Luis and Sam go to the Book Cafe and Luis sees his old girlfriend Beth. Luis orders a coffee and Beth offers sandwiches for the kids at the youth center on the house. Luis had said that he couldn't order the usual sandwiches because of funding cuts. Luis and Sam sit down and talk about Sam's brother, Hank. Luis tells Sam that maybe Hank has changed and won't cause any trouble. Beth brings them their coffee and they talk about Hank's mysterious rich girl. Sam says Sheridan Crane is the only person that fits that description, but Sheridan would have nothing to do with the likes of them. Sam has to leave to meet Grace, and ask Luis reads a magazine, he thinks about his tango with Sheridan. Suddenly, Sheridan walks into the cafe. Luis and Sheridan end up fighting over the last blueberry muffin. They play the "Tell him/her that she can have the muffin" game. Beth tells them to settle it themselves, she has another customer. Sheridan hopes this is the last time she will have to see him. She tells him that she met someone new today who isn't as mean spirited as he is. Luis tells her that he hopes her new friend and community service will keep her out of his way. Sheridan decides to take the muffin after all, and walks out. Beth returns and asks Luis where she went? Luis says "Who cares, as long as she stays out of my life for good!" Luis tells Beth that the woman was Sheridan Crane, and Beth thinks they are dating because people fight like they do when they are in love. Luis says that he is not dating Sheridan Crane. Later, Luis asks Beth out to the Lobster Shack after work.
Sam goes back to the station and runs into Hank. They hug and are happy to see one another. Hank asks about the family, and Sam says they are great. Hank asks if his wonderful wife has a room at the bed and breakfast for him, and Sam says of course. Sam is unhappy that his brother has only written a few post cards over the past year. Hank says he has been busy with so many projects. Sam hopes his brother will settle down now, but Hank says he is only here to make some money to get back out into the world. Hank tells his brother that he has changed, and he's already working on a romance and providing the youth center with some funding. After they bicker a bit, they agree to put the past behind them and start fresh.
Sheridan goes back to the center and when she puts on her perfume, two girls notice it and like it. She decides to give it to them, and they thank her. Hank shows up and Sheridan asks how much she should write the check out for? Hank tells her that he has to make a confession, he isn't the director. He says he was left in charge until the real director comes back. Luis walks in and Hank says "Here he is now!" Sheridan looks at him and exclaims "You!"
At the Bennett home, Jessica gets an email from an english teacher, Mrs. Crump. Jessica says that the english teacher from hell says she received a wonderful email from her begging to be in her class, so she has arranged for her to be in her fourth period class. Kay admits to doing this to get back at her sister. Jessica tells her sister that she is going to die, and she chases Kay around the house. Grace walks in and tells them both that if they don't apologize, they are both grounded! Grace wants to know what is going on, and they both tell her different versions of how Jessica ended up in Mrs. Crump's class. Grace tells them both that there are worse things they can worry about, such as Miguel's situation. Grace leaves and Kay tells Jessica that they are even now, and she better stay out of her way. Jessica says she will never get Miguel, but Kay says she will once she gets her make-over. Kay and Simone go upstairs to work on Kay's make-over. In the kitchen, Ms. Standish calls Mrs. Bennett to talk about Charity. Faith says Charity has gone to Harmony and she is worried. Grace tells her that she was just at Miguel's, and they aren't there. Faith worries, and Grace suggests that her bus is probably just late getting to Harmony. Grace says she will make sure Charity gets on the last bus out of HArmony before dark. Jessica, who was listening, offers to go to Miguel's to see if Charity is there, because Grace has to open up her shop.
At Miguel's place, Charity tells Miguel that she saw her aunt and they have to find her so she can stay in Harmony. Miguel tells her that Mrs. Bennett can help them find her aunt, and they head to the kitchen to talk with her. Unfortunately, Grace is gone. Miguel tells her that he needs to take a shower, and then they can go to the Bennett's. Charity offers to give Miguel her good luck charm, and Miguel is positive that things will work out. Later, Charity tries to get some water, but the pipes start shaking. Miguel shows up, in a towel, and says it is an old house and it's okay, they just can't use the sink when someone is in the shower. Unfortunately the shower won't work for a half hour now, so he rinses his hair out in his sink, and of course Charity helps him. Jessica shows up and wishes Kay could see this. Jessica let herself in, and tells Charity that her mom called her mom, she is worried about her. Charity says she knew it. Jessica says they should go over to her house immediately, she knows Kay would love to see them both.
BAck at the Bennett home, Kay and Simone work on Kay's make-over. Kay has green goop all over her face and plans to dye her hair to out-blonde Charity. Simone hopes nobody walks in and sees her like this. Kay says after the threat she gave her sister, Jessica won't let anyone in here. Kay then fantasizes about Miguel seeing her new look (she looks like Charity), and Miguel falls in love with her because she's a "woman" and Charity is just a girl. The timer goes off and when Simone goes to check out her highlights, her hair begins to fall out! Suddenly, Jessica, Charity, and Miguel show up. Kay screams and runs out of the room. She returns later with a scarf on her head, she claims her hair is wet. Miguel and Jessica tells Kay that CHarity saw the one person who can keep her in Harmony, and they think their mom can help Charity find her.
