts her husband with the statement. SHe asks whim why he's hiding things from her? Sam tells her that it was supposed to be a surprise, he wanted to take her to the old ski lodge for a romantic getaway now that they've fixed it up. Grace is surprised and thanks him with a big hug. She feels silly for being jealous of Ivy while he's been planning a romantic getaway. Jessica shows up with some donuts for her parents, and overhears them talking about the romantic getway. However, Sam refuses to tell her anything, and she tells her to go to the shop to work because the more stuff they sell, the sooner they can take their trip!
At the shop, Jessica brings Charity and Miguel some donuts, but there are no chocolate ones, which are Charity's favorites. Jessica says she has some back in the house, so they head over there. Ivy shows up to look around. She plans to buy Julian's friends presents, a task on the list she gave him, from Grace's "Shop of Horrors." She hopes that she'll also run into Sam if she hangs around long enough. Jessica asks Ivy if she can help her? Ivy tells Jessica that Julian needs gifts sent to people on a list, which she hands Jessica, and she tells her that money is no object. Jessica can't believe this and she tells Ivy that her dad was joking that he wanted her to make lots of money so he could take her mom on a trip. Ivy asks Jessica if she knows where they plan on going? When Jessica finds a brochure for the ski lodge, Jessica tells her they must be planning to go to Devil's Mountain. Jessica leaves to check the store room for some gifts, and Ivy plans to make Grace and Sam's trip unforgettable!
Timmy goes over to the Bennett's yard, and Tabitha tells Timmy to climb up to the window and recite the incantation to save her. The kids leave the kitchen, but leave Reese behind. Reese continues to look through his books and study Tabitha, and he can't believe what he sees. He calls Tabitha a freak of nature, but Tabitha thinks he is talking about Timmy, who is hiding under the window sill. Fortunately for Timmy, Reese was talking about Tabitha's yellow scales. He thinks this might be a new species, so he plans to name it after Kay, which he thinks will make her love him. Reese turns away from the window, so Timmy empties the pouch, which contains Tabitha's three hundred year old toenail, into the bowl. Suddenly, Timmy exclaims "I killed my princess!" In Tabitha's bowl, the water begins to cloud. When it clears, Tabitha's head appears in the bowl! Reese looks aver at the bowl and sees Tabitha's face! Meanwhile, Charity and Miguel show up to get some donuts, and check on the fish!
Kay and Simone go to the youth center, where there will be a dance for Valentines Day. Kay thinks that she will win Miguel at the dance, but she has to learn how to seduce him properly. She asks Sheridan to teach her to tango, which Sheridan agrees to do. However, she says she needs a partner so she can demonstrate the male and female moves, so Kay asks Luis for a favor. Luis says he'd do anything for her, so she tells Luis to dance the tango with Sheridan so she can learn how. Luis agrees to dance with Sheridan so Kay can learn. Kay even requests that they make it hot and sexy like they did it last summer. Luis puts on the music, and Sheridan and Luis begin to dance. As they dance they heat up the youth center, and come close to kissing!