At the cottage, Eve asks Sheridan who she sees under the bloody sheet? Sheridan says he used to come to the mansion all the time to talk to her father and brother, and she saw him all the time on the grounds. Eve asks Sheridan to tell her a name. Sheridan recalls lifting the bloody sheet away from the man's face, and she cries out "I killed Martin Fitzgerald!" Eve asks Sheridan if she is sure? Sheridan says she is positive, she saw his face, she killed him with a letter opener. Sheridan cries that Luis will never forgive her and will always hate her. Eve wants to go over this once again, slowly, and to tell her everything that she remembers. Sheridan remembers that after lifting the bloody sheet Alistair told her she didn't see anything, she was only having another nightmare. Sheridan remembered looking around the room, and realizing that the body was gone. When she asked her father what he did with the body, Alistair said it was never there and it was all in her mind. Eve says perhaps it was all a dream, but Sheridan doesn't know what to believe anymore. Eve asks her to remain calm, they will get to the truth. Silently, Eve fears the truth will cause more pain than any of them can imagine. They continue with the session, and Sheridan says the next day it was as if the events of the night before never happened, and then she was sent to Paris to see a parade of psychiatrists who told her what she saw wasn't real. Sheridan then realizes that everyone lied to her, she remembers! Sheridan says she knows it was real and not a dream because she got out of bed and hid when she heard voices. She says that she could see people downstairs carrying a coffin out of the house, the coffin was real and so was the body! Eve asks Sheridan why she thinks she killed him? SHeridan says she doesn't know, but all she knows she killed him. Eve wonders what this will do to Luis and Sheridan.
Meanwhile, Luis and Hank argue about Sheridan. Hank can't believe that Luis is talking about picking up with Sheridan where they left off after he has told him how he feels about her. Hank says he thinks he could have a serious relationship with Sheridan. Luis says that Sheridan isn't capable of having a serious relationship, just like him. Luis thinks that if Sheridan can remember something from her past she might realize she is worthy of a good man, and what she remembers might bring him and Sheridan closer together. However, Hank thinks that Sheridan will be ready for a relationship with him, not Luis. Luis just laughs, but says maybe Sheridan doesn't want anything to do with him (Luis). Luis says he's not going to predict the future, what is important is that Sheridan is happy. He also tells Hank that he will give it one more try with Sheridan, but Hank tells him that he'll have to get through him first. As Luis thinks about the happy times he had with Sheridan, Eve comes out to talk to Luis about what Sheridan said. Eve tells Luis and Hank that they better sit down, so they do.
Gwen tells Ethan that she can't wait to show him the Russell's African art collection. Ethan says he'd love to see it, but first there is something he needs to do first. Gwen leaves, and Ethan wonders if Chad is right that telling Theresa that he didn't love her was a mistake. Meanwhile, Whitney blames Chad for Theresa's heartbreak, and she says she's never seen Theresa like this and is worried Simone notices that CHad and Whitney are spending a lot of time together, and she wonders if Chad is more interested in Whitney than he is in her. Kay tells Simone that she's being ridiculous, she is the one he loves. Simone thinks she is being silly, and says now that she has Chad they need to make sure she gets Miguel. about what she is going to do. Elsewhere, Miguel can't find his bike, and decides to ask around and see if someone borrowed it. After he leaves, Charity turns evil and scolds Tabitha and Timmy for screwing up again. Tabtitha tells Charity that she didn't do anything, last time she checked the bike was in the driveway, and whoever took it is riding a death machine. Evil Charity says they have ruined their plans for Miguel, and now they will pay! Miguel returns, so Charity turns back to normal. Miguel has learned that Theresa took his bike, and he's sure she won't get very far on it. Tabitha says that she probably just ran down to the market. Miguel approaches Whitney and CHad and asks them if they knew where Theresa might have gone to on his motorcycle? They say no, so Miguel leaves them. Whitney says she doesn't like