On the boat, Brian continues to stare at Sheridan/Diana as they sail to Bermuda. They talk about Bermuda, and Sheridan asks how many rooms they have? He asks if it matters? She says they may have been married in a past life, and he knows how she feels about him, but they aren't married in this life. He says they have two rooms, and he'd never push her into something she isn't ready for. The plane carrying Luis and Beth flies overhead, and Brian and Sheridan imagine who is on the plane, and why they are going to Bermuda. Brian and Sheridan eventually arrive, narrowly missing Luis and Sheridan, and they learn that they have only one room as well. Brian tells her that can find another hotel if she wants, but Sheridan says she trusts him. They take the room, and Sheridan feels the place looks familiar. Later, the bellhop recognizes Sheridan!
At the Book Cafe, Eve talks with TC about the DNA test results. She fears that it will kill Grace to learn that John isn't her son. TC asks her when she started believing that? Eve says it just sounds plausible to her. Later, Eve gets a call from Ivy about the DNA tests, but Eve refuses to change the results. TC catches Eve arguing on the phone, and Eve claims she was just arguing with a stubborn patient.
Zombie Charity and Miguel come home from their date, and Kate breaks up their make- out session on the front porch by walking outside on them, claiming she didn't know they were out here. Miguel takes off, and Charity and Kay begin arguing about Miguel. Grace hears them arguing and asks what is going on out here? The girls say nothing is going on. Sam shows up and asks Charity for some more ideas about her party. Charity says she wants the party to be a surprise, and she heads off to bed. Charity heads upstairs, and Kay follows her. She tells Charity to stay away from Miguel, but Charity tells her to find someone else like Reese. Kay refuses, and ends up slapping the Zombie right across the face! Kay vows to use the book of spells to get rid of the Zombie, so Zombie zaps her with lightening! Zombie Charity tells Kay not to tangle with her. The two then begin fighting big time!
Back downstairs, Grace tells Sam that she knows now that Kay wants Miguel. Sam says hopefully Kay will accept Miguel loves Charity and not her. They return to the party plans, and Grace wants to invite John and David, much to Sam's dismay. Grace says she believes John is her son, but part of her does realize that her grief for her lost child could be making her want to accept John as her son. Suddenly, Sam and Grace hear a struggle upstairs, and find Charity and Kay going at each other's throats! They claims they are just having a pillow fight, that is all. Grace and Sam tell them no more, and to keep it down for the rest of the night. Kay and Zombie eventually call a truce, Kay agrees not to try and get rid of the zombie as long as Zombie agrees not to seduce Miguel. However, neither of them intends to keep their end of the deal! Charity snaps her fingers and makes a fake Charity appear in her bed, and then she sneaks out of the house.
TC and Eve drop by the Bennetts to drop off their statements in Julian's murder. Sam invites them to stay for a beer. Sam and TC go to drink, and Eve talks to Grace about her decision to tell TC the truth. When Grace goes to fix them a snack, Ivy once again calls Eve to badger her about the DNA test results. Once again Eve refuses to lie to Grace. Grace shows up, and Eve claims she was talking to the hospital and can't get the results until tomorrow.
At Tabitha's, Timmy continues to try and think of ways to rescue Charity. Timmy doesn't understand why Tabitha burned the book, because he doesn't think she loves him more than the book. Tabitha says the book is gone, that is that! What neither of them realize is that the book is floating around the house! Later, Tabitha and Timmy see the zombie sneaking out of the house, probably to go see Miguel. Suddenly, Kay shows up telling Tabitha that she has a book of spells she needs to see. Tabitha says that is just a gag gift, and she has no idea where it is. Suddenly, the book appears over Kay's head!
