At the Bennett house, Grace asks Sam why he thinks Tabitha would want to hurt Charity? Sam says he doesn't know, and that perhaps his mind is working overtime. Grace offers to take his mind off work and gives him a kiss.
In the kitchen, Miguel is thrilled that Charity has agreed to go out on a date with him. Charity asks where they are going, but Miguel wants to keep it a surprise. Jessica offers to help Charity pick something special out to wear for her date, but tells Charity to go up and start looking and she'll be up in a bit. Charity tells Miguel that she'll see him in a while and leaves. Charity goes into the living room and interrupts Grace and Sam's make-out fest. She tells them that she and Miguel are going out on their first date, and she was wondering if her aunt would help her with her hair. Grace says of course she will, and that she'll be upstairs in a few minutes.
Grace goes up to see Charity and is glad that Charity is so happy. Charity thinks Miguel is such a wonderful guy and thinks this will be a wonderful date. Grace tells Charity that there will be more dates, and she has a good feeling about her and Miguel. Charity asks Grace how she knew she was in love with Sam, and how she knew he was the man she wanted to spend the rest of her life with? Grace tells her those are questions for another day.
Back downstairs, Sam tells Miguel to take it slow with Charity tonight. Miguel assures Sam that he and Charity will only be getting to know one another better. Sam then begins to question Reese about the Halloween dance and how he and Kay were kissing. Sam says that if they were kissing, that means Kay likes him, and he wants him to take care of her. Reese says he will take good care of her, and then Miguel and Reese leave.
Out in the backyard, Kay tells Simone that she's been such a fool and she has to face the facts, she's lost Miguel forever. Simone tells her that there will be other boys, but Kay says she'll never love anyone like she loves Miguel. Jessica overhears her sister talking to Simone and actually feels bad for her. Simone tries to cheer Kay up by telling her that she has so much going for her right now and there are so many other girls out there worse off than she is. Jessica goes back inside and tells her dad that Kay is feeling very unloved right now. Sam goes outside to visit with Kay and he asks her to tell him about her problems. She thanks him but says this is a problem she has to handle on her own. Sam thinks this has to do with Miguel, and Kay asks "You know?" However, Sam thinks that she's just upset that her buddy Miguel is entering a serious relationship, but she is feeling love has passed her by. However, Sam says perhaps Reese is the man for her! Sam tells Kay that Reese isn't doing anything tonight, so she should invite him over for dinner. Kay doesn't think that would be a good idea. Sam decides to leave, and Simone returns and asks Kay what all this talk about dinner is about? Kay tells her that her dad wants her to have dinner with Reese, he practically has them married! A spying Tabitha tells Timmy that they have to keep Kay focused on Miguel, and she's not pleased when Kay tells Simone that she's lost Miguel to Charity forever.
Sam goes back inside and Miguel has returned for his and Charity's date. He asks Miguel if he's heard anything from his brother yet? Miguel tells him not yet. Charity comes downstairs and Miguel tells her that she looks beautiful. Grace wants to take pictures of Charity and Miguel, and she wants Kay and Jessica in them. Jessica says Kay isn't feeling to well, but Charity says they can't take pictures without her, so she decides to go get her. Charity shouts out the back door at Kay to ask her to come in to take some pictures.
Back outside, Kay tells Simone to go make up an excuse for her, she can't go in there and pretend to be happy for Charity and Miguel. After Simone leaves, Tabitha approaches Kay and offers to help her get Miguel.
Ethan wonders why Gwen would go to see Theresa? He thinks that Gwen is blowing everything way out of proportion, Theresa is not after him. He decides to get over to Theresa's place before something horrible happens.
