In Bermuda, Sheridan and Luis lounge in front of the campfire on the beach. Sheridan says this is perfect, and suggests they come back her for their official honeymoon. Sheridan just hopes Ethan and Theresa can work things out. Luis suggests they not worry about them while they are down here, and they make love under the stars. In Bermuda, after making love, Sheridan hears something come from the fire, which has begun to rise higher. Luis asks her what is wrong? Sheridan feels like something terrible is going to happen. Luis tells her that nothing will happen, they are miles away from her brother and father. Sheridan guesses she just isn't used to being happy and peaceful, and not having to worry. Luis tells her that nobody will ever tear them apart again, she is stuck with him for life.
Back in the hotel, Julian tells Theresa that this is an amazing coincidence running into her here. Julian begins fantasizing about Theresa once again. Julian asks her what brings him to the islands? Theresa says him, he is the only one who can give her what she wants! Julian is excited that she followed him down to Bermuda, and is getting the wrong idea. Julian and Theresa go back into the bar, and Julian brags to his friends that Theresa came down here to be with him! Theresa sits down at the table, and fantasizes about marrying a grateful Ethan Crane. Meanwhile, Julian's friends tell him that Theresa could have any man she wanted, so why would she want him? They bet him a box of cigars he can't get Theresa into bed, and Julian accepts the bet. Julian goes over to the table where Theresa is. Theresa tells Julian that they don't have to have dinner, what she wants won't take that long. Julian tells her to leave that to him! Julian orders some champagne to relax Theresa's nerves. Theresa drinks some, and Julian promises to make her very happy tonight. Theresa finally tells Julian that she's hear to ask him to take Ethan back. Julian spits his wine out, and can't believe that is why she came all the way down here. Theresa tells Julian that she loves Ethan so much, and she want him to get back what he lost. SHe tells Julian that he must still love Ethan as a son, and asks if he doesn't miss him. Julian's gets a call, and has to take it. Alistair is on the phone and asks him if he is behaving? Julian says he is. AListair says good, because Sheridan must die tomorrow when the boat carrying her and Luis explodes! Julian then talks to his friends, and says the bet is still on, he will bed Theresa. Julian returns to Theresa and says that her request is a tall order, but he may be able to be convinced to do it. Julian then continues to plaster Theresa with booze!
Sam and Ivy go to the park to clear their heads, and run into one another in the park. Ivy thinks that Theresa the two-faced scheming tramp is what is bothering Sam. Sam says he's know Theresa for her entire life, and he doesn't believe she would do that. He says there is a difference between keeping a secret and wanting to hurt someone. Ivy refuses to argue about Theresa, she wants to talk about Ethan. Ivy wants Ethan to know he has two parents who love him, and she asks Sam to talk to Ethan, let him know he has a loving father and mother. Sam agrees to call Ethan and see if he's free for dinner. Ivy says she'd like to go too, and assures this is not about them, it is about putting a untied front up for Ethan. Ivy assures Sam she knows that he and Grace have a rock solid marriage that nobody and nothing can tear apart. When the clock chimes midnight, Ivy realizes she is a divorced woman, and she has no idea who she is anymore. Ivy says she didn't love being Mrs. Julian Crane, but she doesn't know who else to be. Ivy says she has to go home and pack. Sam asks her where she is going? Ivy says she has no idea, but she'll find someplace. She says she's only worried about Ethan right now. Sam tries to hold Ivy, but she pulls away and tells him no. She says the last thing she needs to be reminded of now is that she lost him to. Sam knows what it feels like to lose the love of your life, and tells her about the David situation.