Meanwhile, Brain carries Sheridan into their room, and plops her down on their bed! He tells her to get a good nights rest so they can expire Bermuda tomorrow. When Sheridan learns he is going to sleep on the couch, she insists they share the bed. Brian says he wants her to get a good night sleep, and doesn't think that would happen if they were in bed together, so he insists he take the couch. Brian and Sheridan/Diana share a kiss, and he tells her that she makes him very happy. She says the feeling is mutual. As Sheridan sleeps, she dreams of being with Luis. She wakes up and realizes her lover is gone.
Down in the main area of the hotel, the bellhop tells the concierge about Sheridan and Luis, and how he swears he just saw Sheridan, but she is dead! When Luis shows up, the bellhop tells him that he must be very happy to be reunited with his lost love! Luis asks him where he saw her? When the bellhop says in the elevator, Luis thinks he was talking about Beth. Luis returns to his room, and Beth surprises him by wearing a little red negligee! She says she went ahead and changed for bed, she hopes he doesn't mind. Luis says he doesn't. Luis pours the champagne, and proposes a toast to them and their vacation. Later they argue about sleeping arrangements, and agree to share the bed.
Later in the evening, Luis and Sheridan head to their balconies and think about one another, not realizing they are right next to one another!
At the Bennett's, Grace asks Eve if she could have the hospital send over the results tonight? Eve makes excuses and says it might be hard to get a messenger at this hour, but Grace begs her to try. Eve makes the arrangements to have the information sent over, and Grace calls David to let him know the test results are in and are being sent over right away. David says he and John will be right over. Meanwhile, Ivy learns that the results are being sent to Sam's house, so she makes plans to arrive before the results do! Ivy arrives at the Bennetts before the results do, and everyone is shocked to see her. She asks if they know the truth yet? Sam asks "The truth about what?" Ivy says about Julian's killer of course. She then sees everyone is there, and says she didn't know they were having a party. Grace says they are waiting for the DNA test results, and Ivy says good because then they'll know she is not scheming to break them up still. As they all wait for the results, Eve and Ivy argue. Ivy tells Eve that she will be forced to tell everyone about her affair with Julian if she doesn't lie about the DNA tests. Meanwhile, David tries to prepare John for the worst, but he doesn't understand where his dad is going with his talk. John is positive that Grace is his mom.
At Tabitha's, Tabitha and Timmy are shocked to see the book of spells floating over Kay's head. Tabitha claims the book might be in the attic, so she runs up there to search for it. Both Tabitha and timmy are shocked to see the book, and they try and get a hold of the book before Kay comes back down and finds it. Timmy manages to get the book, but it continues to float and carry him around the room! Tabitha manages to get Timmy and the book down, and Kay returns. Kay asks if they are okay, and Tabitha says they are. The book begins to glow, and Timmy tries to keep it out of Kay's sight. Kay eventually leaves, and Tabitha thinks about Miguel's impending death.
Meanwhile, Zombie Charity sneaks over to the Lopez-Fitzgerald house to seduce Miguel, who is busy doing exercises in his room. Charity knocks on his window, and he offers to get dressed and take her to get hot chocolate. However, Charity says she'd rather stay here with him. He invites her in, and the two begin making out. Charity tells Miguel that she loves him and needs to be with him. She says she can't wait any more, she wants to make love to him now! Miguel says he doesn't have protection, but Charity says she does! Miguel says he doesn't feel comfortable doing this in his mom's house, but she wants to do it now! Miguel decides to call Reese and see if they can use his parents cabin, but Charity keeps him from making the call. She makes the door close, and stay closed through magic! Charity tells him to forget about the door, and begins kissing him some more. Charity begs Miguel to make love to her tonight, and they fall onto the bed! As they begin to make love, we see Charity's true form in her shadow, a winged demon from hell!
At Tabitha's, Timmy still wants to rescue Charity and Miguel, but Tabitha tells him they can't rescue either of them! Timmy tries to get the book of spells, but Tabitha stops him. Tabitha throws the book to fluffy, and Timmy actually goes after it. Timmy and Fluffy end up in a huge fight. Tabitha bandages Timmy up after Fluffy attacks him.
