At camp, Kay shows up and distracts Reese by crying. She says she's so scared, and she asks Reese to hold her. Reese holds her, and Kay watches as Charity is drawn to the lights in the woods. The warlocks call CHarity to them, and Kay smiles as Charity walks towards the lights. The warlocks tell Charity that there are things they must tell her about, secrets, but she must come to them because she has the power to help them. They offer to tell her about the girl who will take Miguel from her, if only she will come to them. Kay continues to distract Reese as Charity walks deeper into the woods. Charity continues to ask what girl will take Miguel from her. THe warlocks tell her she has the gift to see into the future. Tabitha eventually returns to camp, she still can't find Timmy, and hopes Charity can help her. Reese realizes he was supposed to be watching Charity, and now she is gone! Back in the woods, the Warlocks lure Charity to their cave, and promise to tell her secrets if she comes inside.
Tabitha runs back into the woods calling out for Timmy. Timmy yells for help, and then is promptly gagged by Norma. Tabitha finally spots Norma and runs towards him, falling right into Norma's trap. Meanwhile, Reese continues to worry about Charity and fears the warlocks might have gotten her. Kay says she's sure Charity is just find. Reese hopes so, because they could be in super-natural trouble if the warlocks have returned.
At the church in Harmony, Pilar is working on the flowers and is shocked when Ivy shows up. She asks Ivy why she is here, evening mass ended awhile ago. Pilar realizes Ivy is up to something, and she asks what she is doing here. Ivy says she only came to leave some flowers on the altar because she feels guilty about crashing her car into the church. Pilar doubts that is why she is bringing the flowers, and asks her if she really thinks God will accept flowers and forgive her for breaking up Sam and Grace's marriage? Ivy tells Pilar to wait just a minute, she gave up on Sam, and she meant it. Ivy says she realizes there is no place in Sam's life for her. However, Ivy says if David and Grace are married, then Sam is free and it is not wrong for her to hope she and Sam can be together. Therefore, until David gives up, Ivy says she will not give up.
Inside, Sam tells Grace that he told her that Hastings was a fake, Father Mike doesn't recognize them, so they weren't married. Grace tells Sam that she's sorry, but it is far from over. Grace wants to make sure she is not married to David. Eve tells Grace to be sensible, if Father Mike's name is on the marriage license and he didn't marry them, then someone must have forged his signature. Sam says exactly, and begins to cuff David. Sam puts David under arrest for kidnapping his wife! Grace asks Sam not to do this, she needs to know for certain that she wasn't married to him. Sam asks her what else there is she needs to prove she wasn't married to him? As Hank is taking David out to meet the police who have been phoned to come pick up David, he offers more proof they are married. David says Grace was found of a chapel next to the church with the statue of a little angel girl in it. Father Mike says they have such a chapel, and people are married there. David says that is where they were married, but Father Mike still can't remember them. David says Grace was wearing a simple white dress and a hat with a broad rim. Sam says that David is just brow-beating Father Mike now. Meanwhile, Pilar and Ivy spy on the whole thing, and Pilar asks Ivy if she will give up on Sam now? Sam tells David that he can either go to jail, or leave Harmony. David says nothing, so Sam says he's taking him to jail. Suddenly, Father Mike asks Grace if her hair was always that color? Grace doesn't know, and David says no it wasn't. David says she tried coloring her hair for the wedding, but it came out blonde, so that is why she bought the hat. Father Mike begins to remember marrying them. David is pleased, and so is Ivy. Sam still doesn't believe it and thinks David just managed to trick Father Mike into believing he married them. David says if the priest can answer one more question, it will prove he married them. David whispers to Grace that the morning they were going to marry, her cat scratched her hand, and they put a band-aid on her ring finger. David says when it time for him to put the ring on, he couldn't because of the bandage. David then asks Father Mike if he can remember anything about Grace's hands? Father Mike says Grace had a band-aid on and they couldn't get the ring on. Grace realizes everything is true, she and David must be married. Father Mike says he remembers the entire ceremony, in the eyes of God they are married. Father Mike says he remembers them being happy and in love. Ivy thinks that Sam is free to be hers again! Grace is shocked, and Sam just says "It can't be!"
