On the plane, the women next to Sheridan talks to her about "man problems," but Sheridan says her heart is closed to men from now on. Later, as Sheridan reads an article about her family, a flight attendant notices her and says that her house looks lovely. Sheridan says she doesn't live there, she is only returning for a visit. The flight attendant says she would never leave a place as lovely as it. Sheridan says sometimes you don't have a choice. We then see a flashback of a woman yelling at a teenage Sheridan that she has to leave, her father wants it this way. Sheridan doesn't understand why her father won't let her stay. Sheridan cries that she is sorry for what she did, please don't send her away. The flight attendant asks Sheridan if she is all right, and she says yes. Sheridan is happy to be going home because she can tell Ethan and Pilar things she can't tell anyone else.
At the mansion, Theresa tells Ethan, who is in the bathroom, that she is not Gwen, she is Theresa. Theresa tells Ethan that she'd like to explain something to him. Theresa explains that she is not a stalker, everything she spilled on him were accidents. She says she would never hurt him, she has had a crush on him ever since she saw his picture in the paper years ago. She tells him how she always dreamed they were meant to be together. She says she could never hurt him because she loves him. She even says one day they will laugh about all of this. She asks Ethan to tell her what he's thinking? Elswhere, Ivy tells Gwen that she is going to hire Theresa. Gwen thinks Theresa can help them find out Ethan's stalker. Ivy thinks the exact same thing. Ivy shouts for Ethan, and Theresa hears her. Ivy tells Gwen she will go back to her room to get Theresa, and they can all meet downstairs. Gwen goes into Ethan's room, and there is no sign of Theresa. Ethan comes out of the bathroom and tells Gwen that he was in the shower and couldn't hear her. Gwen says that Ivy wanted him to meet Theresa in the living room. Ethan tells Gwen about Sheridan, and Gwen says she already knows. Ethan tells Gwen that they have to take care of Sheridan and let her know that she is loved. Ethan begins to rant and rave about the crazy girl who has targeted him and wants to see her put away. He is unaware that Theresa is hiding under his bed! Ethan says he will find the girl who is stalking him and make an example out of her. He says that he never listened to his parents when they always told him people will target him for the Crane money, but now he believes them. Gwen asks Ethan if he really thinks all poor people are gold diggers, and he says of course not. Gwen and Ethan leave and Theresa is devastated and says she's been such a fool. Theresa realizes she has to get out of here.
Downstairs, Ethan and Gwen wait to meet Theresa. Ethan decides that he has to meet this Theresa now and as he walks out of the room, Theresa sneaks down the steps. When the phone rings, Ethan turns around to answer it because it could be SHeridan. It is Sheridan, who tells Ethan that she's worried about his stalker. Ethan says he is handling it. As Theresa tip-toes down the stairs, Gwen shows up and asks what she is doing?
At the Lopez-Fitzgerald household, Pilar is upset to learn what Theresa did to Ethan, who thinks his daughter is stalking him. Pilar says if Ivy finds out what Theresa did to Ethan, and if Luis finds out she is at the mansion, God help Theresa! Pilar calls Ivy to make sure everything is all right. Ivy says Theresa is perfect. Pilar asks if Theresa is still there. Ivy says she's not sure, she wanted her to meet Ethan. Pilar is thrilled to learn that Theresa hasn't meant Ethan. Out in the LF's backyard, Whitney distracts Luis while Pilar talks to Ivy, but Luis soon becomes suspicious. Back inside, Pilar says it is late and Theresa should come home, there is no need for her to meet Theresa tonight. Ivy says there is and tells Pilar that they think Theresa can help them find the local crazy who has been stalking Ethan. After the phone call, Pilar leaves to lay down and Luis asks Whitney what Theresa is up to now? Whitney says it is not her place to say anything, so Luis says he'll find out for himself. When Luis decides to call the cannery to speak to Theresa, Whitney stops him and says she lost the job. Luis asks how, and Whitney says it was an accident. Luis gets a bad feeling and realizes she did something to Ethan, again.