At Faith's place, Faith sees the "seeker" shirt Charity bought her and decides to check out the chat room one last time before she moves, just in case the person who might know her sister is on.
At Grace's shop, Grace has a memory flash of playing store with her twin sister. She wonders if it was a real memory, or her imagination. Suddenly, Grace becomes dizzy and faints! Sam shows up and finds Grace. Grace tells him about her memory flash, she thinks she was playing with someone who looked like herself. Sam and Grace long onto the net to try and find Seeker. Seeker is there, and they talk with her. Faith decides to talk to them, but warns she will sign off if she feels like she can't trust them. Sam asks if Grace has a family, and Faith says yes, me! Grace is thrilled and thinks her search is finally over.
Back in the living room, Ethan is furious to learn from his mother that Julian called the mayor and had him file a sexual harassment charge against Luis. Ethan says he had no right to interfere. Ivy tells him that his father frequently plays God, he'll have to get used to it. Ethan says he won't and Sheridan will not be pleased to learn about this. Ivy says that Sheridan doesn't need to know. Whitney and Theresa return and Theresa and Whitney both tell them that the girl and her family moved. Theresa says that all the accidents were probably just because she was so nervous being close to Ethan. Ethan laughs and says she makes it sound like she was there. Theresa says she was just so nervous when she met them and was afraid she would spill something. Still, Ivy says it is not the same. Ethan tells Frank that there is no point of continuing this investigation. Ivy wants proof, but Ethan believes Theresa. Frank still refuses to believe their story and wants to question them alone, but Ethan says there is no need to. Ethan leaves to make a phone call, and Frank asks Ivy to let him do his job. Ivy tells him to go ahead and continue his investigation. Ivy leaves because she is late for an appointment, and Frank tells the girls that he wants the truth.
At Tabitha's house, Tabitha is out cold on the floor and Timmy thinks she has drunk herself to death. Timmy tells her that she was his reason for living, she was all he had. He toasts goodbye to her and says it won't be the same without her. Timmy says that she made him laugh, she made him cry, they have been through thick and thin together. We then see touching flashbacks of Timmy and Tabitha's misadventures. Timmy is in tears and tells his princess good night, and soon they will meet again. He then realizes that it might be sooner than he thinks if Grace and Faith meet up! Timmy refuses to let Tabitha die and begins performing CPR on her. When Tabitha doesn't come too, Timmy sits down at a mini piano and begins playing "Should Old Acquittances Be Forgot." He then decides he has to make tracks, so packs a little suit case, including Tabitha's fur boa. He says she won't need it where she's going. He also grabs some golf clubs as well. He tells Tabitha that for a crazy old lady, she was okay, "peace!" As he is about to leave, Tabitha moans. Timmy drops everything and screams "She's alive!" Timmy tells Tabby that he brought her back to life, she owes him. Tabitha tells him that he forgot that she gave him life! She tells him that they are even, and then asks Timmy for two extra strength asprins. She says she will never drink champagne again, but at least Charity and her mom are gone forever. Timmy tells her that he has some bad news for her. Tabitha jokes that the only bad news he could give her is to tell her that Charity was next door with the Bennett girls waiting to meet Grace. Timmy tells her that is about it in a nutshell, but she is also with Miguel. Timmy says wait till she sees that Mrs. Bennett is her mom's twin sister! Tabitha lets out "Over my dead body!" Tabitha says Charity is worse than Rasputin! Timmy asks how she is going to stop Charity? Tabitha says Grace is always at her cutseypoo shop at this time, so she'll pay her a visit to make sure the brat doesn't show up. Tabitha asks for her fur boa, and Timmy retrieves it for her. She also asks for her cape. Tabitha puts on her red cape and boa and says "No more nice Tabitha, it is time to play rough!"
At the Bennett house, Jessica tells Miguel and Charity that her mom is at the shop. Miguel tells CHarity that Mrs. Bennett will find her aunt, and then she can stay in Harmony. Kay lets out an "ohhhhh noooooo!" Miguel asks what is wrong, doesn't she want Charity to stay in Harmony? Kay says of course she does, but she doesn't want Charity to get her hopes up. Miguel says he has a good feeling about this, and they leave. On their way out, Reese shows up to see Kay. Kay is happy to see him and tells Miguel and Charity to forget her mom, Reese can help them! Jessica asks how Reese can help Charity? Kay says that Reese's dad is president of the bank, and he has to know the person Charity is looking for. Miguel says it is possible, and says maybe the can talk to him. Unfortunately, Reese says his dad is out of town. Miguel says he will call Luis, and Jessica says she will go to the shop to make sure her mom doesn't go anywhere. On her way out, she tells Kay not to think about sabotaging this! Miguel calls Luis, who agrees to help look for Charity's aunt. Reese asks Charity questions about her mom's sister. Charity says she saw her today, and her mom looks exactly like her sister. Charity says that her mom's sister has been missing for years. Simone yanks Kay aside and tells her that she knows who Charity is looking for. Kay asks who, and Simone says "your mom!" Kay says Charity's mom is not her mom's twin, that is the dumbest thing she's ever heard! Miguel asks Kay what is wrong? Kay says nothing is wrong. Charity uses the phone to call her mom, and Simone continues to try and persuade Simone that Charity is looking for her mom. Charity can't get through to her mom and tells Miguel that she must be on-line.
