At the Book Cafe, Ethan catches Theresa on the phone with the abortion clinic, and thinks that she is calling them to make an appointment for Lynn. He tells her that this is a decision Lynn has to make, and he also can't believe Theresa is doing something he knows she is against because of her upbringing. Theresa and Ethan return to the others, and Lynn becomes suspicious. When Ethan brings Theresa some locs, a bagel, and cream cheese; Theresa becomes nauseous. Lynn calls Theresa out and accuses her of being pregnant. Ethan says that can't be, because she is on the pill. Lynn says that no form of birth control is fool-proof, and she tells Theresa to admit that she is pregnant.
At the pond and surrounding area, the kids find the bloody snow, and fear something has happened to Kay and Charity. Jessica and Simone both wonder if Kay may have done something to Charity. Meanwhile, in the cave, Kay is stunned when a second Charity appears from the block of ice. She is confused, until the second Charity shows her the spell book and points at her to read a passage. Timmy is also confused, so Tabitha explains that this Charity is a zombie who will abide Kay's wishes! Kay and Zombie Charity leave the cave, and meet back up with the others, where Zombie Charity acts very kid like and childish. Miguel thinks that Charity was just trying to lure everyone out of hiding so she could win.
At the Lopez-Fitzgeralds, Pilar and Luis discuss the phone call. Luis calls the caller back, but nobody answers. They are both confused as to who was calling, and Pilar wonders if Sheridan and Antonio could be together. Luis thinks that is impossible, and makes no sense. Pilar lights candles for Martin, Antonio, and Sheridan. She hopes Luis will begin praying again soon. Luis prays at the candle, and asks God to bring Sheridan back to him. As Luis prays, the flame on Sheridan's candle burns brighter.
Down on the islands, Brian refuses to answer his ringing phone, as he thinks it is just his family, whom he doesn't want to talk to. Sheridan and Brian argue, and Sheridan asks him why he called himself Antonio on the phone? Brian tells her that it is his middle name. They head back to shore, and Sheridan sees that Liz has put some candles out. Sheridan lights it, and makes a wish to find someone who cares about her. Brian is reminded of how his mom used to light candles for his father. As Sheridan and Luis both pray, the flames of their candles burn brighter.
At Tabitha's, Zombie Charity continues to obey Kay's every wish. Kay orders her to keep pushing Miguel away, until she pushes him out of his life. Later, after Miguel calls, Kay gets a brilliant idea!
At the Lopez-Fitzgerald house, the teens helps Miguel trim the family tree, but Kay and Charity are absent. Miguel worries about Charity, and decides to give her a call. Kay, however, intercepts the call, hangs up, and says she can't talk to Miguel right now until she knows what to do. Miguel wonders what is up with Charity. Later, Charity and Kay show up, and Charity acts all lovey-dovey with Miguel, which is part of Kay's plan. Simone is relieved that Kay doesn't seem to be up to anything. Kay assures Simone that she has changed. Meanwhile, Zombie Charity gives Kay an evil smile.
Luis continues to grieve for Sheridan. Pilar comes home with food for the Christmas feast. Luis sees that his mom is making tamalis, which are Antonio's favorite. He also sees ingrediants for creme brule, Sheridan's favorite dessert. Pilar says she is just hoping for miracles this Christmas. Luis tells his mom that they have to stop doing this, Sheridan isn't coming back. Pilar knows what she heard on that phone, and she knows that Luis would never mistake someone elses voice for Sheridan's. Luis says it doesn't make sense, why are they together? Pilar doesn't know, but says she will light a candel for Antonio every day until he comes home. She asks him to light one for Sheridan, but he refuses. He tells her that she has to accept that Antonio is not coming back, and neither is Sheridan!
On the island, Brian has a dream about going back to Harmony for Christmas, but being confronted by Luis. Luis asks him if he plans on staying in Harmony, and Brian says no. Luis tells him to leave then, because their mom doesn't deserve to have he heart broken again. Brian wakes up, and realizes he can't do this to his family.
Meanwhile, Sheridan talks to Liz about sailing for Harmony, and how she had a dream about being reunited with the man she loves over the phone before setting sail to Harmony. Liz thinks the dream could be a sign, maybe her man is alive! Brian meets up with Sheridan and Liz, and Sheridan tells Brian that they need to head to Harmony and the states, and they can both face their pasts. Brian refuses to see his family, he's coming right back here. Sheridan says that is too bad, and then goes to get him something to eat. Liz knows now that Brian is running from his family Brian reminds Liz they don't talk about their pasts on this island! Sheridan returns, and appologizes to Brian if she upset him.
In the kitchen, Luis refuses to light a candle for Sheridan. He says she is gone, he has to accept that, and she has to accept that Antonio is not coming home. Pilar refuses to stop believing that, she knows Antonio will be home for Christmas. Hank walks in, and asks if he heard right? Pilar tells Hank what happened on the phone last night. Hank thinks maybe they just wished to hear them so bad that they imagined it, but Pilar still thinks it is a miracle. Luis says her beyond alive is beyond a miracle, she is dead. Pilar refuses to listen to this and walks out to get some air. Hank talks with Luis and tells that even though he is a realist, if a miracle was to happen, his mother and Sheridan are the kind of people they happen to. After Hank leaves, Luis lights a candle for Sheridan. Pilar sees him do this, and says to herself "have faith." Pilar then tells her son not to give up hope, miracles do happen. Later, Beth shows up and tells Luis that the people bringing the boat up should be here for Christmas.