At Tabitha's house, Tabitha asks her spirit board where Faith and Charity are. The board spells out L-O-B, but then stops. When Timmy suggests she buys a vowel, Tabitha threatens to knock him upside the head. Suddenly the reader starts to move again and spells out Lobster Shack. Tabitha says this is a disaster, Grace and Sam are going there for dinner as well. Tabitha says she has kept those two apart for twenty years, she can't let them meet know. Timmy runs around screaming "Timmy and Tabitha are gunna die!" Tabitha tells him to settle down, they will go to the Lobster Shack and somehow keep them from meeting. Tabitha runs to the Lobster Shack, and Timmy complains that he can't run as fast as her. Tabitha says if Grace and Faith meet up, they will die! Timmy pushes her aside, shouts "Out of my way old woman!" and zooms ahead of her.
At the Lobster Shack, Jessica and Simone watch Kay as she is about to profess her love to Miguel. However, before she can do it, Reese walks up and tells Kay that she is so beautiful. When Kay says maybe they should sit down, Reese says their table is right over their. Miguel tells Reese to treat Kay properly, they've been friends for a long time. Kay doesn't understand, and then sees Jessica wave to her from outside. Outside, Jessica says that this is so perfect, Travis and Mindy the school gossips, will spread this all over town by tomorrow. Suddenly, Sam and Grace show up and ask Jessica what she is up to. Back inside, Miguel asks Kay what is wrong, and Reese says it is him, she obviously doesn't like him. Miguel says of course she does, why wouldn't she want to have dinner with him? Kay says that she just doesn't want to leave him alone, but Miguel is sure Charity will show up soon. Kay insists they keep Miguel company and sits down at his table. Grace, Sam, Simone, and Jessica enter, and Grace thinks Jessica was spying on Kay's date. Sam invites Jessica and Simone to join them so Kay can have some privacy. As they eat, Sam keeps Jessica from going over to tease Kay. Later, Grace is overcome with a feeling of love. She thinks that something big is about to happen.
Meanwhile, Kay tells Miguel that maybe his mystery date changed her mind. Miguel decides to go look for his date, but Kay screams "no!" because she doesn't want to be left with Reese. Miguel asks what is wrong? Kay says because she set up the date, she will be the one to find her.
Outside, A man tells Charity and Faith that he's sorry if his dog scared them, he just got loose. Charity tells her mom that they should go to the Lobster Shack, but Faith says there are forces of evil at work all around them. Charity and Faith find the lobster shack and Faith remembers a great memory of Grace. One year Grace took the both of them out for lobster, which they both love, on their birthday. Charity tells her mom that she will find Grace one day, and they go inside. The maitre'de sees Faith and says "Weren't you just . . ." but then says he must have been mistaken. He shows them to a table, and they walk right past a divider separating Faith from Grace! When the waiter comes to take their order, he also stares at her. After he leaves, Faith tells Charity that she can sense her sister so strongly right now.
Tabitha and Timmy shows up and Tabitha freaks when she sees Grace and Faith are both inside. Tabitha faints, and Timmy thinks she is dead. However, she is really casting a spell. Tabitha floats back up to her feet, and straight up off of the ground! Timmy tells her to talk to him, she's scaring him. Tabitha begins to spin around rapidly in the air.
At the mansion, Ethan talks to Sheridan on the phone about his stalker. Meanwhile, Gwen asks Theresa where she is going? Theresa says she was seeing her way out, she didn't want to be a bother. Gwen says that Ethan is just finishing a call, but she knows he wants to meet her. She asks her to come into the living room and wait with her. Theresa says she doesn't want to be a bother, but Gwen says she has to meet Ethan tonight, he needs her help. Gwen takes Theresa into the living room. Ethan's back is towards Theresa, and she hears Ethan's conversation with Sheridan. Sheridan tells Ethan that perhaps this girl is trying to get his attention because she has a crush on him. Ethan blurts out "Did you just say she has a crush on me?" and Theresa's eyes widen. Sheridan says it makes perfect sense, but Ethan doesn't believe that. Ethan says he loathes and detests this girl, besides he is in love with Gwen and couldn't love this girl if she was the last woman on earth. A crying Theresa tells Gwen that her allergies are bothering her and she has to go. On the phone, Ethan tells Sheridan that she should forget about Jean-Luc, she might find Mr. Right here in Harmony. Sheridan doubts that and says she has sworn off men. Theresa leaves just as Ethan hangs up the phone. Ethan asks Gwen to tell him about Theresa. Gwen says she is different now since she first meet her. Earlier she was tense, but when she left she seemed sad. Ethan hopes nothing bad happened to her while she was here and says maybe they should go to her house to check on her. He also asks Gwen to forget what he said about poor people are gold diggers. Gwen says she knows he was just angry. Ethan tells her how Sheridan thinks his stalker may have a crush on her.
