In Harmony, Luis heads to the mansion and is furious that Theresa is living there. Theresa wakes up and rings for a servant, and is shocked when her mom appears! Theresa tells her mom she shouldn't be working here, but Pilar says she works here, and she refuses to live in this evil house! Pilar and Theresa begin arguing. Pilar has a bad feeling about all of this, about her being declared MRs. Crane and her trying to get Ethan back. As they argue, Luis continues to search the house for Theresa. Elsewhere, Rebecca and Ivy continue to discuss their plan. Rebecca plans on getting Theresa to confess to Julian's murder! Luis runs into Ivy and Rebecca, and they tell Luis to please talk some sense into Theresa and get her out of this house! Luis finds Theresa, and he orders her to pack her things or he will do it for her because she is out of here! Theresa tells him to stop, but he says they can stay at the B&B till their house is repaired. Pilar then has to break the news to Luis that their insurance was canceled. Luis is devastated, and Theresa says everyone should move in here with her and even Paloma can come home. Luis says he'd rather sleep in jail than here, this place holds terrible memories for him. Theresa refuses to leave, and she goes to get dressed. Luis talks to Pilar about what is really going on with Theresa. She tells him that he has to talk some sense into her. Luis then remembers what he needed to tell her, he ran into Antonio in Bermuda! Luis says he left him a note about what was going on and thought he'd be here by now. Luis also tells her that Antonio has met someone, and for some reason is calling himself Brian. Pilar hopes this means Antonio will come home, and maybe he'll bring his special lady friend with him.
Later, Ethan talks to Theresa about his appeal, and he says he is convinced he will win. SHe tells him she doesn't think so. She asks Ethan to talk to Luis and tell him that she has a right to stay here, but he refuses because he doesn't think she should be living here. Luis eventually returns, and demands Theresa leave on her own or she will carry her out! Theresa still refuses to leave.
Meanwhile, Rebecca asks Ivy to make a phone call to the governor for the favor they need. Ivy doesn't understand why they really need to find out who killed Julian, do they want to know? Rebecca says they do indeed! Rebecca makes her own call and asks Charles to deliver a certain package to the mansion. Charles brings a video to Rebecca, and she tells Ivy to call the governor. Ivy refuses until she sees what is on the videotape, so Rebecca agrees. They watch part of the video, and Ivy is shocked and tells Rebecca that she owes her one for this one. Ivy then calls the governor and asks what is being done to find Julian's killer! Ethan shows up and asks what the tape is? Rebecca claims it is something for her and Ivy's college reunion, nothing he'd be interested in. Later they watch the tape again, which is from the cannery and shows Julian being killed! Unfortunately the video shows Ethan as the killer! Ivy says this can't be!
At the Crane Mansion, Luis tells Theresa that she is leaving with him, but Theresa refuses. Luis is called by Sam, who wants him to go confirm everyone's alibi's the night of the murder so he has to give up arguing with Theresa. Luis takes off, and Pilar tries to talk some sense into Theresa. Theresa still refuses to move, and Pilar refuses to move into the mansion. Theresa offers to rebuild their old house, but Pilar refuses to accept Crane money. She also refuses to quit her job, and says she must get back to her job. Pilar then asks "Mrs. Crane" what she would like her to do today! Theresa tells her to stop this now, she doesn't have to work again. Pilar realizes she's not going to get through to her, so she decides to go do other chores that need to be done.