the idea of Theresa being on a motorcycle in her condition. Ethan overhears this and becomes worried. Whitney tells Ethan that he broke her heart, he got her hopes up by kissing her. Ethan says he felt terrible about that and that is why he had to tell her the truth tonight, he just wanted her to get on with her life. Ethan tells Chad that he wasn't honest with Theresa or himself, deep down he does love Theresa. Whitney tells them to stop it because they need to find Theresa. Ethan says he'll go find Theresa, and he asks Whitney and Chad to tell Gwen that he's gone to look for her. After Ethan leaves, Chad hopes Ethan realizes he does love Theresa before it is too late. Chad and Whitney stand there and argue about Ethan and Theresa, and Kay overhears Chad says that a person can only run from their feelings for so long before having to come to terms with what is in their heart. As they argue, Gwen shows up and says she knows exactly what is going on here, they have fallen in love! Whitney says they have not fallen in love, but Gwen says she can see all the signs, they have just done a good job keeping it hidden. Whitney says this is silly and leaves. Gwen asks Chad if he is in love with her or not? Gwen then realizes that Chad hasn't told Whitney yet, and she suggests he use his music to tell Whitney how he feels about her. Chad looks through his CDs and finds one, and Gwen wishes him luck. Chad puts on the CD, and looks at Whitney as he plays it. She looks back at him, and he approaches her and asks her if she likes this song? She says it is beautiful, and Chad says this is exactly how he feels about her. He tells her that Gwen was right, she is the one he loves, not Simone. The two then kiss, but it turns out to be one of Whitney's fantasy's. In order to keep them apart, Kay tells Whitney that she thinks the phone might be off the hook, so she should go check it. When Whitney leaves, Kay tells Chad that Whitney hates this song and thinks it is the saddest and sappiest song she's ever heard, which is why she left. Chad decides to change the song because he thinks that is what Whitney wants. Chad puts on Lit's "You Make Me Completely Miserable," and Gwen asks him why he changed the song? Chad says that Whitney thought the song was stupid, but Gwen doesn't believe that. Whitney returns and hears the new song, and she's not pleased. Kay thinks she is good, that is one romance which will never blossom. Simone overhears this and asks if she is talking about Whitney and Chad? Kay covers and says she was talking about Charity and Miguel.
Meanwhile, Evil Charity tells Tabitha that she should kill her and Timmy right now, but she tells them that she won't do anything to them now because too many people are around. Charity says that it won't be Miguel who dies tonight, but Theresa! Evil Charity says they will have to come up with another plan to kill Miguel. Evil Charity tells Tabitha that it was stupid of her to let the motorcycle out of her site for a moment. Meanwhile, Timmy has had enough of the Evil Charity, so he lunges at Charity and grabs the pendant from around her neck. Timmy exclaims "Timmy did it!" Miguel shows up and asks if that doll just talked? Tabitha says it must have been the voice box inside of him that he heard. Miguel says it sounded so real, and then he realizes she isn't wearing her pendant. Miguel wonders if she took it off, but she says no, and that she seems to be missing pieces of time lately. Miguel thinks it might be the strain of all those premonitions, but Tabitha thinks she is just over-tired. Miguel then notices that her pendant is in the doll's hand. Charity wonders how that happened. Tabitha tells Charity that she was holding Timmy while she looked through her handbag, and that it must have just fallen off. Miguel takes it and notices the chain is broken, and he says they can fix it later. Miguel goes to look for Theresa again, and Charity suddenly has a premonition that someone is going to die!
Theresa is unable to control Miguel's bike, and crashes into a car! She is thrown from the bike and lays by the side of the road unconscious. Some bystanders call the ambulance, and one hopes it gets here soon because Theresa doesn't look good. Ethan eventually shows up and is shocked to learn that Theresa has been taken to the hospital. The officer says that the girl didn't have any idea, so if Ethan knows her then he should head to the hospital and fill them in. As Ethan takes off, he overhears someone says it will be a miracle if that girl lives.