In Bermuda, Theresa holds onto Luis and asks if he will be okay. The captain says he is in bad shape, he kept searching for Sheridan. Ethan asks if there is any chance Sheridan could be alive. The captain says if the explosion didn't kill her, the rough seas had to have done her in. Ethan says this can't be, and refuses to believe Sheridan is dead until a body is found. The first mate says they never found Sheridan, the only reason they knew about her was because of Luis. The first mate says he and the captain searched, but the couldn't find Sheridan. A doctor shows up to look at Luis. Ethan calls for a rescue boat, and Luis comes to. Luis asks where Sheridan is? Theresa tells him to save his strength, but Luis refuses to go to the hospital when Sheridan is still out there. Ethan asks what happened, so he recounts the details of the explosion. Ethan tells Theresa that they can't get married now, but he wants to know what she wanted to tell him before when she stopped the wedding. Theresa says she just had a terrible feeling that someone was wrong. Ethan says he trusts her, and he goes off to save Sheridan. Luis wants to go, but Chad tells Luis that he needs to go to the hospital. Luis says his life is no good without Sheridan anyways.
Basil and June show up and tell Julian that Sheridan is dead, just like he ordered. Julian thanks them for a job well done. Basil wants his money, and Julian says he'll get it. LAter, Ethan spots Julian in the shadows and asks why he isn't organizing a search party? Julian says a hurricane is coming, he's not putting other's lives in danger if Sheridan is most likely dead. Ethan, Chad, and Luis are going out, and Ethan asks Julian if he's coming or not? Julian refuses, and asks Basil, the "head of hotel security" to take them out. Basil tells Julian this wasn't part of the deal, but Julian says he'll pay him double to make sure they don't find Sheridan. Whitney tells Chad that he doesn't have to do this, but Chad says if Ethan is going out, he's going. Whitney asks him to keep himself in one piece. Chad asks her if she'd miss him if he didn't come back? Whitney says of course she'd miss him. Whitney backs away from Chad when he gets close, and she says Simone would be devastated if he didn't come back. Chad turns away, and Whitney begs him to be careful. MEanwhile, Ethan promises Theresa that the next time they marry, nothing will stop them.
Basil, Luis, Ethan, and Chad all head out to search for Sheridan. Back on shore, Julian calls Basil and asks what is going on. Basil says even if Sheridan survived the explosion, there is no way she could survive the waves out here. Luis continues to scream Sheridan's name, and asks God not to let him lose her.
Elsewhere on the island, Norma has Tabitha trapped in her pit, and her father tells her to kill them both right now! Norma unties Timmy, and Timmy offers to give her the money from Hidden Passions is she lets them go. Norma says she doesn't want her money, she wants to see them dead! Norma then throws Timmy in the pit. Tabitha tries to catch him, but misses. Later, Norma begins throwing firewood into the pit! Suddenly, the kids show up and ask Norma if she has seen Charity? She says no, so Reese asks about Tabitha and her doll? Norma says she hasn't seen them either. Miguel asks her to help search for Charity, so she agrees to help them, leaving Tabith and Timmy alone. Tabitha and Timmy then make an attempt to escape. Tabitha orders Timmy to dig there way out of the pit. Timmy ends up coming across one of the warlock's scepters as he is digging! Tabitha tells Timmy to be careful, that scepter could destroy the entire island!
At the warlock's cave, the warlocks plead with Charity to come into their cave. Charity says no, she wants to be with her friends. The warlocks say they are her friends, and if she comes to them, they will tell her secrets. Charity asks them who they are? They tell them that they are the warlocks! They beg her to come inside and they will tell her about her family and friends. They tell her they can tell her about her aunt and uncle and the danger they are about to face! They also offer to tell her about the old woman, but they will tell her no more until she helps them! Charity walks towards the cave, but stops when she hears Miguel screaming for her. Charity turns around and calls back to Miguel, but before he can reach her, she is sucked into the cave, which closes behind her!
