At the mansion, Ivy tells Sam that Ethan is a good boy and is just under Julian and Alistair's influence right now. Sam says not right now, forever! The two argue, I was interrupted by a phone call at this point, sorry. Ivy tells Sam that Ethan is nothing like Julian or Alistair, but Sam tells her not to waste her breath. Sam then asks Ivy what was really in that attache case? She was scared to death when he opened up that case, and he knows Pilar covered for her. Ivy admits that Pilar saved her life today by switching her personal paper's with her own, because if Julian saw her papers it would have destroyed her life and the life of the someone she loves. Sam thinks she must be exaggerating, but Ivy says she is not. Sam doesn't understand why she stays with Julian if she is that afraid of him. Ivy asks if he's offering her a way out? Sam says no, but it would be better to live alone then live with Julian. He asks why she stays with him, is it the money, the Crane name? He then realizes it is because of Ethan, and if she left Julian, it would have effected Ethan the most seeing he is the oldest. He also says, seeing that Ethan is the heir to the Crane throne, that it wouldn't be smart for her to rock the boat. Sam says that Ethan is a Crane, and if Ethan pushes him, he will push back! Ivy tells Sam not to do this, she hates to see them fighting. Sam asks why it upsets her to see them fighting? He also wonders why Ethan is so special, what makes him more important than her other children? Ivy says she loves all her children, but if Ethan is her favorite it is because he is an exemplary human being. Sam laughs and asks how she can love Ethan so much when he is just like his father? Sam admits that at first he hoped Ethan was his son, but now he is happy that they aren't related. Sam warns Ivy that if Ethan comes after him, he will destroy Ethan. Sam walks away, and Ivy says Ethan is his son.
In the mansion, Ethan tells Julian that his mother's papers are all about him. Julian is confused and asks why Ivy would be hiding something about his son? Julian says whatever they are about he will find out sooner or later, so Ethan might as well tell him. Pilar tries to interrupt, but Julian tells her to stay out of this and go polish some silver! Ethan tells him that it isn't really a secret, just a surprise. Ethan says that mother is putting together a memory book of his life for him and Gwen as a wedding gift. Julian says that they must be talking about two different sets of papers because his mother is hiding more important papers from him. Ethan asks why his mother would do that? Julian tells Ethan that he doesn't know his mother the way he does. Ethan tells his father not to criticize his mother! Later, Ethan starts bitching about Sam Bennett. Ethan wonders what his problem is, he never did anything to Sam! Julian says that Sam hates him because his last name is Crane, but Ethan thinks Sam's problems with this family have more to do with their money. Ethan says whatever it is, he and Sam are at war. Julian tells Ethan to count him in. Ethan says that their family does a lot for this town, and he's not about to take Sam Bennett's insults lying down. Julian says it is time they put him in his place! Ethan says that Sam must have thought that he was weak because he hadn't been home that long, but he will show Sam. Ethan says he will win, even if he has to destroy Sam.
At the Bennett's, Grace asks the angel who is working against her? The angel says she can say no more right now, and she must keep her guard up. Grace says she isn't giving her enough to go on, but the angel says that is all she is allowed to reveal. She warns her that evil is at hand, and to beware. Grace asks why this is happening to her? The angel says that evil seeks out good, and she is good. She also says that people close to her are keeping secrets, and though they think they are doing it for the right reason, secrets are always bad. She says that someone close to her will do something to hurt her and her family. Grace asks "What if I'm not strong enough to fight this?" The angel says she must be, or her world will be shattered. The angel begins to cry, which scares Grace. The angel says sometimes even her faith is tested. Grace says that the least she can do is be strong, which pleases the angel. However, the angel says not all people are that strong, which is why Grace needs to keep an eye on those she loves. Grace asks what else she can do? The angel girl tells Grace to pray. Grace asks what she should pray against, is a catastrophe is coming? The angel girl says yes, and that there will be a revelation concerning someone close to her husband which will shake her family to its core. Grace asks who? The angel says it is about Sam's son. Grace thinks she is talking about Noah and doesn't understand. The angel tells Grace to be careful, and she vanishes, but not before warning Grace once again to beware. After she leaves, Grace seems to be zapped, and then faints.