At the Bennett's, everyone waits for the DNA results to arrive. Ivy continues to try and blackmail Eve into changing the results, but Eve refuses. David tells Ivy to deal with Eve's answers and pull her claws back in. David tells Eve not to let her get to her, but Eve says she can't help it. Eve and David both discuss how evil Ivy is. They both ask the other why they just don't come forward with the truth? Both of them say they are cowards and afraid of hurting the ones they love. As they talk, Ivy catches them and gloats. Ivy tells them that their stubbornness will not only ruin their own lives, but Grace's and David's as well! Later, Eve tells Ivy that she's had enough of her threats and they won't work! Eve says she is about to go down, and she will end up despised and alone! The doorbell rings, and it is the messenger from the hospital. Everyone waits for Eve to open and reads the results.
Reese shows up to see Kay, he has a book with something in it that he wants to show Kay. Reese says the book is on mythology, and he shows her some of the odd pictures. Kay sees a picture of a succubus, and she asks what it is? Reese tells her what it is, and that if it sleeps with a mortal man he will die. Kay wonders if Zombie Charity could be a succubus. Kay asks Reese about the succubus, and how one gets rid of one? Reese continues to read on about how the succubus seduces a man, and Kay has this sadomasochist nightmare of Charity, in leather, whipping a tied up Miguel, who begs Kay to save him. Kay says she has to find out what the zombie is doing, and takes off. Kay goes up to Charity's room, and discovers Charity is not there. She realizes she must have gone to seduce Miguel.
At the Lopez-Fitzgerald house, as Zombie Charity seduces Miguel, we see her true, winged succubus form in her shadow! Miguel once again thinks they should wait, but Zombie Charity refuses to leave until they have made love. Miguel puts on some mood music, and they continue to make love. As she seduces Miguel, she changes into her succubus, and accidentally scratches Miguel with her demon nails! As the continue to get closer to making love, Kay shows up and sees them together! She realizes she has to stop Charity before she kills Miguel.
Meanwhile, Sheridan wonders if the initials in the sand were real or imaginary. Brian eventually shows up and Sheridan tells him that he feels something very important to her is very close. She tells him about the initials she saw, and how she thinks they may be a clue to the past. Sheridan and Brian walk back to the hotel, and come across Luis' plaque. Brian explains the custom, and when she touches it, she feels the pain of this person. When they finally get back to the hotel, Sheridan hears the same song playing that Luis heard, and she has a memory of dancing with Luis to it. Brian thinks perhaps they should leave Bermuda, but Sheridan refuses and says she hopes this trip, and being with him, will help her put the past behind her.
At the Lopez-Fitzgerald house, Kay sees Miguel and Zombie Charity about to make love. She realizes she has to stop them or Miguel will die, and it will be her fault! Kay then begins to think maybe the book was wrong, and maybe Miguel will be okay. However, Kay then sees Charity's shadow, and realizes Charity really is a succubus! Back inside, Miguel stops and says this just doesn't feel right. He wants to wait, so Charity begins to talk about her premonitions about him and Kay and how she needs to know they are wrong. Miguel assures her that Kay is just his buddy, but during the time she was pushing him away, they did grow closer. However, Miguel says Kay is just one of the guys to him, and to look at her as a girlfriend would be a stretch. Kay hears this and wishes Miguel could just love her. Back inside, Miguel wants to make their first time special, but she assures him that this is romantic enough. Miguel asks her to wait right here, and leaves. Zombie then goes to the window and she and Kay begin arguing. KAy tells the Zombie that she is horrible, and Miguel doesn't love or want her, he wants the real Charity. Zombie says he thinks she is the real Charity, so he does want her. She also says that Miguel only thinks of her as his friend! Kay tells the Zombie that she knows if they make love Miguel will die, and she will stop her. The Zombie says Miguel will die tonight, and there is nothing she can do to stop it! The Zombie also says the best part is, she will have to live the rest of her life knowing that SHE is the reason Miguel is dead! Charity closes the window, and Miguel returns with a flower for Charity. The Zombie tells him that it is perfect, and tonight will be a night she never forgets.