In Bermuda, Julian's friends are shocked that Theresa is still with Julian. At their table, Julian continues to plaster Theresa with champagne. Theresa says she needs to keep a clear head, and refuses anymore champagne. She continues to talk to Julian about the Ethan dilemma, and Julian acts like he's interested in her proposal. Suddenly, Alistair calls for Julian. Alistair wants to make sure everything is set for their plan tomorrow. Julian assures his father that Sheridan will die in the boating explosion. Alistair says he always thought Sheridan was the weakest link of his children, and he'd hate to have to say goodbye to Julian as well! Julian assures his father that Sheridan will be dead in a few hours. Julian returns to Theresa, and assures her that they can come to a mutually satisfying conclusion to their evening. Julian gives Theresa more champagne, and she begins to get drunk. Theresa continues to argue a case for taking Ethan back, including his great work at Crane Industry. Julian says aside from his conscious, Ethan was a great asset, and could negotiate like no one else. Meanwhile, Julian's friends continue to rag about Julian and Theresa, and how she is probably jail bait. Back at their table, when the waiter suspects Theresa is with Julian, she becomes nervous. She says she'd hate for the gossip columns to make the wrong mistake about them, but Julian says nobody cares what goes on here, so let people talk. Theresa tells Julian she would never ask him to take Ethan back if it wasn't something he wanted, and she saw the pain in his face the night the truth came out. Julian realizes Theresa really does love Ethan, and wishes he had married for love. The midnight clock chimes, and Julian realizes he is officially divorced from Ivy. Julian is thrilled, and his friends across the bar scream for joy. Julian proposes another toast, but Theresa says she's had way to much already. Julian tells her that one more won't hurt, so she drinks it down! He then suggests they continue discussing Ethan up in his room. Theresa, who is too drunk to know better, goes up to Julian's room with him!
On the beach, Sheridan gets spooked by the fire, and fears they are in danger. Luis also begins to worry, only about Theresa. However, Sheridan says Ethan and Theresa love one another, she's sure they have worked things out. Luis and Sheridan eventually agree to talk about more pleasurable things, and decide to go back to their room after picking up some champagne at the bar. Luis and Sheridan head to the bar, and overhear Julian's friends talking about Theresa, but they don't recall her name, so they refer to her as jail bait for awhile. Luis and Sheridan are disgusted by their talk. One of the guys asks if they remember her real name? One guy thinks he knows, but he can't recall. Sheridan and Luis order a bottle of champagne, and wait across the room for their bottle. Their bottle is delivered, and as they are heading back to their room, Luis swears he hears Theresa. Sheridan says he must be hearing things, and they go back to their rooms. Luis and Sheridan hang out on the balcony of their room, and Sheridan has no worries because true love conquers all.
On the island, Charity tells Miguel that Theresa took a sip, and now she will regret it for the rest of her life! Miguel tells Charity that she is scaring him. Charity apologizes, and Reese says first thing in the morning they'll take the boat back to Harmony. Charity then sees the fire again, an out of control fire. Suddenly, Charity says Sheridan is in terrible danger, they have to warn her! Then the kids see a light from the woods, and Reese claims it is the Warlock's fires. Meanwhile, Simone tries to talk Kay out of her insane scheme. Kay says she is doing nothing wrong, and enters Miguel's tent. Kay gets nearly naked and gets into Miguel's sleeping bag. Suddenly, a loud banging sound can be heard. Kay and Simone realize there is a bright light coming from outside, and it's getting brighter. Suddenly, the kids wonder where Kay and Simone are? Charity hopes her premonitions aren't about Kay and Simone, so the kids decide to search the tents for them. Simone tells Kay that she is about to get caught half naked in Miguel's sleeping bag!
On the boat, Tabitha and Timmy get ready to leave, unaware Norma is behind door planning on killing them! Unfortunately, Tabitha moves out of the way right as Norma swings her axe. Timmy has found some liquor, and decides to make them some MarTimmies, and Tabitha comes across some Dean Martin records. Norma promises her father that Tabitha and Timmy won't escape the boat alive, and confronts Tabitha when Tabitha refers to Norma as a psycho battle axe! Tabitha and Timmy lock the door to the cabin they are in, and Norma grabs a tank of gasoline and says she will burn them to a crisp! As Tabitha and Timmy scream for help, Norma covers the boat in gasoline. SHe then lights a match, and sets the boat on fire!