At the shop, Sam asks Seeker if she is Grace's family? Faith tells Sam that she is Grace's family. Grace is so happy and she hugs Sam. Sam tells Grace to talk to her family. Grace takes the computer and tells Seeker that it is her, and asks Seeker to tell her who she is, she has been waiting twenty years to find her family. Faith wants to believe it is her, and asks how she knows if it is really her? Grace tells her "cross my heart and hope to die if I ever lie to you." Faith realizes it is her sister because that is what Grace always said to her. Faith tells Grace that she is her twin sister Faith. Grace can't believe she has a twin, she thought she had one. Grace asks where she is, when can they meet? Faith tells her that she is not sure that they should meet. Grace is puzzled and wonders why. Grace asks why, and Faith asks why she hasn't tried to get in touch with her all these years, did they get her? Grace says nobody got her, she was in a fire and lost her memory. Jessica shows up to see her mom, but Sam asks her not to interrupt her right now. Jessica asks if her mom is all right? Sam says she is fine and something wonderful is happening, but he'll explain later. He asks her to tell Miguel to give her a few minutes. Back on the computer, Faith realizes that "they" started the fire to kill Grace. Grace asks Faith where she lives, and Faith says she lives in Castleton. Grace tells Faith that she lives in Harmony, they are practically neighbors! Faith tells Grace that is amazing, her daughter actually hoped she lived there. Grace is thrilled to learn that she has a niece. Grace tells Faith that she and her husband have two daughters, and a son who is away at school. Faith says she'd love to see photos of her nieces and nephew, but says she has a surprise for her, a photo of them when they were younger. Faith tells her it is all she had left of her, and even they couldn't take it away from her. Grace asks Sams who this "they" could be. Faith sends Grace the old photo of them, and Sam says that is exactly how she looked when she first found her. Grace wants to meet Faith in person, but she says it is the only way to keep them away. Grace asks who they are, and Faith tells her they are the forces of darkness, and they are in Harmony and are close to her.
At the youth center, Sheridan asks Luis what he wants now. He tells her that she is the one out of place here! Sheridan says she doesn't know what he is talking about because she is here to serve . . . and then she says "Oh no it can't be!" Sheridan learns he is the director of the youth center. Hank asks what is going on here? Luis tells Hank that this is the woman who has been driving him crazy. Luis tells Sheridan that she obviously made a wrong turn, the jewelry store is down the block. SHeridan says she didn't make a wrong turn, she is here because of him! Luis says the last thing he wants is her to be here. Hank asks when they meet, and Sheridan tells Hank this is the guy she has crossed paths with a couple of times. Luis says she didn't cross his path, she smashed into his car! Suddenly, Miguel calls Luis and tells him that he needs help finding Charity's mom's twin. Luis says he will call him back from the station and will give it a shot. After the call, Luis tells Hank to show the lady to her car. Sheridan says she can't leave, she has to do her community service here! Luis says no way, no how! Luis then accuses Sheridan of planning this so he would throw her out and she wouldn't have to perform her community service. Sheridan accuses him of setting this up so he can torture someone named Crane on a daily basis! Hank interrupts them and says there is a way out of this, Mrs. Crane offered a donation in lieu of her sentence. Luis says "A BRIBE!" and Sheridan says "Oh no, I'm not giving you another reason to arrest me, and rips up her check." Hank asks Luis to let Sheridan write another check, but Luis says no way. Luis decides to call the judge and have her assigned elsewhere. As Luis is on the phone, Hank asks Sheridan out to dinner, and she accepts. On the phone, the judge refuses to reassign Sheridan. Hank tells them it's only a hundred hours, it will be over in no time. They both glare at him.
At the Crane mansion, Frank tells Theresa and Whitney that he wants to know who the girl stalking Ethan is and where she is. Theresa says she does not have to stand here and be says she and Whitney are leaving. Frank refuses to let them leave, and asks Whitney why she doesn't have much to say? He tells her that her loyalty to Theresa will get her in trouble. Whitney says she told him everything she knows. He warns them that they either talk to him, or talk to the police. He asks them once again who is stalking Ethan Crane? Ethan returns and tells Frank that is enough, the investigation is over! Frank says these girls know something, but Ethan says they have told him all they know. Frank doesn't believe them, but Ethan doesn't believe Theresa and Whitney would lie. Frank thinks they would because they know the stalker, very well most likely. He says they may have even planned the stunts against him! Ethan knows the accidents were all caused by one person. Still, Frank thinks they helped her plan the incidents and these girls were involved. Frank turns to Whitney and tells her to answer like she was on a witness stand in court, did she help the stalker! Whitney says she did not help the stalker to do those things to Ethan. Ethan tells Frank that the case is closed and his stalker has stopped bothering him. Frank can't let the case go unsolved, but Ethan tells him to let it go. Ethan tells him to send him a bill, and says goodbye. Frank leaves and Theresa tells Ethan that she doesn't know how to thank him. Ethan tells her that she is his family's good luck charm.