At the Bennett's, Grace asks Eve to open up the test results. Eve's hands begin to shake, and TC asks if something is wrong. Eve says this is just an important moment. Eve tries to stall by wanting to talk about the accuracy of this test, which is 99.9% accurate. As Eve is about to read the result, David stops her and says there is something he needs to say. David talks about what a wonderful person Grace is, and how he never wanted to hurt her. Grace tells David that it is okay, she knows in her heart that John is her son, and she knows God would never take another child from her. John tells Grace that he knows she is his mom, and she is the best mother anyone could have. Ivy tells Eve that she must realize she can't do this to Grace, because it will destroy her! However, Eve says she must tell Grace the truth, everyone will know what she has done! Sam asks Eve to read the results and end this once and for all.
Theresa talks with Whitney about singing with CHad. Whitney says she had to turn him down because she can't be around Chad. Whitney says her parents want her to stay away from him, and she doesn't want to be a singer. Theresa tells her that she has got to find some way to deal with her feelings about Chad and her desire to be a singer. Theresa wants to give her advice, but WHitney says she is in no position to give relationship advice. Theresa says she has made mistakes, but she will get Ethan back. Theresa says she is not the same weepy girl she used to be, and Theresa tells Whitney that she needs to stop wallowing in her own unhappiness. Theresa says she is going to do everything she can to make sure she gets Ethan back, even if it means listening to a dead Julian Crane! Suddenly, Whitney sees the evil yellow eyes again! Theresa thinks Whitney is imagining things, and suggests they go home. Suddenly, they see a fire in the distance, and Theresa thinks it looks like it is coming from her street!
At the Bennett's, Eve refuses to lie to Grace and tells Ivy that she will tell her the truth! Before Eve can reveal the truth, Sam gets a call about the fire at the Lopez- Fitzgerald house. Everyone then runs out to check on their friends. Eve, David, and Ivy stay behind; and Ivy thanks God for the distraction. Eve calls Ivy evil and selfish for not even caring that Pilar's life could be in danger! Ivy tells Eve she should be thankful for this reprieve as well, because her life would have been destroyed along with Grace's! Eve says she doesn't care, she is going to tell the truth and stop her! David applauds Eve's bravery, and says she has his full support! Eve tells them both that they are stupid fools! Ivy tells them that she won't go down alone, she will drag them down with her! Eve and Ivy really begin to go at one another verbally, and when Eve tries to walk out the door, Ivy pulls a gun on her!
At the Lopez-Fitzgerald house, Charity and Miguel once again begin to make love. Kay realizes she has to do something to save Miguel. Kay sees a grill out back, and decides to use it to cause a diversion. She sets some wood and paper on fire, but the fire quickly grows out of control! Theresa and Whitney arrive, and Theresa bangs on the door to try and alert anyone inside. Theresa has lost her keys, so she can't get in. Back inside, Miguel thinks he hears something, but Charity tells him to ignore it. Sam, TC, Hank, and Grace arrive, and soon Miguel and Theresa meet up with them. Theresa doesn't know who is inside. Theresa thinks nobody is inside, but their whole house is burning down. Tabitha and Timmy show up and thinks Miguel and the Zombie will die, which pleases her to pieces. Back inside, Miguel and the Zombie realize the house is on fire, and they are trapped! Back outside, Timmy refuses to let Miguel die, and talks to Theresa and makes her realize that Miguel could be inside because he was at the Bennett's earlier, but left. Theresa runs to the house after Miguel, and Ethan and Chad show up. Whitney realizes Theresa has found a way into the house to find Miguel! Theresa is attempting to break into the basement, and ends up catching fire! Back inside, Miguel searches for a way for him and Charity to escape.