At the church, Ivy is thrilled because she knows if Grace and David were married in the church, Sam will be free to be with her. Pilar tells Ivy that it is wrong to take such pleasure in other's pain! Ivy says she is only trying to get Sam back! Father Mike confirms that he did marry David and Grace over twenty years ago. Sam says this can't be true, Grace would remember it because the church is too important to Grace. Grace says Sam is right, she would remember being married. David asks to have the cuffs removed, and Sam does so when Grace asks him to. Grace tries to remember her wedding, but she can't. Father Mike says that they were very committed, and very in love. Sam tells Grace that she can end this if she tells him that she doesn't remember and to just go away. Father Mike also says he remembers Grace was upset because her twin sister couldn't be there for the wedding. Grace still can't remember, so Eve comes up with a way to make her remember. Grace agrees to do whatever Eve has in mind, and David agrees to go along with it as long as it isn't painful for Grace. Sam asks Eve what she has in mind? Eve suggests they try and jog Grace's memory by re-enact the wedding ceremony. Eve asks Father Mike if he can do it? Father Mike agrees if it will help. Sam tells Grace to do it, because he knows she won't remember. David agrees, and the wedding begins! Sam stops them and makes sure the ceremony won't be legal. Father Mike says no, besides, they are already married. Grace tells Sam she won't do this if he doesn't want her to, but Sam wants her to. The wedding continues, and Sam hopes this works. Eve says she knows of some patients who amnesia vanished when confronted with their past. David begins saying the wedding vows, and Grace closes her eyes. Grace then says her vows, but she still can't recall marrying him. Sam suggests they leave, but Eve says the ceremony is not complete until David kisses Grace. Sam refuses, but the others agree the kiss could be the trigger. David and Grace kiss, and memories of a wedding come flooding back to Grace!
In Bermuda, the hotel manager asks everyone to stay calm because they've been through hurricanes before. The manager asks them all to stay in the loby where they are safest. Theresa thinks this is all her fault, God is punishing her for marrying Mr. Crane. Theresa fears she will never see Ethan again, and it will be all her fault. A weatherman on TV announces that the hurricane has been upgrading to a level five, and Bermuda has only been hit by one level 5 hurricane before that they know of. Theresa fears she'll never see Luis and Ethan again, and Whitney realizes she may never see Chad again. Whitney wishes she had told Simone the truth long ago like Chad wanted. Theresa says this is all her fault for lying to Ethan, fate has done this.
Meanwhile, Julian calls Alistair and tells him that Sheridan is dead, but Luis survived. AListair is pleased and thinks Luis will be so grief-stricken that he won't care about finding out the truth about his father. Julian says he is grief-stricken as well. AListair says he feels bad too, he's not a monster, but Sheridan brought this on herself. AListair tells Julian to get over his grief, concentrate on marrying Rebecca, and running Crane Industries. Julian lets out an "ummmmmmmm" and Alistair asks Julian if there is something he is not telling him? Julian says of course not, everything is fine. Alistair says good, and hangs up.
Julian butts into Whitney and Theresa's conversation and tells her to stop telling people about their wedding. He says his attorney is coming here, and he has to erase all traces of their marriage! Suddenly, the hotel doors blow open! The staff rushes to close them. Julian asks to have a limo sent to the airport to pick up his attorney, but the hotel desk clerk says the airport is closed! A state of emergency is called, and everyone is forced to remain in the hotel. Theresa says one boat is still out searching. The man says that boat is doomed, nobody could ride this one out! As Theresa and Whitney pray, Julian thinks it might be just as well his attorney can't get here. Julian says if Ethan is lost, he might just have to stay married to Theresa!