Theresa and Whitney go to the Book Cafe for lunch, and Theresa goes on about how Ethan came to their rescue. Whitney thinks they could have gone to jail, but Theresa says they won't go to jail, and she is home free now that Frank is gone. Theresa realizes she still has on the disguise, but is unaware that Frank is spying on the both of them! Whintey tells Theresa that she will never get away with this, but Theresa swears that she will tell them the truth eventually and they'll all get a good laugh out of it.
At the youth center, Sheridan and Luis are still arguing. Hank tells them both to set aside their differences and make the best of it, it could turn out to be a really fun experience! Luis and Sheridan both agree to discuss it rationally and make peace. Luis suggests that Sheridan have her nephew petition for a new community service placement, but Hank says if she does that the judge could double her community service here. Sheridan says no way, and Luis thinks that she can't handle working here. Sheridan tells Luis "how dare you, you don't know me!" Sheridan thinks she can work here, but Luis asks how she will deal with kids whose families are employed by her family? Sheridan says she is not involved in her family's business, but she can encourage them to reach for their dreams. Luis thinks she sees these kids as a charity cause, and Sheridan says she doesn't have to put up with these insults! Luis tells Hank that it is just as he always thought, when the going gets tough the Cranes run! Sheridan says she is not afraid to work, she just doesn't want to listen to him insulting her for hundreds of hours. Hank asks Luis to lighten up, he is blowing his (Hank's) opportunity with Sheridan. Luis tells Hank that he has problems to worry other than his love life. Hank leaves, but not before Sheridan thanks him for his support. Luis agrees to let her work here, but doesn't think she will last more than two hours before breaking a nail and having daddy assign her elsewhere. Sheridan leaves, but says she will be here tomorrow.
Sheridan goes home and pours herself a drink. Ethan asks why she is upset, and she tells him that Luis is the director of the youth center! Ethan tells her that she can't work for him and offers to call the judge. Sheridan says that Luis tried that, there is nothing she can do. Sheridan says she will show Luis what she is made of. Ethan warns her not to be goaded into anything by the arrest happy officer, but Sheridan has a plan to handle Luis.
Back at the center, Hank returns and learns that Sheridan and Luis are going to work together, but they have not called a truce. Luis warns Hank about Sheridan, but he says Sheridan has been nice to him. Luis tells him that he'll never make it to first base with her. Hank becomes angry and tells Luis that he can't wait to see how this little game between them plays out. Luis says he'll tell him how it will play out, he will win.
Tabitha is on her way to the shop and is literally pushing people on the streets out of her way. At Tabitha's place, Timmy is running from Fluffy, who is roaring at Timmy. Timmy says he's so tired of Fluffy being mean to him and decides to stand up to Fluffy. Timmy comes up with a plan to deal with Fluffy before Tabitha gets back. Timmy puts on a lab coat and one of those things eye doctors where on their head, and goes to work making a potion to drug Fluffy with. Timmy says the potion will knock Fluffy out, and then he will perform a lobotomy on her! Timmy pours the concoction into Fluffy's bowl. However, Fluffy catches him and chases Timmy around the house. Timmy tries to make it to the front door, but Fluffy corners him. Timmy tries to kiss Fluffy's butt, but Fluffy doesn't fall for it. Timmy ends up backed against the basement door, which still has Tabitha's key in the lock. He knows Tabitha would be upset if he went down there, but says nothing can be worse than Fluffy. Timmy opens the door and stands at the top of the steps. HE thinks as long as Fluffy can't get to him, he is safe. Suddenly, a red light begins to glow in the room and an eerie mist develops on the floor. He quickly rushes out of the basement. However, he thinks if he can make friends with what is down there, it could get rid of Fluffy for them. He soon realizes it could get rid of him just as easily, and decides not to tell Tabitha that he went to the basement.