In the study, Ivy is stunned after seeing the tape that shows Ethan murdering Julian! Ivy thinks Rebecca is going to use this tape to blackmail her, but she refuses to be blackmailed and attacks Rebecca! Rebecca tells Ivy that she doesn't understand, but Ivy says she does and continues attacking her. Ivy gets Rebecca in a chock hold, and Rebecca says the tape is to be used against Theresa. Ivy lets Rebecca go, and Luis shows up to question them. Ivy says they can't let Luis see the tape or he'll arrest Ethan! Luis walks into the study when no one answers the door and finds them struggling to get Rebecca out of her wheelchair, which she is caught in. Luis says he's here to talk about Julian's murder, and if they have remembered anything new? Rebecca says she knows something that he should know, in fact, she'd like to show him what she knows! Rebecca shows him a cup of tea, and tells him that Tabitha can read the future in tea leaves! Luis says he doesn't believe in tea leaves and ends up leaving. Ivy is furious with Rebecca because Tabitha already read her tea leaves and saw that Ethan may have killed Julian, and she refuses to let him go to jail! They begin arguing over the tape, and Rebecca finally tells her that the tape is computer generated, it's a fake! Ivy asks her why she made this tape? Rebecca says to get rid of Theresa! Ivy doesn't understand how framing Ethan will accomplish that? Rebecca tells her to trust her, and she whispers her plan to Ivy. Unfortunately, as the tape continues to play, Pilar is about to walk in to make sure the room is clean!
MEanwhile, Ethan works on the appeal for his mother. When Luis comes to talk to him about the murder, Ethan asks him to testify in court against his sister. Luis agrees to do it because he knows he has to get Theresa out of this house. They talk about Theresa for a bit, and Ethan admits that he still loves her, but they can't be together ever again because she deceived him too many times.
At Tabitha's, ZOmbie Charity wonders where that damn bird of Mordrid is. Tabitha tells Zombie Charity that Timmy is just a little boy and is no threat to her, but Charity says she can't take any chances. Meanwhile, Timmy walks along a stretch of highway and worries about how everything will turn out. As he sits down to cry, a little dog comes up to him. The dog is nice to Timmy, so he shares his sandwich with the dog. Timmy can't believe he is actually crying, and doesn't understand where all these feelings are coming from. Timmy thinks he must be lonely and afraid, and he wonders how he can stop this pain. Timmy calls Tabitha, but she's unable to speak because Tabitha is with the Zombie. The Zombie realizes Timmy is on the phone and she demands to know where he is. Tabitha says it is just the dishwasher repair man. The Zombie leaves to search for the bird, and Tabitha tells Timmy that the Zombie is after him to stop him from destroying her. Timmy says he will destroy her first and save the real Charity. As Tabitha and Timmy talk, the zombie picks up another phone and listens in on them! Fortunately Tabitha knows enough not to allow Timmy to tell him where she is, as Zombie might get it out of her, so she hangs up. Unfortunately, the Zombie imitates Tabitha's voice and says she's changed her mind and asks where he is. Timmy is about to tell her when Tabitha catches the Zombie and yells into the phone not to say a word! Timmy hangs up, and the Zombie is furious with Tabitha for lying to her! Charity grabs Tabitha and tells her to tell her where Timmy is! Tabitha says she doesn't know, and if she did, she wouldn't tell her! As they fight, Luis shows up and hears a crash in Tabitha's house. He wonders what is going on.
Out on the road, Timmy talks to his dog about how worried he is about Tabitha right now. Crusher shows up and tells Timmy that they to get going. Timmy wants to bring the dog, but Crusher says he's allergic so the dog will have to stay. Timmy says goodbye to the dog, but the dog continues to follow Timmy. Timmy eventually chooses to stay with the dog, so he says goodbye to Crusher. Timmy ends up naming his dog Toto, after the Wizard of Oz. MEanwhile, up in the night sky, Charity's spell takes effect. Written in the night sky is "Surrender Timmy!"
Luis goes to the Book Cafe and tells Beth that Tabitha told him that he and Sheridan were on the Titanic together, and he died there. He says that they will have many more lives together in the future. Beth says she didn't think he believed in that stuff? Luis says he didn't use to, but it gives him hope that he and Sheridan will be together in another life. Luis then begins to realize how crazy he sounds, but Beth gets an idea. She says she knows a way to prove if he and Sheridan were on the Titanic.