Out at sea, the Harmony gang continue looking. The coast guard calls the boat and tells them they must return to Harbor, but Luis refuses to go anywhere. Suddenly, a huge wave hits the boat, and Ethan is swept overboard! Chad jumps in after Ethan, and Luis pulls them both back into the boat. Luis then takes control of the boat, so Basil pulls a gun out and says they are going back now! Luis fights with Basil over the gun, and Chad grabs it when Basil drops it. Luis then ties up Basil and says they aren't leaving until they find Sheridan. Suddenly, Ethan sees something in the water.
Grace breaks from her kiss with David and shakily announces she remembers their wedding. Sam is blown away, but he rallies when Grace admits she can't see the face of the groom. Sam is positive the groom wasn't David. Later, Eve spots Ivy in the church and lashes out at her for taking pleasure in Sam and Grace's turmoil.
The government calls a state of emergency in Bermuda. Out at sea, several Harmony residents struggle against the huge waves caused by the hurricane.
Rebecca and Gwen arrive in Bermuda. While Gwen hopes to reunite with Ethan, Rebecca is determined to marry Julian right away.
Elsewhere, Miguel and the others can't seem to find Charity, who has been sucked into the warlock's cave. Simone tells Kay this is all her fault for distracting Reese from watching Charity. Simone tells Kay that if Charity dies, she will tell everyone about her scheme to let Charity die so she can end up with Miguel! Kay says that she is not her cousin's keeper, and it is not her fault that charity is a nutcase. Kay says if anything happens to Charity tonight it is her own fault. Miguel continues to investigate where he heard Charity's voice coming from, but the mouth of the cave Charity was sucked into has closed shut. The kids continue to search for Charity, and Reese notices that Tabitha is also missing, and he thinks her being a witch has something to do with it. Jessica can't believe it, but she's beginning to think Reese is right! Kay tells Jessica not to be such a nervous nelly, Charity has premonitions all the time and most of them don't come true. Miguel says that is true, but he's still worried. Suddenly, Miguel finds a piece of Charity's shirt on the rocks near the now closed cave opening. Reese notices that the shirt is stuck in the rocks, and wonders how that could have happened.
Inside the cave, Charity lies unconscious on the ground. She mumbles "Miguel help me!" Charity begins to have her premonitions again, and says that they are all doomed. Suddenly, the warlocks appear over Charity and laugh that soon Charity's friends will arrive, and then they will all die! The warlocks circle Charity and chant "first you'll help us, and then you'll die." Later, Charity begins to glow and starts floating! The warlocks ask Charity to use her powers to help them! Charity floats upright, opens her eyes, and says she will use her powers to help them.
In Bermuda, the hotel guests watch the news about hurricane Peggy. Julian's friend Bruce tells Julian to forget about Peggy, he should be worried about Rebecca when she finds out it is too late to become Mrs. Julian Crane. Julian says that Rebecca can throw a fit for all he cares, he's married to Theresa now and he wants to keep it that way! Bruce doesn't think Rebecca will take the news lightly at all. Julian says Rebecca can't do anything about it, he and Theresa are legally married. Bruce asks what about Luis? Julian says Luis has been lost in the hurricane with Ethan. Bruce says if Luis makes it back, he will rip off his head and use it as a punching bag! Julian is not worried, he thinks Luis and Ethan are dead, and Rebecca will have to face that he's married to Theresa. Julian says he'll give Rebecca a condolence prize, but Bruce doesn't think Rebecca is the condolence prize type.
