On Warlock Island, Norma catches Tabitha in the net, and tells her that she's going to dig a grave for her and cut her up into pieces. Timmy feels bad for his princess, but Norma says there will be room for him in there too! After Norma leaves to dig the grave, Timmy frees Tabitha from the net by simply untying the rope, causing Tabitha to fall to the ground. Tabitha and Timmy run off, infuriating Norma when she returns and finds they have escaped again.
Meanwhile, Kay foils any rescue attempts the kids have in mind by dousing the signal fires with water so they won't light. As she does this, Charity has more visions. Charity tells the other kids that they aren't going to be leaving this island anytime soon, because no matter what they do, the signal fires aren't going to start. She then sees them all dead, they are skeletons. She screams they are doomed! Charity continue to have more premonitions, and says it is too late for Theresa now, and there is a countdown to Sheridan and Luis' death! Simone tells Kay if they all end up trapped on this island, it will be her fault! Elsewhere, Tabitha runs into Jessica, and is horrified that Jessica has met up and befriended Norma!
In Bermuda, Ethan asks Theresa why she is wearing a wedding ring? Theresa panics, but Ethan assumes it is just to discourage other guys from hitting on her, and he thinks she is very smart. Whitney begins to think something is going on, as she sees a dress and shoes shoved under Luis and Sheridan's bed. Suddenly, Bruce shows up to surprise the newlyweds. Ethan asks him what he is talking about? Julian introduces Bruce to Ethan and his fiancee, Theresa, and he explains that Rebecca was supposed to come down here and marry him right after divorcing Ivy, but that didn't happen. Ethan is relieved and says for a minute it sounded like Julian and Theresa were married. Julian pulls Bruce aside and scolds him for actually allowing him to marry Theresa, and he says he needs to divorce her as quickly and quietly as possible. Meanwhile, Theresa pulls Whitney aside and tells her that she has a huge secret she has to tell her!
On the boat, Luis and Sheridan decide to return to port and call it a day. Luis has to dive down to unhook the anchor, because it has somehow gotten stuck. Sheridan decides to go down below deck and make some coffee. As she is doing that, she comes across the bomb. It takes her awhile to figure out it is dynamite. When she does she screams for Luis. Luis hears her screaming, but it is too late. The show ends with the boat exploding!
Julian finds Bruce out in the hall and yells at him. Julian tells Bruce that he should have stopped him from marrying that girl last night! Bruce things the entire situation is hilarious. Julian tells Bruce to shut up and help him figure out what to do. Bruce says his mind is a blank, he thinks Julian's goose is cooked!
On Warlock Island, Reese prepares to light the fire, and asks Jessica to gather up some more kindling. As Reese is about to light the fire, Charity has a premonition of all of their bones lying on the beach. She says that they are all doomed, they will never get off this island! Simone tells Kay that if Charity's premonition comes true it is all her fault! Meanwhile, Tabitha runs into Jessica, and is shocked to learn Jessica has made friends with Norma. Norma sees Timmy in doll form and says he looks dead. Jessica says that is just Timmy, Tabitha's doll. Norma helps Jessica with her wood, and she tells Tabitha not to run off because she'll be back! Tabitha tells Timmy that they've had it, this time they are dead meat! Tabitha suggests they cling to Jessica, because Norma can't kill them if there is a witness. Unfortunately, Jessica leaves Tabitha with Norma while she gathers some more wood! Fortunately for Tabitha, Jessica returns before Norma can axe her. Jessica asks Norma for help tying up some wood, and Tabitha and Timmy try and figure out what to do. Timmy thinks they should hide in the woods, but Tabitha says if they do that the warlocks are sure to get them. Back at the beach, Miguel tells Charity everything will be fine, a passing boat will see their fire and pick them up. Simone tells Kay that she is horrible and despicable for doing this to Charity, for wanting Charity to die so she can have Miguel. Kay says all she wants is her chance with Miguel, and whatever happens to Charity happens. Simone tells Kay she is being selfish, and putting them all in danger by being selfish, so if anything happens to any of them it will be on her conscious. Kay tells Simone to preach to someone who cares. Simone tells Kay that the only way she'll spend eternity with Miguel is if Charity's premonition comes true and they all die. Meanwhile, a boat comes close to the island, so Reese decides to light the fire. However, the waterlogged wood won't light, and they don't understand why the wood isn't lighting. Reese notices that all the wood is wet! Miguel asks how that happened? Kay says that the weight of the wood probably caused the sea water under the sand to come to the surface, thereby soaking the wood. Reese says that can't be it. Suddenly, Charity sees an explosion, and says Sheridan and Luis are gone! The kids decide to head back to camp to warm Charity up, because she is freezing. Kay is thrilled, but Simone is furious with Kay. Simone is worried about Charity's premonitions, but Kay says she is probably worried about nothing, and besides she already said it was too late to help Theresa. The kids return to camp, and once Jessica learns about the wood incident, she begins to suspect Kay is up to no good again. Reese lights a fire, and Charity continues to have visions of the explosion on Sheridan and Luis' boat, and all of them dead on the beach. Charity breaks down, and Miguel does his best to comfort her. Meanwhile, Norma chases Tabitha through the woods.