At the mansion, Ivy doesn't understand how setting up Ethan for murder will help them rid of Theresa? Rebecca whispers her plan to Ivy. Meanwhile, Pilar and Theresa show up outside the library, and Pilar says she must check to see if it has been cleaned! As the tape continues to roll, Pilar opens the door and walks in. Theresa follows, and exclaims "Oh my God!" Theresa says she said that they could stay here, not watch videos and make themselves at home! Rebecca says they were just packing up some of their things, just in case. Rebecca also thanks Theresa for being so gracious and allowing them to stay here. Theresa wonders what is up with them? Rebecca is stalling for time so she and Ivy can maneuver themselves in front of the TV and shut off the video. Ethan shows up to see what is going on. When Rebecca and Ivy says they are just packing things, Ethan tells them that he's confident he will win the appeal, so they shouldn't pack too much. Theresa decides to rub her status into Ivy and Rebecca's face by asking the cook to make supper from her menus, and she says Ivy and Rebecca will be eating from a pizza delivery place down the street! Phyliss begins to clean the study, and removes the tape from the machine. Rebecca goes to get the tape, and realizes the tape is gone! Phyliss says she put the tape in the box with the others, and Rebecca asks which one was in the VCR? Phyliss grabs the one she thinks was in the VCR, and stick it back in the machine! Rebecca screams no, and Theresa asks what she doesn't want her to see? The tape begins playing, and it ends up being one of her and Julian's sex tapes! Everyone gets grossed out, and ends up leaving. Ivy and Rebecca continue to argue over Rebecca's plan. Ivy thinks that it will put Ethan at risk, but Rebecca says when Theresa sees this tape she will confess to save Ethan! Rebecca says Theresa will be convicted, and then executed!
Meanwhile, Theresa brings Ethan, who is working, some of his favorite cookies. He thanks her, and they agree to be friends. Theresa, however, plans for them to be more than just friends.
In Bermuda, the mystery man makes a phone call and tells him that he's found Brian O'Leary in Bermuda! MEanwhile, Diana/Sheridan thanks Brian for making her so happy and trying to help her forget the past. Brian says his past is behind him too, and he wants to concentrate on where they are going. Sheridan says some people say the past can come back to haunt you. Brian says he used to believe that, but he stopped looking over his shoulder when she came into his life. They talk about their past life together, and Brian thinks they can have that kind of future in this life. Brian then wonders if any of their children from a past life were still alive? Sheridan says that would be incredible! Brian thinks he knows how to find out if they have any children still alive.
At the mansion, Whitney shows up to see Theresa. Whitney doesn't like Theresa living here. Theresa checks on Ethan once again to make sure Ethan has everything he needs. Ethan doesn't understand why she is so concerned about him while he's working on his mother's appeal. She says she just wants him to be comfortable, and they are still friends. Whitney tells Theresa that there is no way Ethan will take her back. She tells Whitney to just watch and see!
Meanwhile, Rebecca tells Ivy that Theresa will confess to Julian's murder to save Ethan. As They watch the video, Theresa and Whitney show up and wonder what they are watching now? Theresa looks at the TV and screams "Oh my god!" The movie version of A Tale of Two Cities is on, and she says this is her favorite! Ivy and Rebecca also love the story. Theresa says she loves when Garton (It's been a long time since I read this, I forget his name) dies for Lucy, and says she would do anything for love just like Garton did. Theresa then begins to fantasize about Ethan committing murder for her (???). Later, Rebecca talks to Ethan about how he feels about THeresa. He says that he still loves Theresa with all his heart, but she has deceived him too many times. Rebecca then gives the tape to her henchman and tells him that he knows what he is to do with it. The man then goes to the front door of the house, and when Theresa answers (because Phyllis is no where to be found). He tells her that he has something she should really see.