Theresa goes home and tells Whitney that tonight was the worst night of her life. Whitney thinks Ethan saw her, but Theresa says he didn't. She explains to her that Ethan thinks she is a psycho and he'd never love her, even if she is the last woman on earth. She shouts that she hates Ethan because he thinks all poor people are gold diggers. Theresa says that Luis was right about Ethan. Whitney says, since she mentioned Luis, he knows she lost her job because of Ethan. Theresa thinks her brother will lock her in her bedroom and will put one of those prisoner bracelets on her that tracks her whereabouts. She swears to Whitney that she is through with Ethan and the Cranes this time. Whitney says she has heard that before, but Theresa proves what she means by breaking her diet and eating whip cream right out of the can. Whitney says she has to dream about something, she knows her. Theresa says she is going to focus on becoming a fashion designer.
Sheridan's plane lands and she takes a rental care home. However, she is so steamed about Jean-Luc that she drives a tad on the fast side. Sheridan does 98 in a 45 mile an hour zone, and Luis, who set a speed trap, goes after her. Sheridan sees him behind her and says that a lecture from a cop is the last thing she needs, so she speeds up. Luis says that was a bad move and radios in and tells the station that some yuppie is trying to outrun him and he'll report in when he has him in custody. Sheridan thinks she has outrun the cop, until she sees him blocking the road ahead of her. She slams on the breaks, but smashes into Luis' jeep. Luis tells "mister" to get out of the car. Sheridan is insulted and says I don't think so!
At the Lobster Shack, Charity tells her mom that her sensing her twin is a good omen. Faith excuses herself to go to the restroom. Grace orders her favorite, Lobster Newburg. As they are about to kiss, Jessica shows up and makes sounds so they stop being affectionate in public. Grace tells Jessica that they will talk to Kay about her dress when they get home, she is wearing a different dress now, and they will also find out if she (Jessica) did anything else to her sister tonight. Grace excuses herself to go to the bathroom.
Elsewhere, Kay talks with Simone about what her sister did, and is thankful that the school gossips left before they learned her date was with Reese. Kay then tells Simone that she will be very supportive of Miguel tonight and act angry that he was stood up. Simone asks about Reese? Kay says she can get rid of him easily.
Miguel talks to a waiter and asks if he has seen his mystery date. The waiter says he did see a girl fitting that description come in awhile ago. Kay finds Miguel and tells him that his date stood her up, but Miguel says she is here somewhere!
Outside, Tabitha floats above the ground and begins to spin around. Soon the wind begins to blow around her. The wind grows stronger and begins to rip through the Lobster Shack. Inside, Faith and Grace return to their families. Faith thinks it is evil, and Sam thinks it the wind from a passing sea storm. Reese tries to comfort Kay, who does not want any of his comfort. Sam suggests they all move into the backroom where it is safe, and Miguel spots Charity. Faith tells CHarity that it isn't safe here and they have to leave. Miguel tells Reese to take Kay into the back so he can find his girl. Later, he thinks he sees her and grabs her arm and says "I've finally found you!" However, it is only Kay.
Back outside, Tabitha drops to the ground. Timmy thinks she is dead, but she soon gets up. Timmy gives her a hug and Tabitha tells him that he looks like he lost a couple of rounds in a dryer. Timmy tells her it was because of the wind she conjured up, and he wasn't scared because he knew what she was doing. Timmy suggests she write a book about these things, it would be a best seller. Tabitha spies on the people in the Lobster Shack and learns that Faith and Charity flew the coup before Grace and Faith could be reunited. She then tells Timmy that it is time to hunt down Faith and Charity and eliminate them. Timmy wants to rest, but Tabitha says they have to get them while they are on the run.
Back inside, everyone wonders what is happened, and Miguel wonders where his dream date went. Miguel goes off to look for her, and Jessica teases Kay about how Miguel would rather be with a girl he hardly knows. Kay tells Jessica that she is going to kill her and warns her to sleep with her eyes open. Grace starts feeling bad and tells Sam that she can't help think something is about to go wrong.
