| Fantasy Bowl I | |||||
| 49ers | 98 | ||||
| Redskins | 99 | ||||
| 1996 Semi-Finals | 1996 Division Finals | Fantasy Bowl II | |||
| Canes | 193.5 | Elvis' | 223.5 | Redskins | 290 |
| Elvis' | 220.5 | Redskins | 279 | 49ers | 207.5 |
| Packers at | 202 | Jimmies at | 176.5 | ||
| Jimmies | 219.5 | 49ers | 261 | ||
| 1997 Semi-Finals | 1997 Division Finals | Fantasy Bowl III | |||
| Panthers | 221 | Panthers | 200.5 | Panthers | 232.5 |
| Vikings | 182.5 | Redskins | 196.5 | Raiders | 267.5 |
| 49ers | 176 | Jaguars | 285 | ||
| Jaguars | 208 | Raiders | 348.5 | ||
| 1998 Semi-Finals | 1998 Division Finals | Fantasy Bowl IV | |||
| Panthers | 231.5 | Redskins | 280.5 | Redskins | 259 |
| Redskins | 260 | Vikings | 227.5 | Raiders | 165 |
| Packers at | 242.5 | 49ers at | 198.5 | ||
| 49ers | 333 | Raiders | 224 | ||
| 1999 Semi-Finals | 1999 Division Finals | Fantasy Bowl V | |||
| Lions | 244.5 | Lions | 175.5 | Raiders | 279 |
| Packers | 226 | Panthers | 263 | Panthers | 196.5 |
| Redskins at | 257.5 | 49ers at | 235 | ||
| 49ers | 262 | Raiders | 235.5 | ||
| 2000 Semi-Finals | 2000 Division Finals | Fantasy Bowl VI | |||
| Jaguars | 228 | Raiders | 318.5 | 49ers | 314 |
| Raiders | 284 | Panthers | 196.5 | Raiders | 191 |
| Vikings | 260 | 49ers | 303 | ||
| 49ers | 305 | Cripps | 152.5 | ||
| 2001 Semi-Finals | 2001 Division Finals | Fantasy Bowl VII | |||
| Jaguars | 246.5 | Panthers | 273 | Cripps | 226 |
| Panthers | 286.5 | Raiders | 277 | Raiders | 224.5 |
| Lions | 284 | Lions | 171 | ||
| Packers | 183 | Cripps | 187.5 | ||
| 2002 Semi-Finals | 2002 Division Finals | Fantasy Bowl VIII | |||
| Raiders | 234.5 | Cripps | 193 | 49ers | 275.5 |
| Cripps | 252.5 | Panthers | 349 | Panthers | 221.5 |
| Vikings | 236 | Vikings | 202 | ||
| Jaguars | 224.5 | 49ers | 218 | ||
| 2003 Semi-Finals | 2003 Division Finals | Fantasy Bowl IX | |||
| Lions | 134 | Vikings | 165.5 | Panthers | 274 |
| Vikings | 195.5 | Panthers | 224.5 | 49ers | 293 |
| Jaguars at | 283.5 | Jaguars at | 243 | ||
| Redskins | 214 | 49ers | 346.5 | ||
| 2004 Semi-Finals | 2004 Division Finals | Fantasy Bowl X | |||
| Lions | 188 | Stamps | 242.5 | Jaguars | 274 |
| Stampeders | 297 | Jaguars | 368 | Panthers | 260.5 |
| Raiders | 234.5 | Raiders | 274.5 | ||
| 49ers | 201 | Panthers | 279 | ||
| 2005 Semi-Finals | 2005 Division Finals | Fantasy Bowl XI | |||
| Irish | 278 | Irish | 154.5 | Copernicus | 295.5 |
| Jaguars | 272 | Hawkeyes | 207 | Hawkeyes | 261.5 |
| Vikings | 213 | Copernicus | 365.5 | ||
| Copernicus | 270.5 | Stamps | 267 | ||
| 2006 Semi-Finals | 2006 Division Finals | Fantasy Bowl XII | |||
| TC | 231 | Packers | 224.5 | Vikings | 271.5 |
| Packers | 284 | Fighting Irish | 305 | Fighting Irish | 241.5 |
| Vikings | 281.5 | Vikings | 214 | ||
| Hawkeyes | 271 | Brown Wave | 213.5 | ||
| 2007 Semi-Finals | 2007 Division Finals | Fantasy Bowl XIII | |||
| Vikings | 288.5 | Vikings | 171.5 | Rose Cougars | 222 |
| Copernicus | 238.5 | Rose Cougars | 278.5 | Sleeve | 318 |
| Raiders II | 211.5 | Brown Wave | 185 | ||
| Brown Wave | 277 | Sleeve | 206 | ||
| 2008 Semi-Finals | 2008 Division Finals | Fantasy Bowl XIV | |||
| Protest | 292.5 | Protest | 309 | Protest | 265.5 |
| Brown Wave | 222 | Sleeve | 206.5 | Raiders II | 241.5 |
| Packers | 178 | Whisperer | 239 | ||
| Whisperer | 243 | Raiders II | 296 | ||