At Tabitha's, Charity tells Tabitha that tonight they will kill Miguel, but first they will kill her! Charity them begins to shoot lightening bolts at Timmy and Tabitha! Tabitha begs Charity to leave them alone because they are not the one she wants to kill. Charity tells the "princess" not to look because her little doll boy has spilled his last MarTimmy! Charity zaps Timmy, which changes him into a doll permanently. Tabitha says that last bolt must have zapped the spell that brought him to life out of him, and she'll cast another one later. Tabitha tries to reason with Charity, but Charity says she and that MarTimmy guzzling doll have failed them for the last time, and it is time to pay the piper! Meanwhile, Miguel thinks Tabitha must be boring Charity with a story, so he should go rescue her. Miguel knocks on the door, but there is no answer. He decides to open the door and walk in just as Charity is about to do away with a cornered Tabitha and Timmy! Miguel walks in yells out Tabitha's name. Charity hears Miguel and smiles. Miguel walks into the living room and approaches Charity from behind. As he asks her if she is okay, her eyes glow red. Suddenly, the pendant stops glowing, and Charity returns to normal. Charity tells Miguel that she didn't hear him come in. Miguel sees the lemonade on the floor and asks what happened? Charity says she must have spilt it. Tabitha shows up and says that is exactly what happened. Charity feels bad, but Tabitha says it is fine. Miguel says that they can get Tabitha some more. Charity decides to stay here and wait with Tabitha while Miguel goes to get the lemonade. After Miguel leaves, the evil Charity returns and tells Tim Tim, whose hair is standing straight up, and Tabitha to be afraid, because they're back!
At the Bennett's, Eve finds Grace on her kitchen floor and asks what happened? Grace says the angel reappeared to her and warned her that bad things were going to happen to her family. Sam shows up and asks what happened? Grace explains to them both how the angel warned her that danger was all around her, and that terrible things are coming to Harmony. Eve has a hard time believing Grace because she is a scientist and looks for scientific explanations. Sam also has a hard time believing the story because as a cop he looks for evidence, but if she says she saw an angel then he believes her. Eve tells Grace that she is under a lot of stress and doesn't get enough rest, which is probably what caused her to see this angel. She says that life is full of danger, and the angel's warning sounds very vague. Grace says that the angel warned her that danger is all around her and her family, but Sam says them and their children are fine. Grace the angel said those around her were keeping secrets from her, but she knows there is nothing that could damage her marriage to Sam or her friendship with Eve because they keep nothing from each other. Grace explains that the angel said these people were keeping secrets for what they think are the right reasons, but they will hurt her nonetheless. Grace believes the angel wasn't lying, so she wonders who other than Sam and Eve is lying to her, because she trusts them both unconditionally. Sam asks if the angel said anything else? Grace says she did say one other thing, some event having to do with Sam's son would rock their family to the core. Sam says Noah is fine and he will stay that way. Eve knows the truth, that the angel was speaking of Ethan, and it shakes her up. Eve suggests Grace go out and get some air, and once she is gone, Sam tells Eve they need to talk about this warning. Eve says they will talk later, so Sam goes to be with Grace. Eve realizes that the angel Grace saw must have been for real. Later, Grace goes to talk to Noah and learns everything is fine with him. Sam, Grace, and Eve go out back, and Sam tells Grace that everything will be fine. Grace says he's right, unless he has another son out there somewhere. Grace's comment causes Eve to choke on her drink. When Grace leaves again, Sam asks Eve if she is certain he is not Ethan's real father? Eve says she is certain, Ethan is not his son. Sam says everything is fine then, and leaves to go upstairs.
