Elsewhere, Kay insists that they not make a big deal about this because maybe Charity is just in a bad mood right now. Jessica thinks they should talk to their parents about Charity, but Kay begs her not to do that because it would kill mom and dad to know how much she is changing. Kay says perhaps her premonitions are just getting to her. Miguel tells Kay that she is a true friend, she cares more about Charity than she does herself. Miguel leaves when he sees Theresa hurting, and Simone apologizes to Kay for thinking she was back to her old ways, but she was trying to be a truly good person. Later, Kay tells Charity that she needs to get a lot meaner, which pleases her. Kay then goes to Miguel and urges him to try and find Charity and work things out.
Meanwhile, Theresa sees Ethan with Gwen and wonders how he could have gotten over their love so quickly. Miguel comes to talk to Theresa, and they both discuss their troubles with love. Theresa wonders what is wrong with their family, why are they so unlucky with love. Theresa wonders if love is real, or just a fantasy they create. Miguel tells her that she has always believed in true love, but Theresa says she has lost her love. Theresa leaves, but then realizes she forgot her coat. Suddenly, Ethan shows up with her coat! Ethan tells her that he saw her leave without her coat, and automatically grabbed it. He says he doesn't want her to get sick. Theresa realizes Ethan still loves her, and jumps into his arms. She thinks there may still be hope for them yet. However, Ethan tells her that nothing has changed, he's sorry. Ethan says he does care about her, but they have no future.
At the mansion, TC realizes that David has fallen in love with Grace, somewhere along the line he fell in love with her. David tells TC that he is in love with Grace, and he thinks any man who gets her is the luckiest man on earth. TC realizes David knows how the DNA test will turn out, and he asks him how it will turn out? David tells TC no matter what he says, he wouldn't believe him anyways, so they better wait for the test. TC says he'll never get Grace away from Sam no matter what. David says all he wants is Grace to be happy, because he loves her.
Outside, Grace gets the feeling that something terrible is coming, that their troubles aren't behind them. Sam asks her what she feels, but she says she doesn't know. She keeps getting premonitions, and they drive her bonkers. Grace says she has no idea how Charity can handle these. Later they talk about Julian's murder, and Sam hates that their friends are suspects in this case. Grace can't believe their friends, or even Ethan could kill anyone, but Sam says sometimes the nicest people can be pushed to kill.
Back in Ivy's room, Eve tells Ivy that if she reveals her blackmail, then Ethan will learn just what a horrible person she really is, so she has just as much to lose as she does! Ivy is shocked when she realizes Eve is right, and Eve laughs and says she is happy to have turned the tables on her for once, because God knows she deserves it! Ivy warns Eve that she can't tell everyone when she tries to explain why she was being blackmailed, and what she has already done for her in the past! Eve reminds Ivy that she doesn't have to explain anything, the DNA will do that, and she should worry about what Sam will do to her once the truth comes out! Ivy claims what she did wasn't that bad, John has filled a void in Grace's life since she lost her baby. Eve tells her that she is sick to sit there and try and pass off her selfish act as one of good. Ivy tells Eve not to be so quick to claim she won't help her, because she has some more juicy info on her! Ivy says she can tells Sam that she saw her with a gun the night Julian died, she'll tell Sam that she murdered Julian! Eve asks her how she knew, and Ivy smiles and says "you just told me!" Ivy says she had opportunity, and motive. Eve tells Ivy that she also saw her with a gun that night too, two can play this game! Ivy says she'll deny everything, but Eve asks who people will believe between the two of them? Suddenly, Eve gets a call from Simone, who asks if she and Whitney can stay at the party a little longer? Eve says it is okay; but no drinking, smoking, or drugs. Eve then continues to tell Ivy that she has lost, she is finished! Eve leaves, and Ivy is not pleased at all. She thinks about Eve's conversation with Simone, and realizes what she has to do to get Eve to do her bidding. Ivy calls her man Marty, and gives him a job.
Back at the dance, Marty arrives and spikes Whitney's drink with a powdery substance. Meanwhile, Miguel tells Kay how special she is and how lucky he is to have her in his life.