At Grace's shop, Sam and Grace wonder what her sister is talking about in regards to forces of darkness being close to her. Grace asks what these forces of darkness are? Faith tells her that they are evil and are waiting to destroy goodness. She says the forces have been gaining strength since their family fought them in the Salem witch trials. Sam thinks Grace's sister is a little out there, and asks her to name these forces. Faith realizes Grace doesn't believe her, so she tries to convince her. She tells her that she has been spared all these years. She says if she wants proof, she will show it to her. Faith tells Grace she will send her a painting of the face of evil which was painted over three hundred years ago, and it might remind her of someone she knows. In her hands, Faith holds a picture of Tabitha dressed up like a Puritan! Tabitha finally shows up at the shop, and Grace tells her that she just found her sister on the internet! Grace tells Tabitha that she is thrilled to have found her sister, but she doesn't understand what all these forces of darkness are. Tabitha says that maybe she has seen the new Star Wars movie a tad too many times. Grace tells Tabitha about the three hundred year old painting that her sister is going to send her a photo off, and Tabitha looks worried. Tabitha has a memory of being put into stocks and trying to be forced to admit to being a witch. As Tabitha stares over Grace and Sam's shoulders, Faith tells Grace she is sending the photo now, but asks her not to show anyone other than her husband. Tabitha says she'll turn away, and the picture begins to come into focus. Tabitha realizes she has to do something before it is too late for her. As they wait for the photo to download, Sam gives Grace a run down of what went on in historic New England: Pilgrims, colonization, the building of towns, and the witch trials. The picture begins to come into focus, Tabitha suddenly feigns ill. When they leave the room to get help, Tabitha takes a peak at the computer. She says she always hated those unattractive hats, and decides to get rid of the picture somehow.
In the Bennett kitchen, Charity tries to call her mom again, but it's still busy. Meanwhile, Kay tells Simone that there is no way Charity's mom is her mom's twin. Simone says her mom's picture is on the fridge, so they'll know when she sees it. When Charity tells Kay that she still hasn't met her mom, Reese says there is a picture of her around here somewhere. Kay grabs the photo off the fridge, and then she and Simone decide to go look for a photo for Charity to see. Once they are out of the room, Simone asks Kay why she swiped the picture? Kay says she doesn't think her mom is Charity's aunt, but what if Charity says she is in order to stay in Harmony? Simone doesn't think Kay would do that, but Kay says Charity is desperate. She then says that Charity and her mom are both nuts, and possibly con-artists. Kay thinks Charity and her mom are plotting against her amnesiac mother. In the kitchen, Charity tells Miguel that she has to get back to home before dark, even if she has to walk home. Kay and Simone return and Kay claims she couldn't find a photo of her mom. Charity thinks she should head home, but Miguel wants her to stay and asks Kay if Charity shouldn't wait to talk to her mom? Kay says she should stay, but she knows what its like to have a mom who expects her home one time. Charity could never forgive herself for worrying her mom and decides to go. Miguel begins to realize that maybe she is right, she should go. However, he promises to take her home on his motorcycle, that way they can talks to Mrs. Bennett. Reese suggests they go talk to her now, and Miguel thinks that is a good idea. However, Kay says her parents are doing something important. Sam shows up and Miguel asks if Mrs. Bennett is free yet? Sam says that it is a bad time, their neighbor is at the shop and is sick. Sam recognizes Charity, and says he will have his wife come home as soon as she is done at the shop. Sam leaves with supplies, and Charity tries once again to get through to her mom. Charity decides she better get going home,but Miguel talks her into going to the shop with him.
Back at the shop, Tabitha tries unsuccessfully to delete the picture and swears she'll put a spell on the entire silicon valley if she gets out of this. Grace hears Tabitha talking and says she will be right out. Tabitha then casts a spell on the computer to delete the picture. At Faith's place, Faith's computer begins to shake and she wonders what is happening. The wind begins to blow inside Faith's place, and suddenly Tabitha's head pops out of her computer screen and begins breathing fire! Tabitha says "Hello Faith, you thought you could run away from me!" Faith screams "it's you!" Tabitha says "Of course it is me, and i am going to get you and your daughter!"
At the Book Cafe, Theresa is thrilled that Ethan gave that nosey PI his walking papers. She thinks she is home free, Ethan thinks she is his lucky charm. Whitney tells her that she'll never be home free unless she takes off that disguise. At the other table, Frank refuses to give up this case until he finds out the truth about the girls, and the stalker. Theresa tells Whitney to calm down and not freak out, but Whitney thinks she has a good reason to be freaking out. She tells Theresa that if she is still wishing to be Ethan Crane, she has to stop dreaming. Theresa says she will always love Ethan, but she knows they can never be together. However, she says if she can't have Ethan, why should Gwen? Whitney warns her that all her dreams will go down the dreams if she keeps mooning over Ethan again. Theresa says she can't just turn her feelings off, and Ethan has become her hero. Whitney tells her that Ethan doesn't know her from Adam. She says if the Cranes find out about her, she will disgrace her whole family, and her mother will probably be fired! She asks what her family will do then, will Luis have to shoulder more of a burden for his family? Theresa tells her that she is being mean, and Ethan will never find the truth about her with this disguise. Whitney suddenly has a terrible thought, if the truth comes out that she covered for her, Julian could get his parents fired! Theresa promises her that they won't get busted, but at the other table Frank tells himself that he will prove the girls are lying. Theresa tells Whitney that her career will have to be her life now that she's lost Ethan. She says she would have done anything to be with Ethan, but Whitney doesn't understand because she's never been in love. Whitney says she doesn't want to fall in love if she will act like her. Theresa then teases Whitney and says that she saw some sparks between her and the PI this morning. Whitney says nothing is going on between them, but Theresa is positive she has a thing for him. They leave and as they walk, Whitney says even if she felt anything for him, he thinks she's a liar. Theresa says she has to get out of this disguise, so she changes in a bathroom. Unfortunately, Frank is standing right outside the bathroom!