Theresa arrives at the hospital and the outlook doesn't look good. A nurse asks if she should reserve a room in ICU, but the doctor tells her to hold off and see if the girl even makes it through the night. Ethan shows up looking for Theresa, but they won't let him in unless he's a family member. Ethan doesn't care and runs into the room. In the room is a body under a sheet. Ethan says she can't be! The nurse says they did everything they could to save her.
At the Russell's, Miguel learns that Theresa took off on his motorcycle and wonders why. Chad says it is his fault, and Whitney explains Chad's latest brilliant plan. Miguel says he doesn't blame Chad, it is Theresa's fault for thinking Ethan loved her. Suddenly, Charity is overcome by a premonition that someone is one the verge of death. This scares them, especially when Miguel finds out that Theresa left the helmets behind. Whitney calls the emergency room and learns that Theresa is there, so they head over to the hospital.
At the hospital, Ethan's declaration of love saves Theresa's life. When she finally comes to, she asks where she is? Ethan explains that she is in the hospital. Theresa remembers him saying he loved her, and Ethan explains that the nurse felt it was the only thing that would save her. Theresa realizes Ethan doesn't love her, and she cries that he should have let her die. Theresa begins to grow weaker, and Ethan doesn't know what to do. The nurse tells Ethan that Theresa must sense he wasn't honest with her, and Ethan says he is in love with another woman. The nurse says he may think he loves this other woman, but if he is honest with himself he might find what he feels for Theresa is true love. As Theresa is at the brink of death, Ethan tells Theresa that he really does love her, and he kisses her. THeresa comes back, again, and looks into his eyes. She thinks he is lying to her again, but he swears he is not. As she fades back off, he yells at her that she can't die, he truly does love her! He grabs her and pulls her into a passionate kiss right as Miguel and Gwen walk into the cubicle!
In Sheridan's bedroom, Alistair tells Eve to go ahead and tell them everything because Sheridan and Luis have a right to know the truth. Eve is shocked and asks if he knows what Sheridan said? Alistair says he knows exactly what Sheridan told her. Eve can't believe he has known about this? Alistair says he has worked for many years to protect his daughter, but she has prevented him from doing so any longer, so the time has come to tell Luis that Sheridan killed his father. Eve still can't believe this and tells Alistair that this makes him an accessory to a capital crime! Alistair says "I suppose it does." She also tells him what will happen when the press gets wind of this story it will devastate his family. AListair says he knows and he has no other choice but to accept the consequences of his actions. Eve hopes he means that because the second they end this call she will go tell Luis and Sheridan everything! Eve says she has to go, but Alistair asks Eve to be gentle with his daughter because this will be tough on her. Eve is glad to know that his daughter's feelings matter to him because Julian is trying his best to keep the truth from coming out. She finds it admirable that he is willing to accept the consequences of his mistakes, and she wishes more people would do the same. Alistair asks her if she applies the same moral principle to her life? Eve says she tries to, and Alistair tells her that he knows it is hard to come to terms with the mistakes one has made in the past, especially mistakes like hers. He then begins to list off all the things Eve has done wrong, her illicit mistakes, her addictions, the baby she gave birth to. He tells her that her family will be destroyed just like his will be, but accepting the consequences is all a part of the game, isn't that right? Eve calls him a bastard, and he tells her that is rather salty language for someone sworn to uphold the Hypocritic, whoops, Hippocratic Oath. Eve tells him to go to hell! Alistair says that when she spoke about how it was a shame more people didn't take responsibility for their actions he thought she meant both of them. Eve tells Alistair that he is more twisted and horrible than people say he is, and she can't imagine how he could let his daughter suffer by keeping this from her. Alistair asks Eve how she justifies keeping the truth about herself a secret? Alistair tells Eve to just hang up the phone and go tell everyone the truth, but he will be forced to tell her family the truth about her, that she was little more than a common whore!