At the Book Cafe, Luis worries why Antonio/Brian hasn't called them. Beth then helps Luis research his and Sheridan's past lives on the Titanic via the internet. They find SHeridan's name on the list, and BEth finds a picture of Luis! Beth also finds a picture of Sheridan. Luis becomes upset because he knows that after he dies, Sheridan ends up with someone else to take care of her. Luis says only this time she died, and he wonders if he has met the guy who always ends up taking care of her in past lives. They decide to try and search for the name of the person Sheridan ended up with after him.
In Bermuda, Brian and Diana/Sheridan go to an internet cafe and search for information on their past lives on the internet. Sheridan is positive that she danced on the deck of the Titanic. Sheridan recalls her name was Susan, so they search for that name and find there was only one Susan in first class. Sheridan wonders if it could be her. Brian says it could be her, many people believe in reincarnation. Sheridan isn't sure, until Brian finds a photo of her on the Titanic! Sheridan asks if he can find a picture of him, and he does. Sheridan wonders if they can find a picture of her DEAD LOVER. Sheridan starts coughing, so Brian leaves to get her some water. After he leaves, she finds a picture of Luis. She calls to Brian to come here and see if he recognizes her DEAD LOVER. Tragedy strikes when there is a computer error, and a Server Error comes up! They end up moving on to children of Titanic survivors, and search for their children. They end up learning they had four children, and Frank Jr. is still alive! They end up learning that Frank Jr. lives in Bermuda!
Timmy realizes he's dealing with bad guys. They tells him that he might as well help them because he's already broken into the store. The kids end up threatening Toto if Timmy doesn't do what they say. Timmy doesn't know what to do, so the angel girl arrives and tells Timmy to follow his conscious. Timmy lets the boys in, and they begin robbing the store. HOwever, he also pushes the button calling the cops. When he tries to leave, one of the kids refuses to let him leave!
Beth and Luis search for answers to what happened to Sheridan in her last life. They try and find out who she married, and if she had children. Beth asks Luis if he finds these answers, will he be able to move on? She asks if he wants to start over, or has he changes his mind about them? Luis assures her that he wants to move on, but he can't turn his back on SHeridan. He says if he knows Sheridan was happy in a past life, it will make it easier for him to move on. Beth and Luis continue searching through the archives and learn about Frank and Frank JR. Luis decides to try and contact Frank by calling the station house. Meanwhile, BEth finds a picture of Frank and realizes it is Antonio! Beth decides not to let Luis know about this because it would hurt him too much. Luis returns after learning Franklin Liva lives in Bermuda. Luis decides to call the number he got from the station.
In Bermuda, Sheridan and Brian track down their son from their past life together. They learn he was a father at a local church, unfortunately they find he's dead. A caretaker tells them about Father Frank and how much he loved his family, especially his mother Susan. Sheridan and Brian grieve for their son. Sheridan has memories of her son from her past life as Susan. Later, BRian and Sheridan look through some of Frank's old stuff in his office. Suddenly, Frank's phone rings, and Sheridan answers!
Rebecca's henchman shows up claiming to see Ethan Crane's mother, Mrs. Crane. Theresa says she is Mrs. Crane, and demands he hand it over, but he refuses. When she threatens to call the cops, he gives her the videotape to Theresa. He says he'll be in touch to discuss a price, because that isn't the only copy. Rebecca and Ivy watch happily as Theresa takes the bait. Whitney shows up and endangers Ivy and Rebecca's plan when Theresa and Whitney plan on watching the tape together. Rebecca tells them to stop and help her because Ivy's in pain! Ivy pretends to have a fit, and Rebecca makes it look real by pinching Ivy. Ivy asks Whitney to find her mother and write her a prescription. Whitney leaves, and Phylliss shows up with some swatches Theresa asked for so she could redecorate. LAter, Ethan shows up looking for a lawbook, and she asks for his opinion on redecorating. Once she is finally alone, Theresa watches the tape. Theresa is stunned as she thinks Ethan killed Julian for her.