| 1967 | 1968 | 1969 | |||
| Overall | Name | Overall | Name | Overall | Name |
| 2 | Steve Rexe | 4 | Garry Swain | 15 | Rick Kessell |
| 11 | Bob Smith | 14 | Ron Snell | 26 | Michel Briere |
| 21 | Dave Simpson | 38 | Yvon Labre | ||
| 50 | Ed Patenaude | ||||
| 62 | Paul Hoganson |
| 1970 | 1971 | 1972 | |||
| Overall | Name | Overall | Name | Overall | Name |
| 7 | Greg Polis | 18 | Brian McKenzie | 24 | Jack Lynch |
| 21 | John Stewart | 32 | Joe Noris | 30 | Bernie Lukowich |
| 35 | Larry Bignell | 46 | Gerry Methe | 40 | Denis Herron |
| 49 | Connie Forey | 60 | Dave Murphy | 56 | Ron Lalonde |
| 63 | Steve Cardwell | 74 | Ian Williams | 72 | Brian Walker |
| 77 | Bob Fitchner | 88 | Doug Elliott | 88 | Jeff Ablett |
| 90 | Jim Pearson | 104 | D'Arcy Keating | ||
| 102 | Cam Newton | 120 | Yves Bergeron | ||
| 110 | Ron Lemieux | 136 | Jay Babcock | ||
| 149 | Don Atchison |
| 1973 | 1974 | 1975 | |||
| Overall | Name | Overall | Name | Overall | Name |
| 7 | Blaine Stoughton | 8 | Pierre Larouche | 13 | Gordie Laxton |
| 23 | Wayne Bianchin | 27 | Jacques Cossette | 31 | Russ Anderson |
| 27 | Colin Campbell | 62 | Mario Faubert | 49 | Paul Baxter |
| 55 | Dennis Owchar | 80 | Bruce Aberhart | 67 | Stu Younger |
| 71 | Guido Tenesi | 98 | William Schneider | 85 | Kim Clackson |
| 87 | Don Seiling | 116 | Rob Laird | 103 | Peter Morris |
| 103 | Terry Ewasiuk | 133 | Larry Finck | 121 | Mike Will |
| 119 | Fred Comrie | 150 | Jim Chicoyne | 139 | Tapio Levo |
| 134 | Gord Lane | 166 | Rick Uhrich | 155 | Byron Shutt |
| 150 | Randy Aimoe | 181 | Serge Gamelin | 170 | Frank Salive |
| 164 | Don McLeod | 195 | Rich Perron | 185 | John Glynne |
| 206 | Rick Hindmarch | 196 | Lex Hudson | ||
| 216 | Bill Davis | 202 | Dan Tsubouchi | ||
| 223 | James Mathers | 206 | Bronisla Stankovsky | ||
| 217 | Kelly Secord |
| 1976 | 1977 | 1978 | |||
| Overall | Name | Overall | Name | Overall | Name |
| 2 | Blair Chapman | 30 | Jim Hamilton | 25 | Mike Meeker |
| 19 | Greg Malone | 48 | Kim Davis | 61 | Shane Pearsall |
| 29 | Peter Marsh | 66 | Mark Johnson | 75 | Rob Garner |
| 47 | Morris Lukowich | 102 | Greg Millen | ||
| 65 | Greg Redquest | ||||
| 83 | Brendan Lowe | ||||
| 101 | Vic Sirko | ||||
| 1979 | 1980 | 1981 | |||
| Overall | Name | Overall | Name | Overall | Name |
| 31 | Paul Marshall | 9 | Mike Bullard | 28 | Steve Gatzos |
| 52 | Bennett Wolf | 51 | Randy Boyd | 49 | Tom Thornbury |
| 73 | Brian Cross | 72 | Tony Feltrin | 70 | Norm Schmidt |
| 94 | Nick Ricci | 93 | Doug Shedden | 109 | Paul Edwards |
| 115 | Marc Chorney | 114 | Pat Graham | 112 | Rod Buskas |
| 156 | Rob Geale | 133 | Geoff Wilson | ||
| 177 | Brian Lundberg | 154 | Mitch Lamoureux | ||
| 198 | Steve McKenzie | 175 | Dean De Fazio | ||
| 196 | Dave Hannan |
| 1982 | 1983 | 1984 | |||
| Overall | Name | Overall | Name | Overall | Name |
| 10 | Rich Sutter | 15 | Bob Errey | 1 | Mario Lemieux |
| 38 | Tim Hrynewich | 22 | Todd Charlesworth | 9 | Doug Bodger |
| 52 | Troy Loney | 58 | Mike Rowe | 16 | Roger Belanger |
| 94 | Grant Sasser | 63 | Frank Pietrangelo | 64 | Mark Teevens |
| 136 | Grant Couture | 103 | Patrick Emond | 85 | Arto Javanainen |