TC takes Eve out to the spot that he proposed to her and they have a picnic. TC begins praising Eve for her virtuous life, and how she is the perfect mother and role model. Eve asks TC what if she wasn't perfect, what if there was something about her that would disappoint him? TC tells her nothing could change the way he feels about her. Eve thinks about Ivy's blackmail, and her claiming she should be honest with TC. Eve decides it is time to come clean with TC, but not tonight. She asks TC to hold him and so she knows he loves her. TC begins to worry and asks her what is wrong? As Eve is about to confess all, her phone rings.
At the dance, Miguel continues to praise Kay. Charity senses something is wrong, and she lets Kay know. Kay asks if she can help somehow? Charity says she knows what is going on, and she'll take care of it and have fun doing so. Later, Kay talks to Miguel about love, and Charity. Miguel feels bad for taking her away from Reese tonight, but she says it is okay, she wants to be with him. He asks her why, but then realizes it is because she's such a good person and a good friend. Miguel just wishes he knew what happened to Charity, and he begins to think that maybe evil has returned and has taken over Charity. Kay doesn't know if that is what has happened, but Miguel says that is the only explanation he could think of. Kay sees a light coming from the cave, which they have walked close to, and tries to get Miguel to go back to her place and talk some more. Suddenly, Miguel hears Timmy scream and thinks someone is in trouble.
Back at the dance, Whitney downs the soda that has been spiked with a drug. The drug begins to take effect, and when Whitney is asked to dance, she goes for it. Whitney soon begins to dirty dance, and it shocks Chad. When Whitneys first dancing partner decides to take a break, she grabs another guy. Simone, Reese, and Jessica are also shocked by Whitney, who is now dancing on a table! Simone says this is not like Whitney, something is really wrong. Simone tries to stop her sister, but she says not now. Simone drags Whitney off the dance floor. Whitney says she's only having a good time, and she's sick of people trying to spoil her fun! Whitney goes back out to the dance floor, and Simone begins to cry because she's so afraid. Later, Whitney remembers the horrible things Kelly told her earlier, and decides to show her. Whitney turns on a funky beat, grabs the microphone, and begins singing about making love like a real woman. Simone ends up calling her mom and tells her something is wrong with Whitney. Simone says Whitney is dancing, singing, and flirting with strange guys, she is out of control! Eve says she'll be right there.
Meanwhile, Tabitha shows up looking for Timmy, who seems to have run off on her. Tabitha sees Whitney dancing, and wishes she had her powers back so she could find out what is going on. Suddenly, Tabitha has a vision of Ivy ordering her man to drug Whitney, and realizes that is what is going on. Timmy heads to the cave were Charity is, and thinks of a way to save the real Charity. Timmy gets into the cave, and begins chipping away at the ice. Suddenly, Zombie Charity shows up! Zombie Charity refuses to allow Timmy to save the real Charity. Tabitha eventually shows up, and tells Zombie Girl to leave her Timmy alone! Charity says she knows all about her, she read her book! Charity says it was really good, but nothing compared to what she has in store for Harmony! Zombie girl then starts attempting to zap Charity with lightening bolts. Charity laughs and says there is so much pain in store for them! Tabitha says she isn't frightened easily, but Charity assures her that she will be! Tabitha tells Charity to just tell her what is in store for her. Charity asks her if she thinks she can handle it?