Later, Hank hangs some mistletoe, and Charity catches him under it. She tells him that he knows what that means, and gives him a very deep kiss! Everyone is stunned!
Theresa heads to the abortion clinic, and Ethan catches her. Ethan says Whitney called him and told him everything. Ethan is sick of Theresa's lies, and tells her that it is over between them! Theresa cries, and it turns out to be a horrible daydream. Whitney catches Theresa outside the clinic, and tells her that she won't talk her out of this. However, she thinks she should let her conscious be her guide. Theresa goes in for her abortion, and Whitney goes with her. The woman tells Theresa that she must meet with the counselor first, it is manditory. Whitney hopes the counselor can talk Theresa out of this idea. Theresa and Whitney go to see the counselor, and Theresa tells her the whole story. The counselor asks if she considered adoption? Theresa says yes, but that would mean going away to hide the pregnancy. She also refuses to allow the father to raise this baby. The counselor gets Theresa some pamphlets to review, and urges her not to go through with this if she has any doubts at all. Later, Theresa tells the counselor she wants the abortion.
Chad catches Ethan in the toy store looking at baby toys. He asks him if it is true, is Theresa pregnant? Ethan says Theresa isn't pregnant, he's buying toys for the children's home in honor of Sheridan. Ethan admits that he can't wait until he and Theresa have their own kids, but he knows now is not the time. Ethan buys a teddy bear for Theresa, and run into some old friends, who just saw Theresa on 4th street. Ethan and Chad decide to head over there and surpsise her.
On the island, Sheridan is excited about going to Harmony. Brian, however, is not, and Liz can see this. Later, Brian promises Sheridan that no matter what happens in Harmony, he'll always be here for her. Later, Liz asks Brian if Sheridan/Diana knows his family is in Harmony? Brian says no, and he doesn't want her to. Liz thinks that fate is sending him to Harmony for a reason. Liz urges brian to go see his family. Meanhile, Sheridan asks God to help her find out who she is. Later, Liz gives Brian an address and person to contact about the boat in case the owner is not in town, Luis!
At the Lopez-Fitzgerald house, Luis talks to Beth about how his mother feels Sheridan could be alive, and Antonio is coming home. He explains what happened with the phone call, the entire story, again. Meanwhile, everyone is stunned when Charity gives her uncle Hank a not-so-family-oriented kiss under the mistletoe! Miguel becomes enraged, and decks Hank! Back in the kicthen, Luis and Beth hear the commotion, and go to see what is happening. Luis breaks up the fight. Miguel thinks Hank made a pass at Charity, but Hank says that Charity kissed him, not the otherway around. Miguel says they all know he is the biggest womanizer in Harmony. Luis takes Miguel's side, and can't believe that Hank is blaming this on Charity. Luis asks Charity to take Miguel outside, and then he asks Hank what happened. Hank says he honestly has no idea. Outside, Miguel asks Charity how she could let Hank kiss her like that, he thought she loved him! Charity tells Miguel that she didn't let Hank kiss her, she kissed Hank! Charity says she doesn't see what the big deal is, kissing someone under the mistletoe is an old tradition. Miguel says that was not a harmless kiss! Charity sinsist that she only loves him, and she admits that she wanted to know what it felt like to kiss someone else other than him. She also didn't think he was the kind who would throw a jealous fit. Miguel apologizes for going off on her, and says he should apologize to Hank. Back inside, Hank defends himself and says that even though Charity seems pure, the way she kissed him told him that Charity isn't as pure as she seems to be! Miguel and Charity return, and Miguel apologizes to Hank. Kay is pleased with Zombie Charity's actions. Charity tells Kay that she wants to do everything she says! Later, Luis catches Pilar making flan, another one of Antonio's favorites. He goes outside for some air, and wishes on the Christmas star to have Sheridan brought home to him.
Outside, Tabitha finally notices that Timmy has run off. Tabitha finds his footprints, and begins to follow them. Timmy has gone to try and rescue his Charity from the block of ice. Tabitha soon learns she Timmy is on his way to the cave, and rushes to stop him before he can free Charity. Tabitha keeps Timmy from dethawing Charity. She also tells him that Charity will never love him, because she wants a real live boy, not a doll! Suddenly, the Christmas star appears, and Timmy asks her what it is. She tells him it is the Christmas star, and boys and girls all over make wishes on it. Timmy makes a wish on the star. He wishes to be a real boy, with a real heart. Tabitha tells Timmy that he is wasting his time, there is no such thing as Christmas magic.
On the island, Brian and Sheridan prepare to set sail for Harmony. Sheridan is excited about the trip, but Brian isn't. Later, Liz asks Brian how he knows this Luis person? Brian says he doesn't, and that her imagination is working overtime. Brian walks off, and Liz knows that Brian is hiding something. Liz thinks that when Brian and Diana meet Luis, all hell will break loose. brian and Sheridan set sail, and Sheridan continues to think she has been to Harmony with the man she loves. She is confused, and then wonders if she has everything mixed up, and perhaps the man she loves is still alive. Sheridan also wishes Brian would attempt to go see his mother while they're in the states. Brian says he'll think about it, and he tells Sheridan that he really does hope she finds her family, but he's going back to the island. Sheridan tells BRian that she has no idea what she would do if she ever lost him. Sheridan says even if she finds out who she is, she never wants to lose him. Brian says he'll always be a part of her life, as long as she wants him around. Later, Sheridan sees the Christmas star, and wishes on it, as does Brian.