| 157 | Peter Derksen | 123 | Paul Ames | 127 | Tom Ryan |
| 178 | Greg Gravel | 163 | Marty Ketola | 169 | John Del Col |
| 199 | Stu Wenaas | 183 | Alex Haidy | 189 | Steve Hurt |
| 220 | Chris McCauley | 203 | Garth Hildebrand | 210 | Jim Steen |
| 241 | Stan Bautch | 223 | Dave Goertz | 230 | Mark Ziliotto |
| 1985 | 1986 | 1987 | |||
| Overall | Name | Overall | Name | Overall | Name |
| 2 | Craig Simpson | 4 | Zarley Zalapski | 5 | Chris Joseph |
| 23 | Lee Giffin | 25 | Dave Capuano | 26 | Rick Tabaracci |
| 58 | Bruce Racine | 46 | Brad Aitken | 47 | Jamie Leach |
| 86 | Steve Gotaas | 67 | Rob Brown | 68 | Risto Kurkinen |
| 107 | Kevin Clemens | 88 | Sandy Smith | 89 | Jeff Waver |
| 114 | Stuart-Lee Marston | 109 | Jeff Daniels | 110 | Shawn McEachern |
| 128 | Steve Titus | 130 | Doug Hobson | 131 | Jim Bodden |
| 149 | Paul Stanton | 151 | Steve Rohlik | 152 | Jiri Kucera |
| 170 | Jim Paek | 172 | Dave McLlwain | 173 | John MacDougall |
| 191 | Steve Shaunessy | 193 | Kelly Cain | 194 | Daryn McBride |
| 212 | Doug Greschuk | 214 | Stan Drulia | 215 | Mark Carlson |
| 233 | Gregory Choules | 235 | Rob Wilson | 236 | Ake Lilljebjorn |
| 1988 | 1989 | 1990 | |||
| Overall | Name | Overall | Name | Overall | Name |
| 4 | Darrin Shannon | 16 | Jamie Heward | 5 | Jaromir Jagr |
| 25 | Mark Major | 37 | Paul Laus | 61 | Joe Dziedzic |
| 62 | Daniel Gauthier | 58 | John Brill | 68 | Chris Tamer |
| 67 | Mark Recchi | 79 | Todd Nelson | 89 | Brian Farrell |
| 88 | Greg Andrusak | 100 | Tom Nevers | 107 | Ian Moran |
| 130 | Troy Mick | 121 | Mike Markovich | 110 | Denis Casey |
| 151 | Jeff Blaeser | 126 | Mike Needham | 130 | Mika Valila |
| 172 | Rob Gaudreau | 142 | Pat Schafhauser | 131 | Ken Plaquin |
| 193 | Don Pancoe | 163 | David Shute | 145 | Pat Neaton |
| 214 | Cory Laylin | 184 | Andrew Wolf | 152 | Petteri Koskimaki |
| 235 | Darren Stolk | 205 | Greg Hagen | 173 | Ladislav Karabin |
| 226 | Scott Farrell | 194 | Tim Fingerhut | ||
| 247 | Jason Smart | 215 | Michael Thompson | ||
| 236 | Brian Bruininks |
| 1991 | 1992 | 1993 | |||
| Overall | Name | Overall | Name | Overall | Name |
| 16 | Markus Naslund | 19 | Martin Straka | 26 | Stefan Bergkvist |
| 38 | Rusty Fitzgerald | 43 | Marc Hussey | 52 | Domenic Pittis |
| 60 | Shane Peacock | 67 | Travis Thiessen | 62 | Dave Roche |
| 82 | Joe Tamminen | 91 | Todd Klassen | 104 | Jonas Andersson-Junkka |
| 104 | Rob Melanson | 115 | Philippe DeRouville | 130 | Chris Kelleher |
| 126 | Brian Clifford | 139 | Artem Kopot | 156 | Patrick Lalime |
| 148 | Ed Patterson | 163 | Jan Alinc | 182 | Sean Selmser |
| 170 | Peter McLaughlin | 187 | Fran Bussey | 208 | Larry McMorran |
| 192 | Jeff Lembke | 211 | Brian Bonin | 234 | Tim Harberts |
| 214 | Chris Tok | 235 | Brian Callahan | 260 | Leonid Toropchenko |
| 236 | Paul Dyck | 286 | Hans Jonsson | ||
| 258 | Pasi Huura |
| 1994 | 1995 | 1996 | |||
| Overall | Name | Overall | Name | Overall | Name |
| 24 | Chris Wells | 24 | Alexei Morozov | 23 | Craig Hillier |
| 50 | Richard Park | 76 | Jean-Sebastien Aubin | 28 | Pavel Skrbek |
| 57 | Sven Butenschon | 102 | Oleg Belov | 72 | Boyd Kane |