Eve and TC head over to the youth center to see what is going on with Whitney. At the youth center, Whitney sings and dances for the boys, stunning Kelly. Simone calls Chad and begs him to get back to the dance to help them out, he had to run to the Book Cafe. Chad is stunned to learn what Whitney has been up to. Chad shows up and realizes something is really wrong. Chad turns off the music, and decides to take care of this. Eve and TC call back and talk to Simone. Simone tries to explain to her dad what Whitney is going on, but static interferes and he thinks Chad has done something to Whitney. Whitney thinks about Chad as he's trying to get through to her, and she ends up grabbing the microphone again, and decides to play a song which expresses how she feels about love. She plays What's Love Got To Do With It, and and starts dancing around. Chad tells him not to do this, but she says she wants to dance. Whitney tries to seduce Chad on the dance floor, and he says he's going to throw her over his shoulder and take her home if he has to. She dares him to just try, and he chases her. This is when Eve and TC walk in, and TC thinks Chad is trying to hurt Whitney. Eve says they don't know what is going on here, but TC isn't about to wait and find out! Simone tries to stop her dad in time, but she is too late. TC decks Chad! Simone wants to tell her dad to stop, but Reese says it is too dangerous to go near them right now. TC yells at Chad to get up! Chad has a flashback of someone standing over him to tell him to get up and take his whooping like a man. Chad goes nuts because of his memory, and jumps all over TC. Eve goes to check on Whitney,
Ivy's henchman calls Ivy and tells her what is happening at the party. He is very concerned that he may have given her too much, but Ivy says as long as she acts like a tramp that is all she cares about.
In Harmony, Luis continues to think about the reunion. Hank is worried about Luis, and thinks he really should stay here in her old cottage. Luis knows she is out there somewhere, Elsewhere, Beth is stunned when she gets a package from Sheridan! She calls Luis' cell phone, and Hank answers for Luis. Beth asks for Luis, and Hank says this isn't a good time. Beth says this is important. She asks where they are, and when she finds out, she says she'll be right over. Luis gets his hopes up and thinks that Beth may know something that will lead him to Sheridan. Beth shows up, and tells Luis she received a package from Sheridan, and she thought he'd want to see it. Luis opens it, and smiles and says "Sheridan!"
On the island, Brian sits outside of Diana/Sheridan's room. He realizes that even though she has amnesia, she is still in love with her dead lover. In her room, Sheridan dreams about Luis. Later, she sleep walks out of her room when Brian leaves to have tea with Liz. Brian worries Sheridan may have gone back to the ocean, which is what she has done! Sheridan is on the beach looking at the water saying that her love is out there. Brian and Liz find her on the beach, and she assures them that she is wide awake and is fine. Sheridan talks to Brian for awhile, and thinks perhaps her memories were wrong and her lover is alive and out there looking for her. Brian says if he was alive, why hasn't he looked for her? Sheridan says maybe he is looking for her, and thing have just gone wrong for him.
In the cave, Zombie Charity decides to kill Tabitha and Timmy, but Tabitha tells her that she can't because she doesn't know enough about the people in this town to cause enough pain. Charity says she read her book, and she knows plenty. Tabitha explains that the book doesn't tell the whole story, and she begins to recount how she broke up Sheridan and Luis in a past life as Antony and Cleopatra. We see Tabitha in ancient Egypt, with Timmy. Timmy is a Roman soldier who stalls Marc Antony so that Tabitha can visit Cleopatra. Cleopatra has a plan to be with her love forever, but Tabitha brings an asp into her room in a basket in order to kill her!
Back in Harmony, Luis discovers Sheridan's gift is a book detailing their entire relationship. BEth explains that Sheridan had the book sent off to the binders, and it just arrived today. She also promised Sheridan that if anything happened, she would give the book to Luis. Beth explains that Sheridan had a feeling she wasn't going to be around much longer, and she wanted Luis to have this. Luis is still sure that Sheridan is alive and out there somewhere. On the island, Sheridan tells Brian that she is positive her love is alive and looking for her, and she is getting many signs that are telling her this.
At the dance, TC and Chad continue to go at it. Chad is in a trance, and eventually Miguel, Reese, and Simone get them apart. Kelly and Reese take Chad outside to cool off. Meanwhile, Eve is horrified when Whitney continues to chase boys around the place. Eve and TC take Whitney home, and Ivy's henchman follows because he's very worried he gave Whitney too much of the drug and she could die. Once home, Whitney collapses, and the man fears she has OD'd. Elsewhere, Chad is upset that TC thinks he hurt Whitney, because he would never do that because he loves her. Later, Miguel talks to Reese, and they head to the cave with Jessica and Kay. Reese has a machine that will detect if there is a cavern behind the rubble!