Grace and Sam meet up at Tabitha's house, and Sam promises Grace that David is pulling a sick joke or an elaborate hoax, and he will prove it. Sam says he will get to work on it first thing in the morning. Grace tells Sam that she doesn't think he should stay here tonight if they aren't married. Sam says he is her husband, not David. Grace asks Sam to stay with her tonight and tell her everything will be all right (Hey, that rhymes!). Meanwhile, Pilar finds Ivy and tries to tell her about Sam and Grace, but Ivy already knows about Sam and Grace. She says "Isn't it unbelievable?"
On the island, Simone tells Kay they have to leave, but Kay refuses to run away. She says she will make love to Miguel, she will get pregnant, and they will be together forever! Meanwhile, as the kids look for Kay and Simone, Charity has another premonition and says the fire is here! Charity and the others begin to search even harder for Kay and Simone. Simone runs out, and tries to distract them from finding Kay in Miguel's tent. Reese spots the fire down at the docks, and the kids run towards it.
Norma sets the boat on fire, with Tabitha and Timmy inside! Norma shows her father what she has done, and he is proud of her. Things begin to heat up in the boat, and Tabitha says they'll be roasted before the flames even reach them! Timmy finds a little doggy door, but realizes Tabitha can't fit through it. Tabitha tells Timmy to escape and flee to safety. Timmy refuses to leave Tabitha, and says she gave him life, so his will end with hers.
The kids show up, and Norma runs. They see Tabitha peering out of a porthole on the boat. Reese says he doesn't know why Tabitha is on that boat, but this fire is too out of control to be put out. Reese says Tabitha is trapped, and she's going to die.
Ethan goes to the Book Cafe and meets up with Chad and Whitney. Ethan still can't reach Theresa. Both Whitney and CHad know where Theresa is and what she is up to, but they don't tell him. Chad tells Whitney that she has to tell Ethan the truth, but Whitney says she promised Theresa she wouldn't. Chad tells her to look at Ethan, look how worried he is! Ethan continues to worry about Theresa, and hopes she isn't in trouble. Whitney and Chad discuss Theresa in Bermuda, and Chad tells Whitney that Julian will take advantage of Theresa, so she better tell Ethan. Whitney says she promised, but Chad says a promise doesn't count when a friend is in trouble. Ethan overhears their conversation, and asks Whitney if she has heard from Theresa? Whitney eventually confesses everything to Ethan. Ethan worries about what happened last time, and says there is no telling what Julian will try and do to her. Ethan calls the hotel, but the hotel refuses to put him through to Theresa's room so late at night. Ethan wonders where she could be. Ethan tries to get a trip to Bermuda immediately, but he can't get one until the morning. Ethan says he'll pay for the ticket when he gets to the airport, and tells Chad and Whitney he really misses being a Crane. Whitney tells Chad that she hopes Theresa isn't getting herself into a situation she can't get out of.
In Bermuda, Julian helps a stumbling Theresa to his room. When he says he has more bubbly in his room, Theresa says she is only going to his room to discuss Ethan. Julian says they can talk all night long in his room if she wants. Theresa says that is exactly what she wants. Before they get into the elevator, Alistair calls Julian again to congratulate him. He says that he's learned that his plan to kill Sheridan is actually set, and he's taken care of everything this time. Julian says he has, though he takes no pleasure in it. Julian says Sheridan will die, and perhaps Luis as well. Julian visits his friend one last time to tell them that he and Theresa are heading up to his room now, and it is time to close the deal so to speak. Julian picks up some more champagne at the bar, gives some to Theresa, and takes her to his room. Julian shows Theresa the view, and then he puts a do not disturb sing on the door! As Julian is about to make his move, Julian's idiot friends show up with some cigars and champagne for him per their bet. Julian tells them to get lost! Theresa asks who that was? Julian says it was room service bringing them some champagne. Theresa says no, she's had too much already. Julian says if she doesn't have another glass, he won't adopt Ethan. A completely drunk Theresa agrees to have another glass of champagne. As Theresa grows ever more drunk, Julian gets wicked ideas in his head.