At the Lopez-Fitzgerald house, Gwen walks into Theresa's room, and Theresa thinks she's finished. Lucky for Theresa, Whitney managed to take care of everything and take down her shrine to Ethan. Unfortunately, one picture of Ethan is still sticking out from underneath her bed! Gwen doesn't understand why Theresa didn't want her to see her room, it is very inviting and attractive, but she suggests Theresa hang some photographs on her wall. Gwen laughs and says she suspected her wall would have been full of pictures of Ethan, which would have proved her hypothesis right. Theresa stands on the picture of Ethan to try and keep it hidden, but when she and Whitney try to get Gwen out of the room, Ethan shows up! To make matters worse, Gwen ends up standing on top of the picture of Ethan! Gwen says she will leave, but Ethan says he came here to see her (Gwen). Ethan says that he learned she was here and came to see her. Gwen says she was just getting to know Theresa better. Ethan apologizes to Theresa for involving her in this, but Gwen says she is involved. Gwen asks Theresa if she wanted something to happen up at the cabin, and if she still wants something to happen? Ethan tells Gwen that is an inappropriate question, Theresa has no interest in him. He suggests they take this outside, and Gwen thinks perhaps he's right. When Gwen goes to leave she hears the picture under her foot crinkle and wonders what the sound was. Whitney quickly grabs the picture off the bottom of Gwen's shoe and says that it is just an article on Arthur Ash she's been looking for. Gwen and Ethan leave, and Theresa tells Whitney that she was incredible! Theresa and Whitney eavesdrop on Ethan and Gwen, who are fighting about Ethan. Ethan wants Gwen to apologize to Theresa, but Gwen refuses to believe she is wrong about Theresa's motives. Gwen wishes Sheridan was here to talk some sense into him. Theresa thinks that Gwen is dumping Ethan, but Whitney says she is just taking shots at Ethan. Theresa tells Whitney that if Gwen leaves Ethan, she's going to go tell Ethan just how she feels about him. Back in the living room where Ethan and Gwen are talking, Ethan asks Gwen for proof that Theresa is after him. Gwen is hurt that he doesn't trust her judgement, so she leaves. Theresa goes into the living room and decides to make her move on Ethan. Theresa goes to Ethan and tells him that she thinks he needs her now.
At the cabin in New Mexico, Sheridan wakes up and sees Luis looking at her. She asks him if he is the great love of her life? Luis tells her that it is just him, Luis. Sheridan tells him that she always dreamed about a man who would love her for who she is, not for her family and money, and she wonders if he is that man? Luis tells her that she needs to rest, but Sheridan fears if she closes her eyes he'll disappear and break her heart. She makes him hold her hand and promise never to leave her. Luis tells her he won't leave her, but she has him confused with someone else. Sheridan kisses him, but he pushes her away. She asks if she's not good enough for him? Luis tells her that she's just confused, but Sheridan thinks he doesn't love her because he knows what she did in the past. Luis asks her what happened in her past? Fortunately for Sheridan, she passes out passes out and begins to moan in her sleep. Luis looks out the window, the wind has picked up and the rain is really coming down. Suddenly the rain comes down the chimney and puts out the fire. Luis realizes that without a fire, Sheridan could die. Luis realizes the only way he can keep Sheridan warm is with body heat, so he takes off all his clothes and hops into bed with her! Sheridan wakes up and tells Luis that she needs him to make love to her now!
Outback, Tabitha gives Kay a gift, a brooch her father gave her. She tells her that legend has it if you look into the center stone you will see the face of the one you will spend all eternity with. Kay thinks she will be spending all eternity alone, but looks into it anyways. She is shocked when she sees Miguel looking back at her. Kay cries and tells Tabitha that this isn't for her, she should give it to Charity. Tabitha tells her that whoever she saw in the brooch is meant to be hers for the taking. Kay says that the brooch is wrong, she will never have Miguel. Tabitha tells Kay that she knows just how she is feeling right now, and she'd hate for the same thing that happened to her to happen to Kay. Kay asks Tabitha what happened to her? Tabitha says she loved a boy that her father greatly admired, her father even told her that he would make a great son in law. Tabitha says she would have done anything to please her father, even if it meant making her boyfriend his son in law. Unfortunately, her boyfriend fell in love with someone else, so she gave up on him completely. She tells Kay that she broke her father's heart because she didn't even try to win him back. Tabitha cries that she's such an unhappy old spinster who lives alone except for a mangy old cat and a doll she pretends is her son. Timmy, who is listening in, begins to cry for his poor princess. Tabitha tells Kay that she may have lost her love forever, but it's not to late for her and Miguel. Tabitha decides to go back inside, and Kay tells herself that she will fight for Miguel and make her dad proud. An eavesdropping Tabitha is pleased and tells Kay to make like a Mountie and go get her man. Timmy tells Tabitha that he's touched that she thinks of him as his child and perhaps he should call her mommy from now on. Tabitha tells him not to even think about it, that entire story she told Kay was a lie! Timmy asks Tabitha how Kay saw Miguel's face in that brooch, has she gotten her powers back? Tabitha says that was wishful thinking on Kay's part, and she hasn't gotten her powers back.