Out on the high sea, Sheridan finds the bomb on the boat and screams for Luis. Luis hears her screaming, but is unable to get to her in time. The boat explodes into a million pieces! Basil and June watch the explosion, and Basil says nobody will swim away from this explosion. Basil thinks this is his greatest triumph ever, but June is disgusted by it. Back in the water, pieces of the flaming boat drift around. The show ends with a shot of Luis' body floating in the water!
In Bermuda, Julian tells Whitney that they have to get to the wedding chapel and stop the wedding before the Justice of the Peace exposes the truth. Whitney thinks Theresa should be the one to tell Ethan the truth. At the chapel, Ethan and Chad talks with the Justice of the Peace. The JotP (Justice of the Peace) tells Ethan that the way he talks about his fiancee makes him feel they will be together forever, not like the old leech and young girl he married last night. He says that couple won't last a week, and that young girl was by no means respectable. Outside the chapel, Theresa decides to go in and be honest with Ethan about everything. Julian and Whitney arrive a the chapel, walk in, and Julian exclaims "Dear God!" Ethan asks Julian what is going on? Julian says he lost track of time and thought he might have missed the ceremony. Ethan says Theresa isn't here yet, and Julian says good they have time to talk. Julian, Ethan, and Chad engage in chit chat. Ethan tells Julian about the odd couple who were married last night, which jogs Julian's memory a bit. Julian defends the "leech" which Ethan finds odd. Ethan thinks Julian knew about the wedding, that he knew who this guy was! Ethan thinks the guy was one of his old friends, and Bruce came by to celebrate with him! Ethan is disgusted and says they have nothing in common. Julian says he'll go find THeresa, and he leaves. Meanwhile, Whitney finds Theresa sitting in a chair and looking sick. She asks her if she is okay? Theresa says she was about to go in to see Ethan, and she suddenly got woozy. Theresa says she doesn't know if it is a hangover, or nerves, or what. Theresa asks why Julian flew into the chapel? Whitney says Julian learned there is only one JotP, so he'll be able to reveal her secret. Theresa wonders what she will do now? Whitney tells Theresa that she has to tell Ethan, because if he finds out from someone else, she'll lose him forever! Julian shows up, and he tells Theresa that they have to come up with an excuse to stall the wedding until he can get an annulment. Whitney tells Theresa not to listen to Julian Crane and just be honest with Ethan. Julian says that will do wonders for their relationship, NOT! Theresa thinks Julian is right, she not only married Julian, she had sex with him.. Theresa tells Whitney that she is right, but she can't bring herself to tell Ethan the truth. Suddenly, Ethan shows up and says "tell me what?" Theresa tries to speak, but Julian says Theresa is to nervous to say. Julian says she wants to wait until they get back to Harmony to get married. Ethan asks if that is true? Theresa says no, she doesn't want to wait, so Ethan grabs her and drags her into the chapel. Once in there, Theresa tells Ethan that she has to tell him something first. Theresa tells him that she's changed her mind, they can't get married here and now. Ethan tells her if she is nervous it is normal, and once they are married she will be fine. Ethan thinks they should become husband and wife right here. Theresa says she wants that, just not right now. Ethan asks Theresa what it is she isn't telling him? Theresa asks him to go with her somewhere to talk, but Ethan refuses and says he wants to marry her now. Whitney tells Ethan that maybe they should wait, and Julian agrees. Suddenly, the JotP returns and exclaims "Good Lord, you two!"