Sheridan and Luis continue to revel in their happiness, and later enjoy a sexy shower together. After their shower, Luis puts on some music, and finds some tango music. The two then tango in their room.
In Bermuda, Basil and June work on the bomb to plant on Luis and SHeridan's boat. Later, they check the boat out.
Julian tells Theresa that he thinks they can come to an arrangement regarding Ethan. Drunk Theresa says she'll do whatever it takes to convince him, slurring her words as she says so. The two sit on the bed, and Julian says he's almost convinced adopting Ethan is the right thing to do. Drunk Theresa says it is so so so the right thing to do, and she always gets what she wants! Theresa continues to try and talk to Julian about Ethan, and she spills her champagne. As she is cleaning it up, finds a brochure for a 24 hour wedding chapel. She thinks this is a sign, if he adopts Ethan, he can fly down her, they can be married, and they can have their honeymoon! Theresa starts spinning around with joy, and accidentally knocks over a lamp. Julian tells her not to worry, and suggests they go out to the balcony with their champagne. Before they can reach the Balcony, Basil and June show up to talk to Julian about the bomb. Julian says he doesn't want anyone to overhear the conversation. He gives them some money, and tells them to just go! They leave, and Julian and Theresa go out to the balcony where Julian continues to give Theresa champagne. Julian attempts to kiss Theresa, but she moves her head and wonders what the chapel looks like? Theresa then knocks over a plant, and then trips and falls down. Julian just happens to fall down next to her, on purpose of course! Julian and Theresa crawl back into the room, and Theresa begins to cry because she misses Ethan. Julian puts his arm around her and tells her not to cry. Julian says she's almost convinced him to adopt Ethan, which makes Theresa very happy. Theresa decides to go to the bathroom to freshen up, and Julian decides to order some more champagne.
Luis and SHeridan finish their tango, and Sheridan tells him that this whole night has been wonderful. Luis tells her that tomorrow will be wonderful. Luis and Sheridan hear the "party" going on next door, which is Julian and Theresa, and Luis continues to worry about Theresa. They go out to their balcony, and Luis can't stop thinking about those guys downstairs talking about that young girl, and it makes him think of Theresa and Julian for some reason. Luis says if he ever caught Julian making a pass at Theresa, he'd kill him! When Luis and Sheridan hear more commotion from the room next door, they go back inside, missing seeing Julian and Theresa on the balcony next to them. When Theresa knocks over the plant outside, Luis becomes fed up and decides to go out and tell them to keep it down. Unfortunately, they are on the ground when Luis comes out to see them. Sheridan comes out after Luis and convinces him to go to their door and confront them, it would seem a lot less hostile. Luis agrees, and decides to get dressed.
Luis knocks on Julian's door, and Julian answers. The two come face to face, and are both shocked!
Out on Warlock Island, Kay continues to tell Simone that she will make love to Miguel and she will make him forget about Charity! Simone thinks they should check on the fire, and Kay decides they should, because if Charity saves a bunny from the fire, Miguel will love her even more. Kay says she has to do something nice before Charity does.
Tabitha and Timmy remain trapped on the boat. Miguel says Tabitha is trapped in there, and Jessica says she will die in there! Charity says this isn't right, this isn't what she saw in her vision! Jessica says this has to be what she saw, but Charity says her premonition was about Sheridan. On the boat, Tabitha and Timmy begin to run out of oxygen! Timmy begins screaming for help, and Reese hears him and exclaims "Tabitha's doll is alive!" When Reese starts talking about the doll, Jessica and Miguel tell Reese to stop this, Tabitha is in danger! Miguel decides to try and find a way to get on the boat and help Tabitha. Miguel kisses Charity and tells her that he loves her. Kay and Simone show up, and Kay tells Miguel that she won't let him try and get on that boat! Simone tells Kay to let him go, they can't let Tabitha die. Miguel says he'll be okay, kisses Charity once again, and goes to save Tabitha. A spying Norma wants to try and stop Miguel, but her father tells her that the fire will kill the witch and the boy. Miguel climbs onto the boot, and begins to swat the flames with his shirt in order to reach Tabitha.