Kay goes back inside and Simone can't believe that she doesn't look upset at all. Jessica also wonders why Kay is looking so calm? Kay poses with Miguel and Charity for a picture and smiles like she's never been happier. Charity and Miguel leave for their date, and Kay tells herself that this will be Charity's first and last date with Miguel. Kay manages to learn that Miguel is taking Charity to the Book Cafe, so she calls Reese and invites him out to the Book Cafe with her. Simone can't believe Kay is going after Miguel again. Kay tells Simone that she is not going to let Charity take Miguel from her! Back outside, a spying Tabitha hopes that this will be the beginning of her getting her powers back. Timmy asks Tabitha how she will know if her powers are coming back? Tabitha tells him that the brimstone in her basement will begin to glow red again. The shot pans over to Tabitha's basement door where a red light begins to seep under the door!
At the Lopez-Fitzgerald house, Theresa thinks that Gwen has dumped Ethan, so she decides to go tell Ethan that she loves him. She approaches Ethan after Gwen leaves and tells Ethan that she thinks he needs her. Ethan asks her what she means? Theresa asks him if it is not obvious? Ethan thinks he knows what she means, and he realizes now how special she is and her appreciates her offering to convince Gwen that she's wrong about her being interested in him. Ethan asks her if that is what she meant, she was going to try and smooth things over with Gwen? Theresa says of course that is what she meant. Ethan thanks her, but says there is nothing she can say to turn Gwen around. He doesn't understand Gwen lately and wonders where all this jealousy is coming from. Ethan asks Theresa if women have a secret radar that allows them to know when a woman is after there man? Theresa says she can't say because she's never been in that position. Ethan thanks her anyways and says Gwen's radar must be out of whack. Ethan gives Theresa a hug, and then tells her goodnight. Theresa breaks down after Ethan leaves, and Whitney comforts her. Whitney tries to talk some sense into Theresa, but Theresa thinks she still has a chance with Ethan and is going to the mansion to see Ethan.
At the Crane Mansion, Julian calls his father to report on Luis and Sheridan's escapades. Alastair is furious with Julian and tells him to take care of this matter now, before he gets drunk! Alastair tells Julian to put down his drink and get to work, he must sacrifice anyone to protect their secret about what really happened that night. Julian assures his father that he will make sure their secret is safe. Ivy returns and Ivy begins to taunt Julian once again about his lack of progress. However, Ivy tells him that if this secret really will hurt the whole family, she will keep it under wraps. Julian assures Ivy that Ethan will be devastated by the secret and they better hope that Pilar never sees her husband again. Ivy says she can't protect her son if she doesn't know what is at stake. Ivy asks Julian what will happen if Sheridan and Luis find Ethan? Julian tells her to just back off, and he walks off.
In New Mexico, Sheridan asks Luis to make love to her right now. Luis tells her that she has him confused with someone else, he's only trying to keep her warm. He tells her to get some rest because they have a big day ahead of them tomorrow. Luis thinks about his dad and what he'll do to him when he finally finds him, will he turn him in, or kill him? Outside, Martin shows up at his cabin thinking that Luis and Sheridan will never find him here. Luis hears Martin outside, so he slips on his pants to investigate. MArtin opens up the front door and Luis grabs him. Luis demands to know if he is his father Martin Fitzgerald. Martin looks at Luis and calls him by his name. Luis thinks that proves he is his father and he tells him that he knows the whole story about how he stole from the Cranes and ran away, and now he's going to get the punishment he deserves. When Sheridan begins calling out for help, Luis has to let his father go to tend to Sheridan. Martin takes off in his car, but Luis vows to find his father again. Luis climbs back into bed with Sheridan to continue keeping her warm.