On Warlock Island, Charity says Theresa's life has been destroyed, and Sheridan and Luis have lost so much. Miguel and Reese tell her that they'll build another fire and signal the next ship that goes by. MEanwhile, Simone tells Kay that she is so selfish, but Kay says she is only doing what she needs to in order to get Miguel. Kay says whatever happens to Charity is not her fault, but Simone says it is for interfering with the fire. If anything happens to Charity, Simone says it will be on Kay's head. Jessica and Norma gather some more wood to make a bigger fire to warm up Charity. Norma tells Tabitha and Timmy not to run off. Miguel continues to comfort Charity, who ends up fainting! Kay asks what is wrong? Miguel says he thinks Charity is dead! Reese checks her out and says she's not dead, she's just in a trance. Reese thinks her mind is protecting her from going on premonition overload by putting her into a trance. Kay thinks this trance is what will kill Charity! Simone can't believe what she is hearing. However, Tabitha tells Timmy that it was the Warlocks who put her in the trance. Timmy asks why they'd do that? Tabitha says she doesn't know, but it can't be good. Simone, who was a candystiper, checks Charity out. Simone says her pulse is steady, but she is cold. Miguel says they need to build a bigger fire. Norma suggests Tabitha help her carry some of the wood she's chopped down. Tabitha says she might not be much help because she's so old, so Jessica volunteers to help. Miguel continues to dote over Charity, which upsets Kay. Kay says Miguel needs to be with her, not some needy girl who always has weird premonitions. Simone scolds Kay for being bad and trying to split up Miguel and Charity. Kay then comes up with a way to break up Miguel and Charity, and Charity may not even have to die. Out in the woods, Jessica talks to Tabitha about Charity's premonitions, and she thinks Charity might actually be able to see into the future. Jessica asks Tabitha if she thinks Charity can? Tabitha says it wouldn't surprise her if she could. Meanwhile, Norma asks her father for help in getting Timmy and Tabitha alone. Norma's father tells her to use Timmy to lure Tabitha to her death by separating them. Norma tells Tabitha it would be more helpful if she put her doll down and carried some wood. Jessica agrees, so Tabitha puts Timmy down. Timmy decides to help gather wood as well. As he wanders off, Norma follows him. Tabitha and Jessica gather the wood, and when it is time to head back to camp, the find Norma and Timmy have vanished! Back at camp, Kay tries to convince Miguel to collect wood with her for the fire, but Miguel refuses to leave Charity. When Simone and Reese leave to find a place where the woods don't interfere with Reese's computer signal, Kay puts her plan into action. She begins crying to get Miguel to leave Charity and see what is wrong. Kay tells Miguel that she is so scared, what if they never make it off the island. Miguel says they will, and puts his arm around her. Kay says she can't stop thinking about Reese's story, but Miguel tells her that it is only a legend, Charity will not die, they will all be fine. Meanwhile, the warlocks call out to Charity from the fire. Charity wakes up and sees the ugly, burnt warlocks in the fire. They tell her that they have so much to tell her, but she must do exactly what they tell her! The warlocks call to Charity and tell her to come to her. They tell her that they can help her save Theresa, Sheridan, and Luis! Charity begins slowly walking towards the fire.
Grace talks with Eve about David and Sam. Eve is worried about Grace and Sam. Grace wishes there was something she could do, but she can't remember if she was married to David or not. Grace says that David was about to leave, but she asked him to stay because she needs to know if he is her husband, she can't spend the rest of her life wondering. Grace says if she was married to David, then she must have loved him. Grace says David must have loved her too, he never remarried. Eve says that is what David says. Grace says David dropped everything and came to Harmony to find her, so in order for him to do that, they must have shared a very strong love. Eve says that perhaps David is just guessing, or found this stuff on the internet like Sam said. Grace tells Eve to get real, she could be married to David, and she can't go on with her life without knowing if David is telling the truth.
At the B&B, David turns down a job offer with a magazine because he is going to be in Harmony a little while longer. Later, Hank, Grace, and Sam confront David. Sam tells David that he has contacted Saint Anistasia's and they do have a record of their marriage, but he doesn't believe it. Sam knows David was never married to Grace, so he contacted the priest at Saint Anistasia's who was in charge of the weddings. Sam says the priest happens to be in town, and he has arranged for a meeting. David says this is ridiculous, and Sam tells David that he sounds worried. Sam is positive that Father Mike won't recognize the two of them, and then he'll deal with him!
Everyone goes to the church, and Sam explains why he wanted to meet with him. Sam introduces Mike to Grace and David, and asks if he remembers marrying them? Mike says he doesn't recognize either one of them. Sam tells Grace that he told him it was a lie. Grace smiles, and David looks upset.
Out at sea, the boat carrying Luis nears the dock. Luis is out cold, and the captain tells his first mate that Luis needs to face the fact that Sheridan is dead. The first mate isn't sure how much longer Luis can last, and when he learns Sheridan is dead, he may give up on living.