Faith and Charity run away from the Lobster Shack until Charity stops her and says the winds have died down. Faith says those winds came from hell and they have to keep running so evil doesn't find them.
On the road, Sheridan plows right into Luis car. She tries to back up and drive away, but Luis warns "buster" that he'll shoot if he doesn't stop the car! Luis approaches the car and Sheridan says "My name isn't buster and you can't arrest me!" Luis asks why, so Sheridan pulls out her idea and says her name is Crane, C R A N E. Luis refuses to give her special treatment and arrests her!
Luis brings Sheridan Crane into the station, and one of the other cops ask if he is crazy? Luis says he is just doing his job. Sheridan wants her phone call, and tells Luis that he is making a big mistake.
At the Lopez-Fitzgerald house, Theresa assures Whitney that she never wants to see Ethan again, her dreams of Ethan marrying her will never happen. Whitney is sorry that Theresa is hurting, but she tried to tell her that life is not a soap opera. Theresa says she knows that, but she should have seen the mansion and Mrs Crane's closet. She says she was made for that job, but she can't have it because of Ethan. Pilar walks into the kitchen and tells Theresa that she is so disappointed in her. Theresa says she didn't mean for the accidents to happen, but Pilar says she made it worse by going to the mansion. Pilar asks what Mrs. Crane said when she turned down the job offer? Theresa doesn't say anything, and Pilar realizes that she didn't tell Ivy no. Theresa says she didn't have the heart to turn it down, but Pilar tells her that she can't have that job. Pilar tells her daughter to act like a grownup and return to the mansion and turn the job down. Pilar says she is going to call Ivy and tell her to expect Theresa to return tonight.
Sheridan calls Ethan at the mansion and tells her that Luis something-or-another arrested her for speeding. Ethan heads to the police station, and Ivy sits and listens to more STIX songs. The phone rings, and it is Pilar. Pilar tells her that Theresa would like to return to speak with her. Ivy says she is alone right now and would love the company. Back at the LF's household, Pilar tells her that Ethan is out, so she is to turn down the job politely.
Miguel is wandering around Harmony looking for Charity. Tabitha and Timmy are also looking for faith and Charity. Faith is dragging Charity by the hand, and Charity eventually stops her and says she doesn't understand her mood swings. Faith says they have found them, they have to find someplace safe from evil until the sun comes up. Charity asks her mom if she is talking about Vampires? Faith says that all evil is more treacherous at night, so Charity suggests they go back to the inn. Faith says it is not safe there, and she knows where she has to go. Tabitha and Timmy are still trying to find Faith and Charity, and Tabitha realizes where Faith would go if she was frightened. Faith continues to drag Charity all over the place, and Tabitha and Timmy finally spot them and tail them. Unfortunate, Faith and Charity go into a church before Tabitha can get to them. Timmy wonders why they don't go in, but Tabitha says lighting will zap their hearts, or worse! Timmy asks how she made such powerful enemies? Tabitha says it is a long story and they don't have time right now. Tabitha says they have to come up with a way to trick Charity into coming out on her own. Inside, Faith tells Charity to make herself comfortable, they will be here all night. Faith goes to the alter to pray, and Tabitha lures Charity out by pretending to be a lost little girl. Tabitha tells Timmy all they have to do now is get her away from the church and her mom, which they do.
Back at the restaurant, the manager says the Lobster Shack is closed, so Grace invites the kids over to their house for pizza. Miguel returns and tells Kay that he couldn't find his date, and asks who she is and how she got a hold of her? Kay says she asked her to come when she ran into her at the carnival, she didn't think to get her name. Sam asks Grace "I thought Miguel was Kay's date?" and Grace says she thought so too. Kay invites him to come home and have pizza with them, but Miguel wants to keep looking. Kay says she will help, and Reese and Kay also agree to help.
Miguel, Kay, Reese, Jessica, and Simone go searching for Charity. Simone tells Jessica how horrible she is, and that she probably created the wind storm as well. Jessica says she didn't, but that was the best part of the show.