Back in Harmony, Ethan returns home and tells his mom that his situation with Gwen has gone from bad to worse. Ethan goes up to his room and Ivy calls Gwen to try and talk some sense into her. She tells Gwen that she knows from experience what it feels like to lose a love and regret it for the rest of your life. Gwen begins to think that perhaps she did over-react, so she agrees to come right over and resolve her problems with Ethan. After she hangs up, Julian asks Ivy who this long lost love of hers is? He says if she doesn't tell him now, he'll find out eventually. Ivy tells him that she'll give him a hint, he lives here in Harmony. Julian wants a name, and Ivy tells him it was him. She tells him that she only told Gwen what was necessary to get him to talk to Ethan. At this point Theresa sneaks into the house, and Julian gets a call from MArtin. Julian excuses himself and asks Martin what is going on? Martin tells him that Luis almost killed him tonight and if he doesn't do something soon then he will expose his entire scheme. Julian tells Martin that he isn't the one who give orders here, and hangs up on him.
Theresa sneaks up to Ethan's room and finds Ethan kicking himself for not telling Gwen the truth about the cabin. Theresa suggests they focus on something else, like that project he wanted her to work on. Ethan says he can't concentrate right now because he's so tense and his neck is noted up. Theresa offers to massage his neck for him, but he refuses the offer. When he tries to work on the project with her, he finds that he can't and decides to take Theresa up on her offer. Theresa begins to massage Ethan's neck for him. Meanwhile, Gwen shows up and makes her way upstairs. BAck in Ethan's room, Theresa can't loosen up Ethan's neck, so she tells him to lie on the bed. Ethan lies on the bed and Theresa climbs on top of him. Suddenly, Gwen walks into Ethan's room and is shocked to see Theresa lying with Ethan on his bed!
Though Ethan frantically insists she's misread the situation, a devastated Gwen informs him they are through. Tabitha explains to a confused Timmy how Charity's love for Miguel has to transcend the spiritual and become physical if she's to come into her full powers. Eve fears that Orville's reentry into her life will threaten everything she holds dear---especially her husband and daughters. Gwen bitterly congratulates Theresa for successfully luring Ethan into her clutches at last. T.C. describes for Chad the familiar looking blue envelopes stuffed with hundred dollar bills which he found hidden in Orville's apartment. Meanwhile, Orville mumbles in his sleep about Eve's secret. Gwen unleashes a flood of venomous words at Theresa as Ethan tries in vain to put an end to her verbal attack. As Tabitha and Timmy eavesdrop, Kay cautions Charity not to let Miguel get to first base. Eve is jarred when Orville warns that someone else knows she's living a lie.
At Tabitha's house, Tabitha is busy ordering Timmy around. She has him help her get comfortable on the couch so she can take a well deserved nap. Timmy tells her not to go to sleep yet, he has a surprise for her! She tells him whatever it is it can wait, and she begins to snore. Tabitha eventually wakes up when she hears Timmy singing "Oh Christmas Tree!" Timmy has set up a little Christmas tree and is wearing a Santa hat. He begins singing "Deck the Halls" and "Silent Night," and Tabitha screams at him to stop it! She is furious with Timmy for doing this and tells him that if she hears a "Ho Ho Ho" come out of his mouth she will send him to the Bennetts! She asks him what their friends in the basement would think if they caught them celebrating Christmas? Timmy doesn't think they have to know, but Tabitha says they know when they are bad or good, so they have to be good for goodness sake! Tabitha throws the tree into a garbage bag and starts screaming how she hates Christmas! Timmy is sad that they won't be celebrating Christmas because he was looking forward to presents. Tabitha tells him that they don't celebrate Christmas, so Timmy asks if they are Jewish? She tells Timmy that they celebrate Halloween, that is their holiday. Timmy feels jipped because all he got for Halloween was chased by a priest. The shot pans over to Tabitha's basement door and we see red fog seep out from under it, exit through Tabitha's window, and pour into the Bennett's kitchen! The fog envelopes the toys on the table, which come to life! Upstairs in Sam and Grace's room, Grace begins to feel the presence of evil Back at Tabitha's place, Tabitha begins to sense that something strange is going on, something that has never happened before.
