-Fantasy Bowl History and ALL-PRO
Teams-
| 1995 | Fantasy Bowl I | Dave/Missy |
| 1996 | Fantasy Bowl
II |
Hegins Torch |
| 1997 | Fantasy Bowl
III |
Hegins Torch |
| 1998 | Fantasy Bowl
IV |
Hegins Torch |
| 1999 | Fantasy Bowl
V |
Hegins Torch |
| 2000 | Fantasy Bowl VI | Wolfpack |
| Quarterback | Brett Favre | Ashland Sprockets | 214 pts. |
| Running Back | Terrell Davis | Hegins Torch | 115 pts. |
| Running Back | Dorsey Levens | Missy's Malitia | 72 pts. |
| Wide Receiver | Antonio Freeman | Hegins Torch | 65 pts. |
| Wide Receiver | Cris Carter | Mad Bombers | 63 pts. |
| Tight End | Ben Coates | Ashland Sprockets | 37 pts. |
| Kicker | Jason Elam | Scranton Storm | 92 pts. |
| Def/Spec. Teams | Denver | Mad Bombers | 24 pts. |
| Quarterback | Randall Cunningham | Hegins Thunder | 251 pts. |
| Running Back | Terrell Davis | Valley View Vipers | 166 pts. |
| Running Back | Jamal Anderson | Valley View Vipers | 110 pts. |
| Wide Receiver | Randy Moss | Hegins Thunder | 120 pts. |
| Wide Receiver | Antonio Freeman | Scranton Storm | 105 pts. |
| Tight End | Shannon Sharpe | Ashland Sprockets | 49 pts. |
| Kicker | Gary Anderson | Hegins Torch | 156 pts. |
| Def./Spec. Teams | Seattle | Scranton Storm | 75 pts. |
| Quarterback | Brad Johnson and Kurt Warner | Cully's Heroes Hegins Thunder | 158 pts.
158 pts. |
| Running Back | Stephen Davis | Hegins Torch | 132 pts. |
| Running Back | Edgerrin James | Cully's Heroes | 105 pts. |
| Wide Receiver | Marvin Harrison | Hegins Torch | 104 pts. |
| Wide Receiver | Isaac Bruce | Hegins Thunder | 88 pts. |
| Tight End | Wesley Walls | Cully's Heroes | 66 pts. |
| Kicker | Olindo Mare | Ashland Sprockets | 111 pts. |
| Def./Spec. Teams | Kansas City | Cully's Heroes | 39 pts. |
| Quarterback | Daunte Culpepper | Wolfpack | 219 pts. |
| Running Back | Marshall Faulk | Hegins Valley Torch | 115 pts. |
| Running Back | Edgerrin James | Dudleyville Dragons | 114 pts. |
| Wide Receiver | Randy Moss | Ashland Sprockets | 90 pts. |
| Wide Receiver | Marvin Harrison | Hegins Thunder | 86 pts. |
| Tight End | Tony Gonzalez | Wolfpack | 61 pts. |
| Kicker | Matt Stover | Catch 22 | 109 pts. |
| Def./Spec. Teams | Tampa Bay | Buccaneers | 35 pts. |