Grace and Sam return home, and Grace tells Sam that she feels strange. Sam asks how, and Grace says she is sensing a threat to someone's soul. Sam tells her that he always knew she was a deep, spiritual person. Grace wishes she knew something about her past, and when Sam suggests they try the interned, he receives a call from the station. One of the police officers tells him that Luis arrested a Crane. Same leaves and Grace tries to knit, but can't. The kids show up and Grace tells them that she has an errand to run. Miguel thanks Kay for trying to set up the date, but decides to leave. Kay says maybe they could have lunch tomorrow. Miguel agrees, and also invites Reese to make up for tonight. After Miguel leaves, Kay tells Reese he should go because she has a headache. After Reese leaves, Kay tells Jessica that this is her last night on earth. She threatens to flush her head down the toilet, and Simone suggests she run. Jessica storms upstairs, and Kay chases after her.
Grace has an overwhelming urge to go to the church. Grace enters the church as Faith is praying at the alter. Grace lights a candle at another alter and prays.
At the station, Sheridan tells Luis that he crossed the wrong person. Ethan shows up and demands Sheridan's release to take her home. Luis says the only place she is going is to jail. Ethan calls the mayor and manages to get Sheridan out of jail. Sam shows up and Ethan asks him to talk some sense into his cop. Sam is told the mayor is on the line, so he takes the call. Ethan thinks they can go, but Sam says he stood up to the mayor and says Sheridan will be arraigned in the morning. Ethan says he won't let them treat her this way, but Sheridan says she is not scared. Ethan tells Sam that he will regret this, and suggests he look for his stalker instead of arresting one of Harmony's most upstanding citizens. Sheridan is locked up in a cell with a very odd and eccentric woman. Luis thanks Sam for backing up his call, but Sam says the Cranes don't forget their enemies.
Theresa arrives at the mansion and Ivy invites her inn. Ivy thinks she is here for more details on the position, and she would like to know a little more about what her future goals are. Theresa says she would like to go into the fashion or magazine world. Ivy says that her job here would prepare her for that, because eventually she would take on all the responsibilities of a personal secretary, such as planning parties and working with her professional shoppers and jewelers. Theresa's eyes widen and she sees herself buying elegant gowns and jewels. Ivy continues to woo Theresa when she says that she would be traveling with her all over Europe to view collections. Ivy tells her she hopes she can start tomorrow. Theresa remembers what Whitney and her mother said, and tells Ivy that she can start tomorrow! Ivy is thrilled and says she will see her in the morning. Theresa asks if she could use the phone before leaving, and Ivy tells her it is okay. Theresa calls Whitney and tells her that she is still at the mansion, she accepted the job offer. Theresa thinks she can work for Ivy and not let Ethan see her. Whitney tells Theresa to get out of the house, do not pass go or collect two hundred dollars. Theresa says she should get out of here before Ethan comes home. On the way out, Theresa runs into Ethan, who recognizes her as his stalker.
Outside, Tabitha continues to cry for help like a little girl in order to lure Charity away from the church. Timmy tells Tabitha to hurry up and get rid of Charity, he needs to go home and dry out. Tabitha says she is trying, she has to destroy her before she destroys them. Timmy doesn't understand how this affects him, she only wants to destroy her. He then says "Timmy good, Tabitha bad!" Tabitha's mouth falls open in shock! Timmy says she is the evil one, not Timmy! Tabitha tells him that he is full of himself, she made him and without her he is nothing but a carnival prize! Perhaps that little girl will win him again and he'll spend his life as an inanimate doll at tea parties! Timmy begs "no not that!" and Tabitha makes him says he is sorry. Timmy asks why she wants to destroy this girl so much? Tabitha says that she has powers to fight evil, but won't come into them until she becomes a woman. Tabitha and Timmy continue to lure Charity farther away from the church. Tabitha puts her shawl over her head and tells Charity that she's lost her granddaughter. Charity tells her not to worry, she will help her find her. Tabitha says she fears her daughter could fall off the pier, so Charity goes to the pier to look. TImmy shows up in a new outfit, a trench coat, gloves, and and beret-like hat! As Charity looks for the little girl, Tabitha and Timmy begin removing some planks from the pier.
At the police station, Miguel shows up to see Luis. Luis wonders why Miguel is so down, and asks how his date went? Miguel says the date didn't happen, it is almost like fate is trying to keep them apart. Miguel tells him about the wind storm, and Luis says it was quiet around here. Luis tells Miguel that he's really got it bad for this girl. Miguel asks Luis if it is possible to fall in love at first site? Luis says it might be for him (Miguel), but it will never happen to him (Luis). Miguel tells him that it could happen if the right woman comes along. Luis says she'll have to wait, his responsibility to the family comes first. Miguel says he better get home, so Luis offers to give him a ride. Miguel is upset when he learns that he arrested Sheridan, and he fears their mother could lose her job over this. Luis says good, I don't want her working there!