Rebecca and Gwen show up at the hotel and run into Theresa and Whitney. Rebecca asks THeresa what she is holding a picture of? Theresa has her and Julian's wedding photo in her hand, its in an envelope, and she says it is nothing they would be interested in. Rebecca disagrees and wants to see the photo. Whitney says that Theresa is just worried about Ethan, who is out at sea. Rebecca says they are all worried, and she demands Theresa show them the picture! Whitney tells Rebecca to leave Theresa alone, this is Theresa's personal property and she doesn't have to show it to her. Rebecca refuses to take no for an answer, but Gwen tells her mom to let it go. Gwen asks Theresa how she could let Ethan go out in that storm? Theresa says she tried to stop Chad, Ethan, and Luis, but they insisted on going out and looking for Sheridan. Gwen says that Ethan might die because of her, I hope she is happy. Rebecca gets a glimpse at the folder and sees it has wedding photos printed on it, and Gwen asks if she and Ethan are married? Rebecca snatches the folder, and decides to take a peak at the photos. A brochure for the wedding chapel falls out of the envelope, and she thinks it is very tacky, but she's seen worse. Rebecca then reaches into the folder, but is delayed by chit-chat. She thinks that Theresa came here for a quickie wedding, because that is why she came here. Rebecca says whatever secret the two of them are hiding, it's about to be made public! As Theresa and Rebecca bicker, Julian ends up hearing the voice of his ex-fiancee! Bruce and Julian come over and ask what is going on? Whitney says that Rebecca has stolen Theresa's personal property. Rebecca explains that she just wants to see if these photos are of THeresa and Ethan's wedding. Bruce blurts out that Ethan and Theresa did not get married. Gwen is thrilled, but Rebecca wonders what the picture is of? Julian tells her to just look at it, so Rebecca decides to do just that. Whitney grabs them, and tells Julian what the pictures are of! Rebecca grabs the envelope again, and Theresa and Whitney chase after her. Julian figures "what's the difference, she'll find out sooner or later." Bruce tells Julian to think this through, they can't leave this island because of the hurricane, he could be stuck here with Rebecca for days! Julian realizes Bruce is right, and tries to convince Rebecca not to invade Theresa's personal property. Rebecca becomes suspicious of her binky and wonders why he is defending Theresa? She asks Julian what is going on between them?
Out at sea, a massive wave sweeps over the boat. Everyone is washed overboard, and Ethan calls out to Luis and Chad. Nobody answers, and Ethan begins shouting for help. Chad eventually answers, and the two of them cling to a piece of wood. Ethan and Chad search for Luis, and they spot Luis floating face down in the water! Ethan and Chad swim to Luis, when another huge wave hits! Ethan and Chad are okay, and Ethan gets to Luis. Chad asks if Luis is okay, but Ethan thinks that Luis is dead!
At the church, Hank tells David to stop saying that Grace is his wife, she is married to Sam now. Hank tells David to leave Harmony and let Sam and Grace be happy. Pilar says Sam and Grace have children now, and that will tie them together forever. Eve says that Grace has no memory of him, so why can't he leave? David says he can't give up the woman he loves, and he asks questions about Sam and Ivy's relationship. Pilar tells David the story of Sam and IVy, and he thinks that they were torn apart by circumstances just like he and Grace were, and maybe deep down inside Sam still loves Ivy. Hank says Sam doesn't love Ivy anymore, but David theorizes that Ivy still loves Sam. Eve says that Ivy has made no secrets of her love for Sam. David asks Pilar about Sam and Ivy's love. Pilar says Ivy and Sam's love was sweet, passionate, intense, and all consuming. However, Eve says Sam and Grace have children, so they should be together. David points out that Ivy and Sam have a child too, so why shouldn't they be together? He says that would free Grace up to be with him, her true husband. Hank says that Sam doesn't want to have anything to do with Ivy, he has a rock-solid marriage to Grace. David hates to point this out, but Sam's marriage to Grace is invalid, the only marriage that counts is his and Grace's. David refuses to leave Harmony now that Grace is recognizing her feelings for him. He says that as strong as Grace's love is for Sam, her love for him is stronger.
Outside the church, Sam wishes David was dead. Grace tells Sam not to say such things, this isn't David's fault. Grace says David just came here to find the woman he loves. Sam thinks David is a liar, but Grace says she thinks David is admirable for wanting to save his marriage. Sam tells Grace that she is his wife, and he won't let anyone take her from him. Grace tells Sam that she may already be married to David, making their marriage null and void. Sam can't believe Grace is defending this guy, but Grace says that David has done nothing wrong, and he only wants to find the wife he lost. Sam is shocked and says the way she talks about him it is almost like she cares for him, like she's starting to remember she had feelings for him. Sam asks her if she is starting to remember caring for David?