At the shop, Sam and Grace are in a back room looking for the smelling salts. Meanwhile, Tabitha projects herself through the computer and into Faith's living room. Tabitha's floating and fire breathing head tells Faith that she is going to get her, and then her daughter! As the wind blows inside Faith's house, Tabitha asks where her precious angels are now? Faith ends up shutting her computer down, and everything settles down in her house. However, her notebook computer springs open and Tabitha returns! She tells her that she can't run from her, and now her daughter is hers! Faiths screams "Not Charity!" and then faints.
At the Bennett house, Miguel tells Charity that they should go next door to the shop, but Kay says her parents are in the middle of a medical emergency. Kay says maybe she should go over and see if it is a good time. Miguel says thanks, but they'll swing by themselves. Kay tells them not to go, do they really want to put themselves in the middle of a life and death situation? Charity says Kay is right. Charity decides to call her mom again and is excited that the phone is ringing, but then wonders why her mom isn't answering. She gets the answering machine, so she leaves her mom a short message saying she will be home soon, and has great news! Simone tells Kay to show Charity a picture of her mom and get it over with, but Kay says "Are you crazy!" Simone says if her mom is not the person Charity is looking for, she'll leave. However, if Charity is looking for her mom, and she prevented her from finding her, she wouldn't be able to live with her conscious. Kay says she doesn't care about her conscious, she cares about getting Miguel! Charity tells Miguel that she is worried about her mom and wants to go home. Miguel says he will take her, but they have to pass by the shop on the way to his bike, so they can at least look in on her. Charity and Miguel leave, and Simone tells Kay to face the facts, if Charity is her cousin then she is here to stay. Kay gets rid of Reese by asking him to go check on Jessica, and Kay and Simone have a talk about family. Simone says she'd be thrilled to have a cousin living in harmony, all her dad's relatives are way older than her, and she's never met any of her mom's family. She says she'd love a girl cousin her age to talk to. Kay says she can talk to her, but Simone says it is different. Simone says she feels left out of her family because Whitney is the center of attention. Kay says she understands what it feels to be left out, but Simone says she is always making herself the center of attention. Kay says that Jessica has mom, and her brother Noah has dad, but she has no special bond with either of her parents. Simone says that is not true, but if it was now she could have Charity. Kay says she doesn't want Charity, she wants Miguel. She says she doesn't want a new family to come out of the blue, they could change things somehow. They sit around and watch the clock, wondering what is happening. Simone thinks Charity is her cousin, and Kay admits that it is possible. Simone says if it is true, can she blame her mom for wanting to spend time with Charity and her mother? Kay says that her mom does too much as is, and she is worried about her mom. Kay tells Simone about her mom's recent visions of a little girl. She says her mom needs rest, and she will be disappointed if Charity and her mom are con-artists. She then rants and raves about Charity and how Miguel would have been with her if Charity hadn't come along. Furthermore, Miguel isn't the kind of guy to cheat on a girl he is in love with. Simone tells Kay that she's forgetting something important, Miguel doesn't love her! Simone says it doesn't matter, Charity is probably at her mom's shop already.
Back at the shop, Sam and Grace find Tabitha sitting in a chair, conscious. Sam offers her oxygen, but she says no thanks. When Grace waves some smelling salts under her nose, she springs out of her chair and exclaims "Bloody hell, what are you trying to do to me!" Grace apologizes, and Tabitha asks her to forgive her, she can't believe those nasty words came out of her mouth. Tabitha says she knows why she keeled over, it was because of her jogging, which she'll have to give up. Sam is happy to see she has bounced right back. Grace asks if she would mind if she return to her computer? Tabitha says of course, so Grace and Sam return to the computer. As they look at the screen, Sam says "What's this?" The picture is one of a little pilgrim boy, and they both laugh about it. Grace doesn't understand why Faith would be afraid of a little boy. She goes to ask her sister, but sees that her sister is no longer on-line. Sam says maybe she lost power. Tabitha says maybe it is a good thing she is gone, she could be one of those internest impersonators. Sam tells her it is called the interenet, and Grace doesn't think her sister would lie to her. Sam tells Grace not to worry, and Tabitha spots the angel brat. She wonders what trouble she is going to cause now. Grace asks Tabitha if she said something? Tabitha says they should be leaving, and Sam says Tabitha is right. Suddenly, Grace remembers levitating out of bed to the backyard the night he found her out there. She says the little girl was there and warned her about danger, but Sam says there is no way she could have floated out the window. Sam says they should get going and talk to Miguel and Charity. Tabitha looks out the window, only to see Miguel and Charity coming down the street! Tabitha asks if they can walk her to her house, and insists they leave by the back door.
On the way to the shop, Miguel tells Charity that she has to believe things will work out. He tells her that he has a good feeling about talking to Mrs. Bennett, he thinks she can help them find her aunt. They arrive at the shop, but it is empty. Charity says they tried, but Miguel tells her not to give up hope. Charity says she would be so happy here, and her mom would love working in a store like this.
