Tabitha, under Hecuba's spell, decides to smash open Hecuba's bottle and set her free because she thinks Hecuba will help her get her powers back and the two will work together to destroy Harmony. Timmy refuses to allow Tabitha do that, and grabs the bottle from her. He then throws a Martimmy in her face, and a furious Hecuba turns Timmy into a toad. Tabitha, however, has snapped out of Hecuba's spell and decides to get rid of her. Tabitha throws Hecuba to the friends in the basement, and tells them that she alone will destroy the good people of Harmony. Timmy turns back to normal, and Tabitha tells Timmy that her friends in the basement have agreed to let her try to do things her way.
Chad and Whitney have trouble saying goodnight as their passion grows, and they continue to kiss, and kiss, and kiss.
At the Lopez-Fitzgerald's, Theresa asks Ethan to spend the night. Ethan agrees, thinking she has something else in mind, but is hurt when she reveals she just wants Sheridan and Luis to be alone so they will get engaged. Theresa then realizes what Ethan was thinking, and she tells him that she promised herself, her mother, and god that she would wait until her wedding night. Ethan tells her that he just hasn't been able to spend much time with her lately.
At the cottage, Sheridan asks her magic 8 ball if there will be a double wedding, and it says yes. Luis catches her with the magic 8-ball and can't believe she believes in these things. Sheridan says they work, and asks it if Luis' present for Ethan and Theresa will be ready soon. The magic 8 ball say yes, but Luis says that is impossible, because he's getting them a car and he can't pick it up for a week. Suddenly, Luis' buddy calls and tells him the car he wanted to buy for Theresa and Ethan is ready for him now! Sheridan tells him these things work. Sheridan then gets an idea for Ethan and Theresa's present, she's going to send them on a honeymoon to Spain. She calls them up, and tells them. As she describes their honeymoon, Luis fantasizes that he and Sheridan are on their honeymoon.
Theresa and Ethan kiss, but Theresa says she should go upstairs before she does something she shouldn't be doing. Theresa then calls Whitney and tells her that she's thinking of making love to Ethan tonight. Whitney tells her she can't, but eventually gives up because Theresa always does whatever she wants to anyways. Theresa goes back downstairs and greets Ethan, who is in his boxers.
At Tabitha's, Timmy and Tabitha celebrate the end of Hecuba. Tabitha begins to sense something evil is going on. Timmy asks Tabitha if she's really going to do all those things she told the people in the basement that she was going to do? Tabitha says of course she is! Timmy says that he feels so sorry for the good people of Harmomy, but Tabitha says there are no good people in Harmony. Timmy asks what about Theresa? Tabitha says Theresa has done nothing but lied and schemed to get Ethan from day one. Timmy asks what about poor sweet Grace Bennett? She says Grace is going to get what she has been praying for, a new baby son. Timmy thinks that is wonderful but Tabitha says it isn't what he thinks. Grace's prayers will be answered, but not in the way she was hoping.
At the Bennett's, New Simone tries to talk Kay out of going into hell, but Kay says it is the only way to save Charity and Miguel. Kay thinks that because she doesn't have a soul, she may have a better chance at leading Miguel and Charity out of hell. Simone asks Kay how she will open the portal, Miguel had to call on the powers of heaven? Kay says she can call on other powers. The portal to hell opens, and the demons tell Kay that they have a special place in here reserved for her. Kay jumps into the portal and begins searching for Miguel.
Downstairs, Reese learns that for evil to have come to Harmony, it would have had to be invited. Grace refuses to believe that anyone would have invited evil here. Sam suggests the Cranes are behind this, but Pilar says the evil has effected them as well, look what has happened to Ethan. Grace pulls away from her family, and Sam tells Grace that they have to get past this. As they bicker, Jessica tells them to please stop this. Jessica tells her parents that she knows Ethan is dad's son, Kay knows Ethan is dad's son, the whole TOWN knows Ethan is dad's son. She just hopes that they can all put their family back together. Suddenly, everyone hears Simone screaming. Everyone runs upstairs and learns that Miguel and Kay have jumped back into hell. Grace tries to use her powers, but the demon serpent tells her that there is nothing she can do this time, they have Miguel, Kay, and Charity and are never letting them go. Everyone can do nothing but listen to what is going on in hell. Miguel can't find Charity, who is screaming for help. MEanwhile, Kay offers to stay in hell if Miguel and Charity are allowed to leave. As tension builds, the Bennett house explodes! We see everyone buried by the rubble, and only Sam begins to move.
At the Lopez-Fitzgerald house, Theresa decides to make love to Ethan, but as they are about to do so, Theresa sees the photo of her mom on the mantel. She remembers the promise she made to her mom, and tells Ethan that she can't do this. Theresa feels horrible for torturing him like this and not being able to give him what he wants. Ethan tells her that he only wants to be with her. Later, Ethan surprises Theresa by lighting candles all around the house. Ethan and Theresa begin kissing again, and Ethan decides that he really better leave this time.
At the cottage, Sheridan and Luis make love after dancing the tango. As they are basking in the afterglow, Sheridan gets a call from the travel agency telling her that the entire honeymoon is booked. Luis begins to fantasize about going on a honeymoon with SHeridan, and upon returning, wondering why it took him so long to propose. Luis excuses himself, and in the other room wonders why he is having such a hard time asking Sheridan to marry him. As he practices proposing to Sheridan, Sheridan overhears and tells herself that she will marry Luis.