In Bermuda at the chapel, the Justice of the Peace shows up and exclaims "Good Lord, you two!" The Justice remembers marrying a very drunk Theresa and Julian the night before. The JotP tells them that he knows them from last night. Ethan asks what he means? Julian claims that the Justice stopped by his table last night when Theresa was there. Ethan says he thought he said he didn't know Theresa was here? Julian says he just meant he didn't know she was here at first, and the Justice just saw them, and they are old chums. Julian says before they begin they begin, he wants to go over some things with the justice. Julian takes the Justice aside and tells him to keep his mouth shut and act like there was no wedding here last night. Julian says he is Julian Crane, and he can have this chapel closed, so as far as he is concerned there was no wedding last night, so he will marry Ethan and Theresa now. Julian says he will take care of the mistake made last night, and he is to go ahead and marry Ethan and Theresa. The Justice says he understands completely. Julian says the ceremony can begin, and Ethan tells Julian that even though he isn't his father, he's glad he's here. Whitney begs Theresa to tell Ethan the truth, but Theresa says she can't because Ethan will never want to be with her again. Whitney thinks they can work this out, but Theresa doubts this can be worked through. Whitney says if she doesn't tell Ethan, and she marries him, she will be a bigamist! Theresa says no, Julian will use the Crane power to erase the marriage, but Whitney says she is just fooling herself. Ethan says it is time for them to marry, the Justice wants to marry them before the storm rolls in. As the wedding is about to start, Theresa begins shaking. Ethan wonders why, she wasn't this nervous back in Harmony. Theresa says it is just happening so fast. Julian gives the Justice a look, so the Justice starts the ceremony. As he speaks, Theresa hears Julian and Whitney's voices in her head yelling at her to tell the truth and to stay quiet. Theresa yells "stop!" and she tells Ethan that she can't go through with this. Julian says "uh-oh!" Ethan asks Theresa what is wrong? Theresa begins to tell Ethan the truth when people begin to scream for help outside of the chapel. They go to investigate, and learn a boat blew up at sea and a man needs medical attention. Julian tells himself that he almost forgot about the boat. Theresa fears it is Luis and Sheridan, but Ethan says there is no way it could be them. However, Luis is brought by on a stretcher, and Ethan asks what happened to the woman? They says that she is gone, there is no way she could have survived.
Out on Warlock Island, Norma and Timmy disappear, which worries Tabitha. Out in the woods, Norma follows Timmy. Tabitha becomes worried and runs off searching for Tabitha. Tabitha finds Timmy, before Norma can kill him, and they head back to camp. Back at camp, Kay pretends like she's very worried that Charity and the rest of them might die. Miguel falls for her act and comforts her. He tells her that nothing bad will happen to CHarity or the rest of them, they will all be fine. Meanwhile, the warlocks call out to Charity and tell her that they can help her save Theresa, Sheridan, and Luis if she comes closer. Charity, in a trance, begins walking towards the fire. Simone returns and screams "Charity no!" Miguel runs to Charity, and all the other kids follow. Simone says Charity was about to walk into the fire! Reese says she is in some sort of a trance. Charity comes too, and she tells Miguel they want her to join him, they want to tell her secrets. Miguel asks who? Charity points to the warlocks and says they are right there, can't he see them. The kids can't see the warlocks, and Charity swears they were there. Miguel tells her to take it easy. Tabitha returns with Timmy and learns Charity was having visions of things in the fire. Tabitha says warlocks, which Reese overhears. Charity wishes they would come back because she wants to go to them and hear what they have to say, but Miguel says she needs to stay with him. JEssica becomes upset and says this is really starting to freak her out. Jessica is afraid the evil is returning. Miguel tells the gang not to panic, they have to stay focused. Miguel thinks they need to get Charity home now. Miguel suggests they all spread out and cover the island to try and find out if someone else is on the island that can help them. Miguel says someone will have to stay with Charity, so Kay offers. However, Simone suggests Reese stay so he can work on his computer. Reese stays, and Kay thanks Simone for being such a pal. Simone tells Kay she won't let her put Charity in danger. Kay says nobody can stop her, she will find a way. The kids split up and begin searching the island. Kay has no plans to search, and runs off to do something better. Kay returns to camp in "tears" and manages to get Reese to leave Charity's side. Kay asks Reese to hold her, and he does. The warlocks once again begin calling to CHarity, and she follows their voices. Kay watches Charity walk off as she continues to distract Reese. Meanwhile, Norma works on a new plan. She digs a hole in the ground, and tells her father that Tabitha and Timmy are goners this time! Later, Norma grabs Timmy, and runs off with him!