Back at Faith's, Faith comes to and wonders if the person on the computer was "them" pretending to be Grace to find Charity. Faith checks her messages and learns Charity is still in Harmony. She says that evil is in Harmony and they have to move far far away.
Back at the Bennetts, Kay sees her parents helping Tabitha to her house, and thinks that it must means that Charity isn't her cousin, otherwise her parents wouldn't have left without her. Simone thought she was so sure, but Kay is glad she was wrong. Simone says "what if your mom didn't see Charity?" Kay asks her friend what she is trying to do to her? Simone says her mother has been like a second mom to her, and she wants to tell her what she suspects. Kay stops her and says Charity could be a con-artist. Simone tells her that she is lying to herself. The phone rings, and Kay answers. Faith shouts into the phone that she has to talk to her daughter Charity, it is a matter of life and death!
Kay runs next door to the shop and gets Charity, she tells her that her mom is on the phone screaming that she has to talk to her. Charity goes back with Kay and asks her mom what is wrong, and Faith says the forces of darkness are closing in on them. Charity tells her mom not to worry, everything will be okay because she saw her twin right here in Harmony.
At Tabitha's place, TImmy worries about Tabitha. He thinks she might be dead, and decides to give her two minutes before splitting. However, he realizes that without Tabitha, life isn't worth living. Outside, Sam and Grace approach Tabitha's house with her. She realizes that she can't go inside with them or they'd see Timmy, so she says she'd like to sit outside in the fresh air. Grace says she will go inside and then bring her some juice, she insists. As Grace approaches the door, she hears someone inside. Tabitha says it is probably just mice. Sam decides to take a look, so he walks inside. He is shocked to see and hear Timmy call out Tabitha's name. He realizes that the doll is alive!
Frank is at the harbor waiting form Theresa and Whitney to come out of the bathroom. In the bathroom, Theresa is changing out of her disguise, despite WHitney's suggestion that she doesn't. Theresa says that Ethan will never see her, and her boyfriend Frank is off the case. Theresa then fantasizes how Ethan would react to seeing her out of her disguise. In her fantasy, Theresa removes her glasses and wig in front of Ethan, who tells her that she is so beautiful. Ethan picks her up and as they are about to kiss, Theresa sees a jealous Gwen watching them. Whitney tells Theresa that she is dreaming, Ethan will throw them both in jail if he learns the truth. Theresa says that will never happen. Whitney lectures Theresa and tells her to cut her losses and move on. She says there is a guy out there who wants her for her. Theresa finishes removing her disguises, and Whitney says they will both find someone one day. Theresa says she already did, but Whitney tells her not to start about Frank Lomax again. Whitney asks Theresa if she thinks he really likes her, and Theresa says definitely. Outside, Frank is suddenly paged, and asks a kid to watch the bathroom for him while he makes a call. Frank tells him that there are two girls in there, and describes Whitney and a mousey Theresa. He says if he seems them come out to get him. Frank goes to make his call, and Theresa and Whitney leave. Theresa ends up dumping her purse, so they pick up her stuff. On the phone, Ethan tells Frank that the case is closed, but Frank refuses to drop the case until he finds the stalker. Frank returns to the kid, who says he only saw two beautiful women leave. The kid runs off, and Frank waits around for them to exit, not knowing they are gone. When a woman comes out, Frank asks if his girlfriends are in there? She says she was the only one in there. Franks looks inside and notices that nobody is in there. The kid comes back and tells Frank he watched the door the whole time. Frank says something weird is going on.
At the Bennetts' place, Faith tells Charity via the phone to leave as quickly as she can! Charity tells her mom that she saw her twin today, but Faith says she couldn't have seen Grace. Charity says she did, and now they can stay here in Harmony. Faith says that is out of the question, she could have been deceived. Faith tells Charity that there are forces of evil in Harmony. Faith says the forces of darkness are masquerading as her twin, that was made clear to her today. She tells Charity to come home so then can get as far away from Harmony as they can. Charity says she will come home right away. Miguel asks why her mom is so upset? Charity says she doesn't know, and she better get home. She wishes she could find her aunt, because that ways she could stay in Harmony. Charity thought she could convince her mom everything would be all right once she found her aunt, but she was wrong. As they are about to leave, Simone tells them to wait while she talks to Kay. Simone and Kay go into the other room and Simone tells Kay that she has to tell them about her mom. Kay says no way. Simone tells Kay that this is wrong, Charity and Miguel are miserable! Kay says she will comfort Miguel. Simone snatches the picture of Grace from Kay and says she will show this picture to Charity. Kay stops her before she can run out of the room. Kay tells Simone that Miguel should be with her, she knows what Miguel wants and needs. Kay works to convince Simone that she is better for Miguel in the long run. She asks her as a friend to give her the chance to be with Miguel. Miguel and Charity walk into the room and asks what is wrong? Kay says nothing is wrong. Miguel decides to give Charity a lift home. Charity thanks Kay and Simone for everything, and Simone asks her to wait a few more minutes for Kay's mom to come home. However, Kay says Charity has to get home. Miguel and Charity leave, and Kay calls Simone a traitor. Simone tells her to think of someone else for a change. Kay tells her that she thought she would know what it was like coming in second. Simone asks what she means, and Kay says she is talking about her sister Whitney. Simone tells Kay that she doesn't have to help Charity for Charity's sake, she should do it for her mom. Kay says she could be a con-artist, but Simone thinks she is real. Simone asks Kay how she could live with herself if she kept her mom from her own flesh and blood?