Ethan races out of the mansion after Gwen and begs her to hear him out because their future is at stake. Gwen is in tears and says they have no future, his future is with Theresa. Ethan says Theresa is a nice girl, but she is not after him and he does not want her. Gwen tells him to open his eyes, Theresa wants him. Ethan doesn't understand how a girl like Theresa could make her so insecure. Gwen says she is not insecure or threatened by the housekeepers daughter because this is not what this is about. Ethan thinks that she's hurt that he hasn't proposed to her again and she's afraid of losing him to Theresa. Gwen says he has one thing right, she has lost him to Theresa. Gwen tells Ethan that she loved him from the minute she saw him, and she knows it took him a little while longer to realize that they were meant to be together. Ethan says everyone wants to see them married, it is there destiny. However, Gwen says not everyone wants to see them married, something inside of him is causing him to not commit to her. Ethan tells her that he is so wrong, so he gets down on one knee and proposes to her.
Up in Ethan's room, Theresa calls Whitney and tells her that she will marry Ethan and Ivy Crane will have her as a daughter in law. Suddenly, someone opens the door, and Theresa fears that Ivy has shown up and heard every word she's said. Theresa turns around and is relieved to see her mother standing in the doorway, not Ethan's. Theresa tells Whitney that she has to go, and she'll see her tonight. Pilar lectures Theresa and tells her that she's deluding herself if she think that Ethan is falling in love with her. Theresa says that Gwen knows Ethan is falling for her, and that is why she is so upset, and she doesn't blame her. Ivy walks in at this point and says "Excuse me!" Ivy wants Theresa to explain what she meant when she said Ethan is falling in love with her? THeresa says that Ethan hasn't fallen in love with her, but Gwen thinks that is what has happened because of what she saw. Ivy asks what Gwen saw? She explains everything and that she was only trying to give Ethan a neck massage, but Gwen mis-interpreted it. Ivy apologizes for jumping to conclusions and says her being in love with Ethan is as ridiculous as Ethan loving her. Ivy looks out the window and sees Ethan on one knee and exclaims to Pilar and Theresa that Ethan is finally proposing to Gwen! Theresa opens the window and hears Gwen tell Ethan that she can't accept this proposal, he's proposing to prove a point, not out of love. Gwen tells Ethan that she wants a proposal to come from his soul so that she knows that she is the only woman he wants, and no other proposal will do. Theresa smiles when she hears Gwen turn down Ethan. Ethan asks if they are over? Gwen tells him that he is proposing to her for all the wrong reason, and if he can't even see that . . . Gwen walks away, and Theresa believes that fate is on her side.
Ivy talks with Ethan and tells him that she knows what happens and is sorry. Ethan hopes Gwen will reconsider because she is making a decision she may regret for the rest of her life. Ivy knows what that it is like to make a decision you live to regret. Ethan tells his mother that he needs to clear his head, so she asks him to take a check to the church for her. Ethan says he'd be glad to do that because the church is one place he won't get into any trouble.
The citizens of Harmony go to the church to decorate it for Christmas. Pilar continues to try to talk some sense into Theresa, but she won't hear it. She rushes over to tell Whitney the good news. Ethan shows up later, and Theresa just happens to faint into his arms! Elsewhere, Pilar finds Father Lonagin praying at the base of the angel statue and tells him that he should rest, but he says he must keep praying to protect innocent souls from the evil which is coming to Harmony.