At Tabitha's house, Sam continues to tell Grace that David is just a con-artist. As they are talking, Sam hears something outside. Sam decides to check it out, and Grace follows. Sam finds David lurking about in the bushes, and Sam accuses him of trying to kidnap Grace again. David says he wouldn't kidnap his own wife. Sam says she is his wife, and tells him to leave before he arrests him for trespassing! Grace begs Sam not to cause problems, and she asks David why he was hiding in the bushes if he came to see her? David says he was bringing her flowers, and was picking some greenery from the shrubs to add to the bouquet. Grace suggests they go inside and talk about this. Sam says there is nothing to talk about, but Grace says she thinks there is.
Out in the park, Ivy has new hope for a relationship between her and Sam. Ivy says Sam is a free man now, and she will wait for him to come back to her, and then they will start a new life together. Ivy says her divorce from Julian, and Sam's being free, is fate. Ivy says God works in mysterious ways, but Pilar says this is not God's doing, and he wouldn't approve. Ivy says she has got a second chance now, all she has to do is wait for Sam to be free! As they are walking throughout town, they spot Sam, Grace, and David. Ivy decides to find out what is going on, so she spies on them!
Back in Tabitha's, Sam continues to insist that David is a con-man. Grace tells David that she still doesn't remember, and she refuses to spend time with him because she doesn't know him. Grace tells David unless he can come up with something that makes her remember him, then he should just go. David says he does have a story, and he knows she'll know she is his wife once he tells her.
At the Book Cafe, Ethan can't find a way to get an earlier flight to Bermuda. Whitney worries that if Julian tries to seduce her, she won't know how to react. Whitney says Theresa always thinks she's doing the right thing, but her schemes end up blowing up in her face. Ethan continues to try and find ways to go to Bermuda tonight. Ethan hates that Theresa thinks she has to make amends to make things right between them.
At Tabitha's, Grace tells David that nothing he has told her so far has sparked any memory of him. David says what he is about to tell her will prove without a doubt that he is her husband. He says it will make her remember, and change her life forever. A spying Ivy listens closely as David is about to offer up his proof, thinking it will help her get Sam back. Pilar tells Ivy that she is being selfish, but Ivy says Grace is going to be reunited with her long lost husband. Back inside, Sam refuses to listen to whatever David has to say, and tells him to get out. David understands Sam is upset, but tells him to think about the hell he went through for twenty years not knowing what happened to Grace. Sam refuses to believe a word he is saying, and accuses him of being a con-artist. David asks what he would gain from coning them, they are homeless. He also asks why he would con a cop? David tells Sam and Grace what he has to say will prove that he and Grace were involved, intimately involved. David tells her that they went to Nantucket for their honeymoon, and they stayed in Sue and Steve's cottage. David says one night they took a walk on the beach, and she stepped on a shell which cut her right foot, leaving a moon-shaped scar. Sam says that Grace doesn't have a scar on her foot! David says he can show her the scar if she takes off her shoe. Ivy thinks this is the moment she has been waiting for, but Pilar says Grace doesn't have a scar on her foot, and David's lies have been exposed. Ivy says it isn't over until it's over. Sam decides to throw David out. David offers them a deal, if Grace checks for the scar, he'll walk out of their lives forever. Sam doesn't trust him to keep his word, so David tells Sam he can throw him in jail for being a con. Sam refuses, and David accuses Sam of being afraid. Sam tells Grace to take off her shoe, this will prove David is lying.