At Tabitha's place, Sam hears Timmy call out Tabitha's name, and then fall lifeless. Grace and Tabitha walk in, and Sam tells Grace that the doll spoke, he is alive. Grace asks how that could be? Sam says he will find out. Tabitha says that is the doll she made, and she put a voice box inside him. Grace asks how the doll she gave away as a prize at the carnival is in her house? Tabitha says it looks an awful lot like the othe one, she isn't very original. Sam keeps poking poor Timmy, who keeps saying "Tabitha" over and over. Timmy won't stop saying Tabitha, so he holds Timmy upside down and starts shaking him to try and shut him up! Sam thinks the box is messed up and pulls out his pocket knife to open him up, but Tabitha says there is no need to take such drastic measures. Timmy's speech starts to slow down, so Sam backs off. Tabitha calls him a bad doll and smacks his head, and Timmy lets out an ow. Grace tells Sam she'd like to go see Miguel's friend Charity, and get back online to talk with Faith. Sam tells her that they will get to the bottom of this when they talk to Faith again. Suddenly, Tabitha grabs her heart and has another "attack." Grace calls Eve to examine Tabitha, and as she checks Tabitha's vitals, Grace tells Eve about finding her sister. Eve tells Tabitha that her heart sounds find, but she wants her to go disrobe in the other room so she can do a few more tests. Tabitha leaves, but tells Timmy to keep an eye on them. Sam tells Faith that he's been thinking about her niece, and says that all the pieces are in the back of his brain but he can't seem to fit them together. Sam and Grace see the Oui-Ja board and Grace decides to play with it. Grace asks if she is with the man it loves, and it says yes. She decides to try something harder, and asks if she will meet her sister? The pointer begins to move without Grace's fingers being on it, which freaks her out. Sam thinks there is probably a magnet making it move. Eve returns and tells Sam and Grace that Tabitha is in perfect health for a woman her age. Tabitha returns and Eve asks her about the scars on her feet, was she in a fire? Tabitha remembers being burned at the stake, but she warned the pilgrims that they have not seen the last of her! Tabitha tells them that she just had a minor accident. Eve is puzzled why Tabitha had attacks, and makes her promise to give her a call if she has anymore signs of symptoms. Grace is eager to leave and reconnect with her sister, but Tabitha asks them to stay for a cup of tea. Tabitha says she'll go make some right now, and carries Timmy into the kitchen. Timmy asks Tabitha how she can ask them to stay for tea? Tabitha says she has to keep her here so she can keep them from running into Charity. Tabitha warns her not to leave the Bennetts alone for long, they were snooping into everything. Tabitha asks like what, and Timmy says Grace used the spirit board, and it worked for her. Tabitha realizes that Grace must have the same powers as her sister, and they better pray those two never get together. Timmy sees Charity and Miguel leaving, and Tabitha says all these years she underestimated the power of prayer. Tabitha and Timmy then begin to sing "Ding dong the brat is gone." Grace and Sam walk in, Grace has Tabby's board, and Timmy goes limp. Grace says she thought she heard something, and asks if everything is all right? Sam asks if she was dancing, but Tabitha says she was just trying to get the kinks out of her legs. Grace asks Tabitha about her spirit board, but Tabitha says she thought it was a tray. Grace tells her that it is used to tell fortunes. Tabitha says she doesn't go in for those kind of things and decides to throw it out. However, Grace stops her and asks if she would mind if she took it home? Sam tells her that it is a bunch of nonsense, so Grace agrees not to take it home. Grace asks for a rain check on the tea, and Tabitha says of course. They leave, and Tabitha yells at her board, which was moving, to shut up. Outside, Grave tells Sam that she forgot about Miguel's friend Charity, she was supposed to help her find someone. Suddenly, Sam gets the craziest thought, he thinks Charity is her niece! Back inside, Tabitha tells Timmy to make sure the person coming in is her before he hollers her name! However, she says it all seems to have worked out, Grace will never find Charity.
At the Lopez-Fitzgerald place, Whitney asks Theresa to borrow her brush, but Theresa realizes she left it in the ladies room. Miguel and Charity show up, and Miguel tells Theresa that he has to take Charity home on his bike. They are sad to learn that Charity might have to move, even though she found who she was looking for. Theresa yanks Miguel aside and tells him to do whatever it takes and more to keep Charity in his life. She tells him that she knows what it is like to loose someone you love. Theresa and Whitney take off, and Charity watches Miguel as he fixes his bike. Miguel asks her if she is ready, and promises it will be okay. Charity says she wants to believe him, but do miracles really happen?