In New Mexico, Sheridan wakes up and has fully recovered, but wonders why she is naked in bed with Luis! Luis wakes up and is glad to see she is better. He explains everything to her, but she thinks he's lying about nothing happening because he has traces of her lipstick on his mouth. She demands to know what he did to her while she was unconscious! Luis is insulted by her accusations and tells her that she is the one who kissed him. Sheridan apologizes, but doesn't know why she would kiss him. Luis says she was delusional and thought he was a mysterious man without a face who was supposed to come rescue and love her. Sheridan says she often dreams about a man coming to her rescue, but he is not the man of her dreams. Sheridan then asks if Martin Fitzgerald being here was a dream or not? Luis says he was here, but he's not 100 percent positive he is his father, but it looks like it could be his father. Sheridan can't believe he doesn't know if the guy is his father, and asks why he didn't stop him from leaving? Luis asks Sheridan why confronting his father is so important, is she hiding something? Sheridan says of course not, but she almost drown trying to get answers and she doesn't want to go back to Harmony empty handed. Luis says that he didn't let his father get away, he had to let him go in order to return to her because she was screaming. Sheridan is touched that he chose to help her instead of going after his father. However, Luis says he was only worried about her and was doing his duty as a policeman to protect her. Sheridan tells him that they aren't in Harmony and he doesn't owe her anything out here, but Luis says he just acted on his cop instinct.
Julian shows up in New Mexico to take care of his problems once and for all. Julian questions a mysterious man to see if he's gotten any new leads on Martin Fitzgerald? The man says no, which upsets Julian. Julian tells the man that he has to find Martin and get him out of town before Luis and Sheridan find him! Later Julian calls Ivy to see if she's heard from Sheridan, but she says she hasn't. Ivy tells him he better be careful while in Santa Fe, he wouldn't want to run into Sheridan and Luis. Julian tells her that he doesn't have to worry about that because they aren't in town. Unfortunately for Julian, Sheridan and Luis have just returned to the hotel where he is staying!
Martin is hiding in some hotel screaming at Julian Crane's answering machine on the phone. Outside his room, Luis and Sheridan show up, and Julian isn't far behind him. Luis tells both Sheridan and Julian to stay out of his way while he takes care of Martin. Luis kicks in the door, and Julian bursts in and makes sure that his voice is the first one Martin hears. He tries to warn Martin to run, but Martin, who wasn't looking at the door, asks Crane where he's been? Luis asks Julian and Martin what in the hell is going on?
At the church, Theresa falls off the ladder she was standing on to hang decorations, and just happens to fall right into Ethan's arms. Theresa isn't all there because she hit her head and is daydreaming about marrying Ethan. Ethan asks her if she is okay? Theresa, who is still daydreaming, tells Ethan that she loves him. Ethan is shocked and asks "What did you say?" Theresa continues her daydream in which she is marrying Ethan. She is reciting her vows to him as her matron of honor, Whitney, tells her to snap out of it! Whitney eventually slaps Theresa to in real time, and Theresa feels very embarrassed. Ethan tells her that it is okay, she bumped her head and was a little delirious. Ethan tells her that she was dreaming about her wedding, and asks who she was marrying? Theresa hopes she didn't say anything she'd regret. Ethan says she did tell him that she loved him, but it was obvious she was dreaming about they guy she's crazy about. Ethan asks Whitney what Theresa's boyfriend is like? Whitney says he's a nice man . . . Theresa interrupts and asks Ethan why he's here? Ethan says he's brought a check for Father Lonagin, so Theresa offers to take him to Father Lonagin's office. Unfortunately they can't find him, so Theresa tries to convince him to wait around for him to return. Theresa starts telling Ethan about how she was an alter girl when she was little and it made her feel that everyone was equal in God's eyes. Ethan looks at the bookcase and asks Theresa what all the books are? Theresa says that they are church records. Theresa pulls down a book and shows Ethan her parents' marriage certificate. Theresa becomes teary eyed when she looks at it. Ethan wonders why her mother never remarried. Theresa is shocked and tells Ethan that marriage is forever, it is sacred. Ethan says he wasn't saying that marriage wasn't sacred, and he agrees that when he gets married it will be forever. Ethan tells Theresa that he admires her family and how close they all are, his family isn't close like hers. Ethan says that he hopes some day when they get married they can have a family like she has. Theresa freaks out at this point because she thinks that Ethan wants to marry her. Unfortunately, Ethan was talking about him marrying Gwen, and her marrying her boyfriend. However, Ethan is taken aback when he sees the light reflecting in Theresa's eyes, and tells her not to move because they are so beautiful, and that the colors are almost like a Monet.