In her cell, Sheridan paces around. The woman sharing the cell with her tells her to sit down and have some of her candy bar. Sheridan thanks her and says she hoped to be dining with her family tonight. She vows that Luis Lopez-Fitgerald will pay for this. Later the other woman is let out on bail. Gwen shows up and tells Sheridan that Ethan says she will be released first thing in the morning. The two then share their experiences with Luis Lopez-Fitzgerald. Gwen tells her that he is Pilar's son, which shocks Sheridan. Gwen says that she sympathizes with her, but she was speeding and crashed into his car. Sheridan says yeah, but he didn't need to get an attitude with me! She laughs and says no girl could ever love that man. Sheridan says she shouldn't be criticizing when her love life is in shambles. Sheridan says her family was right about dating outside your own class after all, she will have to find a man richer than she is. Gwen thinks there is a man out there for her somewhere. They then talk about Gwen getting married to Ethan. Gwen tells Sheridan that she turned down Ethan's proposal because Ethan has things he has to sort out. Sheridan asks if she thinks there is another girl in his life? Gwen says no, she thinks Ethan should mix with a broader range of people. Sheridan tells her that no girl will ever come between them, so she should accept his proposal. Gwen insists that the proposal has to come from Ethan's heart.
Up in Ivy's room in the mansion, Ivy is playing with her locket, listening to Stix, and looking at a picture of Ethan. Julian comes in, and Ivy says she would appreciate it if he would knock before walking in. Ivy asks what he wants, and Julian asks what she would say if he came to collect on his conjugal rites? Ivy laughs, and he tells her not to worry. He wonders why she is listening to this song again, perhaps it is a sign of old age? She turns it off and tells Julian that his sister was arrested by Luis Lopez- Fitzgerald tonight. Julian is furious and intends to call Sam Bennett. Ivy tells him not to bother, Sam is standing by Luis. Julian says he will deal with him when he is up for re-election, and as for Luis, his mother will be fired for his actions! Ivy puts her foot down and tells him that Pilar is her friend and he won't fire her, in fact she is hiring her daughter as well. She warns Julian to keep his hands off of Theresa in the future. Julian tells Ivy that if she hates him so much she could divorce him, but Ivy says he is forgetting about the deal. Julian thinks that Ivy is planning to wait until Ethan takes over the family business so she can rule through him.
At the Crane estate, Ethan runs into Theresa and calls her his stalker. Ethan thinks she's trying to break into his home. Theresa says she wasn't stalking him, everything she did were accidents. Ethan doesn't believe her and thinks she is after the whole Crane family. Ethan grabs her and says he's calling the police and is not letting her get away this time. Theresa tells him to let her go! Ethan wants to know who she is and what she is doing here. Theresa tells him that she used to think he was the most wonderful person in the world and would know how she felt without her having to say a word. Ethan asks her what in the world she is talking about. Theresa says she knew he wouldn't understand. Ethan tells her to explain it to the police, and drags her into the mansion. Ethan says he has to protect his family, and she says she does to. She says her brother Luis will be horrified if he learns about this. Ethan tells her that she needs help for her own good. As he goes to call the cops, Theresa bolts. Ethan calls security and tells them to close the front gate! Ivy and Julian show up and ask Ethan what is wrong? Ethan says his stalker is here! Ivy is furious and can't believe this girl got past their security. Ethan wants to go look for her, but Ivy says no way. Ivy and Julian begin to bicker, Ethan leaves to find the girl. Ivy call security and tells them to let out the dogs. Julian asks if that is necessary? Ivy says she will do anything to protect her son. Julian says sometimes he thinks she loves Ethan more than their other children, and he doesn't know why.
Outside, Ethan hears the dogs and feels bad for "the poor girl" and says he has to find her. Theresa hears Ethan shouting for her, but she refuses to let him find her because Ivy will learn the truth. Theresa tries to clime the gate, but ends up falling. Theresa realizes she lost one of her barrettes, and the fog is so think that she can't find it. Theresa takes off, and Ethan shows up and finds the barrette.