At the mansion, Ivy walks in on Ethan and Julian plotting against Sam, and she is not pleased. Julian tells Ethan that his mother doesn't like it when they talk about crushing the locals. Ivy says she raised Ethan to be better than Julian and Alistair! Julian suggests they go into the other room to continue their discussion. After they leave, Ivy asks Pilar what is going on here? Pilar tells Ivy that Julian question Ethan about the papers, and Ethan told him that the papers were about him. Pilar says that Mr. Crane almost discovered the truth about Ethan! Ivy says she is sorry Pilar was put on the spot, but it could have been worse. Pilar begs Ivy to destroy the papers, but Ivy says she can't and she knows why. Ivy says other than herself, she and Eve are the only ones who know the truth, and Eve won't betray her. Pilar tells her not to be so sure about that after what she put Eve through. Ivy decides to call Eve and warn her to keep quiet about Ethan. Eve says she won't say a thing, but the forces of heaven might not be so easy to shut up! Eve tells Ivy about Grace's vision. Ivy doesn't believe Eve and thinks she is making this up to cover up that she has told Sam the truth. Eve says she hasn't told anyone about Ethan, and she is not making this up. Ivy finds this all a bit disturbing, and Eve agrees. Eve says if an angel did appear to Grace, she seemed to know quite a bit. Ivy says she will team up with the devil if she has to in order to keep the forces of heaven quiet!
Julian and Ethan go into the study to plot against Sam when Alistair calls. Alistair tells Ethan that he is proud of him for standing up against Sam, and when he brings Bennett up on charges he should go for the jugular, completely destroy him! Ethan says he understands, and Alistair says he knows he will make him proud. Alistair says he only wishes he had made Ethan his heir earlier. Ethan tells Alistair that he feels his father should be heir for now because he would do a much better job than he could, and Ethan feels he could learn from his father. Alistair tells Ethan that he has no idea the mess Julian has made, and that Julian would turn against them both if it suited him. Julian says that is not true, but AListair says Julian has already disregarded the family to pursue Ivy's secret which, if she even has, will probably have no effect on this family. They return to talking about Sam's failure to protect Sheridan by assigning Luis to guard Sheridan. Ethan tells his grandfather how Luis and Sheridan were about to investigate Sheridan's past, and they even had a tape recorder ready to record everything. Ethan says he managed to convince Sheridan not to do this, which pleases Julian and AListair. However, Ethan says he thinks Sheridan should know the truth about her past, and he asks Alistair and his father if Sheridan's nightmares are true? Ethan says Sheridan is not only connecting that night with Martin Fitzgerald's disappearance, but she thinks she was involved. Alistair tells Ethan that it was only a nightmare, which satisfies Ethan. He says even though there is nothing in her past that can harm her, if Luis learned about her beliefs he could do great damage to their family.
Ethan runs into his mother later on, and Ivy asks him not to go after Chief Bennett because he is a good man. Ethan says he will defend his family just like father and grandfather. Ivy tells him that he is so different than them, but Ethan says he is a Crane, and he will defend his family, and he thinks that the way Sam runs the department is a threat to his family. Ethan walks off, and Ivy swears she will not let Ethan become like Alistair! Ivy says heaven better not work against her because she will fight God and his angels to the gates of hell! Pilar hears this and tells Ivy that she mustn't talk that way! Meanwhile, Julian tells Ethan that he is proud of him for the way he handled Chief Bennett today, and he is also proud of him for saying what he did to his grandfather about him being heir. Ethan tells his father that the older he gets the closer he feels to him. He says he knows they have had their differences in the past, but he does love him. Julian hugs Ethan and tells him that he is a true Crane.
Back at the cottage, Luis, Hank, and Sheridan have returned and are staring a session. Luis turns on the tape recorder and asks Sheridan to think back to when she was a little girl and when her nightmares began. Sheridan tells Luis that she remembers getting ready for bed, and for some reason she wasn't sad that night like she usually was. Sheridan says she was very tired that night, so she went right to sleep. However, she says a noise woke her up, so she went downstairs. Sheridan says it was dark downstairs, and she felt drawn into the living room where it was cold, as if someone left a window open. She says while there she saw something, someone, out of the corner of her eye. Luis asks who it was? Sheridan says it was just a shadow, but she soon begins to make out a face. Sheridan says it is him, she sees who it is! Luis asks Sheridan if she sees his father?