At the Book Cafe, Ethan is going crazy because he can't get a plane to Bermuda immediately. Chad tells Ethan to just try and relax, he'll be in Bermuda in the morning. Ethan says if their wedding had gone off as planned, he's be in Bermuda with Theresa on her honeymoon. They talk about what Theresa is up to in Bermuda, a recap for those who haven't been watching, and agree that Luis would tear apart anyone who tried to hurt his sister. Ethan knows from experience that anyone who tries to hurt Theresa will feel the wrath of Luis. Later, Ethan gets a vibe that something is wrong with Theresa, that she is in trouble. Ethan decides to leave and pack his things. Chad tells him if he can wait a few minutes till he finishes up, he and Whitney will walk him over. Ethan says okay.
In Bermuda, Theresa goes into the bathroom to freshen up and look her best. Julian decides to call for some more champagne, but first there is a knock at the door. Julian opens the door and is shocked to see Luis and Sheridan. Sheridan and Luis ask Julian what in the hell he is doing here? Luis also asks what is with all the noise, who is he in here with? In the bathroom, Theresa fixes herself up and tells herself she has to convince Julian to adopt Ethan. Theresa realizes her purse is in the other room, so she has to go get it. Back in the main room, Luis demands Julian tell them what is going on. He tells Julian if he doesn't start talking, he'll search the room! Fortunately for Julian, Theresa discovers the bathroom is stock piled with make-up, and she realizes she doesn't need her purse. Back in the other room, Julian tells Luis and Sheridan that he came her to finalize his divorce from Ivy. Luis asks her who is in the room with him, because he sees a woman's purse on the table. He asks if Rebecca is here with him? Sheridan asks if they are planning on getting married here? Julian says Rebecca isn't here with him. Sheridan tells Julian he is such an unfaithful pig. Luis tells Julian that he is disgusted by the thought of him having his way with a young woman, someone who could be his sister. Luis vows to kill Julian if he ever finds out he makes a move on his sister, or any other young woman back in Harmony for that matter. Julian says he understands. Luis also asks Julian to keep it down, he and Sheridan need rest for their trip tomorrow. Luis and Sheridan leave, and go to the dining room for desert. Luis and Sheridan eat their desert, and continue to hear Julian's sleazeball friends over at the bar. The guys talk about how Julian is a pro, and he's going to show that poor innocent girl the ways of the world. Luis refuses to Julian get away with this, and heads up to Julian's room. BAck in Julian's room, Theresa finally comes out of the bathroom. Julian tells Theresa they should pick up where they left off. Julian tells Theresa she seems very tense, and starts giving her a back massage. Julian and Theresa sit on the bed, and Theresa tells Julian that his massage feels so good. Julian says this is only the beginning. Outside, Luis bangs on Julian's door and demands he open up. Theresa hears her brother's voice, and heads for the door!
Basil and June continue to work on building the bomb to plant on Sheridan and Luis' boat.
On the island, Miguel fights the flames on the boat and tries to get to Miguel. Meanwhile, Charity tells them that this isn't what she saw, she was sure Sheridan and Theresa were the ones in danger. Back on the boat, Timmy and Tabitha come too, and hear Miguel screaming for them. Miguel reaches the door, but the flames rise higher, and the kids lose sight of him. Miguel is alive, and is still working to break down the door to the cabin where Tabitha and Timmy are. Miguel finally gets into the cabin, grabs Tabitha, and pulls her out. Unfortunately, Timmy is left behind! Miguel carries Tabitha to the beach, and the kids give her some water. Norma is furious that Tabitha survived, and she begins hacking up an old tree stump with her axe. Reese begins to question Tabitha about why she was on the boat, and about her doll, but the others tell Reese to back off. Tabitha realizes Timmy is still on the boat. Tabitha stands up and screams Timmy's name. Tabitha tries to go back for her doll, but Miguel tells her that he can't let her do that. Reese is positive that she wants Timmy because he is alive, but Jessica says she is just attached to the doll. Miguel holds Tabitha back and she continues to scream Timmy's name. Tabitha eventually breaks free, and runs back onto the boat, which pleases Norma.