24th October 1999 
| OLDHAM 1 READING 2 | ||
| Reading picked up their first away points of the season and ended Oldham's three-match unbeaten run with a 2-1 win. They went in front after nine minutes when Andy Gurney hit his first goal of the season after a Keith Scott effort had rebounded off a post. Oldham fought back to equalise after 20 minutes when Craig Dudley, making his full home debut, scored his first goal for the club after taking advantage of a defensive mistake. The Royals took all three points though with a controversial penalty decision on the stroke of half time. Oldham were pulled up when a shot hit Paul Rickers on the hand with his arms at his side. Keeper Gary Kelly saved Darren Caskey's first spot-kick but he made no mistake with the second after it was ordered to be re-taken when Oldham defenders encroached in the box. | ||
Referee Phil Joslin demanded police protection following a controversial penalty decision which ended Oldham's revival three- match unbeaten run. Reading took the lead through Andy Gurney on nine minutes. The home side equalised 11 minutes later thanks to youngster Craig Dudley. But the heated row after Joslin had awarded Reading a penalty left a sour taste. Darren Caskey's shot was superbly saved by keeper Kelly but it had to be retaken much to everyone's bewiderment. Joslin argued that the Oldham defenders had encroached in the area, and Caskey made no mistake with his second effort.