At Tabitha's, Evil Charity tells Tabitha and Timmy now that Miguel is gone, they can play another lightening round. Fortunately, Miguel returns for the pitcher of lemonade, so Charity is unable to kill Tabitha. Tabitha tells Miguel to forget the lemonade, she'll just have water. Charity's eyes stop glowing, and she tells Miguel that it is no trouble for Miguel to go get her some lemonade. Tabitha says she will just have water, and she'd just die if Miguel went to the trouble to get more lemonade. Miguel brings Tabitha some water, and asks what is wrong with her doll's hair? Timmy says "What is up with your sideburns Zorro!" Tabitha says she just washed his hair and she has yet to comb it. Charity says she thinks it is cute. Miguel and Charity decide to leave to try the swing out, and Tabitha decides to tag along just in case Charity kills Miguel, she doesn't want to miss it. As Miguel and Charity walk out the door, Charity's eyes glow red and she tells Tabitha and Timmy "See you later!"
Tabitha and Timmy sit on the porch. Tabitha is eating cookies and thinks they are safe for now, and hopefully Charity will go demonic on Miguel before coming after them again. Miguel pushes Charity on the swing, and Charity's pendant begins to glow. Charity gives Tabitha a sinister look and smile.
Grace goes inside, and Sam asks Grace if something is wrong, is she still worried about the angel? Grace says it is just hard to get what she said out of her mind. Sam tells her that they are not in danger and are as happy as any family can be. Eve shows up and says that Sam is right. Grace then realizes that the angel didn't say "their son," she said "Sam's son." Grace asks Sam if he has a son by another woman? Sam asks her how she could think such a thing? Grace apologizes and says that there is no way he could have another son, she would know and he would tell her if he did. Sam tells Grace that nothing is going to happen to their family, and he loves her very much.
Grace goes back outside to see Charity, and Charity snaps to. Timmy tells Tabitha that he knows deep down Charity is still good, but Tabitha says once she kills Miguel, Charity will be evil forever! After Grace leaves, Charity tells Tabitha and Timmy that tonight will be Miguel's last ride on his motorcycle! Meanwhile, Miguel gets on his motorcycle and takes off.
At the Russell's, Simone goes into see Chad and asks him if he remembers what he was going to say before her mother gave him the sedative? Was he going to say he loved her? Kay tells Simone not to push it. Chad is still out cold, and is dreaming of telling Whitney that she is the one he loves. Later, Simone leaves, and Chad wakes up. Kay tells Chad that they need to talk about Simone because there is something he needs to know. Kay tells Chad that Simone really doesn't have any friends, she's not even that popular. Kay says the friends that hang around Simone are really her friends, and she has to force them to hang with her. She also says that because Simone doesn't have a boyfriend, she's developed an eating disorder. Chad thinks they need to help her. Kay says the only person who can help Simone is him, and she thinks that him liking Simone can save her life. Kay says there is also something else she should tell him, it is about Whitney. Kay says that Whitney doesn't like men talking about their feelings, she feels that it makes them appear wimpy, and she's only telling him this because she'd hate for Whitney to look down on him. Downstairs, Theresa is still trying to get Whitney to reveal her feelings for Chad when Simone shows up to get Chad a drink because he's waking up. Whitney, Simone, and Theresa go upstairs, and Simone asks Chad if he is ready to finish what he was going to say earlier? Chad says he is ready. Chad says he still doesn't remember who he kissed, or what he said. Chad doesn't want to tell the truth, because he doesn't want Whitney to think he is unmanly. Chad says that all he has to say is he doesn't know how he is feeling. Whitney runs out of the room, and Theresa follows her. Whitney yells at Theresa that she was dead wrong, Chad wasn't thinking about her when he kissed Simone! Whitney says she has to forget about Chad and focus only on tennis. Simone is upset too, but Kay tells her that when she was alone with Chad today he told her that he loved her (Simone), and he didn't say anything just now because he didn't want to hurt Whitney. Theresa goes to see Chad when he is alone and tells him that she is so disappointed in him, she knows he loves Whitney and isn't leaving until he admits it.