At the Bennett house, Grace and Sam are still in bed, and Sam asks Grace why she's thinking about the little girl's warning of evil? Grace says that she doesn't know why. Sam tells her that it is Christmas time and everything is wonderful. Grace still can't shake the feeling that something is wrong, but Sam tells her that everything is fine. As they kiss, the angel girl's ball of white light appears in their room. The next time we see them, Sam and Grace are getting dressed. Grace fears that something is wrong, so she goes to check on the kids.
Downstairs, an eerie red fog begins to seep into the Bennett's kitchen, and it brings the mechanical Christmas toys on the table to life! The angel girl's ball of light floats into the kitchen
Outside, Miguel, Charity, Reese, and Kay return from their double date. Charity says that Christmas must be so much fun in Harmony. Miguel tells her that it is a blast and that everyone goes all out, and that in Harmony Christmas lasts until New Years. Miguel thanks Charity for going out with him, and the two come close to kissing, but Charity backs away, which pleases Kay. When Reese tries to kiss Kay, she backs away from him and asks him what kind of girl he thinks she is? She quickly grabs Simone, who tagged along with them, and goes inside.
In the living room, Hank puts on some Christmas Carol's and warms his hands by the fire. Sam and Grace come downstairs, and all the kids come in. Grace is glad to see that the kids are okay, but she tells Sam that she can't shake this strange sensation that something is wrong. Suddenly, Grace hears a strange noise coming from the kitchen. There is a big whooshing sound and a flash of light comes from the kicthen, and everyone wonders what it was. Sam thinks it may be the toys making the noises. Back in the kitchen, the red fog retreats, and Hank and Sam go in to check on the demonic toys. When they say nothing is wrong, everyone else comes in. They all wonder what is going on, and Grace realizes that they are going to be late for church.
The Bennetts arrive at the church, and Charity is sent down to the basement to retrieve some decorations. The basement is dark and gloomy, and all the angel statues down there begin to call her name. Charity turns on the light and sees the angel statues are moving and calling out her name! The angels tell her that she is the one, which frightens her. Back upstairs, Miguel begins to worry about Charity, but Kay tells him that wherever she is, she'll be back soon. Simone sees Kay looking at her brooch, so she asks Kay what the deal with it is? Kay tells her that it is magic and if you look into it you'll see the face of the boy you love. Simone looks into it and sees Miguel's face, and she tells Kay that it is evil and she should get rid of it.
At Tabitha's place, Tabitha gets the feeling that something is happening, but she doesn't know what. Timmy thinks they should head for the airport and head for Hawaii. Timmy has a little daydream about being in Hawaii enjoying a nice MarTimmy on the beach. Suddenly, Timmy sees the fog seeping out from the basement door and is frightened. He tries to tell Tabitha about it, but she tells him to shut up so she can think. He eventually trips Tabitha to get her attention. She is furious with him because she could have broken something. Timmy yells at her, and she asks what he's yelling about? Timmy points to the basement door and says "that!" Tabitha sees the red fog going back into her basement and realizes it was in the Bennetts house for some reason. Tabitha isn't sure, but she thinks she's getting her powers back. Timmy asks her how she can tell? She says she'll have to test them out by trying to levitate him. She asks her powers to come to her, and thinks they are returning. Timmy asks why he's still on the floor then? Suddenly, Timmy begins to levitate! Needless to say Tabitha is pleased to have her powers back. Timmy starts crying that he wants down, and eventually he crashes to the ground. Tabitha is shocked because she didn't bring him down, so she decides to try and levitate something else, and picks a table. She casts her spell again, but the table doesn't move. Tabitha fears that her powers have left her again, and she sees the glow in the basement is dimming. She tells Timmy that means that goodness is winning, and she has to do something about that.