Luis drives Miguel home and continues to rant and rave about the Cranes. Miguel tells Luis that he knows he wanted to go to law school, but Luis says that was a long time ago. Luis says he can't leave his family alone to pay the bills themselves, plus he has to protect them from the Cranes. Suddenly, Luis gets a call over his CB that the silent alarm at the Crane estate has been triggered and he needs to get over there. Miguel tells his big brother to drop him off at the corner, he can walk home.
At the church, Faith tells the priest that she is terrified for her daughter and doesn't know how she is going to keep her safe from evil. The priest tells her that she is safe here, she is not alone, she must believe that. Faith says she tries, but sometimes she feels so alone. Meanwhile, Grace examines the statue which looks like the little girl who haunts her. Grace turns around and sees Faith talking to the priest. She says the woman looks distraught and wonder if the priest needs help. The priest asks Faith why evil has singled out her daughter? Faith says her daughter has been blessed with special powers, powers her sister had. She says that evil took her twin, and now they are after her daughter. The two pray, and Grace wonders who Faith is and why she is upset. Faith suddenly realizes Charity is gone and she runs out of the church. Grace approaches the priest and asks what is wrong with that woman. The priest says she was troubled. He then realizes the connection and tells Grace that she must go find that woman and her daughter. Grace returns and tells the priest that she couldn't find her. However, she hears Faith calling to Charity and says that voice sounds familiar. The priest tells her to go find her.
On the docks, Tabitha continues to try and lure Charity to her death. Tabitha tells Timmy to pull up the planks so Charity will fall through. Timmy tells Tabitha to do it, so she does. Charity inches closer to the removed planks, unaware that rocks and the sea lie beneath her. Charity takes one more step forward, and then she falls! Charity manages to grab onto the edge of the docks and screams for help. Tabitha wants Charity to let go, but Timmy doesn't want to see Charity die. Timmy wants to leave because this is too horrible to watch, but Tabitha refuses to let him go anywhere. Timmy says this is breaking his heart. Tabitha tells him that he doesn't have a heart, he is a doll!
Miguel is walking around and fantasizes about meeting Charity and dancing with her. Suddenly, Miguel hears Charity's screams. Miguel runs to the docks and offers Charity a hand. Charity cries that she slip if she tries. Miguel eventually saves Charity and asks her what she is doing out here? Charity explains that she was trying to find a lost little girl. Tabitha is furious that her plan failed, and Timmy asks her what she is going to do now. Tabitha and Timmy leave, Tabitha is down in the dumps. However, she vows to find a way to make Miguel pay for this. Elsewhere, Charity hears her mom calling her. Miguel tells her that she has a beautiful name. Tabitha panics when she hears Faith calling for Charity and says they have to keep Faith and Grace from meeting. Tabitha tells Timmy that they have to get rid of Charity before the sisters meet.
At the Crane estate, Ethan searches for Theresa and asks her to give up. Theresa fears that her own brother will end up arresting her, and then he'll kill her. Ethan talks to his stalker and says he won't hurt her, he just wants to get her help. Ethan eventually asks the gate guard to call off the dogs. Luis shows up at the estate, which upsets Ethan. Ethan tells Luis that he can go, this is a private matter and doesn't want the police involved. Theresa sees Luis and says he can't let him find her. Luis eventually agrees to leave after Ethan tells him to go ten times. Gwen eventually shows up and wants Ethan to leave town. Ethan says he won't let this stalker chase him out of his own home. Ethan changes the subject and asks how Sheridan is, and she says that she's angry right now, but she thinks his aunt will bounce back and find the right man. Gwen tells Ethan that they should go up to his room where it is warm and dry, and she will help him forget about his stalker. Ethan caves and decides to go inside.
Luis is driving home in his jeep, unaware that Theresa is hiding in the back seat. Luis wonders what type of nutso girl would stalk Ethan. Luis then realize it could be Theresa! Luis says he has to find his sister and talk to her. Luis arrives home and bangs on Theresa's door. She doesn't answer, so her turns to leave. Suddenly Theresa answers the door in a bathrobe, her hair is in a towel. Luis asks Theresa where she was tonight? Theresa says she was job hunting. Luis asks if she broke into the Crane estate, and she says no. Luis is relieved, kisses her, and says goodnight. Theresa tells herself that she can't go back to the mansion, she'll have to call Mrs. Crane and quit.