At the cottage, Sheridan tells Luis and Hank that she can see someone in the room with her. Sheridan sees only a shadow at first, but then Sheridan sees the man's face. Luis asks if she sees his father? Sheridan cries that she doesn't know. Hank tells Luis to back off because Sheridan is hurting. Luis says he's not trying to hurt her, but he's waited most of his life to find out what happened to his father. Luis asks Sheridan what she sees? Sheridan ends up snapping out of the trance, and Hank tells Luis that he needs to ease up. Luis says Sheridan seems terrified, and he wonders what happened. Luis says Sheridan knows, she has just buried it deep inside. Hank thinks perhaps it should remain buried, but Luis says it has to come out because he thinks there is a connection between that night and his father. Sheridan overhears him and says she doesn't know if there is a connection, but she'll do whatever it takes to find out the truth. They return to their little session, and Sheridan says her mind is being bombarded with images. She sees a dead man being put into a coffin, but she doesn't mention it. She says she sees a shadow, and Luis asks whose shadow is she looking at? Sheridan doesn't answer, she just cries and rocks back and forth. Sheridan sees herself in front of the coffin and her father telling her that the person inside was dead, and that she was a wicked girl. Sheridan breaks down, and starts crying that it's not her fault. Luis asks her who she is talking to? Sheridan says she doesn't know, and then she smashes a glass on the table. Hank goes to get some things to clean up, and Luis apologizes for pushing her too far. Sheridan says she wanted to know as desperately as he did. Hank returns with some antiseptic for Sheridan's cut, and asks Luis if he's put Sheridan through enough of this? Sheridan tells Hank it is okay, but Hank says he thinks this is unhealthy for her. Hank says he does know another way, but there is no telling what might happen if she chooses to go down this road. Sheridan says she's going to find out no matter what it takes. Hank says perhaps she should go see Eve, she has experience with this sort of thing. Luis agrees and says there is no way to know how she will react when she remembers. Sheridan doesn't know, she is afraid to bring more people into this, especially since it has to deal with the family. However, Sheridan says she's tired of family secrets and being afraid of her past. She asks Hank to call Dr. Russell and if she's free, ask her to come over. Eve is free, and she comes over. Eve learns the story and says the only way she can help Sheridan is through hypnosis, if she is okay with that. Sheridan says she is, and Eve says she needs to be alone with her patient. Sheridan suggests they go into her bedroom, so that is what they do. Luis tells Hank that if this works he thinks it will change both his and Sheridan's lives forever.
At the mansion, Ethan tells Gwen that he has asked his grandfather to reinstate Julian as head of Crane Industries because he feels his father would shrivel up and die if he was stripped of everything he worked his entire life for. Gwen asks Ethan how he could do that? Ethan asks her why not? Gwen says she did mean it to come out that way, she just meant that her grandfather did what he did for a reason. Ethan says Alistair was just angry with his father, but Gwen isn't so sure. Gwen feels that Alistair feels Ethan is much more suited to run the company. Still, Ethan can't take that away from his father, but Gwen thinks he could be risking what his ancestors worked so hard to build. She asks him if he wants to risk what belongs to his mother, him, his wife?
At the Russell's, Simone learns Theresa is in with Chad, and becomes upset. Kay tells Simone not to worry, Chad loves her and Theresa can't change that. Whitney says Chad doesn't remember anything, and Simone asks Whitney why she has to ruin the one thing that makes her happy? Simone tells Whitney that she has never experienced true love, and Kay bets Whitney has never been kissed. Whitney remembers kissing Chad and says "do you think I'd tell you if I had?" Whitney thinks that if Kay is involved in this then something must be in it for her. Whitney just hopes that Kay is there for Simone when her heart gets broken!