| 73 | Greg Crozier | 128 | Jan Hrdina | 77 | Boris Protsenko |
| 76 | Alexei Krivchenkov | 154 | Alexei Kolkunov | 105 | Michal Rozsival |
| 102 | Tom O'Connor | 180 | Derrick Pyke | 150 | Peter Bergman |
| 128 | Clint Johnson | 206 | Sergei Voronov | 186 | Eric Meloche |
| 154 | Valentin Morozov | 232 | Frank Ivankovic | 238 | Timo Seikkula |
| 161 | Serge Aubin | ||||
| 180 | Drew Palmer | ||||
| 206 | Boris Zelenko | ||||
| 232 | Jason Godbout | ||||
| 258 | Mikhail Kazakevich | ||||
| 284 | Brian Leitza |
| 1997 | 1998 | 1999 | |||
| Overall | Name | Overall | Name | Overall | Name |
| 17 | Robert Dome | 23 | Milan Kraft | 18 | Konstantin Koltsov |
| 44 | Brian Gaffaney | 54 | Alexander Zevakhin | 51 | Matt Murley |
| 71 | Josef Melichar | 80 | David Cameron | 57 | Jeremy Van Hoof |
| 97 | Alexander Mathieu | 110 | Scott Myers | 86 | Sebastien Caron |
| 124 | Harlan Pratt | 134 | Rob Scuderi | 115 | Ryan Malone |
| 152 | Petr Havelka | 169 | Jan Fadrny | 144 | Tomas Skvaridlo |
| 179 | Mark Moore | 196 | Joel Scherban | 157 | Vladimir Malenkikh |
| 208 | Andrew Ference | 224 | Mika Lehto | 176 | Doug Meyer |
| 234 | Eric Lind | 244 | Toby Petersen | 204 | Tom Kostopoulos |
| 254 | Matt Hussey | 233 | Darcy Robinson | ||
| 261 | Andrew McPherson |
| 2000 | 2001 | 2002 | |||
| Overall | Name | Overall | Name | Overall | Name |
| 18 | Brooks Orpik | 21 | Colby Armstrong | 5 | Ryan Whitney |
| 52 | Shane Endicott | 54 | Noah Welch | 35 | Ondrej Nemec |
| 84 | Peter Hamerlik | 86 | Drew Fata | 69 | Erik Christensen |
| 124 | Michel Ouellet | 96 | Alexandre Rouleau | 101 | Daniel Fernholm |
| 146 | David Koci | 120 | Tomas Surovy | 136 | Andy Sertich |
| 185 | Patrick Foley | 131 | Ben Eaves | 137 | Cam Paddock |
| 216 | Jim Abbott | 156 | Andy Schneider | 171 | Bobby Goepfert |
| 248 | Steven Crampton | 217 | Tomas Duba | 202 | Patrick Bartschi |
| 273 | Roman Simicek | 250 | Brandon Crawford-West | 234 | Maxime Talbot |
| 280 | Nick Boucher | 239 | Ryan Lannon | ||
| 265 | Dwight LaBrosse |
| 2003 | 2004 | 2005 | |||
| Overall | Name | Overall | Name | Overall | Name |
| 1 | Marc-Andre Fleury | 2 | Evgeny Malkin | 1 | Sidney Crosby |
| 32 | Ryan Stone | 31 | Johannes Salmonsson | 61 | Michael Gergen |
| 70 | Jonathan Filewich | 61 | Alex Goligoski | 62 | Kristopher Letang |
| 73 | Daniel Carcillo | 67 | Nick Johnson | 125 | Tommi Leinonen |
| 121 | Paul Bissonnette | 85 | Brian Gifford | 126 | Tim Crowder |
| 161 | Evgeny Isakov | 99 | Tyler Kennedy | 194 | Jean-Philippe Paquet |
| 169 | Lukas Bolf | 130 | Michal Sersen | 195 | Joe Vitale |
| 199 | Andy Chiodo | 164 | Moises Gutierrez | ||
| 229 | Stephen Dixon | 194 | Chris Peluso | ||
| 232 | Joe Jensen | 222 | Jordan Morrison | ||
| 263 | Matt Moulson | 228 | David Brown | ||
| 259 | Brian Ihnacak |
| 2006 | 2007 | 2008 | |||
| Overall | Name | Overall | Name | Overall | Name |
| 2 | Jordan Staal | 20 | Angelo Esposito | ||
| 32 | Carl Sneep | 51 | Keven Veilleux | ||
| 65 | Brian Strait | 78 | Robert Bortuzzo | ||
| 125 | Chad Johnson | 80 | Casey Pierro-Zabotel | ||
| 185 | Timo Seppanen | 111 | Luca Caputi | ||
| 118 | Alex Grant | ||||
| 141 | Jake Muzzin | ||||
| 171 | Dustin Jeffrey |