Eve goes out to see the gang, and Sheridan asks what she said? Eve says she needs a cup of coffee first, and as she gets it she tells Julian about her talk with his father. However, Eve says his father's threats didn't work, she is going to tell Luis and Sheridan exactly what happened that night!
At the hospital, Ethan tells Theresa that he loves her, would he kiss her if he didn't? Theresa doesn't believe Ethan and tells him to just let her die. Theresa's heartbeat grows weaker, so Ethan grabs her and tells her that she can't die, he won't let her die. Ethan tells her that he needs her, he truly loves her, and then he passionately kisses her. Suddenly, Gwen and the others show up and can't believe their eyes. After the kiss, Ethan tells Theresa that she has to get better because he needs her. Miguel tells Charity, who is in tears, that he can't believe this. Charity notices that Theresa's heartbeat has steadied. Miguel decides to go call his mom, so Charity tags along. Ethan continues to tell Theresa not to leave him because he loves her. Whitney and Chad leave, and Ethan looks and sees Gwen after she exclaims "Oh my God!" Gwen runs away, and Theresa begs Ethan to stay with her because she needs him. Ethan is faced with a choice, yet again. He begins to tell Theresa that he'll be right back, but the nurse urges Ethan not to leave Theresa because she doesn't want to see her slip back. Ethan says neither does he.
Miguel can't reach his mom, so he leaves her a message. Charity thinks about how romantic it was how Ethan saved THeresa, and she tells Miguel that she thinks love can work miracles. Miguel says it will take more than a miracle to make Ethan marry Theresa. Suddenly, the pendant, which is in Charity's purse, begins to glow! Still, Charity says Gwen heard him say it, so there is no way they'll be married. Miguel says that doesn't mean he'll marry Theresa, and he fears what might happen if Theresa gets her heart broken again. Charity knows Ethan really does love Theresa, but Miguel says too many things, like the Cranes, will prevent them from ever being together. As Miguel talks about the Cranes, Charity gets another premonition that something big is about to happen, something with Ethan and Theresa. Still, Miguel says not only will the Cranes stand in their way, but so will Luis. Despite Miguel's negativity, Charity thinks that love can conquer all because it is the strongest thing in the entire world.
Meanwhile, Whitney says she can't believe this, and Chad says that is the trouble with some people, they just don't understand love. Chad says no matter how she feels about this, there is no going back for Ethan. Whitney tells Chad to think about poor Gwen and what she will do to Theresa once she gets over the initial shock, she will tear her limb from limb!
Ethan goes to talk to Gwen. He tells her that he needs to explain what she saw, but she says she knows what is going on. Gwen says she spoke to the nurse and got the whole story, she knows why he did what he did and she thinks it is wonderful. Ethan is confused. Gwen says that she knows Theresa needed the man she loved to bring her back, and he pretended to be Chuck. She admits that at first she felt betrayed, but now she knows how lucky she is for marrying a real hero. The nurse tells everyone that Theresa is out of the woods, so they might as well all go home and get some rest. Gwen is beeped, so she takes a call, and Whitney goes to check on Theresa. Chad tells Ethan that he can't believe this, what is he going to do know? Ethan doesn't know and says he loves Gwen too, and though it isn't the same kind he has for Theresa it is real. Ethan says he can't just call off the wedding and tell her that he is in love with Theresa because that would break her heart. Chad says there is only one way to resolve this. Ethan says he needs to think this through carefully. Chad tells him to follow his heart otherwise he'll make everyone involved miserable. Gwen returns, and she and Ethan take off. Chad goes to see Theresa, who is murmuring Ethan's name. He asks Whitney if she's ready to go? Whitney feels she should stay her until Pilar shows up. Whitney asks what Ethan said, and Chad says that he says he loves both Ethan and Gwen. Whitney fears Ethan will chose Gwen, but Chad isn't so sure about that. He doesn't think that Ethan will be able to give Theresa up now that he's admitted he loves her.