Theresa tells Chad that she is not leaving until he admits to her that he has feelings for Whitney. Theresa tells him that he is such a hypocrite for telling her to go after Ethan when he won't go after Whitney. Chad says that WHitney only cares about tennis, but Theresa says that is not true. Chad says he knows Whitney would laugh in his face if he told her those three little words, but Theresa says that is not true either, Whitney would love to hear how he feels about her. Chad says "says you!" and that he doesn't want to hurt Simone. Chad suggests they talk about something else, and asks how it went with her and Ethan? Theresa says that Ethan told her and Gwen that he loves Gwen and will marry her. Chad can't believe it, and Theresa asks if Ethan told him something different? Theresa says she could have sworn Ethan was going to say he loved her, were her instincts correct? Unfortunately, Ethan and Gwen show up and interrupt. Ethan says that Gwen wanted to make sure her musical director was going to be okay for their wedding. Chad asks if the wedding is still on? Gwen says yes, and Chad says it looks like true love wins out again. Theresa tells Whitney that she and Chad were just talking about true love and whether or not Chad had found it. Chad says he is no authority on true love. Theresa thinks they should let Chad rest, but Chad says he is sick of resting and asks Ethan to give him a hand getting up. The girls leave, and Gwen talks to Whitney about a beautiful wall hanging in her living room. Whitney says it is something her parents are very proud of, so Gwen goes to take another look. Whitney tells Theresa that it looks like it is over, neither of them are the apple of Ethan or Chad's eye. Theresa still refuses to give up, and Whitney calls her delusional. Theresa says that in her heart she knows Ethan loves her as much as she loves him, and that Gwen cares about Ethan, but she loves his money and power more. Gwen returns and says tells Whitney that her parents have a significant African art collection, and maybe she'll talk to the museum about mounting an exhibit. She then says better yet, I'll wait till I'm Mrs. Ethan Crane and just do it myself! Back inside the room, Ethan and Chad both argue. Chad tells Ethan he chickened out, but Ethan says he did no better. Chad says at least he doesn't have to marry a woman he doesn't love. Chad asks him why he backed out? Ethan says he couldn't hurt Gwen, and the only reason he got turned around is because of the garbage he and his father have put in his head about Theresa. Chad just doesn't want to see Ethan make a mistake he will pay for for the rest of his life. Chad says there may be a day he will look back and wonder why he didn't admit his true feelings, because it could have changed his life. Ethan tells Chad that he could end up asking himself the same thing.
Miguel and Charity arrive at the Russell's, and Tabitha and Timmy have followed them. They go inside and learn Chad is on his way downstairs. While they wait, Miguel decides to grab some tools and check the breaks on his bike because he didn't like the way they were sounding. Charity helps Miguel with his bike, and her pendant begins to glow. As Miguel is working on his bike, Evil Charity raises a wrench up and is about to knock Miguel over the head! However, Miguel sees her, thinking she is offering it to him, and says he doesn't need that wrench anymore, but thanks her anyways. A song comes on that Kay loves, so Charity asks him to go dance with Miguel. Miguel asks Kay to dance, and she says she'd love to. Meanwhile, Charity turns evil, and then asks Timmy to help her "fix" Miguel's bike. When Evil Charity sees Kay mooning over Miguel, she says poor Kay's heart is going to be broken tonight, and poor Miguel's neck is going to be broken! Elsewhere, Timmy plays mechanic with Miguel's bike.
Chad comes downstairs with Ethan's help and he thanks everyone for their help and support. Simone is glad he is feeling better, but wonders if he is leaving? Chad says they'll talk about that later. Gwen is beeped and has to make a call, so she excuses herself. After Gwen leaves, Chad puts on the song that Ethan and Theresa dances to, and it has an effect on them. Ethan and Theresa stare at one another, and Whitney gives Chad a look, but he turns away from her.
At the cottage, Luis wants to go be with Sheridan, but Hank tells him that Eve says she will have better success if they were alone. Luis can't get his mom's expression "be careful what you wish for" out of his head. He wonders what if he and Sheridan do find out the truth, but wish they hadn't? Luis and Hank talk about the past, and Luis admits that for a long time he thought his dad walked out on his family, and he didn't marry Beth because he was afraid he'd be just like his dad and walk out on her. Luis says that is why it is important he finds out if his dad left on his own, or was forced to leave. Hank asks Luis if he thinks Sheridan had a hand in what happened to his father? Luis says he doesn't know how she could have, she was only a little girl, but something happened to her that night which is tearing her up.