At the hotel, Rebecca asks Julian what harm looking at a simple photograph can cause? Why is he siding with the maid's daughter? Julian asks Rebecca why she cares what is in that envelope? Theresa says she can't believe Rebecca cares about an envelope when their friends and family are out in that storm. Gwen blames Theresa for letting Ethan go out there, but Theresa says that she couldn't stop Ethan. Julian tells everyone that they should prepare for the worst, they must all be dead by now. Theresa refuses to believe that and says that Ethan, Luis, and Chad are alive! Julian orders Rebecca to give the envelope back to Theresa, but she refuses. Whitney then grabs the envelope from Rebecca, and Rebecca says "how rude!" Whitney then lays into Rebecca and Gwen. She tells them to both shut the hell up, because she's sick of the "rich bitches" constantly dogging Theresa, and she's sick of them thinking because they have money they can treat everyone else like third world citizens. She tells them that is she sees either of them giving Theresa a hard time again, she will make them ride out this hurricane tied to a tree! Rebecca and Gwen are shocked, and she can't believe Julian just stood there. Julian goes to get them some drinks to calm their nerves. Rebecca wonders what is up with Julian? Gwen says that he probably found some bimbo and her showing up ruined his plans to have fun. Rebecca thinks Gwen is probably right, and she doesn't care if Julian fools around, as long as she gets the Crane name and power. Rebecca sees the Justice of the Peace, and decides to question him about what is going on. Gwen thinks the Justice has some kind of confidentiality oath he can't break, but Rebecca says she has two fabulous oath breaking weapons at her disposal. Meanwhile, Theresa thanks Whitney for what she said to Rebecca and Gwen. Suddenly, a man from the army announces that they have just found out that the rescue boat has gone down, and nobody has survived! Theresa and Whitney can't believe that they are gone.
Out at sea, Ethan and Chad believe that Luis is dead. However the soon discovers the body belongs to Basil, he is the one who is dead. Ethan and Chad spot Luis in the distance, and swim to him. Luis is alive, but is still mumbling about Sheridan. Suddenly, a huge wave hits, separating them. Chad looks for Ethan and Luis when yet another huge wave hits! This time, nobody is left floating in the water!
On the island, Tabitha's spell fails and the storm dies down, so Timmy encourages her to try again. Tabitha casts another spell, but it doesn't work. Timmy says they have to escape so he can save his true love, Charity. Tabitha says if the warlocks have Charity, she is toast! Timmy refuses to believe that and looks for another way out. Suddenly, the scepter begins to glow! Timmy notices the glowing scepter, and he and Tabitha stare at it.
Meanwhile, Reese believes the mountain is actually a secret cave which opened and closed behind Charity. Jessica doubts that because it is solid rock, but Miguel wonders how else Charity's shirt got stuck in it. Miguel asks Norma to borrow her axe, and basically grabs it from her. Miguel uses the axe to try and pry open the rocks. As he works, Simone tells Kay to look at Miguel trying to get to Charity, that is real love. Kay says she loves him, but Simone says Miguel loves Charity! Kay says Charity will be gone soon, and only she will be left. Kay knows she and Miguel will be together soon.
In the cave, a floating Charity agrees to help the warlocks, if they agree to help her warn Sheridan, Luis, and Theresa about the danger they face. The warlocks show her images of them and tell her that it is too late for them, they are all doomed! The warlocks promise to save her and her friends on the island from their death, but only if she helps them. Charity agrees, and she floats back down to the ground. Charity asks what she has to do? The warlocks as Charity to use her powers to destroy the witch who trapped them on this island centuries ago. Charity asks them what witch? The warlocks show her what happened, and Charity is shocked to see Tabitha is the witch!