In Sheridan's room, Eve asks Sheridan if she is prepared to relive the events of that evening? Sheridan says she has to know if there is a connection between her past and Luis' father. Eve realizes this isn't just for Sheridan. Sheridan says that they both need to know the truth, no matter what it turns out to be. Sheridan says until she knows the truth, she fears she will never be able to have a real relationship. Sheridan says that she feels that the events of that night have always kept her from letting people see inside of her. She hopes finding out what happened that night will help her find real love. Eve asks "what if it doesn't?" Sheridan tells her that is a risk she'll have to take. Sheridan lays down on her bed, and Eve says she will tape-record the session because she won't remember what is said when she comes out of it. Sheridan tells Eve that she wants Luis to know everything that is said. Eve says okay, and then pulls out a crystal and tells Sheridan to concentrate on it. Eve puts Sheridan under, and then goes out to get some water. Eve tells Luis that Sheridan is very brave and determined, and she's doing this for him as well as herself. Luis asks if he can look in on her? Eve says only for a moment, and asks him not to disturb her. Luis goes in and sits next to Sheridan on her bed. Luis promises her that he won't let anything happen to her and gives her a kiss on the forehead. Luis leaves, and Eve warns Luis that he may hear Sheridan cry out, but he is not to disturb them. Eve returns to Sheridan and snaps her to. Sheridan opens her eyes, but remains in a deep sleep. Eve takes Sheridan back to that night, and asks her to tell her what she remembers. Sheridan says she is scared, she is so scared. Sheridan sees herself hiding from a man, she says she can't see his face but can see his shoes. She also sees that she's holding a letter opener in her hand, but suddenly she's not holding it anymore. Eve asks what she did with it? Sheridan sees the blood on her hands and the letter opened in the dead man's chest. Sheridan cries that she has blood all over her hands. Eve tells her to calm down and gets Sheridan some water. Eve wonders if Sheridan could have killed someone? Sheridan answers her by crying out "I did it!" Sheridan remembers Alistair telling her that no one must know what she did. When Eve asks her what she did, Sheridan cries that she can't tell anyone. Eve asks who was under the bloody sheet? Sheridan says she can't tell anyone otherwise they'll send her away and no one will love her. Eve tells Sheridan that she is safe and she can tell her. Sheridan cries that she can't because she is wicked, and it is all her fault. Suddenly, Luis bangs on the door and tells Eve not to make Sheridan do this anymore. Suddenly, Sheridan screams "I killed him!"
Tabitha and Evil Charity look on with glee as Timmy sabotages Miguel's motorcycle. Tabitha implores Timmy not to mess up or they will face death, just as Miguel approaches. Miguel almost catches Timmy working on his bike, but Tabitha covers. This causes Evil Charity to decide to do away with Timmy and Tabitha once and for all. Meanwhile, Miguel admires Kay and wonders aloud to her what would have happened between them if Charity had never arrived in Harmony. This makes Kay more determined to win Miguel away from Charity. Theresa asks Ethan for a dance, but he declines until Theresa challenges him to use a dance to prove whether or not he has feelings for her. Ethan gives in, and can't help being drawn in by the feelings he does have for Theresa. Theresa is devastated when she realizes that Ethan is serious when he claims he doesn't love her and will still be marrying Gwen. Meanwhile, Whitney is confused when Chad says he doesn't want to talk about his feeling with her. Later, Kay continues her lies by telling Whitney that Chad doesn't like girls who push him to discuss his feelings. While Luis vows to make whoever may have hurt his father face the same fate, Eve tries to get Sheridan to remember whom she saw under the bloody sheet. When Sheridan suddenly screams out that, "she killed him", Eve attempts to bring her out of hypnosis before Luis, who is banging on the door out of concern and worry, barges in. When Luis does enter, Eve is relieved when he reveals he heard nothing. Luis begins inquiring as to what Sheridan said, but Eve tries to stall him.